The 2024 HIPAA reproductive health privacy rule after the Purl vacatur, explained
A federal court vacated most of the 2024 HIPAA reproductive health care privacy rule in June 2025 but left most of its notice of privacy practices changes standing. The official code text still prints the vacated provisions, so compliance teams have to read the court order beside the eCFR.
In April 2024 the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) amended the HIPAA Privacy Rule to add protections for health information about reproductive health care [1]. On June 18, 2025, a federal court vacated most of it [2]. Three things now matter to a privacy officer: what the rule did, what the court removed and what it kept, and why the published code text does not match the court’s order.
What the 2024 rule did
HHS published the final rule, titled HIPAA Privacy Rule To Support Reproductive Health Care Privacy, on April 26, 2024, at 89 FR 32976 [1]. It took effect on June 25, 2024 [1]. Regulated entities had to comply by December 23, 2024, except with the changes to 45 CFR 164.520, the notice of privacy practices section, for which the compliance date was February 16, 2026 [1].
The rule’s core was a new prohibition, placed at 45 CFR 164.502(a)(5)(iii), on certain uses and disclosures of protected health information, and a new attestation requirement at 45 CFR 164.509 [6] [3]. Under section 164.509, a covered entity or business associate may not use or disclose protected health information potentially related to reproductive health care for purposes in section 164.512(d), (e), (f) or (g)(1) without first obtaining a valid attestation from the person making the request [3]. A valid attestation verifies that the use or disclosure is not otherwise prohibited by section 164.502(a)(5)(iii) [3]. The text lists defects that make an attestation invalid, including a missing required element, an added element that is not required, and actual knowledge that material information in it is false [3]. An attestation may not be combined with other documents, with narrow exceptions [3].
The rule also changed the notice of privacy practices [1] [4]. Paragraph (b)(1)(ii)(F) of section 164.520 requires a description, with at least one example, of the uses and disclosures prohibited under section 164.502(a)(5)(iii) [4]. Paragraph (G) requires a description, with an example, of the uses and disclosures that need an attestation under section 164.509 [4]. Paragraph (H) requires a statement that information disclosed under the Privacy Rule may be redisclosed by the recipient and no longer protected [4].
What the court vacated and what it kept
The rule was challenged in the Northern District of Texas, in Purl v. United States Department of Health and Human Services, No. 2:24-cv-228-Z [2]. On June 18, 2025, the court granted the plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment [2]. It held that the rule was contrary to law because it limited state public health laws, that it redefined “person” and “public health” in contravention of federal law and in excess of statutory authority, and that under the major-questions doctrine it claimed authority Congress had not expressly delegated [2].
The order vacated the 2024 rule’s modifications to 45 CFR parts 160 and 164 as promulgated at 89 FR 32976 to 33066 [2]. That reaches the prohibition, the attestation section and the rule’s other changes to those parts [2] [3] [6]. The court then treated section 164.520 differently [2]. It found that regulated entities could carry out the notice changes without the provisions tied to the parts it held unlawful, and noted that those changes had their own compliance date [2]. It severed the modifications to section 164.520 and ordered that they stand, except paragraphs (b)(1)(ii)(F), (G) and (H), which it vacated because, in its reading, HHS did not intend them to remain without the rest of the rule [2].
The result is a split outcome. The reproductive health prohibition and the attestation requirement are vacated [2]. The notice changes, other than the three vacated paragraphs, are left in place, with the February 16, 2026 compliance date that the 2024 rule set for them [1] [2].
What the notice text still requires
The current text of section 164.520 includes notice requirements that refer to 42 CFR part 2, the federal rules on substance use disorder treatment records [4]. If a use or disclosure described in the notice is prohibited or materially limited by other applicable law, such as 42 CFR part 2, the description must reflect the more stringent law [4]. The description of each purpose must include enough detail to put the individual on notice of what the Privacy Rule and other applicable law, such as part 2, permit or require [4].
Two separate statements in paragraph (b)(1)(iii) concern part 2 records [4]. One says that substance use disorder treatment records received from part 2 programs, or testimony relaying their content, may not be used or disclosed in civil, criminal, administrative or legislative proceedings against the individual without written consent or a court order that meets the conditions in part 2 [4]. The other applies when a covered entity that creates or maintains part 2 records intends to use or disclose them for its own fundraising: the individual must first be given a clear and conspicuous opportunity to opt out of fundraising communications [4].
These part 2 references arrived with the 2024 rule. Its amendatory text revised and republished paragraphs (a) and (b) of section 164.520 [1], and the eCFR text of the section as of April 25, 2024, the day before the rule was published, contains no reference to 42 CFR part 2 [5]. They are therefore among the 2024 notice changes that the court severed and left standing, apart from the three vacated paragraphs [2]. The opinion notes that the rule’s notice changes reflected changes required by section 3221(i) of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act [2].
Where the code text and the court order part ways
The electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) still prints the vacated provisions [3] [4]. As checked on November 14, 2026, the eCFR text for November 12, 2026 includes section 164.509 with its attestation requirement [3]. It also includes paragraphs (b)(1)(ii)(F), (G) and (H) of section 164.520, which the court vacated [4]. The two sources therefore conflict: the court order says these provisions are vacated [2], and the code text a reader sees does not show that [3] [4].
HHS describes the order the same way on its reproductive health page, as archived on November 3, 2026: the court vacated only paragraphs (b)(1)(ii)(F), (G) and (H) of section 164.520, the remaining notice changes stay in effect, and compliance with them was required by February 16, 2026 [7]. The page says HHS will determine next steps after a thorough review of the decision [7]. We did not find a Federal Register document from HHS removing the vacated text, and we did not confirm whether the judgment was appealed. Those points are left out here for that reason.
For compliance work, the conflict has three practical effects:
- Policies and workflows built on the attestation requirement in section 164.509 rest on text the court vacated [2] [3].
- Notice of privacy practices language based on paragraphs (b)(1)(ii)(F) to (H) of section 164.520 reflects vacated paragraphs, even though they still appear in the eCFR [2] [4].
- The remaining notice changes from the 2024 rule were not vacated, and their compliance date was February 16, 2026 [1] [2].
The case challenged the 2024 rule, not the Privacy Rule that came before it [2]. The court’s order addresses the 2024 rule’s modifications and does not vacate the Privacy Rule as it stood before them [2].
State laws on reproductive health information vary and are outside this explainer. This explainer describes the rule and the court’s order; it is not legal advice, and organizations should confirm with counsel how the order applies to their notices, policies and disclosure workflows.
Moraph’s teams help organizations with work like this. See our solutions.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the explainer where needed.