Medicare’s affiliation rule made enrollment data the evidence
CMS’s September 2019 rule let it deny or revoke enrollment over a provider’s links to sanctioned parties. It planned to find those links in its own data first, so a health system’s own enrollment filings became the evidence that mattered.
Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.
Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article
CMS’s September 2019 rule let it deny or revoke enrollment over a provider’s links to sanctioned parties. It planned to find those links in its own data first, so a health system’s own enrollment filings became the evidence that mattered.
- The week On September 5, 2019, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services announced a final rule titled Program Integrity Enhancements to the Provider Enrollment Process, file code CMS-6058-FC.
- The relationships the rule counts The affiliations authority is broad by design.
- How CMS finds affiliations The statute let the Secretary decide the form, manner and timing of disclosure.
- The records a provider controls If CMS reasons from enrollment data, a provider’s best evidence is the accuracy of its own filings.
- Transactions and contracts that create affiliations Every acquisition, joint venture, management agreement and board appointment can create an affiliation.
- Where the argument is weakest The argument here is that the affiliations authority made enrollment data the evidence.
- With hindsight The affiliations authority was not expected to work as a mass disclosure program.
The week
On September 5, 2019, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services announced a final rule titled Program Integrity Enhancements to the Provider Enrollment Process, file code CMS-6058-FC. The rule was published in the Federal Register on September 10, 2019, at 84 FR 47794. It was a final rule with comment period, effective November 4, 2019, and CMS took further comments on its affiliation provisions until that same date. It finalized provisions proposed in a rule published on March 1, 2016.
The centerpiece was a new “affiliations” authority. The rule implemented section 1866(j)(5) of the Social Security Act, which the Affordable Care Act added. That provision says a provider or supplier that applies to enroll or revalidate in Medicare, Medicaid or CHIP shall disclose current or previous affiliations with providers or suppliers that have had certain problems. CMS calls those problems “disclosable events.” They are an uncollected debt to Medicare, Medicaid or CHIP, a payment suspension under a federal health care program, an exclusion by the HHS Office of Inspector General, and a denial, revocation or termination of enrollment. A voluntary termination made to avoid a revocation counts too. A payment suspension, exclusion, denial, revocation or termination counts regardless of when it happened, and a denial, revocation, termination, exclusion or debt counts even while it is under appeal.
The rule defined an affiliation in five ways. They were a direct or indirect ownership interest of 5 percent or more, any general or limited partnership interest, operational or managerial control over another organization, service as an officer or director of a corporation, and any reassignment of Medicare benefits. Disclosure would cover relationships that existed at the time or within the previous five years. If CMS found that an affiliation posed an “undue risk of fraud, waste, or abuse,” it could deny or revoke enrollment.
CMS did not start collecting these disclosures from everyone. It adopted what it called a phased-in approach. A provider would have to disclose affiliations only when CMS asked, and CMS would ask only after it had determined, from its own data, that the provider might have a disclosable affiliation. Requests would begin only after CMS revised the Form CMS-855 enrollment applications, on paper and in the online Provider Enrollment, Chain, and Ownership System (PECOS).
The rule reached beyond Medicare. Each state had to choose, in consultation with CMS, one of two options for Medicaid and CHIP. Under the first, every provider not enrolled in Medicare would disclose affiliations when enrolling or revalidating. Under the second, disclosure would follow a state request, made when the state and CMS had determined that a provider might have a reportable affiliation. A state could not change its selection once made.
The rule also added other grounds for denial or revocation. CMS could act against a provider that came back under a different name, billed from non-compliant locations, showed a pattern of abusive ordering or certifying, or had a debt referred to the Treasury. The maximum reenrollment bar rose from 3 years to 10, and to 20 years for a second revocation. CMS’s announcement described the package as a step toward stopping fraud before payment, rather than paying claims and recovering the money afterward. CMS could also extend a revocation to all of a provider’s other enrollments, including those held under different names, numerical identifiers or business identities.
The September 2019 rule read like a disclosure regime: providers would tell CMS about their relationships, and CMS would judge the risk. It ran, from the start, as a data regime. CMS would decide from its own records whether a provider might have a problem affiliation, and only then ask. In a November 2026 rule, CMS said it did not anticipate asking at all. For a health system, the evidence in an affiliation case was always going to be what it had already filed. This article takes the issue in five parts: the relationships the rule counts, how CMS finds them, the records a provider controls, the transactions and contracts that create new affiliations, and the limits of the argument.
The relationships the rule counts
The affiliations authority is broad by design. It reaches any provider or supplier enrolled in Medicare, and the rule extended matching requirements to Medicaid and CHIP through the states. Hospitals, physician groups, home health agencies, suppliers of durable medical equipment and individual clinicians all enroll through some version of the Form CMS-855. All of them can be affiliated with someone else.
Five kinds of link, four kinds of event
An affiliation exists only when two things are true. There has to be a relationship of one of the five defined types. And the other party has to have a disclosable event. The first four relationship types follow the enrollment rules’ existing definitions of “owner” and “managing employee,” so they were not new concepts to anyone who had filed an 855. What changed was the direction of the question. The form already asked who owned and ran the applicant. The affiliations rule asked what else those owners and managers owned and ran, and whether any of it had gone wrong.
The disclosable events are records that CMS, a state or another government body already holds. A debt to Medicare counts only when CMS or a state has sent notice of it, or when it is a civil money penalty or assessment. A payment suspension, an OIG exclusion and an enrollment revocation are all government actions. That design choice matters for the rest of the argument. The adverse half of every affiliation lives in government systems. Only the relationship half might need to come from the provider.
Events that do not expire
The five-year limit in the 2019 rule applied to the relationship, not to the event. A payment suspension counts regardless of when it occurred or was imposed. An OIG exclusion counts regardless of when it was imposed and whether it is being appealed. A denial, revocation or termination counts regardless of its reason, its age or a pending appeal. An uncollected debt counts regardless of its amount, whether it is being repaid, or whether it is being appealed.
That asymmetry shapes the evidence. A provider that was affiliated with another organization four years ago, for a short time, may still face a question about that organization’s revocation from a decade earlier. The defense would rest on facts about the relationship: when it started, when it ended, how deep it was and why it ended. The event itself would be settled.
Thresholds that commenters wanted raised
Commenters asked CMS to raise the 5 percent ownership threshold to 25 percent, 50 percent or a majority interest. They argued that a higher threshold would lower the burden on honest providers and focus attention on owners who could influence a provider’s conduct. They also pointed to the work of tracking every 5 percent interest. CMS kept the 5 percent figure, which matched the existing definition of an owner in the enrollment rules and the statute’s definition of an ownership or control interest.
The partnership test has no percentage at all. Any general or limited partnership interest counts. One commenter noted that the 855A at the time asked about limited partnership interests only at 10 percent or more, and CMS said it would consider whether to change the form. For an organization with physician partnerships, ambulatory surgery joint ventures or real estate partnerships, that gap between the definition and the form is the first sign of the problem this article describes: the rule could reach relationships the enrollment record did not hold.
Indirect ownership and layered structures
The ownership test covers direct and indirect interests of 5 percent or more. In a layered structure, that means looking through holding companies, management companies and investment vehicles to the people and organizations at each tier. A physician group owned by a holding company, which is owned in turn by an investment fund, has affiliations at every level where an interest reaches the threshold. Each of those owners may hold interests in other enrolled providers.
The enrollment form already asked about owners and managing organizations. The affiliations rule raised the value of getting that chain right, because each listed owner becomes a node CMS can follow. For a provider with a simple structure, the chain is short. For one with several tiers of ownership, the work is in keeping the chain current as interests are bought, sold and diluted. A change at a holding company two tiers up can be a change of ownership the provider has to report.
Voluntary terminations
The rule counted a voluntary termination as a disclosable event when it was made to avoid a revocation. CMS explained that some providers had terminated their own enrollment to escape a revocation and the reenrollment bar that follows. Commenters objected that many voluntary terminations are for innocuous reasons and pose no risk to federal health care programs. CMS kept the provision while acknowledging that legitimate terminations exist. The practical result is that the history of a closed entity can matter years later. An organization that winds down a subsidiary should keep a record of why.
How CMS finds affiliations
The statute let the Secretary decide the form, manner and timing of disclosure. CMS used that discretion to turn the obligation around. Instead of every applicant listing every affiliation, CMS would look first.
The data CMS said it would use
The rule described the review. CMS would research PECOS, which holds what providers report on initial applications, changes of information, revalidations and reactivations. It would also consider other CMS databases and external, non-CMS databases that could indicate behavior of concern, such as improper billing patterns. After that review, CMS would request disclosure from a provider if the provider, or any of its owning or managing employees or organizations, might have had a reportable affiliation within the previous five years.
The mechanism is entity resolution across enrollment records. PECOS links organizations to the individuals and organizations they list as owners and managing employees. When the same person or company appears on two enrollments, the link exists in CMS’s data whether or not either provider ever thinks about it. When one of those enrollments is revoked, the other becomes a candidate for review. The quality of that matching depends on identifiers: legal names, tax identification numbers, National Provider Identifiers and Social Security numbers for individuals.
The estimates behind the design
CMS’s burden estimate shows how narrow the request channel was meant to be. For its paperwork estimate, it projected an average of 2,500 affiliation requests a year, at 10 hours each. At its assumed rate of $37.50 an hour, that came to 25,000 hours a year, and a cost of $937,500 in each of the rule’s first three years, for initially enrolling and revalidating providers. CMS said administrative staff, such as office managers and support staff, would likely gather the data.
The savings estimates were much larger. CMS projected about 2,600 new revocations a year from its new revocation authorities, with ten-year savings of $4.16 billion, based on an assumed $160,000 per revoked provider. For the affiliations authority itself, it showed a range of projected savings depending on what share of a five-year total the authority would capture. The contrast between those figures and the small request estimate tells the story, on our reading: most of the value was expected to come from decisions CMS could make on information it already had.
Matching across names and identities
The rule showed how CMS thinks about identity in a separate provision. CMS may deny or revoke a provider that is currently revoked under a different name, numerical identifier or business identity while its reenrollment bar is running. To decide whether two enrollments are really the same, CMS investigates the degree of commonality. It considers owning and managing employees and organizations, “regardless of whether they have been disclosed on the Form CMS-855 application.” It also considers geographic location, provider or supplier type, business structure, and any evidence that the new entity was created to get around a revocation.
That clause matters for the argument. CMS said in regulation that it would look at who actually owns and runs a provider, whoever the form lists. An incomplete enrollment record does not hide a relationship from CMS. It only leaves the provider without its own account of that relationship when CMS asks.
What matching can get wrong
Entity resolution produces false links as well as true ones. Two clinicians can share a common name. Unrelated practices can share an address in a medical office building. A managing employee who left years ago may still appear on an enrollment if no one reported the departure. Each of those errors can make an affiliation look closer, longer or more current than it was.
The undue-risk factors give a provider the means to correct them. Duration, whether the relationship still exists, when it ended and why are all questions of fact. A provider with dated board minutes, signed resignations, purchase agreements and reported changes can answer them. One without those records is left arguing from memory against a database.
Medicaid’s parallel path
The Medicaid side added variation. States had to pick between universal disclosure for providers not enrolled in Medicare and disclosure on request. In 2019, CMS said it could not project how many requests states would make, partly because it did not know which states would pick which option or when each would update its data collection. A provider enrolled in several states’ Medicaid programs could face different practices in each.
The programs also connect. The rule revised CMS’s authority to revoke Medicare enrollment when a provider is terminated, revoked or barred by a state Medicaid program or another federal health care program. CMS would weigh the reasons, whether the provider was barred from more than one program, and any other sanctions. CMS may not revoke on that basis until the provider has exhausted its appeal rights. A Medicaid enrollment problem in one state can therefore become a Medicare enrollment problem.
What a request would contain
Where CMS did ask, the rule set out what a provider would report about each affiliation. That included the affiliated party’s legal name, any “doing business as” name, its tax identification number and NPI. It also included the reason for disclosure, the length, type and degree of the relationship, and the reason any relationship ended. Failure to disclose fully, when the provider knew or should reasonably have known the information, could itself lead to denial or revocation.
How CMS would weigh risk
The rule listed the factors for deciding whether an affiliation posed undue risk. They included the duration of the affiliation, whether it still existed and how long ago it ended, its degree and extent, and the reason it ended. For the affiliated party’s disclosable event, CMS would consider its type, when it occurred, whether the affiliation existed at that time, and its reason. For a debt, CMS would look at the amount, whether it was being repaid and to whom it was owed. Each factor is a fact that someone has to prove. Dates of appointment and resignation, ownership percentages over time and the terms of a management agreement are the kinds of records that would settle them.
The records a provider controls
If CMS reasons from enrollment data, a provider’s best evidence is the accuracy of its own filings. The 2019 rule tightened the consequences for getting them wrong.
Reporting deadlines with revocation behind them
Before the rule, CMS’s authority to revoke for failure to report covered physicians, non-physician practitioners and their groups, and only changes of practice location or final adverse action. The final rule extended it to all of the reporting requirements in 42 CFR 424.516(d) and (e), and to the specific requirements for independent diagnostic testing facilities and DMEPOS suppliers. For providers other than physicians, practitioner groups, independent diagnostic testing facilities and DMEPOS suppliers, the reporting rules the final rule describes require a change of ownership or control within 30 days, and most other changes within 90 days. In deciding whether to revoke, CMS would consider whether the data was reported at all, how late it was, and how material it was.
That turns enrollment maintenance into a compliance control. A health system that adds a managing employee, appoints a new board member at a subsidiary, or changes a practice location has a deadline. Missing it now carries a revocation risk as well as a data quality cost. The same record that CMS uses to find affiliations is the one that a missed update leaves wrong.
Accuracy at the first filing
The rule also addressed applications that are wrong from the start. According to CMS’s announcement, it can prevent an applicant from enrolling for up to 3 years if the applicant submitted false or misleading information on its initial enrollment application. In weighing that bar, CMS said, evidence of intent and the materiality of the information would be factors. An honest error is different from a concealed owner, and the record of how an application was prepared is the evidence of which one occurred.
For an organization that enrolls new entities often, the initial application is a repeated process, not a one-time event. A standard package for each new enrollment would hold the ownership chart, the list of managing employees with their appointment dates, the practice locations, and a sign-off by someone who checked them against the legal and HR records. That is ordinary diligence, but the 2019 rule attached a longer bar to skipping it.
Revocation that spreads across enrollments
Under the rule, when CMS revokes one enrollment it may revoke any and all of the provider’s other enrollments. That includes enrollments under different names, numerical identifiers or business identities, and of different types. CMS would consider the reason for the revocation and the facts, any final adverse actions on the other enrollments, and the number and types of those enrollments.
For a system that holds many enrollments, this is the reason enrollment hygiene is an enterprise issue rather than a departmental one. A problem at a small subsidiary can put the larger organization’s other enrollments in question. Clear records of which entities are separate, who manages each and how they relate would help show CMS why a problem at one should not reach the rest.
Who owns the enrollment record
In a large organization, enrollment data is touched by several functions. Credentialing knows the clinicians. Legal knows the corporate structure. Finance knows the billing numbers and reassignments. Human resources knows when managers start and leave. The rule did not tell anyone how to organize this, and nothing in it requires a particular structure. But the affiliations authority rewards an organization that can produce, for any enrolled entity, a dated history of who owned it and who ran it.
A practical design would start with a register of enrolled entities, each with its NPI, tax identification number and PECOS enrollment. For each entity, the register would hold owners at 5 percent or more, partnership interests of any size, officers, directors and managing employees, each with start and end dates. A reconciliation against PECOS, on a set schedule and after every change, would catch differences before CMS did. The register is not a regulatory requirement in itself. It is the evidence a provider would want if CMS ever weighed an affiliation’s duration, degree and end date.
Departures
Additions to an enrollment come with paperwork: a new owner signs documents, a new location needs a billing setup. Removals have no such trigger. A managing employee who resigns, an officer who retires or a director whose term ends may stay on the enrollment record for years if no process connects the departure to an update. Under the affiliations rule, every stale name is a link CMS can still follow. A practical fix is to add the enrollment update to the offboarding steps for anyone listed on an 855, with the enrollment team notified by the same event that ends system access. The date of departure, recorded at the time, is also the date that answers the question of when an affiliation ended.
Reassignments
The fifth type of affiliation is any reassignment relationship under 42 CFR 424.80. When a clinician reassigns Medicare benefits to a group or a hospital, that link is an affiliation for this rule. A system with many employed clinicians holds a reassignment for each one who bills through it. Each is a link between the organization and an individual who may also work elsewhere, including at an organization with a disclosable event. The provider cannot see the other organization’s enrollment history directly. It can make sure its own reassignments are current, and that departed clinicians’ reassignments are ended promptly, so its record reflects relationships that actually exist.
Sequencing the work
The order matters more than the scope. A register of enrolled entities comes first, because every other step refers to it. Reconciliation against PECOS comes second, because it shows where the organization’s own picture and CMS’s picture differ. Attestations from owners and leaders come third, because they cover what neither record holds. Review of contracts, joint ventures and board roles comes last, because it depends on knowing which entities and people are in scope. An organization that started with contracts would find relationships it could not yet attach to an enrollment.
What a reviewer would ask to see
An internal auditor or outside reviewer testing this area would want a short set of artifacts. Our list, drawn from the rule’s factors rather than any CMS checklist:
- A current register of enrolled entities with identifiers and enrollment status.
- For each entity, dated lists of owners, partners, officers, directors, managing employees and managing organizations.
- Evidence that changes were reported within the 30-day and 90-day windows, with the dates of change and of report.
- A reconciliation of the register against PECOS, with differences explained.
- Attestations from owners and leaders about outside health care interests and sanctions.
- Records explaining every voluntary termination and closure.
What the provider cannot see
The rule’s standard was what a provider “knew or should reasonably have known.” CMS can see across enrollments; a provider sees its own. A physician owner might hold an interest in an unrelated supplier that was revoked years earlier. The health system would not find that in its own records. The defensible position is to ask. Annual attestations from owners, directors and managing employees about their other health care interests, and about any sanctions those interests have faced, give the organization a documented basis for what it knew. Exclusion screening covers only one of the four kinds of disclosable event. It does not reveal another party’s debts, payment suspensions or revocations.
Transactions and contracts that create affiliations
Every acquisition, joint venture, management agreement and board appointment can create an affiliation. The rule made those decisions part of enrollment risk.
Acquisitions
When a health system buys a physician practice, a home health agency or an imaging center, the seller’s history follows the people. If the practice’s former owners stay on as managing employees, their other interests become the system’s affiliations. If the target’s enrollment carries an uncollected overpayment, that debt is a disclosable event attached to a party the buyer now controls or manages. Due diligence that already covered billing compliance and exclusion screening would extend to enrollment history: past revocations, voluntary terminations and their reasons, payment suspensions and outstanding debts, for the target and for each owner and manager who will remain.
The 10-year and 20-year reenrollment bars raised the stakes. A target revoked under a different name or business identity is now a ground for denial or revocation in its own right. A buyer would want representations about prior enrollments under other names and identifiers, and an indemnity tied to enrollment actions after closing. Counsel would decide how far those provisions can go.
Divestitures and closures
Closing or selling an enrolled entity creates its own record. The rule lets CMS revoke an enrollment that a provider voluntarily terminated to avoid a revocation CMS would have imposed. CMS would weigh whether the provider knew or should have known it was out of compliance, whether it knew or should have known its enrollment would be revoked, and whether it terminated to get around the revocation. Such a revocation takes effect the day before the Medicare contractor receives the voluntary termination.
A health system closing a clinic or folding a billing number into another would want a closure file. It would state the business reason, the compliance status of the entity at closure, any open audits or overpayments, and who decided. That file costs little at the time. Years later, when the closed entity appears as a disclosable event in someone’s affiliation review, it may be the only evidence of why the termination happened.
Joint ventures and partnerships
Because any partnership interest counts, joint ventures with physicians and other providers are affiliations regardless of size. An ambulatory surgery center joint venture with a dozen physician investors creates a dozen individual relationships. Each investor’s other interests are outside the system’s control. A joint venture agreement could require investors to report sanctions against their other health care interests within a set period, and give the venture a way to unwind an investor’s interest if a disclosable event creates enrollment risk.
Management and services agreements
The third type of affiliation covers operational or managerial control, “either under contract or through some other arrangement.” A management services organization that runs day-to-day operations for a practice is an affiliate of that practice. So is a contracted administrator. A health system that manages rural hospitals or physician groups under contract creates affiliations in both directions. The contract inventory belongs in the enrollment record alongside the ownership chart.
Locations and ordering patterns
Two of the new revocation grounds reach operations directly. CMS may revoke a provider that billed for services performed at, or items furnished from, a location it knew or should have known did not comply with enrollment requirements. The revocation can reach the provider’s other enrollments even if their locations comply. CMS would weigh the reasons for the non-compliance, the number of locations, the provider’s history, the risk to the Medicare trust funds, how long the location was non-compliant and how much was billed from it. A system that opens, moves or closes sites needs its billing setup and its enrollment record to change together.
The second ground applies to physicians and other eligible professionals. CMS may revoke one who has a pattern or practice of ordering, certifying, referring or prescribing that is abusive, threatens beneficiaries’ health and safety, or otherwise fails Medicare requirements. The factors include whether diagnoses support the orders, whether the patient could have been evaluated at all, for example because the patient was deceased or out of state, and the clinician’s disciplinary history. Order and referral analytics that a system runs for compliance, where it has them, can be pointed at the same patterns the rule names.
Board seats and officers
Serving as an officer or director of a corporation is an affiliation with it. A health system leader who also serves on the board of another health care organization, such as a community provider, a post-acute operator or a supplier that enrolls in Medicare, creates one. A conflict-of-interest questionnaire that already asks about outside roles can add the questions this rule makes relevant: is the outside organization enrolled in Medicare, Medicaid or CHIP, and has it had a debt, suspension, exclusion or revocation.
Where the argument is weakest
The argument here is that the affiliations authority made enrollment data the evidence. Three objections deserve a direct answer, and the argument does not apply evenly across organizations.
Large systems were never the target
CMS framed the rule as a tool against bad actors who reappear under new corporate names. Its announcement said the new authorities were intended to burden only those with real histories of problematic conduct and relationships. A large nonprofit health system might reasonably decide that its exposure is low and its existing compliance program sufficient. That is a fair reading of intent. It is weaker as a reading of mechanism. The definitions do not distinguish by size or tax status, and the matching CMS described runs across every enrollment. A system with many reassignments, joint ventures and managing employees has more links, not fewer. Most links will never matter. The organization still benefits from being able to show quickly why one does not.
Disclosure requests might never come
By the rule’s own terms, the disclosure obligation applied only on request and only after the 855 was revised. A provider could reasonably wait. The argument does not depend on requests, though. Revocation for an affiliation, and for failure to report changes, rests on data CMS already holds. If requests never come, the enrollment record is the only evidence in the file.
The cost of perfect records
Maintaining dated ownership and management histories for every enrolled entity is real work, and commenters on the rule said so. The cost falls on enrollment and credentialing staff who also process new clinicians and revalidations. Organizations should scale the effort to their exposure. A single-specialty practice with one location has little to track. A system with many enrollments, partnerships and management contracts has more. The question to ask is how long it would take to answer an affiliation inquiry from CMS with dated, sourced records, and whether that answer would match PECOS.
CMS’s data may be good enough
The strongest objection is that CMS already holds the data, so a provider’s own effort adds little. If PECOS links owners and managers across enrollments, CMS will find what it finds whatever the provider does. The objection misreads where PECOS data comes from. It is what providers filed. A late or missing update leaves CMS’s picture wrong in a way only the provider can fix, and the undue-risk factors invite exactly the facts a provider holds: dates, depth and reasons. The provider cannot control what CMS sees. It can control whether its own filings are accurate and whether it can prove the history behind them.
How the picture differs by organization
For an academic medical center, the main exposure is breadth: faculty practice plans, reassignments, joint ventures and leaders with outside board roles. For an independent physician group, it is the outside interests of its physician owners. For a small supplier or agency whose revenue depends on one enrollment, the exposure is less about breadth than severity: a revocation followed by a reenrollment bar of up to 10 years would end the business. For state Medicaid agencies, the rule created a parallel obligation to require affiliation disclosures under 42 CFR 455.107. CMS said in 2019 that states would have two options for requesting affiliation information, and that it could not predict which states would choose which, or when each would update its data collection.
In each case the useful question is the same. Could the organization show, from its own dated records, who owned and managed each enrolled entity, and what else those people and organizations were connected to, before CMS asked?
With hindsight
The affiliations authority was not expected to work as a mass disclosure program. In a final rule published on November 9, 2026, at 91 FR 72022, mostly about home health payment, CMS said that although it retained the right to request affiliation data, it did not anticipate doing so because of the burden on providers. It said it would use existing data, to the extent feasible, when deciding affiliation denials and revocations. It added that the overwhelming majority of the information it relies on is already on file from Form CMS-855 submissions and linked in PECOS to other providers’ submissions, such as shared managing employees.
The same rule widened the authority. CMS said it had found three problems with the 2019 provisions. Relationships older than five years could still pose undue risk. Some problematic relationships fell outside the five defined types. And the managerial-control category needed to reach a provider’s own owning and managing employees and organizations. The rule removes the five-year lookback, changing the disclosure provision to read “has or has had.” As checked on November 14, 2026, the eCFR still showed the five-year text, with a link to the amendment. It added a sixth type of affiliation: any marketing, business, fulfillment, financial or managerial relationship, direct or indirect, including common use of the same organization to perform those services. CMS dropped “beneficiary” relationships from the proposal. Commenters objected that the new category could cover almost any dealing. CMS replied that the terms have their plain meanings and that not every such relationship would lead to denial or revocation.
The rule also showed where CMS’s attention had moved. It added a revocation ground for a provider whose location is in a limited area with an excessive number of providers, comparing that risk-based approach to the affiliations authority. It cited CMS data that home health agencies in Los Angeles County rose by over 45 percent between 2019 and 2023. It also broadened the definition of managing employee to include medical directors, clinical directors, department heads, supervising physicians and nursing directors. It added a revocation ground for home health agencies, hospices and DMEPOS suppliers that do not comply with CMS’s requirements on changes in majority ownership. And it added a new kind of final adverse action: a federal or state misdemeanor conviction related to sexual assault or financial misconduct within the past 10 years before enrollment, revalidation or reenrollment.
Ownership transparency grew alongside it. A November 2023 final rule, effective January 16, 2024, required additional ownership and management disclosures from nursing facilities and defined private equity companies and real estate investment trusts for enrollment purposes. That rule noted that CMS had proposed applying those definitions to every provider that completes the 855A.
What held up was the 2019 design choice. The adverse events lived in government systems, and CMS chose to find the relationships there too. What changed was scope: under the November 2026 rule, older relationships count, more kinds of relationship count, and more people inside a provider count as managers. The 2019 rule had already said CMS would weigh owners and managers whether or not a provider disclosed them. By 2026 the enrollment record had become a larger body of evidence than the 2019 rule implied.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.