Encryption requirements at rest and in transit compared
| Rule | Required or addressable | Standard named | Safe harbor | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HIPAA Security Rule (current)1 | Required or addressableAddressable, at rest and in transit: implement a mechanism to encrypt and decrypt ePHI, and to encrypt ePHI in transmission whenever deemed appropriate. Addressable means implement it if reasonable and appropriate, or document why not and use an equivalent alternative if reasonable and appropriate.1 | Standard namedNone named in the rule. It defines encryption as an algorithmic process giving a low probability of assigning meaning without a confidential process or key (164.304).1 | Safe harborYes. Breach notification applies only to unsecured PHI (45 CFR 164.402). HHS guidance names encryption consistent with NIST SP 800-111 for data at rest, and NIST SP 800-52, 800-77, 800-113 or FIPS 140-2 validated processes for data in motion, with the key not breached.2 | Citation45 CFR 164.304, 164.306(d)(3), 164.312(a)(2)(iv), 164.312(e)(2)(ii)1 |
| HIPAA Security Rule (proposed update)3 | Required or addressableProposed, not in force: encrypt all ePHI at rest and in transit, with listed exceptions. As of 2026-11-14 the Federal Register shows no final rule.3 | Standard namedEncryption that meets prevailing cryptographic standards3 | Safe harborThe proposal does not amend the breach notification rule (45 CFR part 164, subpart D); it amends 45 CFR 160.103 and the Security Rule (subpart C)3 | CitationProposed 45 CFR 164.312(b), 90 FR 8983 |
| FTC Safeguards Rule4 | Required or addressableRequired: encrypt all customer information held or transmitted, in transit over external networks and at rest. Where encryption is infeasible, effective alternative compensating controls reviewed and approved by the Qualified Individual.4 | Standard namedNone named. Encryption must be consistent with current cryptographic standards and come with appropriate safeguards for key material.5 | Safe harborYes, for FTC notification: a notification event is acquisition of unencrypted customer information. Data counts as unencrypted if the key was accessed.5 | Citation16 CFR 314.4(c)(3); 314.2(f) and (m)4 |
| NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulation6 | Required or addressableRequired: a written policy requiring encryption of nonpublic information in transit over external networks and at rest. If encryption at rest is infeasible, compensating controls approved in writing by the CISO; the CISO reviews feasibility and effectiveness at least annually.6 | Standard namedEncryption that meets industry standards6 | Safe harborNone stated in 500.156 | Citation23 NYCRR 500.156 |
| FIPS 140-3 (federal agencies)7 | Required or addressableApplies to all federal agencies that use cryptographic-based security systems to protect sensitive information; it shall be used in designing and implementing cryptographic modules that agencies operate or have operated for them under contract7 | Standard namedFIPS 140-3, four security levels for cryptographic modules7 | Safe harborNone. The standard's requirements cover the design, implementation and operation of cryptographic modules, not breach notification.7 | CitationFIPS 140-3 (March 22, 2019)7 |
| Executive Order 140288 | Required or addressableAgencies shall adopt encryption for data at rest and in transit, to the maximum extent consistent with federal records laws and other applicable laws, within 180 days of May 12, 20218 | Standard namedNone named in section 3(d)8 | Safe harborNot addressed in section 3(d)8 | CitationExecutive Order 14028, sec. 3(d)8 |
| IRS Publication 10759 | Required or addressableRequired for federal tax information: cryptographic protection in transit (SC-8) and at rest on end-user devices and portable storage (SC-28); in the cloud, encrypted in transit and at rest9 | Standard namedLatest FIPS 140 validated encryption; NIST SP 800-52 for TLS. SHA-1 for digital signatures is prohibited.9 | Safe harborNone stated: the incident reporting section (1.8) has no exception for encrypted FTI. Separately, in the cloud, using FIPS 140 certified encryption at rest exempts third-party contractors from some protection requirements, such as training and background investigations.9 | CitationIRS Publication 1075, SC-8, SC-13, SC-28; section 1.8; cloud computing requirements9 |
| CJIS Security Policy (version 6.1)12 | Required or addressableRequired for criminal justice information (CJI): cryptographic mechanisms to prevent unauthorized disclosure of CJI in transmission (SC-8(1)), and of CJI at rest on systems and digital media outside physically secure locations (SC-28(1))12 | Standard namedFIPS 140-3 certified modules, or FIPS 197 (AES), with a symmetric key of at least 256 bits in transit and at rest (version 6.0 allowed 128 bits in transit and for FIPS 140-3 modules at rest). The policy says FIPS 140-2 certificates are not acceptable after September 21, 202612 | Safe harborNot addressed in SC-8, SC-13 or SC-2812 | CitationCJIS Security Policy v6.1, SC-8(1), SC-13, SC-28 and SC-28(1)12 |
| GLBA Interagency Guidelines Establishing Information Security Standards10 | Required or addressableA measure each bank must consider and adopt if it concludes it is appropriate: encryption of electronic customer information, including in transit or in storage on networks or systems unauthorized people may access10 | Standard namedNone named10 | Safe harborNot addressed in the guidelines' encryption measure10 | Citation12 CFR part 30, appendix B, III.C.1.c (OCC text)10 |
| FTC Health Breach Notification Rule11 | Required or addressableNo encryption requirement in the rule11 | Standard namedRefers to the HHS guidance on technologies and methods that secure information11 | Safe harborYes. Notification applies to unsecured information: information not protected by a technology or method in the HHS guidance under section 13402(h)(2) of the 2009 Recovery Act.11 | Citation16 CFR 318.2 (definition of unsecured)11 |
License: CC BY 4.0. Underlying government texts are public domain or under their own terms. Attribute "Moraph Insights" with a link to the page.
Method
We read each rule in its official source: the eCFR for federal regulations, the Federal Register for the executive order, the HIPAA proposal and HHS's 2009 encryption guidance, the NYDFS copy of Part 500, NIST's FIPS 140-3 page, the IRS's current Publication 1075 and the FBI's CJIS Security Policy version 6.1 PDF (dated 06/25/2026, opened on 2026-11-14; the FBI's CJIS resource center page blocks automated access, so whether a version later than 6.1 exists could not be checked). Version 6.1 raised the CJIS minimum symmetric key from 128 to 256 bits for CJI in transit and for FIPS 140-3 modules at rest. Cells were first checked on 2026-11-13 (the CJIS row on 2026-11-14), and every cell was re-checked on 2026-11-14 against its source. The HIPAA Security Rule is cited from the eCFR text of 45 CFR part 164, subpart C. Safe harbor means a rule where encrypted data falls outside a notification duty. Sources we could not open or cite were left out (see Omitted). This table explains the rules; it is not legal advice.
Omitted
What was left out, and why.
- A row left out: No single primary source summarizes state breach-law encryption safe harbors; a summary row would rest on secondary compilations.
Notes
- The HHS guidance is cited from its 2009 Federal Register text; the HHS web page that carries the current guidance blocked automated access on 2026-11-13.
- The GLBA guidelines are shown in the OCC's text; the Federal Reserve and FDIC publish their own versions in their rules.
- NYDFS publishes the amended Part 500 on its website with a note that its copy is not an official version.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 45 CFR part 164, subpart C, Security Standards (HIPAA Security Rule): 164.304, 164.306(d) and 164.312. Checked .
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Breach Notification for Unsecured Protected Health Information, interim final rule with guidance on technologies that render PHI unusable (74 FR 42740). Checked .
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. HIPAA Security Rule To Strengthen the Cybersecurity of Electronic Protected Health Information, proposed rule (90 FR 898). Checked .
- Federal Trade Commission. 16 CFR 314.4(c)(3), Standards for Safeguarding Customer Information. Checked .
- Federal Trade Commission. 16 CFR 314.2, Definitions (encryption; notification event). Checked .
- New York State Department of Financial Services. 23 NYCRR 500.15, Second Amendment text (DFS copy; DFS notes it is not an official version). Checked .
- National Institute of Standards and Technology. FIPS 140-3, Security Requirements for Cryptographic Modules. Checked .
- Executive Office of the President (published by the Office of the Federal Register). Executive Order 14028, Improving the Nation's Cybersecurity, section 3(d) (86 FR 26633). Checked .
- Internal Revenue Service. IRS Publication 1075 (Rev. 11-2021), Tax Information Security Guidelines for Federal, State and Local Agencies, controls SC-8, SC-13, SC-28, section 1.8 and cloud requirements. Checked .
- Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. 12 CFR part 30, appendix B, Interagency Guidelines Establishing Information Security Standards (OCC text). Checked .
- Federal Trade Commission. 16 CFR 318.2, Health Breach Notification Rule definitions. Checked .
- Federal Bureau of Investigation, Criminal Justice Information Services Division. Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) Security Policy, Version 6.1 (06/25/2026), controls SC-8(1), SC-13 and SC-28(1). Checked .
How we source and check every fact: Editorial standards · Corrections
Last reviewed .
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the table where needed.