Information blocking: OIG penalties for developers and networks, and CMS disincentives for providers

Providers, certified health IT developers, and health information networks and exchanges have been subject to the information blocking rules since April 5, 2021. OIG may fine developers, networks and exchanges up to $1,000,000 per violation; providers face disincentives under a rule effective July 31, 2024.

The information blocking rules come from the 21st Century Cures Act. ONC wrote the definitions and exceptions in 45 CFR part 171. Enforcement runs on two tracks: civil money penalties imposed by the HHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) on developers, networks and exchanges, and disincentives that other agencies apply to health care providers that OIG refers to them [2] [4].

Who the rules cover, and what counts as information blocking

Part 171 applies to four kinds of actor, as defined in section 171.102: health care providers, health IT developers of certified health IT, health information exchanges and health information networks. They have been subject to it on and after April 5, 2021 [1]. A health information network or exchange is defined by function: an individual or entity that controls or administers the policies or agreements that enable exchange among more than two unaffiliated parties for treatment, payment or health care operations purposes, among other conditions [1].

Information blocking is a practice that, unless required by law or covered by an exception, is likely to interfere with access, exchange or use of electronic health information. The knowledge standard differs by actor [1]:

  • a developer, network or exchange is covered if it knows, or should know, that the practice is likely to interfere;
  • a health care provider is covered if it knows that the practice is unreasonable and is likely to interfere.

The exceptions

A practice that meets every condition of an exception at all relevant times is not information blocking. Part 171 groups them in three subparts [1]:

  • Not fulfilling requests (subpart B): preventing harm, privacy, security, infeasibility, health IT performance, and protecting care access.
  • Procedures for fulfilling requests (subpart C): manner, fees, and licensing.
  • TEFCA participation (subpart D): the TEFCA manner exception in 171.403, for an actor that fulfills a request only via TEFCA when both parties are part of TEFCA and other conditions are met.

Each exception has its own conditions, and an actor relying on one has to meet all of them. In our view, the documentation that shows those conditions were met at the time is as important as the practice itself; that is a practice point, not a requirement stated in the rule.

OIG civil money penalties: developers, networks and exchanges

OIG’s penalty rule was published July 3, 2023. It took effect August 2, 2023, except for the information blocking sections, 42 CFR 1003.1400, 1003.1410 and 1003.1420, which took effect September 1, 2023 [3].

  • Who. Section 1003.1400 lets OIG impose a penalty on any individual or entity described in 45 CFR 171.103(a)(2) that commits information blocking [2]. The rule’s preamble explains that the Cures Act authorizes these penalties for health IT developers of certified health IT or other entities offering certified health IT, health information exchanges and health information networks [3]. Part 171 has since been reorganized, and the developer, network and exchange standard now appears at 171.103(b)(1) [1]; the eCFR text of 1003.1400 we checked still cites (a)(2) [2].
  • How much. Not more than $1,000,000 per violation. A violation is a practice, as defined in 171.102, that constitutes information blocking [2].
  • How OIG sets the amount. Section 1003.1420 directs OIG to consider the nature and extent of the information blocking and the harm it caused, including where applicable the number of patients affected, the number of providers affected and the number of days the information blocking persisted [2].

OIG says the penalty rule does not impose new information blocking requirements; it relies on ONC’s regulations [5]. OIG lists five enforcement priorities for selecting cases for investigation: conduct that resulted in, is causing or could have caused patient harm; that significantly affected a provider’s ability to care for patients; that was of long duration; that caused financial loss to federal health care programs or other government or private entities; or that was done with actual knowledge [5]. Its published process runs from complaint to investigation, an opportunity for the entity to discuss OIG’s investigation, a demand letter if OIG concludes there was information blocking, and an opportunity to appeal [5]. Complaints can go through ONC’s Information Blocking Portal or the OIG Hotline [5].

Disincentives for health care providers

The disincentives rule, published July 1, 2024 and effective July 31, 2024, implements the Cures Act provision that a provider OIG determines has committed information blocking is referred to the appropriate agency for disincentives [4]. It sets disincentives for certain providers that are also Medicare-enrolled providers or suppliers, and the agencies state that it does not establish disincentives for every provider in the part 171 definition [4]. The disincentives in 45 CFR 171.1001 are [1]:

  • Eligible hospitals and critical access hospitals: not a meaningful EHR user. The rule explains that an eligible hospital then cannot earn the three quarters of the annual market basket increase tied to that status, and a critical access hospital’s payment drops to 100 percent of reasonable costs from the 101 percent it might otherwise earn [4].
  • MIPS eligible clinicians, including groups: not a meaningful EHR user for MIPS, so a clinician required to report the Promoting Interoperability category earns a zero score in it, which the rule says is typically a quarter of the final score [4].
  • Medicare Shared Savings Program: an ACO, ACO participant or ACO provider/supplier will be removed from, or denied approval to participate in, the program for at least one year [1].

The hospital and MIPS disincentives apply when OIG refers the determination during the calendar year of the reporting period [4]. The agency imposing a disincentive must send the provider a notice describing the practice, the basis for the disincentive, its effect and how it will be implemented [1].

Public posting

Subpart K of part 171 requires ONC to post on its public website information about actors OIG has determined committed information blocking. For providers this includes the name, business address, the practice and when it occurred, and the disincentives applied, and it is not posted before a disincentive is imposed or before any administrative appeals process the provider pursues is complete [1]. Subpart K was added by the disincentives rule and also covers developers, networks and exchanges that OIG determines have committed information blocking; their information is not posted until OIG enters into a resolution of penalty liability or a penalty becomes final [1] [4].

We read part 171 and 42 CFR part 1003 subpart N as shown in the eCFR on November 14, 2026 [1] [2]. This explainer describes the rules; it is not legal advice, and organizations should confirm with counsel how they apply to them.

Moraph’s teams help organizations with work like this. See our solutions.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the explainer where needed.

  • information blocking
  • 45 CFR part 171
  • OIG
  • civil money penalties
  • 42 CFR part 1003
  • disincentives
  • 21st Century Cures Act