A 2017 House bill offered banks one capital ratio in place of a rulebook; its exit terms shaped its worth
On June 8, 2017, the House passed the Financial CHOICE Act, which would have let banks with a 10 percent capital ratio leave capital and liquidity rules. In our reading, fallback terms decided the offer’s value, as later changes to the community bank version suggest.
Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.
Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article
On June 8, 2017, the House passed the Financial CHOICE Act, which would have let banks with a 10 percent capital ratio leave capital and liquidity rules. In our reading, fallback terms decided the offer’s value, as later changes to the community bank version suggest.
- The week On June 8, 2017, the House of Representatives passed H.R. 10, the Financial CHOICE Act of 2017. [1] The Clerk’s record shows the vote on passage at 4:38 p.m. It passed 233 to 186, with 11 members not voting. [2] Every vote in favor came from a Republican member.
- The entry test: one ratio, four quarters, one family The entry test had three elements.
- The relief: what a qualifying organization would stop doing Section 602 listed the relief.
- The exit: what happened when the ratio slipped The election was not permanent.
- The evidence: what a qualifying organization would still compute and keep The fourth part concerns the records that support an election.
- How the design reached different institutions Title VI applied the same test to every banking organization. [1] The effects would still have differed by size, charter and business.
- Objections, in order H.R. 10 passed the House and did not become law.
- What finance and technology leaders could check The bill’s four parts translate into checks any bank or credit union can run on an opt-in capital framework, whether under the 2018 law, NCUA’s rule or a future proposal.
- With hindsight A Treasury report to the President dated June 2017 took up the idea.
The week
On June 8, 2017, the House of Representatives passed H.R. 10, the Financial CHOICE Act of 2017. [1] The Clerk’s record shows the vote on passage at 4:38 p.m. It passed 233 to 186, with 11 members not voting. [2] Every vote in favor came from a Republican member. One Republican and 185 Democrats voted against it. [2]
The bill’s long title described its aims. It was to end bailouts and Too Big to Fail, hold Washington and Wall Street accountable, cut red tape on capital and credit, and repeal parts of the Dodd-Frank Act. [1] The engrossed text closes with the line that it passed the House on June 8, 2017. [1]
The bill was broad. Its table of contents ran across twelve titles. [1] Title I would repeal the orderly liquidation authority and add a bankruptcy process for large financial companies. [1] Title II raised civil penalties for securities violations. Title III set new cost-benefit and review duties for financial regulators. [1] Title VII would turn the consumer bureau into a Consumer Law Enforcement Agency. Title IX would repeal the Volcker Rule. [1] Title X dealt with the Federal Reserve’s oversight and its monetary policy committee. [1]
For bank technology, risk and compliance leaders, one title stood apart. Title VI was headed regulatory relief for strongly capitalized, well managed banking organizations. [1] It did not change any capital rule. It offered an election instead. A banking organization could choose to be treated as a qualifying banking organization and receive the relief listed in section 602. [1]
The price of entry was a single ratio. An organization qualified if its average ratio of tangible equity to a defined measure of exposure was at least 10 percent. [1] The average covered the four most recently completed calendar quarters. [1] A holding company and each of its insured depository subsidiaries had to elect at the same time. [1]
The relief was wide. A qualifying organization would be exempt from any federal law, rule or regulation addressing capital or liquidity requirements or standards. [1] It would be exempt from rules letting a federal banking agency object to a capital distribution. [1] Several financial stability considerations in merger and activity reviews would not apply. Most of the deal-related relief held only if the organization kept its ratio at 10 percent or more after the deal. [1] The organization would also be deemed well capitalized for the prompt corrective action statutes. [1]
The bill reached past banks. Its definition of a banking organization included insured credit unions, as well as insured depository institutions and their holding companies. [1] For a credit union, the numerator was its net worth and the denominator its total assets, each as defined in the agency’s rules on enactment. [1]
Title VI also set terms for losing the election. A quarterly ratio below 10 percent triggered notice, possible limits on distributions and a capital restoration plan due within three months. [1] A ratio below 6 percent ended the election at once. [1] Two studies rounded out the title. The banking agencies were to study contingent capital, and the Comptroller General a different trigger for prompt corrective action. [1]
The week therefore produced a House-passed bill, not a law. What it put on paper was a trade: hold more simple capital and leave a body of rules behind. [1] [2]
A capital rule can be an obligation every bank must meet, or an option a bank may take. The CHOICE Act’s Title VI made relief from the capital rulebook an option. [1] An organization that held enough tangible equity against its exposure could elect to leave capital and liquidity rules behind. [1] The obvious question was whether 10 percent was the right number. A second question was what an election would cost to run.
Our argument is that the exit terms, more than the entry ratio, decided what the election was worth. A bank that elects must plan for the day its ratio slips. [1] If falling back means rebuilding a capital compliance function quickly, the bank keeps that function running in the background. The relief then shrinks to a reporting change. [1] [7]
We take the election in four parts:
- The entry test: what an organization had to show to elect.
- The relief: what a qualifying organization would stop doing.
- The exit: what happened when the ratio slipped.
- The evidence: what an organization would still have to compute, keep and report.
The first part covers the day of election. The second covers the period of relief. The third covers the way out. The fourth covers the records that run underneath all three. Together they span an election from decision to reversal. After the four parts, we look at how the design reached different kinds of institution, answer objections in order, and list what finance and technology leaders could check.
A note on sources and our reading. We describe the bill from its engrossed text and the vote from the Clerk’s record. [1] [2] We describe what followed from the 2018 law and the agencies’ rules. [4] [5] [6] [7] Statements about what the bill would have required of a particular organization are our reading. Institutions should confirm their own obligations with counsel.
The entry test: one ratio, four quarters, one family
The entry test had three elements. The first was the ratio itself. The second was the period over which it was measured. The third was the group of entities that had to move together. [1]
What the ratio counted
The numerator was tangible equity. For a bank or holding company, the bill defined it as common equity tier 1 capital plus additional tier 1 capital issued on or before enactment. [1] Some smaller holding companies could also count trust preferred securities issued before May 19, 2010, where existing rules already let them. [1] For a credit union, tangible equity meant net worth as the agency defined it on enactment. [1]
The definitions pointed to the agencies’ capital rules “as in effect on the date of the enactment.” [1] In our reading, that froze the definitions at a moment in time. Later changes to the capital rules would not change what counted toward the election unless Congress acted again.
What it divided by
The denominator depended on the organization’s business. For a traditional banking organization, it was total assets, less items deducted from common equity tier 1, as reported on the organization’s regulatory filing. [1] A traditional banking organization had zero trading assets and liabilities. Its swaps were limited to interest rate and foreign exchange types, with total notional exposure of no more than $8 billion. [1]
Other organizations used the total exposure measure defined in the agencies’ capital rules. [1] Credit unions used total assets as the agency defined them. [1] The choice mattered. In our reading, a bank outside the traditional definition would measure its equity against a different base, built for firms with trading and derivatives.
Averaging and the family rule
The average ratio was the mean of the quarterly ratios for the four most recently completed calendar quarters. [1] Each quarterly ratio was measured on the last day of the quarter. [1] Averaging could smooth one weak quarter on the way in. After election, as the exit terms show, each quarter stood alone.
The election also bound the corporate family. A holding company could elect only if each insured depository subsidiary elected at the same time. A bank could elect only if its parent holding company did too. [1] A group could not shelter one weak bank outside the election while the rest took the relief.
The agency’s thirty days
The election did not wait for an approval. It took effect unless the agency objected in time. The organization filed it with its federal banking agency and any state supervisor. It reported its average ratio and its quarterly ratio for each of the last four quarters. [1] A holding company had to include the same figures for each insured subsidiary. [1]
The election took effect at the end of a 30-day period, unless the agency determined the requirements were not met. [1] An agency that found them unmet had to say so in writing within the same period, with specific reasons and the steps the organization could take. [1] A newly chartered institution could elect in its charter application, if its tangible equity was at least 10 percent of its exposure on the day it became a banking organization. [1]
What the entry test asked of operations
For a finance or technology team, the entry test was a data exercise. The team would need four quarters of figures for every entity in the group, tied to regulatory filings. [1] The numerator relied on capital definitions frozen at enactment, while the filings used live definitions. Someone would have to keep a mapping between the two.
The family rule added coordination. Every insured subsidiary had to be ready on the same date. [1] A group with banks on different core systems, or with different chartering agencies, would have to align its calculations and filings across them. Each of those steps needs an owner, a timeline and a control set.
The decision in the boardroom
The bill placed the election with the organization, and its text did not say who inside the organization decides. [1] In our reading, a board would treat it as a capital policy decision. It would set the target cushion above 10 percent, approve the notice and accept the exit terms.
A board asked to approve an election would want three things in front of it. The first is the four-quarter history for every entity. The second is a forecast showing the ratio under the capital plan. The third is a statement of what the bank would keep running in case it fell out. The third item is the one a quick reading of the bill skips.
What an examiner could test at entry
The agency had thirty days to determine whether the requirements were met. [1] Within that window, it could check the arithmetic and the definitions. It could ask how tangible equity was built, which instruments counted as additional tier 1, and whether any trust preferred securities met the bill’s dates. [1]
It could also test the denominator. An organization claiming the traditional banking definition had to show zero trading assets and liabilities and swaps within the limits. [1] That claim depends on how the bank classifies positions in its ledger. A single misclassified position could move an organization from one denominator to the other.
The relief: what a qualifying organization would stop doing
Section 602 listed the relief. In our grouping, most of it fell into five kinds: capital and liquidity rules, objections to distributions, stability reviews, enhanced prudential standards and well-capitalized status. [1] Each kind retired a different kind of work.
Capital and liquidity rules
A qualifying organization would be exempt from any federal law, rule or regulation addressing capital or liquidity requirements or standards. [1] The words were broad. In our reading, they reached risk-based capital ratios, liquidity coverage requirements and the calculations behind them.
The calculations are where the work lives. Risk-based capital requires assigning a risk weight to each exposure, which draws on loan, collateral and counterparty data. A liquidity requirement draws on cash flow assumptions and deposit data. An exemption removes the duty to produce those figures for the agency. It does not, on its own, remove the systems that produce them.
Liquidity, exempted by a capital test
The exemption covered liquidity requirements as well as capital. [1] The entry test, though, measured only capital. A bank could hold a high ratio of equity to assets and still face a run on its deposits. Capital absorbs losses. Liquidity pays depositors on the day they ask.
In our reading, that pairing put more weight on the bank’s own liquidity management. An electing bank would no longer report against a formal liquidity standard. Its treasury would still need cash flow forecasts, contingency funding plans and stress scenarios. Those tools rely on the same deposit and cash flow data the formal standard used.
For a technology leader, the practical result is that liquidity data pipelines stay in place. Their outputs move from a regulatory template to an internal dashboard. The data quality bar does not fall, because the bank now relies on those figures without an outside check.
Objections to distributions
The bill also exempted a qualifying organization from any rule that let a federal banking agency object to a capital distribution. [1] A Treasury report later that month described the same kind of off-ramp as an exemption from stress tests and capital planning, among other standards. [3] For an electing holding company, the agency’s check on dividends and buybacks would have gone.
Stability reviews in deals and activities
Several statutes ask the agencies to consider risks to financial stability when reviewing an acquisition, merger or new activity. [1] The bill said those considerations would not apply to a qualifying organization. [1] Much of the merger and acquisition relief carried a condition: the organization had to keep its ratio at 10 percent or more after the deal. [1]
That condition turned deal planning into a capital forecast. A bank weighing an acquisition would need to project its ratio after closing. The projection would matter as much as the ratio on the day of the election.
Enhanced prudential standards
The bill exempted qualifying organizations from rules implementing several subsections of section 165 of the Financial Stability Act of 2010. [1] Section 165 carries the enhanced supervision and prudential standards for larger bank holding companies. [4] The bill exempted electing organizations from section 163 of that Act as well. [1]
Well-capitalized status
A qualifying organization would be deemed well capitalized for several purposes. The bill listed section 216 of the Federal Credit Union Act and sections 29, 38, 44 and 46 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act. [1] In our reading, the deeming would have tied well-capitalized status under those sections to the single ratio.
What the relief did not touch
The list is as telling for what it left out. Section 602 named capital, liquidity, distributions, stability considerations and enhanced standards. [1] It did not name examinations, consumer protection, anti-money laundering, information security or vendor management. In our reading, a qualifying bank would still meet every one of those.
That matters to technology and compliance leaders. A capital election would not shrink the security program, the third-party risk program or the BSA function. The relief fell on treasury, finance and capital modeling teams. Others in the bank would see little change.
What the relief was worth in staff and systems
The relief can be described in the language of a budget. Some reporting work ends. Some model validation work ends, where the models served only regulatory capital. Some review cycles with the agency end, such as objections to distributions. [1]
Other work continues. The bank still closes its books, files its reports and runs its risk management. It still needs to know where its capital would stand under stress, because the exit terms punish a fall. [1] The net saving depends on how much of the capital function existed only to answer the agency. In our reading, that share differs widely from one bank to another.
Relief as a management choice
The election also changed incentives. A bank in the election would manage to one number, the quarterly ratio, rather than to a set of risk-weighted ratios. [1] A simple ratio gives the same weight to a government bond and a commercial loan. In our reading, an electing bank would face no capital charge for shifting toward riskier assets, so long as the ratio held.
A risk team would therefore keep its own measures after election. The bank’s credit, market and liquidity limits would carry the risk discipline the formal rules had carried. The capital rulebook would leave. The internal risk framework would have to grow to fill part of its place.
The exit: what happened when the ratio slipped
The election was not permanent. The bill tested the ratio every quarter after election, and it set out two paths out of the election. [1] The first path was gradual. The second was immediate.
Below 10 percent: a year to recover
If the agency determined that a qualifying organization’s quarterly ratio for the most recent quarter was below 10 percent, three things followed. The agency notified the organization and any state supervisor. [1] The agency could prohibit capital distributions. The organization had to submit a capital restoration plan within three months of the first such determination. [1]
The organization then had a one-year period beginning on the date of the determination. It had to raise its quarterly ratio to at least 10 percent for a quarter ending within that period. If it failed, the election terminated. [1] A parent holding company could also face limits on distributions, and lost its own election if the subsidiary’s election ended. [1]
Below 6 percent: no grace
A quarterly ratio below 6 percent ended the election at once. [1] The same rule reached up the corporate chain. A parent holding company’s election also terminated when an insured subsidiary’s did. [1]
Re-entry after eight quarters
An organization whose election ended could not elect again right away. It first had to keep a quarterly ratio of at least 10 percent for eight consecutive calendar quarters. [1] A bank that fell out would spend that time under the full rulebook.
What we did not find in the exit terms
We did not find a provision in Title VI giving a terminated organization time to rebuild compliance with the rules it had left. [1] In our reading, the exemption simply stopped when the election ended. An organization could then owe risk-based capital and liquidity figures for the next reporting date.
If that reading is right, the exit was a cliff for operations as well as capital. An organization that had decommissioned its risk-weighting engine, its liquidity models and its staff would need them back within a quarter. The careful choice would be to keep them warm.
The later community bank rule handled the same gap differently. It gave an electing bank that slipped a two-quarter grace period, during which it was still treated as meeting the requirements if its ratio stayed above 8 percent. [5] The 2026 rule lengthened that period to four quarters. [7] Both choices gave a bank time to restart its risk-based reporting before it was due. The House bill, as we read it, gave no such time once an election ended.
A bad year, step by step
Consider a hypothetical regional bank that elected with a ratio of 11 percent. In the second quarter, a credit loss lowers the ratio to 9.6 percent. The agency notifies the bank and may stop its dividend. [1] Within three months, the bank files a capital restoration plan. [1]
The bank then has one year from the determination to report a quarter at 10 percent or more. [1] If it raises capital or sells assets in time, the election survives. If not, the election ends, and the bank owes the full set of capital and liquidity figures. [1] If losses push the ratio below 6 percent in any quarter, the election ends at once. [1]
Each step needs data the bank must already have. The restoration plan needs forecasts. The decision to raise capital needs a view of the risk-based ratios the bank would face after exit. The bank that had kept its old engines running could answer quickly. The bank that had not would be rebuilding them under pressure.
The parent’s exposure
The exit terms reached the holding company. When an insured subsidiary’s ratio fell below 10 percent, the agency could bar the parent from distributions other than contributions to that subsidiary. [1] When the subsidiary’s election ended, so did the parent’s. [1]
For a multi-bank group, one subsidiary’s quarter could therefore end the election for the whole family. Group treasury would need each subsidiary’s ratio as closely as its own. In our reading, that ties the group’s relief to its weakest bank.
Why the exit set the value of the election
The value of an option depends on its exercise terms. The CHOICE Act let an organization in on notice, and let it fall out on a single quarterly figure below 6 percent. [1] A bank planning for that path would keep the systems it would need after a fall. The relief would then be smaller than the list in section 602 suggests.
The later history supports this reading. When the banking agencies lowered the community bank ratio in 2026, they reported that some electing banks kept parallel record keeping systems to limit the cost of falling out. [7] The agencies said the change could enable some of them to discontinue those systems. [7]
The evidence: what a qualifying organization would still compute and keep
The fourth part concerns the records that support an election. Every element of Title VI depended on figures the organization had to compute, file and defend. [1] The election changed which figures mattered. It did not remove the need for accurate ones.
The ratio as a controlled number
Under the bill, one number decided a wide set of exemptions. The quarterly ratio had to be computed for each entity and each quarter. [1] A misstatement could do more than mislead the agency. It could put the organization outside the election without anyone noticing.
That raises the control standard for the ratio. A bank that elects would want the ratio produced from the same ledger and filing data as its regulatory reports. It would want reconciliations, review and sign-off at the same level as a published financial statement.
The frozen definitions
The definitions of tangible equity and exposure referred to agency rules as in effect on the date of enactment. [1] In our reading, a bank would keep two sets of definitions over time. One would be the frozen set for the election. The other would be the live set used in its regulatory reports.
The result is a data lineage problem. Each component of the numerator and denominator would need a documented source, a rule version and a mapping to the filing. Auditors and examiners would ask for that mapping.
Forecasts and deal models
The merger relief required the ratio to stay at 10 percent or more after a transaction. [1] The agency could limit distributions once the ratio fell below 10 percent. [1] A bank would therefore forecast the ratio under its business plan and under adverse conditions. The capital forecast would survive the exemption from formal stress tests.
The shadow rulebook
The exit terms gave a bank reason to keep calculating risk-based capital and liquidity measures after election. [1] Those figures would not go to the agency. They would go to the board and the treasury function, as a measure of readiness to fall back.
In operational terms, the bank would run the same engines with fewer outputs. The data feeds, models and reconciliations would stay. The regulatory reporting templates would shrink. The savings in preparation and review time are real, but they are smaller than retiring the work outright.
What this part means for technology teams
For a technology leader, the election would change requirements, not the platform. The capital calculation system would stay in production. Its outputs would gain a new consumer, the election monitor, and lose another, the formal capital filing. Data quality controls would matter more, because one ratio would carry more weight.
Assurance around one number
Internal audit would have a new target. A ratio that unlocks exemptions deserves the same testing as a regulatory capital ratio, and arguably more. The bill gave the agency thirty days to object on entry. [1] After entry, the bank’s own controls would carry the main burden of getting each quarter right.
A practical assurance plan would test four things each quarter. The first is the completeness of the ledger feeds into the numerator and denominator. The second is the version of each definition used. The third is the classification of trading and swap positions. The fourth is the reconciliation of the ratio to the filed report.
Vendors and packaged reporting tools
Banks that buy regulatory reporting software would face a specific gap. Vendor tools follow the live rules and the current report forms. The bill’s definitions referred to rules as in effect on the date of enactment. [1] A bank would have to confirm its vendor could hold a frozen definition set, or maintain that set itself. That is a contract and configuration question, settled before the election rather than after.
How the design reached different institutions
Title VI applied the same test to every banking organization. [1] The effects would still have differed by size, charter and business. The cases below are our reading of the text, not findings about any institution.
Community banks
A community bank with no trading book and simple swaps would use the total-assets denominator. [1] Its relief would come mainly from risk-based capital reporting. Section 165 then reached holding companies from $50 billion in assets, as the 2018 amendment shows, so that part of the relief would be worth little to it. [4]
Credit unions
Credit unions were in scope as insured credit unions. [1] Their numerator was net worth and their denominator total assets, as the agency defined them. [1] An electing credit union would be deemed well capitalized under section 216 of the Federal Credit Union Act. [1] In our reading, the election would have mattered to larger credit unions facing NCUA’s 2015 risk-based capital rule, which had not yet taken effect. [6]
Regional holding companies
For a regional bank holding company subject to enhanced standards, the relief list reached further. The section 165 exemptions, distribution objections and stability reviews all applied. [1] The cost was higher too. A regional bank with trading or derivatives would use the broader exposure measure. [1] Its ratio would be harder to reach.
Groups with several banks
The family rule made multi-bank groups move together. [1] A group with one thinly capitalized subsidiary would have to raise that subsidiary’s capital or forgo the election. The test would sit at every level of the corporate chart.
New charters
A de novo bank could elect in its charter application, with tangible equity of at least 10 percent of exposure on its first day. [1] That option would let a new bank start without building risk-based capital reporting. In our reading, it would also leave the bank with no fallback system if its ratio slipped.
Mutual holding companies
The bill’s numerator gave a specific allowance to organizations that were mutual holding companies as of May 19, 2010. They could count trust preferred securities issued before that date, where existing rules already let them treat those securities as tier 1 capital. [1] For such an organization, the election’s value would turn on how much of its capital took that form, and on how long those instruments remained outstanding.
Objections, in order
1. A bill that did not become law tells us little
H.R. 10 passed the House and did not become law. The idea did. A narrower capital ratio for community banks was enacted in 2018, and the agencies made it an opt-in framework in 2019. [4] Its exit terms became the focus of agency rulemaking in 2026. [7] The bill set out the design in full, and the questions it raised recurred.
2. A single ratio is too blunt to set capital
The objection is about safety, and our argument is about operations. It is still relevant. The 2019 community bank rule added qualifying criteria on off-balance-sheet exposures and trading, which is an answer to bluntness. [5] Those criteria are more figures to monitor, which supports our point about evidence.
3. A bank with a high ratio would never fall out, so exit terms do not matter
A bank that holds a wide cushion faces little risk of a fall. In our reading, capital is costly, and a bank that holds a large cushion gives up some of the gain from the election. The 2026 rule records that some electing banks kept parallel systems to limit the cost of falling out. [7] That conduct suggests the risk was treated as real.
4. Capital relief is a finance matter, so technology leaders can ignore it
The relief fell on finance. The work it changed ran on technology. Technology teams build and run the capital engines, data feeds, reconciliations and filing tools. An election would change their requirements and raise the importance of data quality around one ratio. [1]
5. Credit unions already had a simple net worth ratio
Credit unions did use net worth. The bill would still have changed their position, by deeming an electing credit union well capitalized for statutory purposes. [1] NCUA later built its own optional ratio for complex credit unions. [6] The same questions about entry, exit and parallel systems applied there.
6. The threshold, not the exit, was the real design question
The level of the ratio drew the political attention, and it matters. The 2018 law set a range of 8 to 10 percent for community banks, and the agencies have set the requirement at different points within that range. [4] [5] [7] But the 2026 rule changed two things at once: the level and the grace period. [7] The agencies tied both to concerns about adoption, and said the change could let some banks drop parallel systems. [7] Their own account treats the way out as part of the design.
7. Supervisors could ease a fall case by case
An agency has discretion in how it supervises a bank under stress. The CHOICE Act text set fixed triggers: notice below 10 percent, a plan within three months, a one-year cure period and termination below 6 percent. [1] Some steps allowed discretion, such as whether to bar distributions. [1] Once the agency determined that a quarterly ratio was below 6 percent, termination was mandatory under the text. A bank could not plan on leniency it had no right to.
8. Electing banks would simply hold more capital, which is the goal
More capital was the stated price of relief. [1] [3] The objection is right that the trade could make banks safer. Our point is narrower. The operational savings that justify holding the extra capital depend on what the bank can switch off. If the exit terms force it to keep the old systems, the bank pays twice: more capital and much of the old cost.
What finance and technology leaders could check
The bill’s four parts translate into checks any bank or credit union can run on an opt-in capital framework, whether under the 2018 law, NCUA’s rule or a future proposal.
- Can the qualifying ratio be produced each quarter from the same data as the regulatory filing, with documented reconciliations?
- If the ratio fell below the framework’s floor next quarter, how long would it take to produce full risk-based capital figures again?
- Which systems, models and roles would the bank keep running after an election, and what do they cost?
- Does the deal and capital plan forecast the qualifying ratio after each planned transaction and distribution?
- Who in the organization owns the decision to elect, and who owns the decision to exit?
The checks apply beyond banks. A complex credit union weighing NCUA’s optional net worth framework faces the same questions about entry, monitoring and return to the risk-based rule. [6] A holding company planning around asset thresholds faces a version too, since crossing a threshold switches rules on rather than off. [4]
The second check is the one the exit terms make decisive. A bank that can answer it quickly can retire more of the old work. A bank that cannot will keep a shadow rulebook running. [1] [7]
With hindsight
A Treasury report to the President dated June 2017 took up the idea. It supported an off-ramp from stress tests, capital planning and certain prudential standards for a bank electing a sufficiently high level of capital. [3] It named the 10 percent ratio proposed by H.R. 10 as an example. [3]
The House bill did not become law. Congress took a narrower route. The Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act was approved on May 24, 2018. [4] Section 201 told the banking agencies to set a community bank capital ratio of not less than 8 percent and not more than 10 percent. [4] It applied to banks and holding companies with total consolidated assets of less than $10 billion. [4]
A qualifying community bank above the ratio would be considered to meet the general capital requirements and the well-capitalized ratios. [4] Section 201 also required procedures for a bank that fell below the ratio after exceeding it. [4] The statute thus required the agencies to address the exit. Section 401 of the same law raised the main asset threshold for enhanced prudential standards from $50 billion to $250 billion. [4]
The agencies set the ratio in a final rule published November 13, 2019, effective January 1, 2020. [5] An electing bank needed a ratio of greater than 9 percent and assets under $10 billion. It also needed off-balance-sheet exposures of 25 percent or less of assets and trading assets plus liabilities of 5 percent or less. [5] A bank that slipped had a two-quarter grace period, so long as its ratio stayed above 8 percent. [5] The agencies said opting in would let a bank stop reporting a range of line items in the capital schedule of its Call Report. [5]
The requirement moved during the pandemic. As NCUA later recounted, the CARES Act temporarily set the community bank ratio at 8 percent, with the 9 percent requirement returning effective January 1, 2022. [6] NCUA built its own version for credit unions. Its final rule, published December 23, 2021, let a complex credit union with more than $500 million in assets opt into a 9 percent net worth framework. [6] A credit union in that framework need not calculate a risk-based capital ratio and is considered well capitalized. [6]
In 2026 the banking agencies revisited the exit. A final rule published April 29, 2026, effective July 1, 2026, lowered the community bank ratio from 9 percent to 8 percent. [7] It extended the grace period from two quarters to four, limited to eight quarters in the previous five years. [7] A bank whose ratio fell to 7 percent or below would have to meet the risk-based rules for that quarter. [7]
The 2026 rule explained why. The agencies proposed the change to address concerns that the framework did not provide effective relief and discouraged broader adoption. [7] They reported that some participating banks maintained parallel record keeping systems to limit the cost of falling out. [7] They said the final rule could enable some of those banks to discontinue the systems and realize meaningful cost savings. [7]
The FDIC’s analysis put numbers on adoption. Among FDIC-supervised small institutions, 1,753 were eligible under the 9 percent framework and 989 had elected. [7] The lower ratio would add 240 eligible institutions, and the FDIC estimated about 158 more would elect. [7] The FDIC noted that not every bank that qualifies chooses to elect. [7]
What held up from June 2017? The core trade, simple capital in place of risk-based calculation, became law for community banks and a rule for complex credit unions. [4] [5] [6] The relief for larger firms came by asset thresholds instead. [4] What the House bill underplayed was the way out. The agencies’ own 2026 account suggests that exit terms shaped how many eligible banks elected, and how much work the electing banks retired. [7]
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.