HIPAA enforcement, 2008 to 2026: more cases, smaller amounts, a turn to ransomware
We counted every HIPAA resolution agreement and civil money penalty OCR has published to see how its cases changed in number, size and cause.
What OCR's record covers
The HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) enforces the HIPAA Privacy, Security and Breach Notification Rules, and it publishes the cases that end in money on one page: "Resolution Agreements and Civil Money Penalties" [1]. A resolution agreement is a settlement in which a covered entity or business associate agrees to obligations and reports to HHS, generally for three years, and may pay a resolution amount; if OCR cannot resolve a case informally, it may impose civil money penalties [1]. Most complaints never reach that page: as of October 31, 2024, OCR reported that it had settled or imposed a civil money penalty in 152 cases, against more than 374,000 complaints received since 2003 [2].
We read every entry on that page and every OCR press release behind it, and counted the actions year by year. The result is 191 monetary actions announced between July 16, 2008 and October 29, 2026, worth $163.6 million in total [1] [16]. Entities are named below only as OCR names them, and an OCR settlement is not an admission of liability: the agreements say so in terms [13] [18].
Data and method
Frame: the OCR listing as captured by the Internet Archive on October 23, 2026, because www.hhs.gov refuses scripted requests; we read archived copies of the exact hhs.gov URLs [1].
- One row per entity that paid or was penalized. Releases that announce several cases at once were split into their cases: five Right of Access settlements in September 2020, five in November 2021, four actions in March 2022, eleven in July 2022, three in September 2022, three hospitals in September 2018, two entities in May 2014, and four ransomware settlements in April 2026 [1] [3] [11].
- Left out: entries that are not HIPAA monetary actions (a 42 CFR Part 2 rule fact sheet, a civil rights agreement on kosher devices, a disposal FAQ, and OCR's 2018 year-end summary), and a second link to the Montefiore agreement listed under two dates, counted once [1] [18].
- Added: two actions OCR announced in releases that the captured listing does not show: American Medical Response (August 1, 2024, OCR's 49th Right of Access action), which the listing omits, and Lehigh Valley Health Network (October 29, 2026), announced after the capture date [20] [16].
- Coverage: OCR's listing is not a complete record, since it omits at least the American Medical Response penalty [1] [20]. We searched OCR's news releases for actions missing from the listing only from 2023 onward; for earlier years we rely on the listing alone, so counts for those years, and especially the early ones, may be low.
- Year: the date OCR announced the action in its press release, or the listing date where we used no release. This moves Green Ridge Behavioral Health (listed October 30, 2023, announced February 21, 2024), Top of the World Ranch Treatment Center (agreement June 6, 2025, announced February 19, 2026) and three of the four April 2026 ransomware settlements into the year of announcement [1] [6] [11]. One listing entry, Raleigh Orthopaedic Clinic, has no date; it sits between two 2016 entries and is counted in 2016 [1].
- Amount: the resolution amount or penalty as OCR states it, rounded where OCR rounds (for example "$4.3 million") [1]. Medians are of the actions in that year.
- Initiatives: an action counts toward the Right of Access Initiative, ransomware or the Risk Analysis Initiative only where OCR's release, listing title or agreement says so. We checked our totals against OCR's own running counts: 56 Right of Access actions (Shen Smiles was the 56th) [15], 22 ransomware actions (Lehigh Valley Health Network was the 22nd) [16], and 14 Risk Analysis Initiative actions (the Spencer Gifts plan was the 14th) [12]. OCR's April 2026 release says its four settlements brought the Risk Analysis count to 13 but does not say which of the four was the 13th, so that action is counted in 2026 without being named [11]. OSF Healthcare System's agreement describes a ransomware attack and OCR's listing title calls it a ransomware investigation, which is consistent with Lehigh Valley being the 22nd [1] [13] [16].
Cross-check: counting our rows up to October 31, 2024 gives 153 actions and $149.2 million, while OCR's highlights page gives 152 cases and $144,878,972 for the same date [1] [2]. Our count is higher by one action and $4,275,718 [1] [2]. OCR does not say which cases its figures include, so we cannot tell which rows make up the difference. One row is close to that size, the $4,348,000 judgment against MD Anderson in June 2018 that OCR's 2018 summary counts [3], but leaving it out would leave our total $72,282 below OCR's [1] [2] [3]. We keep every action the listing shows.
Fewer large cases, more small ones
Read the counts for years before 2023 as a minimum: the listing omits at least one action we found elsewhere, and for those years we did not search OCR's releases for others, so early-year counts may be low [1] [20].
| Year announced | Actions | Total paid or imposed | Median | Right of Access Initiative | Ransomware (as OCR labels it) | Risk Analysis Initiative |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 to 2018 | 63 [1] [3] [17] | $100.9 million [1] [3] [17] | $800,000 [1] [3] [17] | 0 [1] [3] [17] | 0 [1] [3] [17] | 0 [1] [3] [17] |
| 2019 | 11 [1] [4] | $15.3 million [1] [4] | $1,600,000 [1] [4] | 2 [1] [4] | 0 [1] [4] | 0 [1] [4] |
| 2020 | 19 [1] | $13.6 million [1] | $70,000 [1] | 11 [1] | 0 [1] | 0 [1] |
| 2021 | 14 [1] | $6.0 million [1] | $67,500 [1] | 12 [1] | 0 [1] | 0 [1] |
| 2022 | 22 [1] | $2.2 million [1] | $40,000 [1] | 17 [1] | 0 [1] | 0 [1] |
| 2023 | 13 [1] [6] | $4.2 million [1] [6] | $100,000 [1] [6] | 4 [1] [6] | 1 [1] [6] | 0 [1] [6] |
| 2024 | 16 [1] [5] | $9.3 million [1] [5] | $177,600 [1] [5] | 5 [1] [5] | 6 [1] [5] | 1 [1] [5] |
| 2025 | 21 [1] [9] | $8.3 million [1] [9] | $182,000 [1] [9] | 3 [1] [9] | 8 [1] [9] | 9 [1] [9] |
| 2026 (to October 29) | 12 [1] [11] [12] [15] [16] | $4.0 million [1] [11] [12] [15] [16] | $282,500 [1] [11] [12] [15] [16] | 2 [1] [11] [12] [15] [16] | 7 [1] [11] [12] [15] [16] | 4 [1] [11] [12] [15] [16] |
From 2008 to 2018 OCR announced 63 monetary actions with a median of $800,000, and 29 of them were $1 million or more [1]. From 2019 to October 2026 it announced 128, twice as many, but with a median of $100,000; 18 were $1 million or more and 63 were under $100,000 [1]. The record single amount is still Anthem's $16 million in October 2018 [17], and OCR's own 2018 summary counted $28.7 million for that year once Cottage Health's $3 million, announced in February 2019, is included [1] [3].
The fall in size is mostly a change in what OCR chose to pursue. OCR's first Right of Access Initiative case, settled for $85,000 in September 2019 [4], was with Bayfront Health St. Petersburg [4]. By 2022 those cases made up 17 of OCR's 22 actions, when the year's median was $40,000 and its total $2.2 million [1]. Across all 56 Right of Access actions to date the median is $55,000 [1] [15]. Large breach settlements did not stop: Montefiore Medical Center agreed to pay $4,750,000 in an agreement OCR listed in February 2024 [1] [18], and Warby Parker received a $1,500,000 civil money penalty announced in February 2025 [8]. But only four of the 49 actions announced from 2024 to October 2026 reached $1 million [1].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: the totals understate how busy OCR has been and overstate how much the typical case costs. A health system reading the headline numbers should expect the likely outcome of a breach investigation to be a six-figure payment and a two- or three-year corrective action plan, not an eight-figure settlement.
From records requests to ransomware and risk analysis
The mix turned in 2024. OCR said its February 2024 settlement with Green Ridge Behavioral Health was its second after a ransomware investigation [6]; the first on its listing is Doctors' Management Services, in October 2023 [1]. In October 2024 OCR announced its seventh ransomware action, with Bryan County Ambulance Authority, and the first in a new Risk Analysis Initiative, which it said it created to increase the number of completed investigations and draw attention to the Security Rule's risk analysis requirement [5]. In 2025, 8 of 21 actions were ransomware cases and 9 were in the Risk Analysis Initiative, against 3 for the right of access [1]. In 2026 to October 29, ransomware accounts for 7 of 12 actions [1] [16]. The two labels overlap: many ransomware cases also count toward the Risk Analysis Initiative [5] [12].
The ransomware cases are larger than the right of access cases but small next to the earlier breach settlements: the median of the 22 is $232,500 [1] [16]. The four settlements announced together in April 2026 paid $1,165,000 between them, from $225,000 to $375,000 each [11], and Lehigh Valley Health Network paid $800,000 with a three-year corrective action plan [16]. The Risk Analysis Initiative includes cases with almost no payment: MMG Fusion, whose breach OCR said affected 15 million individuals, paid $10,000 as the initiative's 12th action [10].
Civil money penalties rose too. OCR called its December 2024 penalty against Children's Hospital Colorado its seventh penalty of that year [7], more than in any earlier year in our count, where the previous high was two [1].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: the Risk Analysis Initiative is the clearest signal in the record. It turns one documentable control, an accurate and thorough risk analysis, into the first potential violation OCR lists in case after case, which is consistent with the reading in our healthcare cybersecurity outlook that enforcement is moving faster than the proposed Security Rule update.
Cases close years after the breach
Several settlements announced in 2026 resolve incidents from 2020 to 2023. Ambry Genetics discovered its phishing compromise in January 2020, and OCR announced its settlement in September 2026 [19]. Regional Women's Health Group reported its breach in December 2020 and settled in the April 2026 group [11]. In the Spencer Gifts plan's case, the ransomware attack on the company's network was in November 2021 [12], and Lehigh Valley Health Network discovered its ransomware on February 4, 2023 [16]. Contested penalties take longer still: OCR proposed a penalty against Concentra on June 29, 2021 and the matter settled on May 5, 2025, before an administrative hearing, for $112,500 [9].
That lag ties this record to the breach portal. Our health data breaches trend report shows hacking or IT incidents passing half of large-breach reports in 2019; the 2026 settlements above concern incidents from the years after that.
What to watch
- Whether the Risk Analysis Initiative keeps its 2025 pace: OCR announced its 14th such action in June 2026 [12], and the Lehigh Valley Health Network and Ambry Genetics releases that followed did not carry the label [16] [19].
- Whether the right of access work resumes at volume: two actions in 2026 to date, the 55th and 56th [14] [15].
- Whether any settlement returns to the multi-million range of 2016 to 2020, when 2016 alone totaled $23.5 million across 13 actions [1].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: expect OCR to keep announcing a steady stream of modest Security Rule settlements, with ransomware as the most common cause and a missing or stale risk analysis as the potential violation OCR most often lists. This page describes OCR's published record; it is not legal advice about any organization's obligations.
What this means for you
- Health system CISOs and compliance leads: Keep a dated, enterprise-wide risk analysis and risk management record that could be handed to OCR. The failure to conduct an accurate and thorough risk analysis is the first potential violation OCR listed in its 2026 Lehigh Valley Health Network and Ambry Genetics settlements [16] [19]. Our risk analysis checklist sets out the parts.
- Group health plans and their sponsors: Treat the plan as a regulated entity in its own right in incident planning: OCR's 14th Risk Analysis Initiative action was against an employer-sponsored group health plan after a ransomware attack on the employer's network [12], and a health plan was among the four ransomware settlements of April 2026 [11].
- Health information management and release-of-information teams: Track the time from each access request to fulfillment against the HIPAA deadline; OCR has brought 56 Right of Access actions, the latest in October 2026 [15], and several earlier ones ended in civil money penalties when entities did not settle [1].
- Legal and finance teams budgeting for a breach: Plan for a long tail: several settlements announced in 2026 resolve incidents from 2020 to 2023 [11] [19], and a contested penalty took almost four years from proposal to settlement [9]. A corrective action plan of two or three years usually follows [11] [16].
Moraph predictions
Every prediction is Moraph's view, not a fact. Each has a date, a confidence level (70% means we expect to be wrong about three times in ten) and a test anyone can apply. We score them on this page when the date comes and never remove one. How we make and score predictions.
P1 By Confidence 75% Open
OCR announces at least 12 HIPAA resolution agreements or civil money penalties during calendar year 2027.
How we will check: In January 2028, count the entries on OCR's Resolution Agreements and Civil Money Penalties page, plus any HIPAA settlement or penalty in an OCR press release, whose public announcement is dated in 2027, counting each paying entity once as in this report's method. Right if 12 or more.
Basis: OCR announced 21 such actions in 2025 and 12 in 2026 through October 29, and at least 10 in every year from 2016 [1] [16].
P2 By Confidence 75% Open
No single HIPAA resolution agreement or civil money penalty announced by OCR in calendar year 2027 exceeds $5,000,000.
How we will check: In January 2028, read the amount of every OCR HIPAA settlement and penalty announced in 2027. Right if none is above $5,000,000.
Basis: The largest action announced since February 2021 is Montefiore Medical Center's $4,750,000 [18]; only 4 of 49 actions from 2024 to October 2026 reached $1 million [1].
P3 By Confidence 65% Open
The median amount of OCR's HIPAA resolution agreements and civil money penalties announced in 2027 is $100,000 or more.
How we will check: In January 2028, list the amounts of all OCR HIPAA settlements and penalties announced in 2027 (method as in this report) and take the median. Right if it is $100,000 or more.
Basis: The yearly median was $100,000 in 2023, $177,600 in 2024, $182,000 in 2025 and $282,500 in 2026 to October 29, after falling to $40,000 in 2022 [1].
P4 By Confidence 60% Open
OCR announces its 18th or later enforcement action in the HIPAA Risk Analysis Initiative on or before December 31, 2027.
How we will check: Read OCR's HIPAA press releases published through December 31, 2027. Right if one describes an action as the 18th or a later action in the Risk Analysis Initiative.
Basis: The initiative's first action was announced on October 31, 2024 [5] and its 14th on June 18, 2026 [12]; the October 2026 Lehigh Valley Health Network release did not carry the label [16].
Facts on this page link to their sources. Text marked "Moraph's view", and every prediction, is our own analysis, not a fact or advice. Methodology.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the piece where needed.