Checklist: a broker-dealer’s electronic records under the amended SEC Rule 17a-4(f)

Thirteen steps for broker-dealers since the 2022 amendments: choosing the audit-trail or non-rewriteable option, proving download and backup, deciding who signs the undertaking, and getting the right undertaking from a cloud or other outside recordkeeper.

What the 2022 amendments changed

The SEC published amendments to its broker-dealer recordkeeping rule in the Federal Register on November 3, 2022 (87 FR 66412). They took effect on January 3, 2023, and the compliance date for the amendments to Rule 17a-4 was May 3, 2023; for the parallel rule for security-based swap dealers and major security-based swap participants, Rule 18a-6, it was November 3, 2023 [2]. The amended paragraph (f) lets a broker-dealer keep electronic records either with a complete time-stamped audit trail or in a non-rewriteable, non-erasable format, adds download, backup and production requirements, and lets a designated executive officer sign the undertaking that previously required a third party [1] [2]. Paragraph (i) gained an alternative undertaking for outside entities, such as cloud providers, whose servers hold the records when the broker-dealer has independent access, and the amendments removed the old requirement to notify the designated examining authority before using an electronic storage system [2].

Using the steps

Each step names the work, who usually owns it and the paragraph of Rule 17a-4 behind it, from the current text in the eCFR [1]. The owner under each step is a typical role, not one the rule names, unless the step says the rule names it. Where a step is our suggestion, it says so. The steps cover broker-dealers under Rule 17a-4; security-based swap entities should read Rule 18a-6, which has its own paragraph numbers. This page explains the rule; it is not legal advice.

Moraph’s teams help organizations with work like this. See our solutions.

The checklist

Tick the steps as you go. The ticks are kept in this browser only; nothing is sent to us.

  1. Records management with compliance

    Paragraph (a) requires certain records to be kept for not less than 6 years and paragraph (b) others, including business communications under (b)(4), for not less than three years, in each case the first two years in an easily accessible place [1]. Paragraph (f) then sets the conditions for keeping any of them electronically. A single inventory is our suggestion.

  2. Enterprise architecture

    Paragraph (f)(1)(ii) defines it as a system that preserves records in a digital format in a manner that permits the records to be viewed and downloaded [1].

  3. Chief Technology Officer with the Chief Compliance Officer

    Paragraph (f)(2)(i)(A) is the audit-trail alternative added in 2022; paragraph (f)(2)(i)(B) keeps the option to preserve records exclusively in a non-rewriteable, non-erasable format [1]. The adopting release says one goal of the rulemaking was to make the rule more technology neutral [2]. Recording the choice per system is our suggestion, since the later steps differ by option.

  4. Application owners with internal audit

    Paragraph (f)(2)(i)(A)(1) to (4) lists the four elements and requires the trail to be kept for the duration of the record’s retention period [1].

  5. Records management

    Paragraph (f)(3)(iii) applies to a broker-dealer operating under (f)(2)(i)(B), and (f)(3)(iii)(A) and (B) require the results to be available for examination and preserved for the time required for the audited records [1].

  6. IT operations

    Paragraph (f)(2)(ii) and (iii) [1].

  7. Compliance with IT operations

    Paragraph (f)(2)(iv) requires the capacity to readily download and transfer copies in both formats, and paragraph (j) requires the firm to furnish a record and its audit trail in a reasonably usable electronic format if an SEC representative asks [1]. A timed rehearsal is our suggestion.

  8. Business continuity lead

    Paragraph (f)(2)(v)(A) requires the backup to keep the records as a redundant set if the original system is temporarily or permanently inaccessible; (f)(2)(v)(B) allows other redundancy capabilities designed to ensure access instead [1]. The switch test is our suggestion.

  9. Chief Compliance Officer

    Paragraph (f)(3)(i) and (ii) require facilities for immediately producing records and readiness to provide them immediately; paragraph (f)(3)(iv) requires the firm to organize, maintain, keep current and provide promptly all information necessary to access and locate the records [1].

  10. General counsel with the Chief Compliance Officer

    Paragraph (f)(3)(v)(A) requires the undertaking to be on file at all times, signed by either. A designated executive officer is a member of senior management with access to and the ability to provide the records, under (f)(1)(iii); a designated third party is a person not affiliated with the firm who has that access and ability, under (f)(1)(vi) [1].

  11. Designated executive officer

    The rule names this owner. Paragraph (f)(3)(v)(B) allows the appointments, and (f)(3)(v)(C) says relying on them does not relieve the designated executive officer of the undertaking [1]. Keeping the appointments current is our suggestion.

  12. Third-party risk management with legal

    Paragraph (i)(1)(i) sets the standard undertaking; (i)(1)(ii)(A) allows the alternative one for records on servers an outside entity owns or operates, including an affiliate, if the firm has independent access as defined in (i)(1)(ii)(B): regular access without the outside entity’s intervention that lets it permit examination and promptly furnish copies. Paragraph (i)(2) says the agreement does not relieve the firm of its own duties [1].

  13. Compliance policy owner

    The adopting release states that the amendments eliminate the requirement that a broker-dealer notify its designated examining authority before employing an electronic recordkeeping system [2]. The procedure update is our suggestion.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the checklist where needed.

  • SEC
  • Rule 17a-4
  • 17 CFR 240.17a-4
  • broker-dealers
  • electronic recordkeeping
  • audit trail
  • WORM
  • third-party undertaking