Hospital and health plan price transparency: outlook to 2027
Hospital price files now carry remittance-based allowed amounts and a signed attestation, plan files move to a new quarterly format in 2027, and the insured cost estimate still has no rule.
The question for 2027
Price transparency has moved from posting files to proving their accuracy. Hospitals must now publish allowed amounts computed from remittance data, name a senior official in their files and attest that the data are complete [1]. Health plans face restructured files from March 2027 [9], and the No Surprises Act estimates for insured patients still wait for a rule [12]. This outlook sets out where each strand stands as checked on 16 November 2026 and what CMS's enforcement records show.
What part 180 asks of hospitals now
Under 45 CFR part 180, each hospital publishes one machine-readable file of standard charges for all items and services and a consumer-friendly display of shoppable services, and updates the file at least once a year [1]. The CY 2024 outpatient payment rule, published November 22, 2023 and effective January 1, 2024, added a CMS template, more data elements, a .txt file in the website root folder linking to the file, a website footer link to the page that hosts it, and changes to the enforcement process [4]. The file has had to follow the CMS template layout since July 1, 2024, and since January 1, 2025 it has had to carry drug units and the modifiers that change a charge [1].
The CY 2026 rule, published November 25, 2025 and effective January 1, 2026, went further [6]. Where a negotiated charge is a percentage or algorithm, hospitals must encode the 10th percentile, median and 90th percentile allowed amounts and the count of remittances used, drawn from a lookback of no less than 12 and no more than 15 months [1]. CMS requires those amounts to be calculated from EDI 835 electronic remittance advice data or an equivalent remittance source [6]. Each file must also carry the hospital's Type 2 NPIs, an attestation that the data are true, accurate and complete, and the name of the chief executive, president or senior official designated to oversee the encoding [1]. CMS delayed enforcement of these changes until April 1, 2026 [6] [8].
Penalties scale with size. Since January 1, 2022 the maximum daily penalty has been $300 for a hospital with 30 or fewer beds, $10 per bed for 31 to 550 beds and $5,500 above 550 beds, adjusted each year for inflation [1]. From January 1, 2026 a penalty is cut by 35 percent if the hospital waives its right to a hearing within 30 calendar days, with exceptions [1] [6].
From the 2025 executive order to the 2026 rules
Executive Order 14221 of February 25, 2025, published February 28, 2025, directed the Secretaries of the Treasury, Labor and Health and Human Services to take action within 90 days of the order to require the disclosure of actual prices of items and services, not estimates; to issue updated guidance or proposed regulatory action ensuring pricing information is standardized and easily comparable across hospitals and health plans; and to issue guidance or proposed regulatory action updating enforcement policies [5]. Both the CY 2026 hospital rule and the 2026 Transparency in Coverage rule cite the order [6] [9].
The order also reached Medicare payment. In the same CY 2026 rule CMS finalized a requirement that hospitals report, on the Medicare cost report for cost reporting periods ending on or after January 1, 2026, the median payer-specific negotiated charge by MS-DRG for their Medicare Advantage organizations, taken from their machine-readable file, and to use it in MS-DRG relative weights beginning in FY 2029 [6]. The next step on the hospital side is open: the CY 2027 rule, published November 6, 2026 and effective January 1, 2027, amends no part of 45 CFR; it reports 185 timely pieces of correspondence on a request for information about the standardization and comparability of the files and the consumer-friendly display, and says CMS will take them into consideration for future rulemaking [7].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: the cost report link changes the stakes. A negotiated rate that was once a disclosure becomes, from FY 2029, an input to how Medicare weights inpatient payment. An error in the file can now travel into a federal payment calculation.
Enforcement: what CMS's own records show
CMS posts each civil money penalty notice on its enforcement page; as checked on 16 November 2026 the page, last modified June 11, 2026, lists 28 hospitals and links 29 notices, the latest dated June 3, 2026 [2]. Two of the linked documents, for UF Health North and Holy Cross Hospital, are notices that CMS resolved its disputes with the hospital, and three hospitals are marked as under review [2]. On the page as last modified June 11, 2026, the other 27 notices imposed penalties totaling $4,938,685, with a median of $84,216 and a range of $32,301 to $883,180; these are amounts imposed, not amounts collected [2].
| Year of notice | Notices linked | Penalty notices with an amount | Amounts imposed (page last modified June 11, 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 2 [2] | 2 [2] | $1,097,500 [2] |
| 2023 | 12 [2] | 10 [2] | $1,621,300 [2] |
| 2024 | 3 [2] | 3 [2] | $966,084 [2] |
| 2025 | 10 [2] | 10 [2] | $1,161,830 [2] |
| 2026 (to June 3) | 2 [2] | 2 [2] | $91,971 [2] |
The largest single notice, dated June 7, 2022, imposed $883,180 on Northside Hospital Atlanta and combined $300 a day for the last 121 days of 2021 with $10 a bed for 536 beds over 158 days in 2022 [17]. The most recent, a subsequent notice to Pinnacle Hospital dated June 3, 2026, imposed $40,356: $342 a day for a hospital with 30 or fewer beds over 118 days [18].
Penalties end a long funnel. CMS's enforcement dataset, in its release covering activity to July 31, 2026, records 3,646 warning notices, 2,107 requests for corrective action plans and 29 penalty notices since 2021 [3]. Warning notices rose from 615 in 2023 to 1,030 in 2025, and the first seven months of 2026 already show 953 [3]. In the CY 2026 rule CMS gave its own tally of 2,531 warning notices, 1,419 corrective action plans and 27 penalties over the first four years [6].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: CMS's records show it relying far more on warning letters and corrective plans than on fines. Warnings rose after the executive order; penalty notices did not. We read the attestation and named official as the next lever, because they turn a file's accuracy into a signed statement.
Health plans: Transparency in Coverage on a new clock
The 2020 Transparency in Coverage rule, effective January 11, 2021, required plans and issuers to post in-network rate, out-of-network allowed amount and prescription drug files for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2022, and to phase in a member cost-sharing tool from 500 items and services in 2023 to all items and services in 2024 [10]. The Departments published an amending rule on October 6, 2026, effective December 7, 2026 [9]. Its file changes apply from March 6, 2027, and its new contextual files and website footer from September 6, 2027 [9].
Under the amended text, in-network rate and out-of-network allowed amount files are posted quarterly on the first day of each calendar-year quarter, with one in-network rate file for each provider network carrying the network name and identifier, while the prescription drug file is updated monthly [9]. Out-of-network data cover a 6-month period beginning 9 months before publication, and are withheld only where fewer than 11 claims would be reported [9]. Price information must also be available by phone, where a plan may limit a request to no fewer than 20 providers a day; meeting that requirement also satisfies section 114 of the No Surprises Act [9]. On prescription drug prices, the rule says the Departments plan to begin working to implement the prescription drug file soon [9].
No Surprises Act estimates: one half in force
For uninsured and self-pay patients, good faith estimates have applied since January 1, 2022: an estimate is due within 1 business day of scheduling when the service is at least 3 business days away, and within 3 business days when it is at least 10 business days away or on request [14]. A patient may dispute a bill that exceeds the estimate by at least $400 [15]. HHS still does not enforce the inclusion of co-provider and co-facility charges in those estimates, pending future rulemaking [13].
For insured patients the law has providers send estimates to the plan, which then gives the patient an advanced explanation of benefits, but that half has no rule yet [12]. The Departments sought information in September 2022 [11]. Their December 13, 2024 progress update weighed X12 and HL7 FHIR options for moving estimates between providers and payers and said they were working toward rulemaking [12]. As checked on 16 November 2026, CMS's No Surprises Act rules page lists that request for information and the two progress updates but no proposed rule on the advanced explanation of benefits [16], and a Federal Register search for proposed rules containing the phrase returns the 2022 request for information and other rules that mention it, but no proposed rule implementing it [19].
What this asks of hospital data systems
The 2026 requirements reach past the chargemaster. For each item or service whose negotiated charge is a percentage or algorithm, the percentiles must be computed from 835 remittance data or an equivalent source [6], and each negotiated charge must be tied to a named payer and plan [1]. The file must give the license number, every inpatient facility and stand-alone emergency department under that license, and the Type 2 NPIs [1]. CMS added the NPIs so hospital data can be compared with plans' Transparency in Coverage files [6]. And when CMS acts on a hospital that is part of a health system, it may notify the system's leadership and work with it to address similar deficiencies across the system [1].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: most systems built for the 2021 rule export charges once a year. The 2026 rule asks for a repeatable pipeline: remittance ingestion, a documented percentile method, location and NPI master data, version control on each file and a sign-off record for the named official. Teams that run the file as a product with owners and tests will absorb the next round of standardization at lower cost; the insured estimate, when a rule arrives, will need the same price data at scheduling.
What to watch through 2027
The CY 2028 outpatient proposed rule, for any part 180 amendment that follows the request for information [7]; new notices on the enforcement page and dataset [2] [3]; plan readiness for March 6 and September 6, 2027 [9]; and any proposed rule on the advanced explanation of benefits [12].
Data and method
Penalty counts and amounts come from the CMS Hospital Price Transparency Enforcement Actions page (last modified June 11, 2026), opened November 16, 2026 [2]. We read the page's table row by row, took every linked notice PDF in table order and paired each with its "Date Action Taken"; one row, Pinnacle Hospital, links two notices [2].
- Kind of notice: a PDF headed "Notice of Resolution" counts as a resolution notice and has no amount; all others count as penalty notices [2].
- Amount: the dollar figure following "total CMP of" or "subsequent CMP of" in the notice text, as imposed; it is not the amount collected, and does not reflect any later appeal, reduction or settlement [2].
- Year: the year of the notice date shown on the page [2].
- Under review: rows whose hospital name carries CMS's "Under Review" mark, which under 45 CFR 180.90(e)(2)(i) means the hospital requested a hearing [1].
Funnel counts come from the CSV of the data.cms.gov dataset Hospital Price Transparency Enforcement Activities and Outcomes, release dated July 2026 (modified August 14, 2026), with 13,355 rows covering actions dated January 7, 2021 to July 31, 2026 [3]. We counted rows by the Action field and by the year of Date_of_Action, without deduplicating hospitals; the dataset's 29 CMP Notice rows match the 29 notices on the enforcement page [3].
What this means for you
- Hospital revenue cycle and finance: Treat the allowed-amount percentiles as a governed calculation: CMS requires 835 remittance data or an equivalent source [6] and a lookback of 12 to 15 months [1]. Reconcile the MRF's Medicare Advantage medians with what will go on the cost report [6].
- Hospital executives and compliance: Decide who is the named official for each file and what evidence supports the attestation, since part 180 now requires both [1]; weigh the 35 percent reduction for waiving a hearing against the admission it involves [6].
- Multi-hospital health systems: Audit every hospital's file together, because CMS may notify a health system's leadership and work with it on similar deficiencies across the system [1], and check that each location and NPI matches registration records.
- Health plans and issuers: Plan the move to network-level, quarterly files by March 6, 2027 and the contextual files and footer by September 6, 2027 [9]; align provider and network identifiers with hospital files where you contract.
- Patient access and scheduling: Keep uninsured estimates on the 1- and 3-business-day clocks [14], and track the advanced explanation of benefits standards work, which the Departments tied to X12 and HL7 FHIR options [12].
Moraph predictions
Every prediction is Moraph's view, not a fact. Each has a date, a confidence level (70% means we expect to be wrong about three times in ten) and a test anyone can apply. We score them on this page when the date comes and never remove one. How we make and score predictions.
P1 By Confidence 70% Open
CMS publishes a proposed rule in the Federal Register that would amend 45 CFR part 180.
How we will check: A Federal Register proposed rule dated on or before August 31, 2027 that includes amendments to 45 CFR part 180 (for example in the CY 2028 OPPS/ASC proposed rule).
Basis: CMS amended part 180 through the CY 2024 and CY 2026 outpatient rules [4] [6], and the CY 2027 final rule says the 185 comments on its standardization request for information will be considered for future rulemaking [7].
P2 By Confidence 60% Open
CMS's Hospital Price Transparency Enforcement Actions page links at least 32 civil money penalty notices.
How we will check: Count the notice PDFs linked in the table on the CMS enforcement actions page on December 31, 2027, by the method in this piece; 32 or more is a hit.
Basis: The page links 29 notices as of November 16, 2026, with 10 dated in 2025 and 2 in 2026 [2]; enforcement of the 2026 requirements began April 1, 2026 [8].
P3 By Confidence 70% Open
No proposed rule implementing the No Surprises Act advanced explanation of benefits is published in the Federal Register.
How we will check: No Federal Register proposed or final rule dated on or before December 31, 2027 that sets requirements for the advanced explanation of benefits.
Basis: The Departments' request for information dates from September 2022 [11]; their latest progress update, December 13, 2024, still weighed competing data standards [12]; CMS's rules page and a Federal Register search list no proposed rule as checked on 16 November 2026 [16] [19].
P4 By Confidence 80% Open
The March 6, 2027 applicability date for the amended Transparency in Coverage rate files is not postponed by a Federal Register document.
How we will check: No Federal Register rule or notice dated on or before March 6, 2027 that delays the March 6, 2027 applicability date in 45 CFR 147.212(c)(1).
Basis: The October 2026 rule already moved the date to 5 months after publication after considering comments on timing [9].
P5 By Confidence 60% Open
CMS's Hospital Price Transparency enforcement dataset records at least 1,500 warning notices dated in calendar year 2026.
How we will check: In the latest release of the data.cms.gov dataset Hospital Price Transparency Enforcement Activities and Outcomes published on or before June 30, 2027 that covers all of 2026, count rows with Action Warning Notice and a 2026 Date_of_Action.
Basis: The July 2026 release records 953 warning notices dated January 1 to July 31, 2026, against 1,030 in all of 2025 [3].
Facts on this page link to their sources. Text marked "Moraph's view", and every prediction, is our own analysis, not a fact or advice. Methodology.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the piece where needed.