The 2018 budget law made a Medicare video visit depend on four facts about the patient

The Bipartisan Budget Act, signed February 9, 2018, opened Medicare payment for remote care in home dialysis, acute stroke, Medicare Advantage plans and some ACOs. Each door turned on a different fact about the patient, so eligibility had to be checked before the visit.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

The Bipartisan Budget Act, signed February 9, 2018, opened Medicare payment for remote care in home dialysis, acute stroke, Medicare Advantage plans and some ACOs. Each door turned on a different fact about the patient, so eligibility had to be checked before the visit.

  1. The week On Friday, February 9, 2018, the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 became law as Public Law 115-123.
  2. The condition: two diagnoses opened two different doors Two of the four provisions were defined by the patient’s condition.
  3. The coverage: Medicare Advantage plans could design their own door The second fact was how the patient was covered.
  4. The attribution: an ACO assignment the patient may not have known about The third fact was the least visible to patients.
  5. The location: where the patient sits decides what the visit is The fourth fact cut across the other three.
  6. How this differed across organizations Each organization met a different subset of the four facts.
  7. Objections, in order We take five objections to our argument, numbered in the order we address them.
  8. What a leader could check These checks follow from the four parts.
  9. With hindsight CMS put the 2019 provisions into its annual physician fee schedule cycle.

The week

On Friday, February 9, 2018, the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 became law as Public Law 115-123. The bill that carried it, H.R. 1892, still bore the long title of a measure about flying the flag at half-staff when a first responder dies in the line of duty. By enactment it was a large budget and appropriations law. One of its divisions, titled the Advancing Chronic Care, Extenders, and Social Services (ACCESS) Act, held health provisions. Within it, a title called Creating High-Quality Results and Outcomes Necessary to Improve Chronic (CHRONIC) Care changed how Medicare could pay for care delivered over video and other links.

Medicare’s rules for paying remote visits are in section 1834(m) of the Social Security Act. That section limits where the patient may be by type of facility and by geography. The 2018 law did not remove those limits. It made four targeted exceptions, each defined by a different fact about the patient.

Section 50302 dealt with home dialysis. From January 1, 2019, an individual with end stage renal disease receiving home dialysis could choose to receive the monthly ESRD-related clinical assessment remotely. The law set a condition: a face-to-face assessment at least monthly for the first 3 months of home dialysis, and at least once every 3 consecutive months after that. It let the patient be at a renal dialysis facility or at home, only for this purpose, and switched off the geographic requirements for them. No facility fee would be paid when the patient was at home.

The same section amended the civil monetary penalty law. From January 1, 2019, telehealth technologies, as the Secretary defines them, provided by a provider of services or a renal dialysis facility to a home dialysis patient whose care Part B paid for would fall outside the law’s definition of remuneration. Three conditions applied: the technologies could not be offered as part of any advertisement or solicitation; they had to be for remote services related to the patient’s ESRD; and they had to meet any requirements the Secretary set by regulation.

Section 50325 dealt with stroke. From January 1, 2019, the patient-location requirements would not apply to remote services for the diagnosis, evaluation or treatment of symptoms of an acute stroke, as determined by the Secretary. The patient could be at any hospital, any critical access hospital, any mobile stroke unit as the Secretary defined it, or any other site the Secretary found appropriate. No facility fee would be paid to a newly eligible location that did not otherwise qualify.

Section 50323 dealt with Medicare Advantage. For plan year 2020 and later, an MA plan could provide what the law called additional telehealth benefits. These were Part B services, including those not payable under section 1834(m)’s conditions, identified as clinically appropriate to furnish when the practitioner is not at the same location as the enrollee. The term excluded capital and infrastructure costs. The Secretary had to seek public comment by November 30, 2018, and to specify requirements such as practitioner qualifications and coordination with in-person care. A plan offering a service this way had to keep in-person access to it, and the enrollee would choose.

Section 50324 dealt with accountable care organizations. From January 1, 2020, for physicians and practitioners in an applicable ACO furnishing remote services to an assigned fee-for-service beneficiary, the beneficiary’s home would count as a permitted location. The geographic limitation would not apply, subject to state licensing. An applicable ACO was one in a two-sided risk model, under the Shared Savings Program rule the law cited or a model tested under section 1115A, with prospective assignment of beneficiaries. There would be no facility fee for the home, and no payment for services inappropriate to furnish in the home, such as those furnished in inpatient settings. The Secretary had to report to Congress on the provision by January 1, 2026.

The same title made other changes to Medicare Advantage and chronic care. Section 50322 let MA plans offer chronically ill enrollees supplemental benefits that need not be primarily health related, from plan year 2020. Section 50321 required the Medicare Advantage Value-Based Insurance Design model to be expanded to all states by January 1, 2020. We focus on the four provisions about remote care.

A patient experiences telehealth as a choice: a video visit instead of a trip. The February 2018 law did not offer Medicare beneficiaries that choice in general. It offered it to some of them, for some services, depending on facts the patient might not know about themselves. We read the law as a patient experience problem written in payment terms. Before a provider could offer a billable video visit, someone had to establish four things. They were the patient’s condition, the patient’s coverage, the organization the patient was assigned to, and where the patient would be during the visit.

Each of the four provisions answered one of those questions differently. Home dialysis turned on a diagnosis and a treatment setting. Stroke turned on a diagnosis and a site of care. Medicare Advantage turned on the plan’s benefit design. The ACO provision turned on the patient’s assignment to an organization under a particular payment model. The result was that two patients in the same waiting room, or the same household, could have different telehealth rights.

We take the problem in four parts. Each is one fact a scheduler or a care team had to establish about the patient. Together they decide whether a given video visit was payable under the 2018 law:

  • The condition: whether the patient’s diagnosis and treatment opened a door, as for home dialysis and acute stroke.
  • The coverage: whether the patient was in original Medicare or in an MA plan, and what that plan offered.
  • The attribution: whether the patient was assigned to an ACO that qualified under the law.
  • The location: where the patient would be during the visit, and whether that place counted as an originating site.

Our argument is that the law moved the hard part of telehealth from the technology to the front desk. The video connection was the same for every patient. Whether it could be billed, and what the patient could be told in advance, depended on eligibility checks that scheduling built for in-person care had never needed. Patients would experience those checks as inconsistency unless providers explained them. After the four parts, we look at how this differed across organizations, at objections, and at what a leader could check.

A note on scope. We describe the statute as enacted and the rules CMS later adopted under it. Payment and coverage details changed repeatedly after 2018, and organizations should confirm current rules with CMS guidance and their counsel or compliance teams before relying on any description here.

The condition: two diagnoses opened two different doors

Two of the four provisions were defined by the patient’s condition. Both took effect on January 1, 2019. They shared nothing else.

Home dialysis: a monthly visit, with in-person anchors

The home dialysis provision covered one recurring service: the monthly ESRD-related clinical assessment. A patient on home dialysis could choose to receive it by telehealth, from home or from a dialysis facility. But the law required in-person assessments: monthly for the first 3 months of home dialysis, and at least once every 3 consecutive months after that.

For the patient, that created a schedule, not a switch. In the first months, every assessment was in person. After that, the patient could alternate, but an in-person visit had to fall within each run of three months. A scheduling system had to know when the patient started home dialysis and when the last in-person assessment happened. It also had to know that the patient had chosen telehealth, since the statute made it the patient’s choice.

The care team had to explain this. A patient told in month two that a video visit was not allowed, and in month five that it was, would want to know why. The reason was in the statute, not in clinical judgment. Our reading is that the explanation belonged in the patient’s home dialysis education, so the schedule did not feel arbitrary.

Home dialysis: the equipment question

The civil monetary penalty clarification addressed a second patient experience issue. A home dialysis patient might not own a tablet, a camera or a reliable connection. Before the law, a provider giving a patient such equipment risked it being treated as remuneration that could induce the patient to choose that provider. From 2019, the law said telehealth technologies given to a home dialysis patient would not be remuneration, if they were not advertised, were used for ESRD-related telehealth and met any rules the Secretary set.

That gave providers a way to close the gap between eligibility and ability. A patient eligible for telehealth assessments but without the means to use them had a right in name only. The conditions mattered, though. A provider could not use the equipment in marketing. Its compliance team would need to document why each device was provided and that its use was tied to ESRD care.

Home dialysis: who explains the choice

The statute made remote assessment the patient’s choice. Someone had to present that choice. In a home dialysis program, the natural owner is the nephrologist or the home dialysis nurse who trains the patient. The explanation needs three parts: that remote assessment is available after the first months, that in-person visits still have to happen at set intervals, and that the patient may decline remote visits altogether.

Recording the choice also matters. A patient who chose remote assessments in one quarter might prefer in-person visits the next, for clinical reasons or personal ones. The record should show the choice as made each time, not as a standing setting that nobody revisits. That protects the patient’s right to change their mind and gives the provider evidence that the choice was the patient’s.

Stroke: speed in the hospital, not access at home

The stroke provision was different in purpose. It lifted the originating site requirements for services diagnosing, evaluating or treating symptoms of an acute stroke. It named hospitals, critical access hospitals and mobile stroke units as originating sites, with room for others the Secretary approved. It was about getting a stroke specialist to a patient wherever the patient arrived, quickly.

For the patient, this provision was mostly invisible. A person with stroke symptoms does not schedule a video visit. They arrive at an emergency department or are met by an ambulance or mobile stroke unit. The patient experience question was whether that hospital could reach a specialist. Before 2019, the geographic limits could prevent Medicare payment for that consultation at a hospital outside the qualifying areas. The law removed that barrier for this condition.

Stroke: what the provision did not do

The provision did not make the home an originating site for stroke care, and did not cover follow-up visits after the acute episode unless they were themselves for acute stroke symptoms, as the Secretary determined. A patient discharged after a stroke, receiving rehabilitation or follow-up at home, was not covered by this door. Their telehealth eligibility depended on the other three facts. That boundary is easy for a patient to misunderstand. The same condition opened a door in the emergency department and not in the living room.

For a health system, the stroke provision called for clear definitions. It had to define which encounters counted as acute stroke care at a distance, and who decided, and when, if the diagnosis changed during evaluation. Documentation and coding rules would come from CMS. The operational point was that the condition had to be recorded at the time of the service, because it determined whether the service was payable.

Stroke: the record at the moment of care

Stroke care moves fast, and documentation can lag. A remote consultation in the first minutes after arrival may be recorded after the patient has moved on to imaging or treatment. If the record does not show that the consultation was for acute stroke symptoms, the payment basis is lost. For the patient, that is invisible. For the hospital and the specialist group, it determines whether the arrangement pays for itself.

A stroke protocol that includes a documentation step, completed by the remote specialist at the time of the consultation, closes that gap. The protocol should say who records the reason for the consultation, where, and by when. It should also cover the case where the evaluation finds something other than stroke, so the record reflects what the consultation was for at the time it began.

The coverage: Medicare Advantage plans could design their own door

The second fact was how the patient was covered. A beneficiary in original Medicare was subject to section 1834(m). A beneficiary in a Medicare Advantage plan could, from 2020, have additional telehealth benefits if the plan chose to offer them.

Coverage can also change during a year. A beneficiary can move between original Medicare and an MA plan at set enrollment periods. A coverage check made when a series of visits was booked may be out of date by the third visit. Rechecking coverage before each visit, rather than once per series, keeps the answer current. The check is cheap when automated and costly when a patient is told after the fact that a visit was not covered.

A benefit the plan designs

The law let a plan treat certain Part B services delivered at a distance as basic benefits for bidding purposes, rather than as supplemental benefits. The services had to be ones the plan identified as clinically appropriate to furnish that way. The law left the requirements to the Secretary, including practitioner qualifications and coordination with in-person care. Capital and infrastructure costs were excluded.

That made the plan’s benefit design the deciding document. Two MA plans in the same county could offer different sets of telehealth services. A patient switching plans at open enrollment could gain or lose telehealth access for a service they used. The plan’s evidence of coverage and marketing materials became the place a patient would learn what was covered.

The in-person guarantee

The law protected the patient’s choice. If a plan offered a service as an additional telehealth benefit, it had to keep providing access to that service in person, and the enrollee decided which way to receive it. A plan could not use telehealth to narrow its network for that service.

For the patient, that was a clear right. For the plan, it meant maintaining in-person capacity alongside the telehealth channel. For providers in the plan’s network, it meant scheduling processes that offered both options and recorded the patient’s choice. Our reading is that the choice should be recorded each time, because the patient could change their mind from one visit to the next.

The provider’s view of the plan

A provider seeing patients from several MA plans and from original Medicare faced several rulebooks at once. A video visit could be covered for one patient’s plan, not covered for another’s, and subject to section 1834(m) for a third. The eligibility check before the visit had to include the patient’s plan and that plan’s telehealth benefit, as well as active coverage.

A response confirming active coverage does not, by itself, show which services a plan covers by telehealth. That gap fell to staff, who would check plan documents or call. A patient who booked a video visit and was later told it was not covered experienced the gap directly. The fix was to check the plan’s telehealth benefit at booking, not at billing.

Plans that chose not to offer it

The provision was optional. A plan could decline to offer additional telehealth benefits, or offer them for a narrow set of services. Its enrollees would then have the same remote care rules as original Medicare for everything else. A patient comparing plans would need to look for the benefit, because its absence would not be obvious from a plan’s name or premium.

For providers, a plan without the benefit looked the same at the front desk as one with it, unless the check went to the benefit level. Our reading is that eligibility processes should treat each plan’s remote care benefits as data to load and refresh each year, since plan designs change at each contract year.

Cost sharing a patient can see

The statute did not set cost sharing for these benefits. As our hindsight section describes, CMS’s later rule allowed plans to set different cost sharing for in-person and remote delivery of the same service. For the patient, that meant the choice between a video visit and an office visit could carry a different copayment. A patient told the price at booking could make an informed choice. A patient who learned it from a bill would not.

Explaining the difference to patients

Medicare beneficiaries talk to each other. One whose MA plan covered a video visit, and a neighbor in original Medicare whose identical visit was not covered, would compare notes. The difference came from the law and the plan, not from the provider. But the provider was the one who had to say no. Clear scripts for staff, explaining that coverage for telehealth depends on the patient’s type of Medicare and plan, would reduce confusion.

The attribution: an ACO assignment the patient may not have known about

The third fact was the least visible to patients. From 2020, a beneficiary assigned to an applicable ACO could receive telehealth at home, without geographic limits, from physicians and practitioners in that ACO. The beneficiary did not choose this door. It depended on the ACO’s payment model and assignment method.

Which ACOs qualified

The law limited the provision to ACOs in two-sided risk models, either the Shared Savings Program track the law cited or a model tested under section 1115A. The ACO also had to use prospective assignment, so that beneficiaries were assigned at the start of the period. ACOs in one-sided models, or using retrospective assignment, did not qualify.

That tied the patient’s telehealth access to decisions the ACO made about financial risk. An ACO that moved from a one-sided to a two-sided track, with prospective assignment, opened home telehealth for its assigned patients. An ACO that stayed in a one-sided track did not. Patients had no part in that decision and might not know which ACO, if any, they were assigned to.

Assignment as an eligibility fact

For the provider, the check was twofold. The clinician had to be participating in an applicable ACO, and the patient had to be prospectively assigned to it. Both facts had to be true at the time of the service. Assignment is set under CMS’s rules for the ACO’s track. A practice seeing patients inside and outside its ACO needed those lists in its scheduling system, refreshed as they changed.

In our reading, ACOs that qualified had a reason to treat assignment data as patient-facing information. A patient told they could have a video visit from home because they were part of a particular care organization might value that, and might want to know what else assignment meant. The provision gave ACOs a concrete, visible benefit to explain.

Telling patients about assignment

An ACO that qualified under the 2018 law had a practical reason to tell its assigned patients something useful: that their clinicians could see them at home by video for covered services. Whether and how to say that was the ACO’s choice, within Medicare’s marketing rules, which we do not analyze here.

Accuracy mattered. Assignment can change from year to year, and the ACO’s track can change too. A message telling a patient they could have home video visits would become wrong if either changed. Any patient-facing statement about the benefit needed an owner who would update or withdraw it when the facts changed.

Boundaries inside the door

The provision excluded services inappropriate in the home, such as those furnished in inpatient settings. It required no facility fee for the home. And it remained subject to state licensing, so a clinician still had to be licensed where the patient was. An ACO with patients near a state border, or with snowbirds who spent winters elsewhere, had to track where the patient would be during the visit, which brings us to the fourth fact.

The location: where the patient sits decides what the visit is

The fourth fact cut across the other three. Section 1834(m) defines originating sites by type and geography. Each of the 2018 provisions changed that definition for its own purpose, and only for that purpose.

Four different site rules

For home dialysis, the home and the dialysis facility became originating sites for the monthly assessment, without geographic limits. For acute stroke, hospitals, critical access hospitals and mobile stroke units qualified, along with other sites the Secretary approved, without the usual requirements. For applicable ACOs, the home became an originating site without geographic limits. For MA additional telehealth benefits, the law defined the benefit by the practitioner not being at the same location as the enrollee, and left the details to rule.

So the same location could count for one purpose and not another. A patient at home could be at a valid originating site for a dialysis assessment, and not for a stroke follow-up. A patient in a rural clinic might be at a valid site under the general rule and the stroke rule alike. The location had to be recorded with the purpose of the visit, because the purpose decided whether the location counted.

The device and the connection

A permitted location does not guarantee a working visit. The patient needs a device, a connection good enough for video and the ability to use both. The 2018 law addressed equipment only for home dialysis, through the penalty law change. For ACO patients and MA enrollees, the law said nothing about devices, and the MA provision excluded capital and infrastructure costs from the benefit.

That left a gap between eligibility and access. A patient eligible for a home video visit, without a usable device or connection, could not use the right. Providers had several responses available: offer audio support to help patients connect, schedule a short test before the first visit, or keep in-person options open. Each is a patient experience choice with a staffing cost.

Privacy at home

A visit at home happens where others may be listening. A clinic visit happens in a private room. For a patient discussing a diagnosis, medications or mental health, the home can be less private than the clinic. Clinicians conducting home video visits need a simple step to confirm the patient can speak freely, and an option to reschedule or switch to in-person care if not.

The provider’s side carries obligations too. The platform used, the clinician’s surroundings and the handling of any recording all bear on the privacy of the visit. We do not analyze the privacy rules here. Organizations should have their privacy officers review home video visit workflows before expanding them.

Licensing follows the patient

The ACO provision said explicitly that the lifting of geographic limits was subject to state licensing requirements. The MA rules CMS adopted later required plans to ensure providers met licensing rules for the state where the enrollee was located. For patient experience, this meant a video visit could depend on where the patient happened to be that day. A patient traveling out of state could find a scheduled video visit unavailable.

A scheduling process that asked where the patient would be for the visit, and checked the clinician’s licensure against that state, would avoid a visit called off at the last minute. That question was new for providers used to in-person care, where the patient’s location is the clinic.

Licensure checks are not a one-time task. A clinician licensed in two states this year may let one license lapse next year. A patient who winters in another state may need a different clinician for those months, or in-person care. The scheduling record should hold the patient’s expected location by date when the patient tells the provider about regular moves, so the check runs automatically for future bookings.

No facility fee at home

Each of the home provisions said no facility fee would be paid when the patient was at home. Under the general rule, a qualifying facility where the patient is located can receive a fee for hosting the visit. At home there is no host facility. For the patient, that removed one possible charge from the visit. For facilities that had hosted remote visits, it meant those visits brought no fee when they moved to the home.

The stroke provision handled the point differently. It allowed new kinds of location, such as mobile stroke units, and said no facility fee would be paid to a location that did not otherwise qualify. A hospital that already qualified kept its position. A mobile unit gained eligibility for the professional service, not a fee for hosting it.

Recording location honestly

Billing depends on the recorded location. A patient who said they would be at home but joined from a car, a workplace or another state created a mismatch between the record and reality. Providers needed a simple step at the start of each visit to confirm and record where the patient was. That step protected the patient, by confirming licensure, and the provider, by keeping the claim accurate.

How this differed across organizations

Each organization met a different subset of the four facts. The patient experience burden fell differently on each.

Dialysis providers and nephrology practices

For dialysis organizations, the home dialysis provision was the main door. Their task was to track the start of home dialysis and the cadence of in-person visits, to record each patient’s choice, and to decide whether and how to provide equipment within the penalty law’s conditions. Their patients were a defined population with a recurring service, which made the process easier to build than for a general practice.

Hospitals and stroke networks

For hospitals, the stroke provision was the one that counted. A hospital that relied on a remote stroke specialist could now be an originating site for Medicare payment regardless of its location. The work was in agreements between hospitals and specialist groups, in credentialing, and in documentation that tied each encounter to acute stroke symptoms. The patient would see the result as a faster specialist assessment, not as a telehealth benefit.

Medicare Advantage plans

For MA plans, the provision was a design choice with bidding consequences. A plan had to decide which services to offer as additional telehealth benefits, build the in-person guarantee into its network, and explain the benefit in its materials. Plans competing for enrollees had a reason to offer and advertise the benefit. Their members would then expect providers to deliver it.

ACOs and their participants

For ACOs, the provision was tied to their risk track. Those in qualifying tracks needed assignment data in participants’ scheduling systems and a way to tell patients about the benefit. Participants in several ACOs, or seeing patients across ACO and non-ACO populations, faced checks on every fact at once.

Rural providers, clinics and health centers

Facilities in qualifying rural areas were the originating sites the general rule contemplated. The 2018 law did not change their position as sites. It did let some patients, in ACOs and on home dialysis, receive certain telehealth at home instead of traveling to them. For the patient, that was a gain. For the rural site, it could mean fewer visits through its doors for those services. The organization’s role would shift toward the in-person visits the law still required.

Integrated systems that meet all four facts

A large health system might run a stroke network, a home dialysis program, an ACO and contracts with several MA plans at once. For such a system, the four facts are not separate programs. They are fields in one scheduling record. A single patient could be a home dialysis patient, assigned to the system’s ACO, enrolled in an MA plan and seen in the emergency department for stroke symptoms in the same year.

The system’s choice was whether to build one eligibility process that checks all four facts, or several program-specific processes. One process is harder to build and easier for patients to understand, because the answer comes from one place. Several processes are easier to build and harder to explain, because each program gives a partial answer. Our view is that the patient’s experience favors one process, even at higher build cost.

Public payers and agencies

Medicaid programs and state employee health plans were not governed by these Medicare provisions. Beneficiaries dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid would encounter both sets of rules. State agencies that run Medicaid, and that coordinate with Medicare for dual-eligible people, had to explain why a telehealth visit covered under one program might not be under the other.

Objections, in order

We take five objections to our argument, numbered in the order we address them.

1. The provisions were small, so their patient impact was small

The first objection is that four narrow exceptions affected few patients. They were narrow. But each created an eligibility check for every Medicare patient a provider saw, because the provider could not know whether a patient qualified without checking. The burden fell on the process, whatever the number who qualified.

2. Billing staff handle this, not the patient experience

The second objection is that coverage rules belong to billing. Billing finds the problem after the visit. The patient experiences it before, when told a video visit is or is not available. Moving the check to scheduling turns a denied claim into an explained choice.

3. CMS rules would sort out the details

The third objection is that the statute left details to rulemaking, so it was premature to plan. CMS did adopt rules, for the physician fee schedule in November 2018 and for MA in April 2019. But the four facts came from the statute. Planning for them did not need to wait for the rules, which added detail within each door.

4. Patients would choose in-person care anyway

The fourth objection is that older Medicare beneficiaries preferred in-person visits, so telehealth eligibility mattered little. We have no data in our sources on 2018 preferences, and the law protected in-person choice in MA. The point stands either way: patients who wanted a video visit needed to know whether it was available to them.

5. A broader change would come and make this moot

The fifth objection is that broader telehealth changes would overtake these narrow doors. They did, temporarily, as our hindsight section describes. But the statute’s doors remained, and the broad changes were time-limited. Organizations that had built the four-fact check were ready for the narrower world the law still describes after the broad changes end.

What a leader could check

These checks follow from the four parts. They reflect our reading of good practice, not requirements.

  • Does the scheduling process record, for each telehealth visit, the purpose, the patient’s coverage type and plan, any ACO assignment, and where the patient will be?
  • Does eligibility checking at booking include the specific plan’s telehealth benefits, as well as active coverage?
  • Do staff have plain scripts explaining why a video visit is available for one patient and not another?
  • Is the patient’s choice between telehealth and in-person care recorded each time it is offered?
  • Is clinician licensure checked against the state where the patient will be, before the visit starts?

Each check takes a few seconds per visit once the systems hold the data. Building the data feeds, for plan benefits, ACO assignment and licensure, is the larger task. That task is the one the 2018 law made necessary, and it serves every later change in remote care rules as well.

Ownership matters for each feed. Plan benefit data belongs with managed care contracting, which already receives plan documents. ACO assignment belongs with the ACO’s operations team. Licensure belongs with medical staff services. Patient location and choice belong with the clinicians and schedulers who record them. A leader should be able to name the owner of each feed and the date it was last refreshed.

With hindsight

CMS put the 2019 provisions into its annual physician fee schedule cycle. Its final rule for calendar year 2019, published on November 23, 2018 and effective January 1, 2019, also included an interim final rule on telehealth for substance use disorder. That rule implemented amendments made by the SUPPORT for Patients and Communities Act to the Medicare telehealth provisions, on permissible originating sites for treating a substance use disorder or a co-occurring mental health disorder. By November 2018, Congress had added another condition-defined door.

CMS adopted the Medicare Advantage rule on April 16, 2019, effective January 1, 2020. The final rule said it implemented certain provisions of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018. The resulting regulation, 42 CFR 422.135, defines additional telehealth benefits and sets the conditions. A plan must furnish in-person access at the enrollee’s election and advise each enrollee of the choice. It must meet provider selection and credentialing rules and ensure by contract that providers meet licensing rules in the state where the enrollee is. It may offer the benefits only through contracted providers; coverage by non-contracted providers can only be a supplemental benefit. It may set different cost sharing for in-person and remote delivery.

Then the doors were flung open, for a time. On April 6, 2020, CMS published an interim final rule responding to the COVID-19 public health emergency. It changed Medicare payment rules during the emergency so that physicians, other practitioners and a range of providers had broad flexibilities to furnish services using remote communications technology. For as long as broad flexibilities applied, the four-fact check mattered less.

Congress later made one class of change permanent. CMS’s telehealth answers, updated in October 2026, say the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 permanently removed geographic and place of service restrictions for behavioral health telehealth services. Beneficiaries in rural and urban areas alike can receive those services at home. After December 31, 2027, the statute requires an in-person visit within 6 months before the first mental health telehealth service, and CMS requires one within 12 months of each later service, with limited exceptions. CMS reads the 6-month visit as not applying to patients who began such care at home before January 1, 2028; they need the yearly visit only.

For other services, the broad flexibilities were extended for a fixed period. The same CMS answers say that through December 31, 2027, beneficiaries can receive Medicare telehealth services anywhere in the United States and its territories. Starting January 1, 2028, except for behavioral health services, beneficiaries will generally need to be in a medical facility and in a rural area. If those dates hold, the general rule returns, and with it the importance of the narrower doors.

The 2018 ACO door is still described in CMS’s answers. They say the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 lets clinicians in applicable Shared Savings Program ACOs furnish covered telehealth to certain beneficiaries without geographic restriction and in the home. CMS now defines applicable ACOs as those with prospective assignment in the ENHANCED track or BASIC track levels C, D or E. ACOs using preliminary prospective assignment with retrospective reconciliation do not qualify. Services must be billed through the taxpayer identification number of an ACO participant. The law also required the Secretary to report to Congress on this provision by January 1, 2026; we have not reviewed whether or what was reported.

What held up from our argument is the structure. From 2028, under current law as CMS describes it, a Medicare video visit will again depend on facts about the patient: condition, coverage, attribution and location. The 2018 law’s doors, along with the later substance use and behavioral health doors, will define who can be seen at home. What did not hold is the assumption that the doors would stay narrow throughout. For several years, broad flexibilities made them matter less. Our expectation, which no source here measures, is that many patients will have come to count on video visits under those rules, so the explanation at the front desk will be harder in 2028 than it was in 2018.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • telehealth
  • Medicare
  • Medicare Advantage
  • ACO
  • Bipartisan Budget Act