Checklist: building and running a Regulation S-ID identity theft prevention program
Fourteen steps for SEC-registered broker-dealers, funds and investment advisers: deciding whether you hold covered accounts, the four required elements of the written program, board oversight, service providers and the card issuer address check.
Who the rule reaches
Regulation S-ID is 17 CFR 248.201 and 248.202. It applies to a financial institution or creditor, as the Fair Credit Reporting Act defines those terms, that is a registered (or required to be registered) broker-dealer, investment company or investment adviser, a business development company or an employees’ securities company [1]. The SEC and the CFTC adopted their identity theft red flags rules together in a release published on April 19, 2013, effective May 20, 2013, with a compliance date of November 20, 2013 [2]. The release gives three illustrative examples of SEC-regulated firms that could be financial institutions because they hold transaction accounts belonging to individuals: a broker-dealer that offers custodial accounts, a registered investment company that lets investors wire money to other parties or write checks, and an investment adviser that directly or indirectly holds transaction accounts and is permitted to direct payments or transfers out of them to third parties [2].
On July 27, 2022 the SEC announced that it had charged three firms under the rule. The orders found that their programs lacked reasonable policies and procedures to identify relevant red flags, to respond to red flags detected and to update the program; individual orders also found failures in board involvement, staff training, service provider oversight and periodic review of account types. Without admitting or denying the findings, each firm agreed to a cease-and-desist order, a censure and a civil penalty [3].
Using the steps
Steps 1 to 3 decide whether a program is needed and set it up; steps 4 to 7 are the four elements every program must have; steps 8 to 12 are administration; steps 13 and 14 cover card issuers and related duties. Citations are to the eCFR text current to November 12, 2026 [1]. Appendix A to the subpart holds the guidelines a firm must consider; where a step draws on them, or is our suggestion, it says so. The owner under each step is a typical role, not one the rule names, unless the step says the rule names it. This page explains the rule; it is not legal advice.
Moraph’s teams help organizations with work like this. See our solutions.
The checklist
Tick the steps as you go. The ticks are kept in this browser only; nothing is sent to us.
Chief compliance officer
Section 248.201(c) requires the periodic determination and the risk assessment for accounts under section 248.201(b)(3)(ii), considering the methods to open accounts, the methods to access them and previous experiences with identity theft [1]. One of the 2022 orders found a failure to review new or existing types of customer accounts periodically [3]. Recording the date and outcome is our suggestion.
Board or an appropriate board committee (named in the rule), with the chief compliance officer
Section 248.201(d)(1) requires a written program appropriate to the firm’s size, complexity and activities, and section 248.201(e)(1) requires approval of the initial written program by the board or an appropriate committee. For a firm with no board, section 248.201(b)(2) treats a designated senior management employee as the board [1].
Fraud prevention lead, with operations
Section 248.201(d)(2)(i) requires it. Appendix A, section II, lists the risk factors to consider, the sources of red flags and five categories: alerts from consumer reporting agencies or service providers, suspicious documents, suspicious personal identifying information, unusual account activity, and notice from customers, victims, law enforcement or others. Supplement A gives illustrative examples [1].
Client onboarding and operations
Section 248.201(d)(2)(ii) requires detection. Appendix A, section III, points to verifying identity at account opening, for example under the customer identification program rules, and to authenticating customers, monitoring transactions and verifying change of address requests on existing accounts [1].
Fraud prevention lead
Section 248.201(d)(2)(iii) requires appropriate responses. Appendix A, section IV, lists options from monitoring the account and contacting the customer to changing credentials, reopening with a new account number, closing the account or notifying law enforcement, and names a data security incident affecting account records as an aggravating factor [1].
Chief compliance officer
Section 248.201(d)(2)(iv) requires periodic updates to reflect changing risks. Appendix A, section V, lists the triggers to consider, including the firm’s own experience, new methods of identity theft and of detecting it, new account types and changes in business arrangements such as mergers and service provider arrangements [1]. The 2022 orders found failures to update [3].
Board, board committee or designated senior manager (named in the rule)
Section 248.201(e)(2) requires that involvement. Appendix A, section VI(a), describes oversight as assigning responsibility, reviewing staff reports on compliance and approving material changes [1]. Two of the 2022 orders found that the board was not adequately involved [3].
Program owner
Appendix A, section VI(b), says staff responsible for the program should report at least annually on compliance with section 248.201, and that the report should address material matters such as the effectiveness of the policies and procedures for new and existing accounts, service provider arrangements, significant identity theft incidents and management’s response, and recommendations for material changes [1].
Third-party risk management
Section 248.201(e)(4) requires appropriate and effective oversight of service provider arrangements. Appendix A, section VI(c), gives as an example requiring the provider by contract to have policies and procedures to detect relevant red flags and to report them or take steps to prevent or mitigate identity theft [1]. Two of the 2022 orders found weaknesses here [3].
Chief compliance officer
Section 248.201(f) requires the firm to consider the guidelines and include those that are appropriate [1]. Keeping a record of which were included and why is our suggestion.
Card operations
Section 248.202(c) requires written policies and procedures to assess the validity of a change of address when a request for an additional or replacement card follows within a short period, during at least the first 30 days after the change of address notice: the issuer may not send the card until it notifies the cardholder at the former address or by another agreed means and gives a way to report an incorrect change, or otherwise assesses the change under its program. Section 248.202(d) allows validating the address when the change arrives, and section 248.202(e) requires notices to be clear and conspicuous and separate from regular correspondence [1].
AML officer, with compliance
Appendix A, section VII, lists these related legal requirements for firms to keep in mind [1].
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the checklist where needed.