The 2017 arbitration disapproval voided the class-action ban and the records requirement in one law
Public Law 115-74, signed November 1, 2017, voided the CFPB’s arbitration rule whole. In our reading, that removed a public record of consumer arbitration along with the class-action ban, and neither has returned in the Bureau documents we cite.
Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.
Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article
Public Law 115-74, signed November 1, 2017, voided the CFPB’s arbitration rule whole. In our reading, that removed a public record of consumer arbitration along with the class-action ban, and neither has returned in the Bureau documents we cite.
- The week On Wednesday, November 1, 2017, the President signed House Joint Resolution 111 into law as Public Law 115-74.
- The contract half: what the class-action provision would have required of agreements Section 1040.4(a) of the rule would have changed the terms of consumer arbitration agreements.
- The records half: what providers would have submitted and the Bureau would have published Section 1040.4(b) would have created a records pipeline.
- The mechanism: how a disapproval resolution operates and what it forbids next The Congressional Review Act lets Congress disapprove a rule by joint resolution.
- The ground left standing: the arbitration regimes and contract terms that remained After November 1, consumer arbitration in covered markets continued under the terms providers chose, subject to arbitration law, administrator rules and specific statutes.
- How the outcome reached different firms The rule’s coverage and exclusions mean the disapproval reached firms differently.
- Objections, in order The argument that the disapproval removed both halves in one law, and that losing the records half mattered, faces objections.
- What a chief compliance officer could check The disapproval left firms in covered markets free to use arbitration and class waivers, with no federal records duty.
- With hindsight The Bureau completed the removal that month.
The week
On Wednesday, November 1, 2017, the President signed House Joint Resolution 111 into law as Public Law 115-74. Its operative text was one sentence. Congress disapproved the rule submitted by the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection relating to arbitration agreements, published at 82 FR 33210 on July 19, 2017, and the rule would have no force or effect.
The resolution’s path was short. The legislative history printed with the law shows that the House passed it on July 25, 2017, and the Senate on October 24, 2017. The Senate’s roll call vote 249, at 9:46 p.m. that day, recorded 50 yeas and 50 nays, with the Vice President voting yea. The joint resolution passed.
The resolution used the Congressional Review Act, codified at 5 U.S.C. 801 and following sections. Section 801(b)(1) provides that a rule shall not take effect, or continue, if Congress enacts a joint resolution of disapproval. Section 801(b)(2) adds a bar. A disapproved rule may not be reissued in substantially the same form. A new rule substantially the same may not be issued unless a later law specifically authorizes it.
The rule itself had been published on July 19, 2017, and took effect on September 18, 2017. It was issued under section 1028(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act, which let the Bureau regulate pre-dispute arbitration agreements in consumer financial contracts. The Federal Register summary described two parts.
The first part barred covered providers from using a pre-dispute arbitration agreement to block a consumer from filing or joining a class action about a covered product or service. The rule set out text that covered agreements had to contain: “We agree that neither we nor anyone else will rely on this agreement to stop you from being part of a class action case in court. You may file a class action in court or you may be a member of a class action filed by someone else.”
The second part required providers in arbitrations under pre-dispute agreements to submit specified records to the Bureau. They included the claim, the answer, the agreement and any award. They also included court filings relying on an arbitration agreement to seek dismissal or a stay. The Bureau would post the records, redacted, in a public repository, beginning no later than July 1, 2019.
Compliance would have applied to pre-dispute agreements entered into on or after March 19, 2018. Agreements made before that date were not covered. The rule listed the products it reached, including consumer credit, deposit accounts, remittances, consumer reports provided to consumers, check cashing and related debt collection.
The rule also listed exclusions. It did not apply to persons regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission or the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Nor did it reach broker-dealers and investment advisers to the extent regulated by state securities commissions. It excluded federal agencies, states, tribes and their arms, providers serving no more than 25 consumers a year, certain merchants and employers offering products as employee benefits.
Broker-dealers already operated under a different arbitration regime. FINRA’s Rule 12204, in effect since 2007 and amended in 2008, said class action claims may not be arbitrated under FINRA’s code. It also said a member firm may not enforce an arbitration agreement against a member of a certified or putative class until certification is denied, the class is decertified, or the customer leaves the class.
By November 1, the outcome was settled in law. The rule had taken effect in September but had not reached any agreement, because its compliance date had not arrived.
The congressional disapproval of the Bureau’s arbitration rule is remembered as the end of a class-action ban. The resolution did more than that, because of how the Congressional Review Act works. It voided the whole rule. That included the second half, which would have built a public record of consumer arbitration. And it barred a substantially similar rule without new legislation.
The two halves of the rule were different instruments. One changed the terms of consumer contracts. The other created a data flow from providers to the Bureau and then to the public. A legislature that objected to the first could not, under this procedure, keep the second. The resolution had one sentence and one effect.
Our argument is that the disapproval removed the class-action ban and the records requirement in one law, and that the loss of the records half shaped what consumers, regulators and firms could see afterward. We take the episode in four parts:
- The contract half: what the class-action provision would have required of agreements.
- The records half: what providers would have submitted and the Bureau would have published.
- The mechanism: how a disapproval resolution operates and what it forbids next.
- The ground left standing: the arbitration regimes and contract terms that remained.
The first two describe the rule. The third describes the law that removed it. The fourth describes what remained for firms and consumers. Together they cover the rule’s substance, its removal and its aftermath. After the four parts we look at how the outcome reached different firms, at objections, and at what a chief compliance officer could check.
A note on sources and our reading. We describe the rule from its Federal Register text, the vote from the Senate’s record, and the law from its published text and the Congressional Review Act. Later events come from Bureau documents in the Federal Register. Statements about what the law permits or forbids are our reading. The reach of the substantially-the-same bar has not been settled for this rule, and firms should check with counsel.
The contract half: what the class-action provision would have required of agreements
Section 1040.4(a) of the rule would have changed the terms of consumer arbitration agreements. It did not ban arbitration. It barred providers from relying on a pre-dispute arbitration agreement to stop a class action about a covered product, unless and until the court ruled the case could not proceed as a class action.
The required clause
The rule specified the words. A covered agreement entered after the compliance date had to state that neither party would rely on it to stop the consumer from being part of a class action in court. It had to state that the consumer may file a class action or be a member of one filed by someone else. Providers could add sentences on scope, such as that the clause did not apply to agreements made before March 19, 2018.
For agreements covering several products, only some of them covered, the rule offered an alternative clause. It named the Bureau’s rule and limited the class-action promise to covered products. In our reading, this let a bank with one agreement for deposit and investment accounts apply the clause only to the deposit side.
Agreements a provider inherited
The rule reached agreements a provider had not written. If a provider acquired or began servicing accounts under another party’s agreement that lacked the clause, it had to amend the agreement or send a written notice within 60 days. The rule gave the notice text. In our reading, this would have reached loan buyers, servicers and debt collectors relying on originators’ contracts.
Delegation clauses
Arbitration agreements can contain a delegation provision, which sends questions about the agreement’s own scope or validity to the arbitrator. The rule anticipated this. It let providers add a sentence saying the class-action provision also applied to the delegation provision. In our reading, that closed a route by which a provider could have argued that an arbitrator, not a court, should decide whether the class-action promise applied.
Prepaid cards in packages
The rule recognized a practical problem. General-purpose reloadable prepaid cards are sold in retail packages with the agreement inside. A package printed before the compliance date could not contain the new clause. The rule exempted such agreements if the card was bought in person and the agreement was packaged before the compliance date. A provider able to contact the consumer in writing had to send an amended agreement within 30 days of getting contact details.
Sovereign immunity and language
The rule allowed one more addition. A provider with a genuine belief that sovereign immunity might apply could add text about it. The text said defendants in a class action may claim immunity, and that the provision does not create or waive it. The rule also allowed the clause in another language if the agreement was in that language. In our reading, both details show the drafters working through real contract populations, not abstract ones.
What it did not change
The rule did not stop individual arbitration. A consumer with an individual dispute could still be required to arbitrate under a valid agreement. The rule did not reach agreements made before March 19, 2018. It did not reach excluded persons, such as broker-dealers regulated by the SEC. In our reading, its effect would have grown over time as new accounts were opened under new agreements.
The operational work it would have required
For a provider, the contract half meant document changes. Every consumer agreement with an arbitration clause for covered products would need the new clause for accounts opened from March 19, 2018. Product, legal and operations teams would need to version agreements by date. Systems would need to record which agreement version applied to each account. A provider that could not tell which version a customer signed could not tell which rights applied.
Telling customers
New agreements reach customers at account opening. Inherited agreements needed the rule’s written notice within 60 days. Either way, customers would see new language about class actions. In our reading, a provider would need its customer service staff ready to explain the clause, and its complaint team ready for questions about what it meant for past disputes. The clause applied only to agreements after the compliance date, which is a hard point to explain to a long-standing customer.
Litigation exposure as a planning input
Class actions affect how firms estimate legal risk. A provider facing class claims on covered products would need reserves, litigation management and settlement processes it might not have needed under individual arbitration. In our reading, the rule would have changed the inputs to a firm’s legal risk models, which feed capital and pricing decisions. The resolution removed that change before it began.
The records half: what providers would have submitted and the Bureau would have published
Section 1040.4(b) would have created a records pipeline. It applied to pre-dispute agreements entered after the compliance date. For each arbitration and for court cases relying on an arbitration agreement, the provider would have sent copies of key documents to the Bureau.
What providers would have sent
For each arbitration claim by or against the provider about a covered product, the provider would submit the claim and any counterclaim and the answer. It would also submit the agreement filed with the arbitrator and any judgment or award. If an arbitrator refused to administer a claim because the provider had not paid fees, the provider would submit that communication.
The list went further. If an administrator found that the provider’s agreement did not meet its fairness principles or rules, the provider would submit that determination. In court cases, the provider would submit any filing that relied on an arbitration agreement to seek dismissal, deferral or a stay, with the agreement relied on.
Deadlines and redaction
Each record was due within 60 days of the provider filing it, or of receiving it from someone else. Before submission, the provider had to redact individuals’ names, other than the provider’s or arbitrator’s, and individuals’ addresses except city, state and zip code. It also had to redact email addresses, phone numbers, photographs, account numbers, Social Security and tax numbers, government identification numbers and passport numbers.
In our reading, redaction would have been the hardest operational step. Arbitration records contain personal data in narrative text, exhibits and attachments. Reliable redaction across all of that requires tooling and review. A provider that missed a field would send personal data to a government agency for publication. The rule’s list was specific, which helps, but the documents are not structured.
Court records as well as arbitral ones
The records duty reached court filings too. When a consumer sued and the provider moved to dismiss, defer or stay the case by relying on an arbitration agreement, the provider would submit the motion and the agreement. In our reading, this would have shown how often providers used arbitration clauses to move cases out of court, and which agreements they relied on. Court filings are public in principle, but scattered across courts. The rule would have gathered them.
Routing documents inside a firm
A provider’s arbitration documents arrive in several places. Outside counsel receive pleadings. The administrator sends notices and awards. Business units receive consumer demands. The rule’s 60-day clock would start when the provider received a record. In our reading, a provider would need intake rules so that every covered document reached one compliance team quickly, with the date received logged. Without that routing, deadlines would be missed by default.
Publication
The Bureau was required to maintain a central public repository of the submitted records, easily accessible and retrievable by the public. Before posting, it would make further redactions needed under privacy laws. It had to begin posting no later than July 1, 2019, and then post each year’s records annually. The preamble said the Bureau expected to make the records searchable by text, date, administrator, provider and product type.
What publication would have meant for reputation
A public repository searchable by provider name would have made each firm’s arbitration history visible to journalists, competitors and customers. A provider with frequent fee defaults or adverse fairness findings would be identifiable. In our reading, the reputational effect could have changed provider behavior as much as the class-action provision, without any lawsuit. Firms would have had reason to review their own records before the first posting date.
Why the records half mattered on its own
The records half would have given regulators, researchers and consumers something they lacked: a systematic view of consumer arbitration outcomes. Individual arbitration decisions are generally not public, as the Bureau later observed. In our reading, the repository would have let anyone compare outcomes by provider, product and administrator. It would have shown whether a provider failed to pay fees, or had agreements found unfair.
That view would have served supervision too. Examiners could see patterns of disputes before visiting a firm. State attorneys general could see claims about firms in their states. In our reading, the records half was a market monitoring tool that would have worked whether or not class actions were allowed.
The study behind the rule
The removal notice later recalled that the rule followed the Bureau’s March 2015 study of pre-dispute arbitration agreements, delivered to Congress as section 1028(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act required. In our reading, the records half would have turned a one-time study into a continuing dataset. The study described the market at one point. The repository would have tracked it year by year, so changes in providers’ practices would be visible.
The cost side
The records half carried costs. Providers would need processes to capture every arbitration document within 60 days, redact it and submit it in the Bureau’s format. Outside counsel and arbitration administrators would need to route documents to the provider’s compliance team. In our reading, the burden would scale with the number of arbitrations a provider faced, not with its number of accounts.
The mechanism: how a disapproval resolution operates and what it forbids next
The Congressional Review Act lets Congress disapprove a rule by joint resolution. If enacted, the rule shall not take effect or continue. A resolution under the Act disapproves a rule as submitted. This one named the rule by its Federal Register citation.
All or nothing
Public Law 115-74 disapproved the rule published at 82 FR 33210. That publication contained both halves. In our reading, Congress had no way, within this procedure, to keep the records requirement while removing the class-action provision. A member who supported the records half and opposed the class-action half faced one vote on both. The Senate’s tie, broken by the Vice President, shows how close the vote was.
No force or effect
The resolution said the rule shall have no force or effect. The rule had taken effect on September 18, 2017. Its compliance date, March 19, 2018, had not arrived. In our reading, no provider ever had to include the clause or submit a record. The rule’s effect on contracts and records was nil. Its effect on planning had begun, since firms preparing for March 2018 would have started work.
The substantially-the-same bar
Section 801(b)(2) forbids reissuing the rule in substantially the same form, or issuing a new rule substantially the same, unless a later law specifically authorizes it. The Act does not define substantially the same. In our reading, the bar would likely reach a new class-action ban in this market. Whether it reaches a records-only rule is an open question. A records requirement alone would differ from the disapproved rule, which had both parts.
Effective, then voided
The Act’s text covers a rule that has already taken effect. A rule shall not take effect, or continue, once a resolution is enacted. That fit this case. The rule was in effect from September 18 to November 1, 2017, with nothing yet required of providers. In our reading, a firm planning for a new rule cannot treat its effective date as final. A rule within the Act’s review window can still be removed, and the firm’s preparation work lost.
Between the vote and the signature
The Senate voted on October 24. The President signed on November 1. In the days between, the outcome was likely but not law. In our reading, a provider would have paused build work after the Senate vote and stopped it after the signature, with a record of what was spent and what could be reused. Version control on agreements, intake of arbitration documents and redaction tooling all had value beyond this rule.
Who bore the planning cost
Between July and November 2017, covered providers had a final rule with a compliance date and a pending resolution that could void it. Each had to decide whether to build. In our reading, firms that built early carried costs that the resolution made unnecessary. Firms that waited would have faced a compressed schedule if the resolution had failed. The procedure left that bet to each firm, with no way to hedge it fully.
Uncertainty as a deterrent
An open question about the bar has its own effect. An agency considering a records-only rule would face the risk of a challenge arguing the new rule was substantially the same. In our reading, that risk would weigh against the attempt, whatever its merits. The bar works partly through what it forbids and partly through the doubt it creates.
The route Congress left open
The bar has an exit. A substantially similar rule may issue if a later law specifically authorizes it. In our reading, that moves any return of the class-action ban from the Bureau to Congress. A firm assessing the chance of the rule’s return would watch legislation, not the Bureau’s regulatory agenda. That is a different signal to monitor, with a different timeline.
What the resolution did not touch
The resolution addressed one rule. It did not repeal section 1028 of the Dodd-Frank Act, which authorizes the Bureau to regulate arbitration agreements. It did not change the Bureau’s supervisory or enforcement authority over firms that use arbitration. It did not change other statutes that restrict arbitration in specific settings. In our reading, the Bureau kept its authority and lost this exercise of it, with a bar on repeating it.
The ground left standing: the arbitration regimes and contract terms that remained
After November 1, consumer arbitration in covered markets continued under the terms providers chose, subject to arbitration law, administrator rules and specific statutes. Several regimes stood apart from the rule and were unaffected by its disapproval.
Broker-dealers under FINRA’s code
Broker-dealers were excluded from the Bureau’s rule, and their customer arbitration was already governed by FINRA. Rule 12204 keeps class claims out of FINRA arbitration and bars a member from enforcing an arbitration agreement against a class member until the class question is resolved. In our reading, a customer of a broker-dealer kept a class-action path the Bureau’s rule would have given bank customers, and that path survived the disapproval.
Arbitration law itself
The Bureau’s rule would have operated alongside federal arbitration law, which generally enforces arbitration agreements according to their terms. The rule was the Bureau’s use of the specific authority Congress gave it in section 1028 to limit such agreements in consumer finance. In our reading, once the rule was voided, providers’ agreements returned to the general framework, in which class waivers in arbitration clauses are enforced unless another rule applies. FINRA’s code and the Military Lending Act were such rules for their markets.
Servicemembers and covered credit
The Military Lending Act prohibits arbitration agreements in consumer credit to covered servicemembers and dependents, as the Bureau later summarized. It does not apply to some credit, such as residential mortgages and automobile finance. In our reading, a lender serving military customers already had to run two contract regimes. The disapproval left that split in place.
Administrators’ fairness rules
Arbitration administrators apply their own rules to consumer cases, as the rule’s records list implies, including fee requirements and fairness principles. The rule would have required providers to report when an administrator found an agreement out of line with them. With the rule gone, those findings stayed between the administrator and the parties. In our reading, a provider’s own compliance program would be the only place such findings were tracked systematically.
Public enforcement was unaffected
The resolution did not limit the Bureau’s or states’ own enforcement against providers. Arbitration agreements bind consumers, not regulators. The Bureau later cited its 2015 study as indicating that class actions and public enforcement do not always address the same claims. In our reading, public enforcement remained a separate route to redress, with its own priorities, resources and limits. It could not replace private class claims for harms regulators chose not to pursue.
Firms’ own choices
Providers remained free to include arbitration clauses, to include class waivers, or to omit them. That made the clause a product and risk decision for each firm. In our reading, a firm’s choice would reflect its view of litigation risk, customer relations and reputation. The disapproval removed a federal floor. It did not require firms to use the room.
Complaint handling as the remaining window
Disputes that never reach arbitration still pass through a firm’s complaint process. Consumers can complain to the firm, to the Bureau and to state regulators. Those channels were untouched by the resolution. In our reading, a firm’s complaint data became the main internal record of disputes, and complaint trends the main early signal of problems that might later become arbitrations or lawsuits. A firm that analyzed complaints by product and cause would see much of what the repository would have shown.
Merchants and employers outside the rule
The rule excluded certain merchants that extend credit for their own goods and services, and employers offering covered products to employees as benefits. The exclusions fell with the rest of the rule. They still show where the Bureau drew its line. In our reading, a retailer or employer with a financial product for customers or staff would check whether it fell inside the Bureau’s authority before assuming any future rule would pass it by.
Visibility after the disapproval
Without the records half, the public view of consumer arbitration in covered markets depended on what administrators chose to publish and what firms disclosed. In our reading, regulators lost a systematic feed they would have had from 2019. Supervisors could still request records from firms they examined. But a request covers one firm at a time, and its results stay out of public view.
How the outcome reached different firms
The rule’s coverage and exclusions mean the disapproval reached firms differently. The sections below follow the rule’s own categories.
Card issuers and large banks
Large providers of credit cards and deposit accounts were squarely within the rule’s coverage. For them, the disapproval removed planned contract changes and a records process. In our reading, they also kept the litigation profile their existing agreements produced. Their compliance teams could stop building the March 2018 changes, while keeping any document version control they had begun.
Community banks and credit unions
Smaller institutions using arbitration clauses would have faced the same duties at lower volume. Some smaller institutions may not use arbitration clauses at all. For those, the rule would have changed little, and so did its disapproval. In our reading, the main effect for small institutions was on vendor-supplied account agreements, which would have needed new versions.
Fintech and payment providers
The rule covered remittances, accounts under the Electronic Fund Transfer Act and certain payment processing for consumers. Fintech firms offering these products would have been covered. In our reading, the disapproval let them keep standard online terms with arbitration clauses and class waivers. It also meant no public record would show how their disputes were resolved.
Debt collectors and debt buyers
The rule covered collection of debts arising from covered products, including by debt buyers. These firms rely on agreements they did not write. The inherited-agreement provisions would have required notices or amendments within 60 days. In our reading, the disapproval spared them a difficult process of reaching consumers on accounts they had bought.
Credit reporting and credit repair firms
The rule covered providing consumer reports and credit scores directly to consumers, and services claiming to improve a person’s credit record. Firms selling these products online with standard terms would have been covered. In our reading, the disapproval left their consumer terms unchanged. Disputes about the accuracy of credit files have their own statutory routes, which the rule did not change.
Check cashers and money transmitters
The rule covered check cashing, check collection and check guaranty, as well as transmitting or exchanging funds for consumers. These firms serve customers who may not have bank accounts. In our reading, their dispute terms affect people with fewer alternatives if something goes wrong. The disapproval left those terms to each firm and to state licensing regulators.
Prepaid card providers
Prepaid card providers would have used the packaging exception for cards already printed. They would then have needed new packages and agreements for later stock, and notices to customers whose contact details they obtained. In our reading, the disapproval spared them a distribution problem: tracking which retail stock contained which agreement version.
Broker-dealers and investment advisers
Excluded from the rule, broker-dealers and SEC-regulated advisers saw no direct change. Broker-dealers stayed under FINRA’s rules. In our reading, firms with both bank and brokerage affiliates would have run different arbitration regimes by affiliate in any case. The disapproval kept the bank side closer to the brokerage side in one respect: both could use arbitration, but only the brokerage side faced FINRA’s class-action rule.
Auto lenders and lessors
The rule covered automobile leases and consumer credit, which includes auto finance. It excluded persons to the extent they were outside the Bureau’s rulemaking authority, citing 12 U.S.C. 5517 and 5519. In our reading, that would leave out dealers who fall outside that authority, while reaching lenders and lessors within it. The disapproval left auto finance agreements as they were. Lenders serving servicemembers still faced the Military Lending Act’s separate limits where they applied.
Objections, in order
The argument that the disapproval removed both halves in one law, and that losing the records half mattered, faces objections. We take the strongest six in order.
1. The records half was a means to the class-action end, so its loss is incidental
The Bureau linked the two, but the records half stood on its own. It applied to arbitrations and court filings whether or not class actions followed. It would have shown outcomes, fee failures and fairness findings. Those are useful to supervision whatever the class-action rule. Losing them was a separate loss.
2. The Bureau could collect the same information through supervision
It can request records from supervised firms. That is one firm at a time, and it is not public. The rule would have built a market-wide, public dataset. Supervision cannot replace that without a rule. In our reading, a market-wide collection by rule is exactly what the substantially-the-same bar makes risky.
3. Publishing arbitration records threatened consumer privacy
The rule required redaction by providers and further redaction by the Bureau. Redaction of unstructured documents is hard, and errors are possible. That is a real concern about implementation. It is not a reason the records half had to fall with the class-action half. A separate rule could have addressed privacy differently.
4. Congress decided, so further analysis is moot
Congress decided the rule’s fate. Firms still decide their own contracts and dispute programs. Regulators still decide what to examine. Understanding what was lost helps each of them choose what to track. The decision closed one path; it did not settle what firms should do.
5. The bar is uncertain, so a records-only rule remains possible
It may be possible. The uncertainty is part of the effect we describe. Hindsight shows the Bureau’s later approach. Its 2023 proposal on contract terms chose not to collect arbitration agreement contents at all. That proposal was later withdrawn.
6. Firms will not keep records nobody requires
Some may not. But a firm defending its arbitration program before a regulator, a court or its own board will need the facts. Tracking disputes, fees and outcomes is cheap compared with reconstructing them under pressure. In our reading, the absence of a federal duty changes who benefits from the record, not whether it is useful.
What a chief compliance officer could check
The disapproval left firms in covered markets free to use arbitration and class waivers, with no federal records duty. That freedom carries its own compliance work. The history suggests a short set of checks:
- Keep version control on every consumer agreement, so you can show which dispute terms applied to each account and when.
- Track every arbitration and court motion to compel arbitration, with outcomes, fees paid and any administrator findings on fairness.
- Map which products and affiliates fall under FINRA, the Military Lending Act or other arbitration limits, and apply the right terms to each.
- Review inherited agreements in acquired or serviced portfolios, and know what dispute terms they contain.
- Report arbitration outcomes to the board, as the rule would have made them public in summary form.
- Keep the redaction and intake processes you built for the rule, if any, since they serve litigation holds and privacy reviews as well.
Each check also serves a firm that never used arbitration. Agreement version control matters for any contract term. Dispute tracking matters for any litigation risk. Mapping regimes by affiliate matters wherever a group spans banking and brokerage. The rule’s disappearance did not remove the reasons to know these things. It removed one external reason. The internal reasons, knowing the firm’s own exposure and treating customers consistently, were never in the rule and did not leave with it.
These checks give a compliance officer facts the rule would have required anyway: how many disputes, how they ended, and what terms governed them. In our view, a firm that keeps its own arbitration record would be ready for any future rule, whether it comes by new legislation or by a narrower path the bar allows.
With hindsight
The Bureau completed the removal that month. In a document dated November 15, 2017, and published November 22, 2017, it removed part 1040 from the Code of Federal Regulations. It said that under the joint resolution and by operation of the Congressional Review Act, the rule had no force or effect.
The removal notice restated what had been lost. It said the rule would have prohibited providers from using pre-dispute arbitration agreements to block consumer class actions. It said the rule would have required providers to redact and submit certain arbitral and court records, and required the Bureau to publish them on its website. It said the rule would have applied only to agreements entered after March 19, 2018.
The notice recounted the votes as well: the House on July 25, 2017, the Senate on October 24, 2017, and the signature on November 1, 2017. It cited Public Law 115-74 and the Congressional Review Act as the authority for removing part 1040.
The notice also said the action was not an exercise of the Bureau’s rulemaking authority under the Administrative Procedure Act. The Bureau said it was effectuating changes to the Code to reflect what congressional action had already accomplished. It did not seek comment.
The Bureau returned to contract terms in 2023, from a different angle. On February 1, 2023, it proposed a registry of supervised nonbanks that use form contracts with terms that waive or limit consumer legal protections. Nonbanks would register each year and report covered terms. The Bureau proposed to publish information identifying registrants and their use of such terms.
The proposed covered terms ranged widely. They included waivers of claims, limits on the company’s liability, limits on where and when a consumer could sue, limits on class actions, limits on complaints and reviews, and arbitration agreements. Covered terms would count whether or not they were legally enforceable.
The proposal listed arbitration agreements among covered terms, but chose not to collect their contents. It said substantial information was available about the generalized risks of arbitration agreements. It named two: class actions are not available, and decisions in individual arbitration generally are not public. It said those risks remained after the Bureau’s 2017 rulemaking to address them was voided by a joint resolution of Congress. It cited the November 2017 removal notice.
On October 29, 2025, the Bureau withdrew that proposal. It said legislative rulemaking was not necessary or appropriate at that time and that it would take no further action on it. As checked on November 15, 2026, that withdrawal is the latest Bureau action on these terms that we cite.
What held up is the shape of the outcome. The class-action ban did not return. The records half did not return in the Bureau documents we cite. Its 2023 proposal described the lack of public arbitration decisions as a remaining risk and then declined to collect arbitration content. In our reading, the one-sentence law of November 1, 2017 removed both the rule and the public record it would have built.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.