Regulation F’s 2019 draft gave creditors a specification for collection
The CFPB’s May 2019 debt collection proposal regulated collectors, not lenders. It still described, call by call and notice by notice, what a customer in collection should experience, and much of that depended on data the creditor hands over.
Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.
Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article
The CFPB’s May 2019 debt collection proposal regulated collectors, not lenders. It still described, call by call and notice by notice, what a customer in collection should experience, and much of that depended on data the creditor hands over.
- The week On May 7, 2019, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau announced a proposed rule to implement the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.
- How often the consumer is contacted The Act has long prohibited causing a telephone to ring or engaging a person in conversation repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy, abuse or harass.
- When, where and through which channel The Act already barred collectors from communicating at times or places they knew or should have known were inconvenient to the consumer.
- What the consumer is told at the start The Act requires a debt collector to give the consumer a validation notice, with certain information about the debt and the consumer’s rights, within five days of the initial communication unless that information was already provided.
- What happens to the credit report and to old debts The proposal would bar a collector from furnishing information about a debt to a consumer reporting agency before communicating with the consumer about it.
- The data handoff as a customer experience system Each of the four parts above depends on information that moves from creditor to collector and back.
- What a creditor would ask its collectors in 2019 Pulling the four parts together, a creditor reviewing its collection vendors after the proposal could have used a short set of questions.
- Where the argument is weakest The first objection is that the proposal regulated debt collectors, not creditors, so a bank had no obligation to act.
- How it differs by kind of creditor A large bank may place high volumes of accounts with several agencies and law firms, and may sell charged-off debt.
- With hindsight The Bureau finished the rule in two parts.
The week
On May 7, 2019, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau announced a proposed rule to implement the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. The proposal, signed by the Bureau’s director on May 6, would amend Regulation F, which then contained the procedures for states to apply for exemption from the Act. It was published in the Federal Register on May 21, 2019, with comments due by August 19.
The Bureau’s announcement explained why the proposal was new. Before the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010, Congress had not given any agency authority to issue substantive rules interpreting the 1977 statute. Dodd-Frank gave that authority to the Bureau. The proposal used that authority to write federal rules for the activities of debt collectors, and much of it addressed what the announcement called newer communication technologies that had developed since the statute’s passage in 1977: voicemails, emails and text messages.
The announcement listed four main changes. First, a bright-line limit on telephone calls: debt collectors would generally be limited to seven call attempts per week to reach a consumer about a specific debt, and after a telephone conversation they would have to wait at least a week before calling again. Second, a required disclosure at the start of collection, with an itemization of the debt, plain-language information about how a consumer could respond, including by disputing the debt, and a “tear-off” the consumer could return. Third, clarity on how collectors could lawfully use voicemails, emails and text messages, with a way for consumers to unsubscribe, and on how consumers could limit contact at a particular number, at work or at certain hours. Fourth, a ban on suing or threatening to sue on debts the collector knew or should have known were past the statute of limitations, and a ban on reporting a debt to a credit bureau before communicating with the consumer about it.
The proposal itself filled in the mechanics. It would define a “limited-content message,” a voicemail with specified content that would not count as a communication under the Act, so a collector could leave one without risking disclosure to a third party. It would clarify that a consumer need not use specific words to say a time or place was inconvenient, and that a consumer could designate a medium, such as email, that the collector could not use. It would require each collection email and text message to tell the consumer how to opt out of further messages, and it would offer procedures that, if followed, would protect a collector from liability for unintentional third-party disclosures by email or text. It would provide a model validation notice and rules for delivering it electronically. The Bureau said it would test disclosures about time-barred debt before deciding whether to require one.
The proposal applied to “debt collectors” as the Act defines them, which generally means third parties collecting debts owed to others, not creditors collecting their own debts in their own name. Some provisions rested on the Bureau’s Dodd-Frank authority instead, and would apply only to collectors of debts related to consumer financial products or services. A proposed record retention requirement, also based on Dodd-Frank authority, would apply to all collectors covered by the Act.
Debt collection is the point in consumer finance where a lender’s relationship with a customer is under the greatest strain, and the work may be handled by someone other than the lender. A bank, credit union or fintech lender can place delinquent accounts with collection agencies, hire law firms, or sell charged-off debt to buyers who then collect it themselves. For the consumer, the experience of that collector becomes the last experience of the lender’s brand.
The CFPB’s May 2019 proposal was written for debt collectors, not for those lenders. A bank collecting its own debts in its own name is generally outside the Act’s definition of a debt collector. Read narrowly, the proposal was a matter for the collection industry. Read from the lender’s side, it did something more useful. It set out, in a proposed federal rule, a detailed description of what a consumer in collection should experience: how often the phone rings, which channels are used and when, what the first notice says, and what happens to the consumer’s credit report and old debts. Each of those depends partly on information that starts with the creditor.
Our argument is that the 2019 draft turned the consumer’s collection experience into a set of specifications a creditor could write into its vendor contracts and its data handoffs, and that the creditors who did so would be better placed whatever the final rule said. We break that experience into four parts that do not overlap and together cover it. First, how often the consumer is contacted. Second, when, where and through which channel. Third, what the consumer is told at the start. Fourth, what happens to the consumer’s credit report and to old debts. We take each in turn, then test the argument and look at how it applied to different kinds of creditor.
On scope: the Act and Regulation F apply to debt collectors as defined. Creditors collecting their own debts are outside that definition but not outside the law; the proposal itself notes that the Bureau’s Dodd-Frank authority can reach those who collect debt related to consumer financial products or services, and state laws vary. Which rules apply to which activity is a legal question that each firm should take to counsel. Our concern here is the customer experience the creditor controls through its choices of vendor, data and process.
How often the consumer is contacted
A number where there had been a standard
The Act has long prohibited causing a telephone to ring or engaging a person in conversation repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy, abuse or harass. That standard depends on intent and on facts. The 2019 proposal replaced uncertainty with a number: generally no more than seven call attempts within seven days to reach a consumer about a particular debt, and no call within seven days after a telephone conversation about it.
A number changes how a collector runs its operation. Dialing systems can be configured to count. Compliance teams can test against a limit. Consumers and regulators can measure. For a creditor that places accounts with an agency, the number also became something to ask about: how the agency counts, whether per debt or per consumer, across which systems, and with what evidence.
Per debt, and what that means for a creditor’s portfolio
The proposed limit applied to calls about a particular debt. A consumer with several delinquent accounts, for example a credit card and an auto loan from the same bank, could in principle receive calls about each. A creditor that placed several of one customer’s accounts with the same agency, or with different agencies, would shape how many calls that customer received. We think a creditor concerned about customer experience should decide deliberately how to place multiple accounts for the same person, and should ask its agencies how they handle a consumer with more than one account in collection.
Evidence of compliance
A limit is only useful to a creditor if it can verify it. The practical step was to ask for reporting: call attempts and conversations per account and per consumer, over time, from the agency’s own systems. A creditor that receives that data can spot outliers, compare agencies and answer a complaint quickly. One that receives only recovery rates cannot tell whether its collectors are within the limit or how its customers are being treated.
Calls, not every contact
The proposed limit concerned telephone calls. Emails, text messages and letters were governed by other provisions, including the general bans on harassment and on communication at inconvenient times. A collector could therefore shift volume from calls to electronic messages. That may suit a consumer who prefers writing, or it may not. A creditor that wants to understand its customers’ experience should ask for the full contact record across channels, with the call count that the proposal would test as one part of it.
Testing the dialer
A limit configured in a dialing system is only as good as its configuration. Accounts can be loaded twice, a consumer’s number can be attached to several accounts, and manual dialing can bypass automated counters. We would expect a collector to test its counting logic against sample accounts, to keep the results, and to repeat the test after system changes. A creditor can ask to see those tests as part of its vendor oversight, which is a stronger check than a statement in a questionnaire.
Calls the creditor makes itself
A bank collecting its own early-stage delinquencies was not bound by the proposed limit. But a consumer does not distinguish between calls from the bank and calls from the agency the bank later uses. A creditor that calls heavily before placement, and then places the account with an agency that is limited, has a customer experience that gets better when the account leaves the bank. We think creditors should look at the full sequence of contacts a customer receives from first delinquency to resolution, whichever party makes them.
When, where and through which channel
Inconvenient times and places, in the consumer’s words
The Act already barred collectors from communicating at times or places they knew or should have known were inconvenient to the consumer. The proposal clarified that a consumer did not need to use specific words to make that known. “I can’t talk at work” would be enough. It also clarified that a consumer could designate a medium, such as a particular email address or telephone number, that the collector could not use.
For a collector, that meant capturing consumer statements in a form its systems could act on. A preference expressed on a call has to become a flag in the dialing system and the email platform. For a creditor, it raised a question about the information the creditor itself held. A customer who had told the bank not to call at work, or who had asked to be contacted only by email, might reasonably expect that preference to survive the move to collection. Whether the law requires a collector to honor preferences given to the creditor is a legal question. Whether the creditor passes them on is a customer experience choice it controls.
Local time depends on knowing where the consumer is
The Act treats a time before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. local time at the consumer’s location as inconvenient, absent knowledge to the contrary, and Regulation F now restates that rule. Local time requires knowing the consumer’s location, which a mailing address may not show for a customer who has moved or who travels. A mobile number with an area code from one state may belong to someone living in another. Creditors that pass current address and time zone information, rather than the address at account opening, help collectors respect calling hours. The same applies to text messages and emails, which arrive whenever they are sent.
Email and text, with an exit
The proposal clarified that collectors could use email and text messages, subject to limits. Each message would have to tell the consumer how to opt out. The proposal also offered procedures that, if followed, would protect a collector from liability for an unintentional disclosure to a third party, such as a family member or employer who sees an email. The aim was to let collectors use channels consumers might prefer without exposing consumers’ debts to others.
Electronic channels raise their own data questions: which email address or mobile number the collector uses, where it came from, whether the consumer consented, and whether the address is a work account that an employer can read. A creditor that hands a collector a customer’s email address is part of the answer to each of those questions. We think creditors should record, for each contact point they pass on, where it came from, when the customer last used it and whether the customer limited its use.
Voicemail that says little
The limited-content message was the proposal’s answer to a long-standing difficulty: a collector who leaves a voicemail risks revealing the debt to whoever hears it, and a collector who leaves no message cannot reach the consumer. The proposed definition allowed a message with specified, limited content that would not count as a communication. For consumers, it meant voicemails that said less. For creditors, it meant that the business name used in those messages, and whether it signaled debt collection, would matter. A creditor that cares about its customers’ privacy would want to see the scripts its agencies use.
Work addresses and shared devices
A consumer’s email address at work, or a family tablet that receives text messages, is a channel where a collection message may be seen by someone else. The proposal’s third-party disclosure procedures addressed that risk for collectors. Creditors hold the same kind of contact data and decide which pieces to pass on. A creditor that flags addresses it knows to be employer-provided, and numbers it knows to be shared, gives its collectors a better chance of reaching the right person privately.
Channel choice as a service
Seen from the consumer’s side, the channel provisions were a step toward letting people manage collection the way they manage other financial tasks: on their own schedule, in writing, without a phone call at an awkward moment. A creditor that offered self-service tools, such as a portal to see the balance, set up a payment plan or dispute an item, would complement that. We think creditors should treat the collection channel strategy as part of their digital service design, not as a separate back-office matter.
What the consumer is told at the start
A notice built from the creditor’s records
The Act requires a debt collector to give the consumer a validation notice, with certain information about the debt and the consumer’s rights, within five days of the initial communication unless that information was already provided. The proposal would specify the content, require information about the debt including an itemization, add prompts the consumer could use to dispute it or request the original creditor’s name and address, and offer a model notice.
Every number in that itemization starts in the creditor’s systems. A collector cannot itemize what it was not given. A creditor that places accounts with incomplete or inconsistent data, or sells debt with thin records, makes an accurate notice harder and invites disputes. The proposal therefore created a data quality obligation for creditors in practice, even though it did not address them in law.
What a placement file should contain
We think a creditor’s placement or sale file should carry, for each account, the reference balance and the date it relates to, the interest, fees, payments and credits since that date, the identity of the original creditor and current creditor, the account number in the form the consumer would recognize, and the consumer’s known contact points and stated preferences, each with its source. It should also carry any dispute history. That list is our view of good practice, not a requirement, but each item maps to something the collector would need to tell the consumer or to respect.
Matching what the customer last saw
A consumer who receives a validation notice will compare it with whatever they last saw from the creditor: a monthly statement, a charge-off letter or an online balance. If the numbers do not reconcile, the consumer is likely to dispute, and reasonably so. We think creditors should make sure the reference balance and date they pass to a collector correspond to a document the customer actually received, and should keep that document available for verification. A notice the customer can recognize is the start of a better collection experience.
Disputes that travel back
The validation notice invites disputes. Under the Act, as Regulation F now restates it, if a consumer disputes a debt in writing within the validation period, the collector must stop collecting the disputed debt until it sends verification or a copy of a judgment. Verification depends, again, on creditor records. A creditor that cannot respond quickly to a collector’s verification request leaves the collector unable to resume and the consumer waiting. Service levels for verification belong in the placement agreement.
Names the consumer recognizes
The proposed prompts would let a consumer ask for the name and address of the original creditor. A consumer may know a credit card by a retail brand, a loan by a fintech app’s name, or an account by a bank that has since merged. If the name in the notice is the legal entity on the charter, the consumer may not recognize the debt at all. We think creditors should pass the names under which customers knew the account, alongside the legal names, so that notices and calls refer to something the consumer can place.
Electronic delivery
The proposal set out how the validation notice and other disclosures could be delivered electronically, including a safe harbor for delivering the notice in the body of an email that is the collector’s first communication. Electronic delivery of a legally significant notice raises questions of consent, deliverability and proof. A creditor that has the customer’s e-sign consent for account statements may assume it carries over. Whether it does is a question for counsel, and we would not assume it.
What happens to the credit report and to old debts
No reporting before reaching out
The proposal would bar a collector from furnishing information about a debt to a consumer reporting agency before communicating with the consumer about it. The practice it targeted, sometimes called passive collection, meant a consumer might first learn of a debt from a credit report. The rule put a communication first.
For creditors, this provision interacted with their own furnishing. A creditor that reports a charged-off account and then places it with an agency that also reports will produce two tradelines the consumer must understand. Coordination between the creditor’s furnishing and the agency’s is part of the consumer’s experience, and errors in either produce disputes under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Disputes about what is reported
Consumers who see a collection account on their credit report may dispute it with the credit bureau, the collector or the creditor. Each of those routes has its own process under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and each depends on accurate underlying data. A creditor that receives a dispute about an account it has placed or sold should be able to see what the collector has reported and when, so that the two do not give the consumer contradictory answers.
Time-barred debt
The proposal would bar collectors from suing or threatening to sue on time-barred debt. It also said the Bureau would test disclosures telling consumers that a collector could not sue on an old debt, before deciding whether to require them. For creditors that sell older charged-off debt, the provision raised a question about records: whether the buyer has the information needed to determine when the statute of limitations expires. That depends on dates the creditor holds, such as the last payment and the charge-off date, and on which state’s law applies.
Debt sales and what goes with them
The Bureau also proposed to bar debt collectors, with exceptions, from selling, transferring or placing for collection a debt they knew or should have known had been paid or settled, had been discharged in bankruptcy, or was the subject of an identity theft report. That restriction binds debt collectors, including debt buyers that are debt collectors under the Act and later resell or place debts. Whether those buyers can tell which debts it covers depends on the records the creditor passed on. Clean records of payments, settlements, bankruptcies and identity theft claims, passed with the account, reduce the chance that a consumer is pursued for a debt that should not be collected.
Estates
The proposal would let collectors communicate with the personal representative of a deceased consumer’s estate and treat that person as entitled to the validation notice. For creditors, accounts of deceased customers are a distinct customer experience: the people dealing with them are grieving family members or executors. A creditor that identifies these accounts and handles them through a dedicated process, whether in-house or with a specialized agency, reduces the risk of collection contacts that cause distress and complaints.
The data handoff as a customer experience system
Each of the four parts above depends on information that moves from creditor to collector and back. In some firms that movement is handled as a file transfer, owned by operations and judged by whether the file arrived. The proposal’s detail made it worth treating the handoff as a system that shapes what customers experience, with its own owner, standards and tests.
One placement data standard
A creditor that uses several agencies, law firms and buyers can end up with a different file format and field list for each. Differences in what each vendor receives produce differences in what each customer experiences. We would define one placement data standard covering balances and itemization data, account identifiers, contact points with provenance, stated preferences, dispute history, and flags for bankruptcy, deceased customers, identity theft claims and military status. Every vendor would receive the same content, whatever the transport.
Provenance for every contact point
The proposal’s channel provisions made the origin of a phone number or email address matter. A number the customer gave at account opening, a number found by skip tracing and a number the customer asked the bank to stop using are different things. A field that records the source and date of each contact point, and any limits the customer placed on it, turns a list of numbers into information a collector can act on responsibly.
Changes after placement
Customers keep contacting the creditor after an account is placed. They make payments directly, file disputes, report identity theft, ask for hardship arrangements or change their contact details. Each of those events needs to reach the collector quickly, or the collector will act on stale information. We would set service levels for passing such updates, test them, and include them in vendor reporting.
Information coming back
The flow also runs the other way. Collectors receive disputes, complaints, payments, new contact information and statements about inconvenient times. A creditor that receives none of this cannot see its customers’ experience or correct its own records. Regular return files, with defined content, close the loop and let the creditor update its systems and its own furnishing.
An owner for the handoff
The handoff touches collections operations, compliance, information technology, vendor management and customer experience. Without a named owner, each assumes another is responsible for its content. We would give one senior manager responsibility for the placement data standard, the update and return flows and the reporting, with compliance reviewing changes. That owner should also sign off on any new vendor’s ability to receive and use the standard before accounts are placed.
Protecting the file
A placement file holds names, addresses, account numbers, balances and sometimes hardship or health-related information. It is one of the more sensitive sets of customer data a creditor sends to an outside party. We would treat its transmission, storage and retention at the vendor as a security matter subject to the same review the creditor applies to other vendors holding customer data, and we would require the vendor to return or destroy data when accounts are recalled or the relationship ends.
Recalling accounts cleanly
Creditors recall accounts from collectors when a customer files for bankruptcy, dies, reports identity theft, enters a hardship program or simply when a placement period ends. A recall that is not processed promptly can leave a collector contacting a consumer it should no longer pursue. We would make recall a defined transaction with a confirmation back from the vendor, and would check periodically that recalled accounts have stopped generating contact.
Complaints as a measure
Complaints about collection reach creditors directly, through collectors and through regulators. A creditor that combines all three by vendor and by issue has an early warning system for problems the proposal was meant to prevent, such as excessive calls, messages to the wrong person, or confusing notices. We would review those combined complaints with each vendor on a fixed schedule and tie the results to placement decisions.
What a creditor would ask its collectors in 2019
Pulling the four parts together, a creditor reviewing its collection vendors after the proposal could have used a short set of questions. They are good practice in our view, not legal requirements:
- How do you count call attempts and conversations, and can you report them by account and by consumer?
- How do you record and honor a consumer’s statement that a time, place or channel is inconvenient?
- Which email addresses and mobile numbers do you use, how did you obtain them, and how do consumers opt out?
- What do your voicemail scripts and validation notices say, and how do you build the itemization from our data?
- When do you furnish to credit bureaus, and how do you coordinate with our own reporting?
The answers would show which vendors were ready for the proposal and which would need to change, and they would give the creditor a baseline to measure against once a final rule arrived.
Where the argument is weakest
The rule did not bind creditors
The first objection is that the proposal regulated debt collectors, not creditors, so a bank had no obligation to act. That is right as to the Act. Our argument is about the creditor’s exposure through its vendors and its brand. The federal banking agencies issue guidance on managing the risks of third-party relationships; their joint guidance of June 2023 replaced each agency’s earlier general guidance on the subject. A collector’s failures can lead to complaints, supervisory attention and reputational harm for the creditor that hired it. The proposal gave creditors a specification to manage against.
A proposal is not a rule
The second objection is timing. In May 2019 the proposal was open for comment and could change. Investing in data and contracts around draft provisions risked wasted work. We think the parts of our argument that matter most did not depend on the final details: knowing how often customers are contacted, passing accurate itemization data, recording contact preferences and coordinating credit reporting all made sense under the existing statute as well.
Not every consumer wants digital contact
A third objection is that the proposal’s embrace of email and text could disadvantage consumers who lack reliable internet access or prefer paper. The proposal kept letters and calls, and let consumers restrict channels. For a creditor, the point is to honor the consumer’s choice in either direction. A placement file that records a preference for paper, or a lack of email, is as useful as one that records a preferred email address.
Customer experience in collection is a contradiction
A fourth objection is that collection is inherently adversarial, so customer experience is the wrong frame. We disagree. Consumers in collection include people who want to pay and cannot, people who do not recognize the debt, and people who are victims of identity theft or error. How they are treated affects whether they pay, whether they dispute, whether they complain and whether they come back as customers. The proposal’s focus on channels, clarity and limits was a recognition of that.
Data handoffs are already governed by contracts
A fifth objection is that placement agreements already cover data. They may well do so at the level of file formats and fields. We think fewer specify the provenance of contact points, the consumer’s stated preferences, itemization reference dates or dispute history with the precision the proposal implied. The gap was in content, not in the existence of a contract.
Costs may rise
A sixth objection is cost. Tighter call practices, new electronic procedures, richer data and more reporting all cost money, and some of that cost would flow back to creditors in collection fees or lower prices for sold debt. That is likely true. Against it, a creditor should weigh the cost of complaints, disputes, supervisory findings and lost customers. We think the proposal’s detail made it easier, not harder, to compare vendors on those terms.
How it differs by kind of creditor
Large banks
A large bank may place high volumes of accounts with several agencies and law firms, and may sell charged-off debt. Their challenge is consistency: the same data and preferences, delivered the same way, to every vendor, with comparable reporting back. A single placement data standard across vendors, with tests that each vendor’s systems can consume it, is where we would start.
Credit unions and community banks
Smaller institutions may collect more in-house and place fewer accounts. Their relationships with members and customers can be local and long-standing, which raises the reputational cost of a collector’s misstep. For them, the proposal offered a ready checklist for vendor due diligence: call limits, channel practices, voicemail scripts, validation notice content and furnishing practices.
Fintech lenders
Digital lenders already communicate with customers by app, email and text. For them, the proposal’s channel provisions described a collection experience consistent with the rest of their product. Their risk is the reverse of a traditional bank’s: a customer used to self-service who is suddenly called by an agency. Choosing collectors who can work in digital channels, with the opt-outs and safeguards the proposal described, keeps the experience consistent.
Card issuers and retail partnerships
Credit cards issued with a retail or brand partner put three names in front of the consumer: the issuing bank, the brand and, in collection, the agency. Confusion about who is collecting, and for whom, is a ready source of disputes. Issuers in these programs have reason to agree with their partners and their collectors how the account will be described at every stage, so that the consumer sees one consistent story.
Auto lenders and servicers
Auto finance adds repossession to the collection experience, and an account can move between servicing, collection and recovery vendors. For these creditors, the consistency of data across that chain matters more than for unsecured lending, because each handoff is a point where a payment, a dispute or a hardship arrangement can be lost. The proposal’s emphasis on accurate information at the start of collection applies at every handoff.
Debt sellers
Creditors that sell debt lose control of the collection experience at sale, but not of the data that shapes it. The quality and completeness of the records sold, and the terms of the sale agreement about what buyers may do, are the creditor’s last influence. Whether a buyer that collects is a debt collector under the Act depends on the facts: the proposal noted the Supreme Court’s 2017 holding in Henson v. Santander that a company collecting defaulted debts it purchased is not covered under one prong of the definition. Either way, the data a buyer receives determines whether it can treat consumers as the proposal described. A creditor that sells thin files exports risk to its former customers.
Across all of these creditors, the same conclusion follows. The 2019 draft described the collection experience in enough detail to be written down, measured and contracted for. Creditors could not make collectors comply with the Act; that was the collectors’ obligation. They could decide which collectors to use, what data to give them, what to require in return and how to check it. Those decisions shaped what their customers experienced in collection, whatever the final rule turned out to say.
With hindsight
The Bureau finished the rule in two parts. A final rule on communications and related practices was published on November 30, 2020, and a second, mainly on validation disclosures and time-barred debt, was published on January 19, 2021. Both took effect on November 30, 2021. In April 2021 the Bureau proposed delaying that date by sixty days, to January 29, 2022; it withdrew the proposal in a notice published on September 1, 2021, and the original date held.
The call limit survived in a modified form. As codified in 12 CFR 1006.14, current through November 12, 2026, a collector is presumed to comply with the prohibition on repeated or continuous calls if it calls a person about a particular debt neither more than seven times within seven consecutive days nor within seven consecutive days after a telephone conversation about it, and is presumed to violate the prohibition if it exceeds either frequency. The November 2020 rule described these as presumptions that can be rebutted, with non-exhaustive lists of factors. Calls with the person’s prior consent, given directly to the collector, are excluded within limits.
Other pieces of the 2019 draft are in the regulation today. The limited-content message is defined. Collectors must offer an opt-out in each email and text. The regulation sets out procedures for email addresses, including one route that depends on the creditor: the creditor must have obtained and used the address, and must have sent the consumer a notice disclosing the transfer of the debt and the collector’s possible use of the address, with an opt-out window of at least 35 days. The validation notice rests on an “itemization date,” one of five reference dates for which the collector can ascertain the amount of the debt, such as the last statement date or the charge-off date. Collectors may not sue or threaten suit on time-barred debt, may not furnish information before reaching out to the consumer, and must keep records evidencing compliance until three years after their last collection activity on a debt, and call recordings for three years.
Guidance around the rule moved more than the rule did. The Bureau published interpretive documents under Regulation F on pay-to-pay fees in 2022, on time-barred debt in 2023 and on medical debt in 2024. On May 12, 2025, it withdrew all three, along with other debt collection bulletins and circulars and dozens of other guidance documents, saying it would avoid issuing guidance except where necessary and where compliance burdens would be reduced. The regulation itself was not changed by that withdrawal.
What held up is our central point: the final rule made the creditor part of the machinery. Its email procedure gives the creditor a defined role, and its itemization rules depend on dates only the creditor holds. The final rules kept the parts of the 2019 draft that placement data standards and vendor reporting would serve: the call-frequency test, the electronic opt-outs and the itemized validation notice. What did not hold was any expectation that interpretive guidance would keep filling gaps; in our reading, after May 2025 the text of Regulation F, its official interpretations and the statute are the main reference points. Firms should check current status with counsel before relying on any withdrawn document.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.