Bank third-party risk guidance: the 2023 interagency guidance and the 2026 proposal to replace it, explained

The 2023 interagency guidance still governs how banks manage vendors and partners. A September 2026 proposal from the OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC and NCUA would replace it with shorter, explicitly non-binding guidance built on risk tiering. On November 13, 2026 the agencies extended the comment period to December 16.

What the 2023 guidance says

In June 2023 the Federal Reserve Board, the FDIC and the OCC issued joint final guidance on managing risks from third-party relationships. It is directed to all banking organizations the three agencies supervise and replaced each agency’s existing general guidance: the Board’s 2013 guidance, the FDIC’s 2008 guidance, and the OCC’s 2013 guidance and 2020 frequently asked questions [1]. The guidance was final as of June 6, 2023 [1].

The 2023 guidance is organized around a life cycle for each relationship [1]:

  1. planning;
  2. due diligence and third-party selection;
  3. contract negotiation;
  4. ongoing monitoring;
  5. termination.

It adds governance (oversight and accountability, independent reviews, documentation and reporting) and a section on supervisory reviews of third-party relationships [1]. The agencies described the guidance as principles-based, with examples that are illustrative, and said sound risk management takes into account the banking organization’s level of risk, complexity and size and the nature of the relationship [1].

A central idea is the critical activity. In the final text the agencies dropped concepts such as “significant investment” and “significant bank function” and pointed instead to activities that could cause significant risk if the third party fails to meet expectations, or that have significant impacts on customers or on the bank’s financial condition or operations. They noted that an activity critical for one bank may not be critical for another [1]. When critical activities are involved, plans may be presented to and approved by the board or a board committee [1].

Why the agencies now want to replace it

The 2026 proposal says the agencies still see the principles-based approach of 2023 as relevant, but that the 2023 guidance “frequently has been interpreted in an overly broad manner and with an insufficient focus on tailoring” [2]. It gives four reasons [2]:

  • Breadth. Because it addresses a wide range of relationships, banks reported struggling to see which considerations apply to which context, for example core providers compared with fintechs or facilities maintenance vendors.
  • Focus on the activity. The critical-activities concept looks at the activity more than at the relationship or the magnitude and likelihood of harm, and banks reported applying heightened practices to many relationships regardless of actual risk.
  • Read as prescriptive. The 2023 text has been interpreted as setting prescriptive requirements. The agencies say words like “should” in its examples failed to convey the importance of tailoring, and that it encouraged process-driven approaches that fail to prioritize higher-risk relationships.
  • Read as discouraging newer firms. The agencies say the 2023 text suggested newer and innovative third parties present elevated risks, and cite Executive Order 14405, “Integrating Financial Technology Innovation into Regulatory Frameworks” (91 FR 30475, May 19, 2026).

What the proposal would put in its place

The proposed guidance is organized around four components instead of a life cycle [2]:

  1. Risk identification and assessment: identifying and categorizing relationships, identifying relevant risks, and assessing them.
  2. Risk oversight proportionate to significance: due diligence and selection, contract negotiation, ongoing monitoring, termination and cross-cutting topics.
  3. Residual risk acceptance.
  4. Governance.

Several points in the text change the working assumptions of a vendor management program:

  • Definition. A third-party relationship is a business arrangement for products, services or other activities that support the bank. The use of subcontractors alone does not typically create an independent third-party relationship or a presumption of direct oversight of subcontractors. A footnote asks whether the guidance should apply only to third parties under a written agreement [2].
  • Inventories. A large or complex bank may benefit from a detailed inventory mapped to business units; a community bank may benefit from a simpler one. Banks may decide not to keep extensive inventories of limited-risk relationships such as administrative tasks, professional support including audit and legal advice, and office support including physical security [2].
  • Residual risk. The agencies say they do not expect banks to eliminate third-party risk. The text recognizes that a bank may lack bargaining power to conduct full due diligence, negotiate custom contract terms or monitor in depth, and that a relationship may still be beneficial and necessary [2].
  • Governance. Banks may consider practices that set roles, risk appetite and tolerances, prioritization by assessed risk, reporting to senior management and the board, documentation, and periodic independent reviews. The text says there is no one right way to structure them [2].
  • Status. The proposal states that it does not set enforceable standards, that non-compliance with it will not result in supervisory action, and that deviation from it will not alone be a basis for supervisory action. The agencies may still act on violations of law, unsafe or unsound practices or other material risks resulting from insufficient management of third-party risk [2].

The proposal covers insured credit unions as well as banks, and the NCUA joins it [2]. The agencies’ announcement says the NCUA also plans to rescind its existing third-party risk management guidance and will conduct its own reviews to update related guidance [4].

What does not change

The proposal keeps one principle from the earlier guidance: a bank’s use of third parties does not diminish its responsibility to operate safely and soundly and comply with the law, to the same extent as if it performed the activity itself, including where the third party is an affiliate, a highly regulated service provider or a subcontractor [2].

The proposal also says what it would sweep away. Any finalized guidance would replace the 2023 guidance and the supplemental resources: OCC Bulletin 2002-16 on foreign-based service providers, the July 25, 2024 joint statement on arrangements with third parties to deliver deposit products, and the May 3, 2024 guide for community banks. The agencies also ask whether other guidance or interpretive letters should be rescinded [2]. Their announcement says the federal banking agencies plan to rescind the existing guidance when the proposal is finalized [4].

The community bank guide

Alongside the interagency proposal, the Federal Reserve Board proposed a guide for traditional community banking organizations. It would discuss the key risks those banks face in third-party relationships in general and in the categories of relationship most common to them [3]. Its comment deadline was also November 16, 2026 [3], and the Board extended it to December 16 [4].

Dates and status

  • June 6, 2023: the 2023 guidance became final; it was published June 9, 2023 [1].
  • September 15, 2026: the proposed interagency guidance and the Board’s community bank guide were published [2] [3].
  • November 13, 2026: the four agencies announced an extension of the comment period to December 16; comments had been due November 16 [4].

The proposal says OIRA determined it is not a significant regulatory action, and that the agencies expect it to be a deregulatory action under Executive Order 14192 if finalized as proposed [2]. As checked on November 14, 2026, the 2023 guidance has not been rescinded, and the final shape of its replacement depends on the comments.

In our view, the inventory and risk-tiering work a bank did under the 2023 guidance maps onto the proposal’s first component, so it is likely to remain useful under the final text. That is a practice view, not a requirement. The steps under the current guidance are in the companion third-party risk management checklist.

This explainer describes supervisory guidance; it is not legal advice, and institutions should confirm with counsel how it applies to them.

Moraph’s teams help organizations with work like this. See our solutions.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the explainer where needed.

  • OCC
  • Federal Reserve
  • FDIC
  • NCUA
  • third-party risk management
  • vendor management
  • supervisory guidance