Comparison tables

CFTC system safeguards testing and recovery rules compared across exchanges, SEFs, clearing houses and swap data repositories

CFTC system safeguards testing and recovery rules compared across exchanges, SEFs, clearing houses and swap data repositories Each number links to the cell's source. Cells checked unless the cell shows another date.
Registered entityRuleVulnerability testingExternal penetration testingInternal penetration testingKey controls testingIncident response plan testing and enterprise technology risk assessmentRecovery timePrompt notice to Commission staff
Designated contract market (not covered)1Rule17 CFR 38.10511Vulnerability testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; no fixed minimum1External penetration testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; by independent contractors or by employees not responsible for development or operation of the systems tested1Internal penetration testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; no fixed minimum1Key controls testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; may be done on a rolling basis1Incident response plan testing and enterprise technology risk assessmentAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; no fixed minimum for either1Recovery timeResume trading and clearing during the next business day following a disruption (applies to a designated contract market not determined by the Commission to be a critical financial market)1Prompt notice to Commission staffElectronic trading halts and significant systems malfunctions; cyber security incidents or targeted threats that actually or potentially jeopardize automated system operation, reliability, security, or capacity; activation of the business continuity-disaster recovery plan1
Covered designated contract market (annual trading volume of 5% or more of the combined volume of all designated contract markets, in calendar year 2015 or any later year)1Rule17 CFR 38.10511Vulnerability testingNo less frequently than quarterly1External penetration testingNo less frequently than annually; the required annual test by independent contractors1Internal penetration testingNo less frequently than annually1Key controls testingKey controls no less frequently than every three years (rolling basis allowed), with independent contractors testing and assessing key controls no less frequently than every three years1Incident response plan testing and enterprise technology risk assessmentBoth no less frequently than annually1Recovery timeResume trading and clearing during the next business day following a disruption (applies to a designated contract market not determined by the Commission to be a critical financial market)1Prompt notice to Commission staffSame as other designated contract markets1
Swap execution facility2Rule17 CFR 37.14012Vulnerability testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; no fixed minimum2External penetration testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; no fixed minimum2Internal penetration testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; no fixed minimum2Key controls testingAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; may be done on a rolling basis2Incident response plan testing and enterprise technology risk assessmentAt a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis; no fixed minimum for either2Recovery timeResume operations and ongoing fulfillment of its responsibilities and obligations during the next business day following any disruption (applies to a swap execution facility not determined by the Commission to be a critical financial market)2Prompt notice to Commission staffElectronic trading halts and material system malfunctions; cyber security incidents or targeted threats that actually or potentially jeopardize automated system operation, reliability, security, or capacity; activations of the business continuity-disaster recovery plan2
Derivatives clearing organization3Rule17 CFR 39.183Vulnerability testingNo less frequently than quarterly3External penetration testingNo less frequently than annually; the required annual test by independent contractors3Internal penetration testingNo less frequently than annually3Key controls testingKey controls no less frequently than every three years, with independent contractors testing and assessing key controls no less frequently than every three years3Incident response plan testing and enterprise technology risk assessmentBoth no less frequently than annually3Recovery timeRecovery time objective of no later than the next business day following a disruption3Prompt notice to Commission staffTo staff of the Division of Clearing and Risk: any hardware or software malfunction, security incident, or targeted threat that materially impairs, or creates a significant likelihood of material impairment of, automated system operation, reliability, security, or capacity; any activation of the business continuity and disaster recovery plan3
Systemically important derivatives clearing organization or subpart C derivatives clearing organization4Rule17 CFR 39.34, in addition to 39.184Vulnerability testingAs for other derivatives clearing organizations (39.18)3External penetration testingAs for other derivatives clearing organizations (39.18)3Internal penetration testingAs for other derivatives clearing organizations (39.18)3Key controls testingAs for other derivatives clearing organizations (39.18)3Incident response plan testing and enterprise technology risk assessmentAs for other derivatives clearing organizations (39.18)3Recovery timeRecover operations and resume daily processing, clearing, and settlement no later than two hours following the disruption, for any disruption including a wide-scale disruption4Prompt notice to Commission staffAs for other derivatives clearing organizations (39.18)3
Swap data repository5Rule17 CFR 49.245Vulnerability testingNo less frequently than quarterly5External penetration testingNo less frequently than annually; the required annual test by independent contractors5Internal penetration testingNo less frequently than annually5Key controls testingKey controls no less frequently than every three years (rolling basis allowed), with independent contractors testing and assessing key controls no less frequently than every three years5Incident response plan testing and enterprise technology risk assessmentBoth no less frequently than annually5Recovery timeResume operations and duties during the next business day following a disruption (a swap data repository not determined to be critical); a swap data repository the Commission determines is critical must achieve a same-day recovery time objective, within the same business day5Prompt notice to Commission staffSystems malfunctions; cyber security incidents or targeted threats that actually or potentially jeopardize automated system operation, reliability, security, or capacity; any activation of the business continuity-disaster recovery plan5

Get the data: CSV · JSON

License: CC BY 4.0. Underlying government texts are public domain or under their own terms. Attribute "Moraph Insights" with a link to the page.

Method

Sections 37.1401, 38.1051, 39.18, 39.34 and 49.24 of title 17 were read in the current eCFR text (versioner API, text up to date as of 2026-11-12) on 2026-11-14. Frequencies, recovery times and notice triggers are copied or closely paraphrased from that text. Definitions of each test, scope requirements, recordkeeping, reporting of test results to the board, and the CFTC's other system safeguards provisions (for example 17 CFR 40.9 for critical financial markets) are not compared. Rules for futures commission merchants and swap dealers are outside this table.

Notes

  • Where a rule says a test is done at a frequency determined by an appropriate risk analysis and adds no minimum, the cell says no fixed minimum.
  • Designated contract markets that are not covered, and swap execution facilities, may use independent contractors or employees who are not responsible for development or operation of the systems tested.

Sources

  1. Commodity Futures Trading Commission. 17 CFR 38.1051, General requirements (designated contract markets, Core Principle 20, system safeguards). Checked .
  2. Commodity Futures Trading Commission. 17 CFR 37.1401, Requirements (swap execution facilities, Core Principle 14, system safeguards). Checked .
  3. Commodity Futures Trading Commission. 17 CFR 39.18, System safeguards (derivatives clearing organizations). Checked .
  4. Commodity Futures Trading Commission. 17 CFR 39.34, System safeguards for systemically important derivatives clearing organizations and subpart C derivatives clearing organizations. Checked .
  5. Commodity Futures Trading Commission. 17 CFR 49.24, System safeguards (swap data repositories). Checked .

How we source and check every fact: Editorial standards · Corrections

Last reviewed .

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the table where needed.