One records request, two rulebooks: Korunda and Ciox

OCR’s December 2019 Korunda settlement punished a slow, overpriced transfer of records to a third party. In January 2020 a court narrowed the third-party right and removed its fee cap, leaving health systems to sort each request by legal basis before setting format or fee.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

OCR’s December 2019 Korunda settlement punished a slow, overpriced transfer of records to a third party. In January 2020 a court narrowed the third-party right and removed its fee cap, leaving health systems to sort each request by legal basis before setting format or fee.

  1. The week On December 12, 2019, the Office for Civil Rights at the Department of Health and Human Services announced its second enforcement action under the HIPAA Right of Access Initiative.
  2. How one complaint became a settlement OCR handled the Korunda complaint in two stages.
  3. The clock: the protection that survived The HIPAA right of access gives individuals timely access to their records.
  4. The format: electronic copies, and to whom The Privacy Rule requires covered entities to provide access in the form and format the individual requests, if readily producible, and otherwise in a readable form agreed with the individual.
  5. The fee: one cap, applied to fewer requests The Privacy Rule allows a covered entity to charge an individual a reasonable, cost-based fee for a copy of her records.
  6. The vendor: who does the work, and who is liable Covered entities may contract with companies such as Ciox to process records requests on their behalf, and the Ciox opinion treats such a company as a business associate.
  7. Where the argument is weakest One objection is that the Korunda case was really about a provider that ignored a patient for months.
  8. What to change first The four parts have a natural order.
  9. With hindsight On January 23, 2020, the court ruled in Ciox Health v. Azar.

The week

On December 12, 2019, the Office for Civil Rights at the Department of Health and Human Services announced its second enforcement action under the HIPAA Right of Access Initiative. Korunda Medical, LLC, a Florida provider of primary care and interventional pain management, agreed to pay $85,000 and to adopt a corrective action plan with one year of monitoring. OCR described Korunda as serving about 2,000 patients a year.

OCR had announced the initiative earlier in 2019. It promised to enforce patients’ rights to get their medical records promptly, without being overcharged, and in the readily producible format of their choice. The Korunda case touched all three of those promises at once.

The facts were short. In March 2019, OCR received a complaint that Korunda, despite repeated requests, had failed to forward a patient’s medical records in electronic format to a third party. OCR said Korunda had not provided the records on time, had not provided them in the requested electronic format, and had charged more than the reasonable, cost-based fees HIPAA allowed. OCR gave technical assistance and closed the complaint.

The records still did not arrive, and a second complaint followed. After OCR’s second intervention, the records were provided in May 2019, free of charge and in the requested format. The settlement in December was OCR’s response to a provider that had needed two federal interventions to send one patient’s file.

The case landed while a federal lawsuit over the same rules was waiting for decision. In January 2018, Ciox Health, a company that handles records requests for health care providers, had sued HHS in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. It challenged a 2016 HHS guidance document. The court’s opinion refers to the fee limit for patients’ own requests as the Patient Rate. The 2016 guidance said that limit also applied when a patient directed a covered entity to send records to a third party, such as a law firm or insurer. It offered a flat fee of up to $6.50 for electronic copies of electronically maintained records as one way to comply.

The third-party directive itself came from the HITECH Act of 2009. Before then, sending records to a third party required a full HIPAA authorization from the patient. HHS had already acted on the 2016 reading. In March 2017, it warned a covered entity that a records vendor’s charge for sending a patient’s electronic records to her law firm could violate the fee limit.

Ciox also challenged a provision of the 2013 Omnibus Rule. That provision required covered entities to send protected health information to a third party designated by the patient whatever the format of the records. Ciox argued the HITECH Act required this only for electronic copies of electronic health records.

The case had been briefed and argued through 2019. On May 24, 2019, HHS told the court it had published a fact sheet on its website, which said HHS lacked the authority to enforce the reasonable, cost-based fee limitation against business associates. The final brief in the case was filed in July 2019. When OCR announced the Korunda settlement, the court had not yet ruled.

Korunda’s case, then, rested on a third-party request: a patient directing records to someone else, electronically, and being charged too much for it. That was exactly the kind of request the pending lawsuit was about.

OCR presented the Korunda settlement as a warning to providers that slow-walked patients’ records. It was that. It was also a case about a request to send records to a third party, decided under rules a federal court was about to cut back. On January 23, 2020, the court in Ciox Health v. Azar vacated the extension of the patient fee limit to third-party directives. It also vacated the 2013 rule’s requirement to send non-electronic records to third parties on a patient’s direction.

Our argument is that Korunda and Ciox, read together, split what could be handled as a single records request into two kinds with different rules. A patient asking for her own records kept every protection: the clock, the format choice and the fee limit. A patient directing records to a third party kept a narrower right, limited to electronic copies of electronic health records, with no federal patient-rate cap on fees. Health systems that kept treating every request the same way would either overcharge patients or undercharge lawyers and insurers, and could not show OCR which was which.

The response breaks into four parts that follow the life of a request. The first is the clock: meeting the response time, the protection that survived intact and became the core of later enforcement. The second is the format: what must be provided electronically, and to whom. The third is the fee: which requests carry the patient-rate limit and which do not. The fourth is the vendor: the release-of-information company that may do the work, and the covered entity that remains liable for it.

The parts do not overlap. Clock, format and fee are the three dimensions of every response, and the vendor is who performs them. A first section explains how one complaint became a settlement. The four parts follow. A sixth section tests the argument against objections and against different kinds of provider. The last sets out what to change first. Organizations should confirm the current rules with counsel, because they changed after 2019.

How one complaint became a settlement

Technical assistance first

OCR handled the Korunda complaint in two stages. The first complaint, in March 2019, ended with technical assistance: OCR explained the rules and closed the matter. Technical assistance carried no penalty.

The second complaint changed the outcome. It showed that guidance had not produced compliance. OCR intervened again, the records were provided free in May 2019, and OCR then pursued a settlement. The $85,000 payment and the one-year corrective action plan followed from the repeat failure, not from the original lapse alone.

What the initiative changed

The initiative made right of access problems a named enforcement priority. OCR’s announcement described a shift to imposing corrective actions and settlements. For a provider, the message was that a second complaint about the same request could cost money and bring monitoring.

The amount mattered less than the precedent. For a practice serving about 2,000 patients a year, $85,000 is significant. For a large health system, it is small. What any organization should have noticed was the trigger: one patient, one request, two complaints.

Why a small case drew a national announcement

OCR announced the Korunda settlement nationally, though the practice was small and the harm involved one patient. The choice fits an initiative built on deterrence. A single failure of this kind is small and easy to repeat. Penalizing a few clear cases, and publicizing them, tells every provider that the cheapest fix is to answer requests on time.

Compliance teams should read such announcements for their triggers rather than their amounts. Here the trigger was a repeat complaint after technical assistance. A provider that receives technical assistance from OCR on an access complaint should treat it as a final warning for that request and check whether the same failure affects others.

How the 2016 guidance had reshaped the business

The Ciox record shows what the 2016 guidance did to the market for records requests. According to the opinion, the records industry had understood the patient fee limit to apply only to patients’ own requests. Requests made under HIPAA authorizations, such as those from law firms and insurers, carried what Ciox’s evidence described as typically higher state-authorized fees. After 2016, according to evidence HHS did not contest, requesters shifted toward directives, and some covered entities required Ciox to charge the $6.50 flat fee for them.

That shift moved costs. Vendors earned less per request. Covered entities, liable for their vendors’ fees, pushed for the lowest safe charge. Law firms and insurers paid less. Patients asking for their own records were not directly affected.

The parts of the case that were about third parties

OCR’s description of the complaint is precise. The patient asked Korunda to forward records to a third party in electronic format. Korunda failed to do so on time, failed to use the requested format and overcharged. Each of those failures was measured against the rules as OCR read them in 2019, including the 2016 guidance that applied the patient fee limit to third-party directives.

By the end of January 2020, part of that reading was gone. That does not mean the Korunda settlement was wrong. Korunda’s delay was a problem under any reading. The fee finding, however, rested on a rule the court vacated as applied to third-party directives.

The clock: the protection that survived

What the rule required

The HIPAA right of access gives individuals timely access to their records. At the time, covered entities had 30 days to act on a request, with the possibility of one 30-day extension. Ciox did not touch this. HHS’s notice after the ruling said that the right of individuals to access their own records was undisturbed and that OCR would continue to enforce the provisions the order did not restrict.

That makes the clock the most durable part of the right. It also makes it the easiest for OCR to prove. A request has a date. A response has a date. The gap is a number.

Why requests miss the clock

In our view, requests are more likely to miss deadlines because they are not recognized, routed or tracked than because staff refuse to act. A patient asks at the front desk, sends a letter to a clinic, emails a physician, or uses a portal message. Each channel may reach a different person. Some channels may not be monitored for records requests at all.

Once received, a request may wait for identity verification, for records held in several systems, or for a vendor to pick it up. Each handoff adds days. Without a single log that starts the clock on receipt, no one knows how long a request has been waiting.

Records spread across several systems

A complete response can draw on more than one system: the main electronic health record, a separate system from an acquired practice, an imaging archive, a billing platform and sometimes paper. Each may have a different custodian. A request for “all records” can stall while staff wait for the slowest one.

A map of where each kind of record lives, with a named custodian and a target turnaround for each, prevents that. Where one source is slow, the organization can send what it has and follow with the rest, telling the patient what is coming and when.

Identity checks that do not stop the clock

Covered entities must verify that the person requesting records is the patient or a personal representative. Verification is necessary, and it can also cause delay, for example when staff ask for notarized forms or copies of identification that the patient must mail.

A proportionate approach uses the verification methods the organization already trusts for other purposes. A patient logged into the portal has already been verified. A patient at the front desk can show identification in person. Asking for more than the organization asks for when it shares results or schedules care invites delay without adding much protection.

Controls that keep the clock

  • A single intake log for all access requests, wherever they arrive, with the date of receipt recorded at first touch.
  • Instructions for every front-line channel, including front desks, clinics and portal inboxes, on recognizing and forwarding a request the same day.
  • An aging report reviewed weekly, showing every open request by days elapsed, with escalation well before the deadline.
  • A written rule for when an extension is used, with the required notice to the patient sent before the first deadline passes.
  • A closure record showing what was sent, how and when, kept with the request.

What an investigator asks for

An OCR investigation of a right of access complaint starts with the request and the response. The investigator will ask when the request was received, what happened to it, when records were sent and why any delay occurred. Policies matter less than the record for that patient. An organization that cannot reconstruct the timeline from its own logs is in a weak position before any other question is asked.

Measuring from the right date

One measurement error is starting the clock late, by measuring from the date a request reaches the records department or the vendor. The regulatory clock starts when the covered entity receives the request. A request that waited a week in a clinic inbox has used a week of its time before anyone counts it. Measuring from first receipt can show a worse number, and it is the real one. Reporting both numbers side by side for a quarter shows leaders the size of the gap and where the days are lost, which makes the case for fixing intake.

The format: electronic copies, and to whom

The patient’s choice of format

The Privacy Rule requires covered entities to provide access in the form and format the individual requests, if readily producible, and otherwise in a readable form agreed with the individual. When records are held electronically, the individual can ask for an electronic copy in a form and format that is readily producible. Ciox left those rules in place for patients’ own requests.

Korunda’s failure to provide records in the requested electronic format was part of OCR’s finding. A practice that keeps records electronically but answers requests with paper copies, or with scanned images when structured exports are readily available, invites the same finding.

Readily producible formats

The rule turns on what is readily producible. A health system with a patient portal may be able to produce a download of key records. An electronic health record may be able to export a structured summary. Imaging archives can produce image files. Paper records can be scanned. Each organization should know which of these it can produce for each kind of record, and offer them by default rather than waiting to be asked.

Delivery matters too. Secure email, portal download, encrypted media and mail each carry different costs and risks. The organization’s list of formats should say which delivery methods it offers for each, and who can approve an exception when a patient asks for something else.

Directing records to someone else

The third-party directive is different. The HITECH Act gave individuals a right to direct a covered entity to send an electronic copy of information in an electronic health record to a person they designate. The 2013 Omnibus Rule extended that right to records in any format. The Ciox court vacated the extension. After January 2020, the federal right to direct records to a third party covered electronic copies of electronic health record information, not paper records or records held in other systems.

That distinction is hard to apply at intake. A request may ask for “all records” to be sent to a law firm. Some of those records may be in the electronic health record. Others may be in a billing system, an imaging archive or paper files. Under the narrower right, only part of the request is a directive. The rest may need a HIPAA authorization from the patient.

Records outside the electronic health record

The right of access covers records in the designated record set, which is wider than the electronic health record. Billing records, some imaging and older paper charts can all be part of it. After Ciox, a patient still had the right to get those records for herself. The narrower right to direct them to a third party reached only electronic copies of electronic health record information. A patient who wanted billing records sent to her lawyer might need to sign an authorization or receive them herself.

Staff need a short guide for this. It should say which systems count as the electronic health record for directive purposes, which hold other designated record set information, and what to tell a patient whose directive reaches records in both.

Requests from third parties on their own behalf

A third category sits outside the right of access entirely. A law firm or insurer may request records with the patient’s HIPAA authorization. That is a disclosure, not an access request. Ciox’s evidence was that it charged above the Patient Rate for requests made under authorizations. Their fees depend on other law, including state law, and on the provider’s own policies and contracts.

Why the categories matter for systems

A release-of-information process that sorts requests by requester type, such as patient, attorney, insurer or other provider, no longer matched the law. An attorney could be forwarding a patient’s own directive, or making a request under an authorization. The patient could be asking for records for herself or directing them elsewhere. The system needed to sort by legal basis, not by who sent the paper.

The fee: one cap, applied to fewer requests

What the court left and what it removed

The Privacy Rule allows a covered entity to charge an individual a reasonable, cost-based fee for a copy of her records. The fee may include certain labor for copying, supplies and postage. The 2016 guidance said labor costs for searching for and retrieving records could not be charged. It offered a flat fee of up to $6.50 for electronic copies of electronically maintained records as one option.

The court upheld the guidance on what labor counts, finding it an interpretive rule. It held that the guidance’s list of three ways to calculate the fee, including the flat fee, was not a reviewable final action. It vacated only the extension of the patient fee limit to third-party directives. HHS’s notice after the ruling said the fee limit applied only to an individual’s request for her own records.

Two fee schedules, not one

The practical effect was two fee regimes. Patients’ own requests stayed under the federal limit. Third-party directives and authorized disclosures did not, though state law and contracts might still limit them. A health system that charged everyone the patient rate after January 2020 was undercharging some requesters. One that charged everyone a commercial rate was overcharging patients, which is what the initiative targeted.

The court record showed how much money turned on this. Ciox’s evidence was that after the 2016 guidance, covered entities insisted on the $6.50 flat fee for third-party directives. It also said directive volumes rose sharply as law firms used them to avoid higher fees. HHS did not contest that evidence. The ruling reversed the incentive.

Controls that keep fees right

  • A fee schedule for each legal basis: patient access, patient-directed electronic transmission, and authorized disclosure, each reviewed by counsel against federal and state law.
  • A required field at intake recording the legal basis, which drives the fee automatically.
  • A rule that any request with unclear basis is treated as a patient access request until clarified, so patients are never overcharged by default.
  • Periodic sampling of invoices against the recorded basis, with refunds where patients were overcharged.

State law can still set third-party fees

Removing the federal cap from third-party directives did not leave fees unregulated. The Ciox record describes state-authorized rates that vendors charged for authorized requests before 2016. State law can still set limits. A covered entity operating in several states needs a third-party fee schedule that reflects each state’s law, reviewed by counsel. It also needs a rule for choosing the right schedule, such as where care was delivered.

Waiving fees for patients

A provider may choose to provide patients’ own records free. That choice removes the fee calculation for patients’ own requests and, we would expect, many fee complaints with it. The cost is the revenue those fees brought, which may be small next to the staff time spent calculating and collecting them. A provider that waives patient fees still needs classification, because directives and authorized requests may carry charges.

The patient who does not know which she made

Patients may not know the legal difference between asking for records and directing them. A patient who asks for her records to go to her lawyer may intend either. A covered entity cannot let the cheaper or dearer reading default to its own benefit. We think the better practice is to explain the options plainly, let the patient choose, and record the choice.

The vendor: who does the work, and who is liable

Release-of-information companies

Covered entities may contract with companies such as Ciox to process records requests on their behalf, and the Ciox opinion treats such a company as a business associate. Ciox’s evidence described the model: nearly all of its contracts limited its pay to the fees chargeable for sending records, and required it to charge in line with the Privacy Rule’s fee provision.

Liability stays with the covered entity

HHS told the court in 2019 that it lacked authority to enforce the fee limit against business associates. It had also told the court that a covered entity is liable when its business associate, acting as its agent, overcharges. The court noted that covered entities are liable for civil money penalties for acts of their agents. It also noted that a covered entity that knows of a business associate’s pattern of violation must act to cure it or end the contract. Ciox’s own contracts, the opinion noted, let covered entities terminate them if Ciox charged more than the Patient Rate.

For a health system, this means the vendor’s errors are its own. A patient overcharged by the vendor complains about the hospital. A delayed request handled by the vendor is the hospital’s delay. Outsourcing the work did not outsource the risk.

The business associate agreement as the control point

The Privacy Rule requires the relationship between a covered entity and a business associate to be documented in a written contract or similar arrangement. For a release-of-information vendor, that agreement is where the access rules become enforceable duties. A generic agreement that only repeats the rule’s privacy terms leaves the access process undefined. The service agreement and the business associate agreement together should set out how the vendor meets the clock, format and fee rules described here.

What the contract should require

  • Intake that records the legal basis of every request and applies the matching fee schedule.
  • Service levels tied to the regulatory clock, measured from the date the covered entity first received the request, not the date the vendor logged it.
  • Reports by request type showing volumes, ages, fees charged and complaints, delivered monthly.
  • Prompt notice of any OCR complaint or inquiry touching a request the vendor handled.
  • Indemnity for penalties and refunds caused by the vendor’s errors, and audit rights to verify fees and timeliness.

Pricing models after the ruling

Before the ruling, the Ciox evidence showed Ciox renegotiating contracts after the 2016 guidance and charging the flat fee for most directives. After the ruling, vendors could seek to return to higher charges for directives. That shift raised a risk for covered entities. A vendor eager to recover revenue might classify patients’ own requests as directives, or charge higher fees where the legal basis was unclear.

The covered entity’s defense is the classification rule described above, applied by contract. The vendor should be required to treat unclear requests as patient access, to show the recorded legal basis on every invoice, and to report fee complaints promptly.

Auditing the vendor

Contract rights are useful only if exercised. A quarterly sample of closed requests, checked against the vendor’s records and the covered entity’s own intake log, tests three things at once. It shows whether the clock was met from first receipt, whether the legal basis was recorded correctly, and whether the fee matched the basis. Findings should go to the vendor in writing with a date for correction, and repeat findings should reach the compliance committee.

Requests the vendor never sees

Vendors process the requests routed to them. Some requests never reach them: a portal message to a physician, a letter to a clinic, a phone call. The covered entity must make sure those requests are captured and forwarded. A vendor’s service level means little if the clock started days earlier in a clinic inbox.

Where the argument is weakest

Korunda was about delay, not fees

One objection is that the Korunda case was really about a provider that ignored a patient for months. Fees and formats were secondary, and the Ciox ruling changed nothing that mattered to its outcome.

The objection is right about the outcome and wrong about the lesson for operations. Korunda shows what OCR would pursue. Ciox shows that the rules OCR applied to third-party requests could change underneath it. A provider building its process after both needed to keep the clock strict for every request while sorting fees and formats by legal basis.

Two regimes are too complex for front-line staff

A second objection is practical. Front-desk and clinic staff cannot be expected to classify requests by legal basis. A single process, charging every requester the patient rate, is simpler and protects patients.

Simplicity has a cost, but it can be a sensible choice. A provider may decide to apply the patient rate to all directives as a matter of policy, absorbing the revenue loss to avoid complexity. What it should not do is apply a commercial rate to everyone. The classification burden can also be moved off the front line by routing all requests to a trained central team.

OCR will not chase third-party fees

A third objection is that, after Ciox, OCR had no fee rule to enforce for directives, so the fee part of this argument mattered little.

That is true for federal enforcement of directive fees. It ignores the patient side. The risk after the ruling was overcharging patients by treating their requests as something else. That risk lay squarely inside the initiative, whose own description named overcharging patients as a target.

Portals and apps make the paper process obsolete

A fourth objection is that electronic access through portals and applications will replace most paper-era requests. Classification by legal basis is a problem that will shrink.

Electronic access may reduce some requests. It does not remove requests for complete records, for records outside the portal, or for records sent to lawyers and insurers. Those are the requests that cause complaints and carry fees. The proposal that would have created a cleaner electronic pathway between providers and plans remained unfinished as of November 2026.

Small practices cannot afford this

A fifth objection is cost. A practice the size of Korunda has no privacy office, no vendor manager and no analytics team.

The core controls are cheap. A shared log, a weekly look at open requests, a one-page guide to legal bases and a default rule for unclear requests need no software. For a small practice, the clock part of this argument is nearly all of it.

Differences by kind of provider

A small practice like Korunda may handle requests in-house, through one or two staff members. Its risk is the clock, because requests compete with daily work. A simple log and a weekly review can do much of the job.

A large health system may use a vendor and many intake channels. Its risk is fragmentation: requests that never reach the vendor, and vendor practices it does not see. Contract terms and reporting matter most.

A health plan is also a covered entity. Its records, such as claims and enrollment data, may not be electronic health records in the HITECH Act’s sense, so the narrower third-party directive may not reach them. It still owes members timely access to their own records.

An ambulatory network that shares one electronic health record across many practices sits between these. It can centralize intake through the shared record and portal, which is its advantage, if it trains every practice to route requests there.

Where the argument does not hold

For providers whose only requests are from patients for their own records, the split hardly matters. Their task is the clock and the format. The fee and vendor parts apply mainly to organizations with significant third-party request volume.

The argument also assumes the federal rules stay where Ciox left them. If HHS finalizes its 2021 proposal, or something like it, the categories will change again. The third-party directive would remain limited to electronic health record information, but fees for it would follow new rules, and response times would shorten. An intake process built around a recorded legal basis can absorb that change by updating its fee table and its clock. A process built around requester type would have to be rebuilt a second time.

What to change first

The four parts have a natural order. The clock is the enforcement priority and depends on intake, so it comes first. Format and fee both depend on classifying the request. The vendor contract should be updated once the internal rules are clear, so it can require them.

  1. Start one log. Capture every access request on receipt, from every channel, and report open requests by age every week.
  2. Classify by legal basis. Add a required field for patient access, patient-directed electronic transmission or authorized disclosure, and default unclear requests to patient access.
  3. Set fee schedules per basis. Have counsel review each against federal and state law, and sample invoices quarterly.
  4. Test electronic delivery. Confirm which records can be produced electronically, in which formats, from which systems, and offer those by default.
  5. Rewrite the vendor contract. Tie service levels to first receipt, require reporting by legal basis, and secure indemnity and audit rights.

Training completes the change. Every staff member who might receive a request needs to know three things, from the front desk to physicians and the call center. A request can arrive in any form. It must be logged the same day. And the patient should never be told to wait for the right form. We would expect those three rules to prevent many of the delays that produce complaints.

Ownership should be explicit. One workable split gives the privacy officer ownership of the right of access, health information management the process and the vendor manager the contract. A short written charter naming who does what avoids the gaps where requests are lost.

Keep an evidence file. For each request, it should hold the date first received, the channel, the recorded legal basis, any verification steps, the date and method of delivery, the format, the fee charged and any patient communication. If OCR opens an investigation, the file answers its first questions in a day. If a pattern of complaints emerges, the files show where the process breaks.

Two measures show whether the work is succeeding: the share of requests closed within the time limit, measured from first receipt, and the number of patient fee complaints. Both should be reported to the privacy officer every month and to the compliance committee every quarter.

With hindsight

On January 23, 2020, the court ruled in Ciox Health v. Azar. It vacated the 2013 rule insofar as it extended the third-party directive beyond electronic copies of electronic health record information. It vacated the 2016 guidance insofar as it extended the patient fee limit to third-party directives without notice and comment. HHS posted a notice saying the fee limit would apply only to an individual’s request for her own records. OCR would keep enforcing the parts of the right the order did not restrict.

The court also left two things standing. It upheld the 2016 guidance on which labor costs may be charged, calling it an interpretive rule. And it declined to enter judgment on whether the HITECH Act itself forbids applying the patient rate to directives, so as not to prejudge any future rulemaking. That left HHS free to try again through notice and comment.

In January 2021, HHS proposed to rewrite the access rules. Its notice of proposed rulemaking, published on January 21, 2021, would shorten the response time to 15 calendar days, with one 15-day extension. It would create a pathway for individuals to direct electronic health record information between providers and health plans. It would limit third-party directives to electronic copies of electronic health record information and amend their fee structure. It would require covered entities to post estimated fee schedules and give itemized bills on request. It would also specify when electronic copies must be free and reduce identity verification burdens on individuals. The comment period was extended to May 6, 2021.

That rule has not been finalized. On January 14, 2026, HHS announced a Tribal consultation on the same proposed rule, set for February 6, 2026. A Federal Register search on November 14, 2026 found no final rule.

Enforcement continued on timeliness. On December 16, 2025, OCR announced its 54th right of access enforcement action, a settlement with Concentra, an occupational health provider, for $112,500. The complaint concerned an individual who made six requests beginning in February 2018 and did not receive his records until March 2019. OCR had proposed a civil money penalty in June 2021. Concentra requested a hearing before an administrative law judge, and the parties settled in May 2025, before any hearing took place. OCR’s release said the initiative began during the first Trump administration and restated the 30-day standard with one 30-day extension.

The Concentra case also shows how long enforcement can run. The first request was made in 2018 and the settlement came in 2025. A records request mishandled today can still produce a settlement payment years later, which is a reason to keep the request log and closure records for at least that long.

What held up was the clock. Concentra’s settlement, the 54th action, turned on whether an individual got his records on time. What changed was the scope of the third-party directive and its fees, which the court narrowed and HHS has not yet rebuilt. Health systems still run two regimes, and the proposal that might simplify them remains unfinished.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • HIPAA
  • right of access
  • release of information
  • OCR enforcement
  • business associates