Treasury’s 2016 proposal set four tests for intercompany loan files; the final rule let regulator terms count

In April 2016, Treasury proposed that large groups document related-party loans on a deadline or risk stock treatment. The final rule conditionally accepted terms bank regulators required; the rules were removed in 2019. In our reading, the four tests still define a sound loan file.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

In April 2016, Treasury proposed that large groups document related-party loans on a deadline or risk stock treatment. The final rule conditionally accepted terms bank regulators required; the rules were removed in 2019. In our reading, the four tests still define a sound loan file.

  1. The week The announcement listed several actions.
  2. The record: four things an intercompany loan file had to prove The preamble described the problem it was solving.
  3. The clock: when the record had to exist The proposal set deadlines measured from events.
  4. The perimeter: who was in, and why regulated groups were treated differently The documentation rules reached only large groups.
  5. The price: what the file cost, and how that cost was weighed The proposal priced its documentation burden.
  6. How the rules would have reached different organizations Consider a domestic bank holding company that files a consolidated return with its U.S. subsidiaries.
  7. Objections, in order Removal took away the prescribed file and its deadline. [6] It did not take away the question of whether an instrument is debt.
  8. Checks a treasury, tax or finance systems lead could run List every intercompany balance that crosses a consolidated return boundary.
  9. With hindsight The documentation rules changed twice in 2016 and 2017, then disappeared.

The week

On Monday, April 4, 2016, the Treasury Department and the Internal Revenue Service issued temporary and proposed regulations aimed at corporate tax inversions and at what Treasury called earnings stripping. [1] Treasury’s announcement described an inversion as a transaction in which a company moves its tax residence overseas to avoid U.S. taxes without making significant changes in its business operations. [1]

The announcement listed several actions. One limited inversions by disregarding foreign parent stock attributable to recent inversions or acquisitions of U.S. companies. [1] The others addressed earnings stripping, and they are the subject of this article. [1]

Treasury described three earnings-stripping measures. The first targeted transactions that generate large interest deductions by increasing related-party debt without financing new investment in the United States. [1] The second allowed the IRS on audit to divide a debt instrument into part debt and part equity. [1] The third required certain large corporations to do up-front due diligence and documentation on the characterization of related-party instruments as debt. [1] If those requirements were not met, Treasury said, the instruments would be treated as equity for tax purposes. [1]

The proposed regulations were published in the Federal Register on Friday, April 8, 2016, under the title Treatment of Certain Interests in Corporations as Stock or Indebtedness. [2] They carried the docket number REG-108060-15. [2] Comments and requests for a public hearing were due by July 7, 2016. [2]

The preamble explained why the rules were new. Congress enacted section 385 in 1969 to let Treasury write regulations on whether an interest in a corporation is stock or debt. [2] Because no regulations under section 385 were in effect, the preamble said, case law had continued to control the question. [2] Courts had applied various sets of factors to the facts of each case. [2]

The proposal had three working parts. Proposed section 1.385-1 dealt with interests that are debt in part and stock in part. [2] Proposed section 1.385-2 set documentation requirements for certain related-party interests. [2] Proposed sections 1.385-3 and 1.385-4 treated as stock certain related-party debt issued in distributions and similar transactions. [2]

The rules reached members of an expanded group. The proposal treated a corporation as a member if expanded group members owned 80 percent of its vote or value. [2] Section 1504(a) generally requires 80 percent of the vote and value. [2] The preamble said this kept the rules to transactions between highly related parties. [2]

The documentation rules applied only to large groups. An instrument was covered only if a member’s stock was publicly traded, or if the group’s financial statements showed total assets above $100 million or annual total revenue above $50 million. [2]

The proposal grouped the required records into four categories. Each reflected what the preamble called an essential characteristic of debt: a binding obligation to repay, the creditor’s rights to enforce the terms, a reasonable expectation of repayment, and actions evidencing a genuine debtor-creditor relationship. [2]

Timing was part of the test. Documentation generally had to be prepared no later than 30 calendar days after the relevant event. [2] Documentation of the ongoing debtor-creditor relationship could be prepared up to 120 calendar days after the payment or event. [2] The records had to be kept while the instrument was outstanding and until the limitations period expired for any return where its treatment mattered. [2]

The Paperwork Reduction Act section gave Treasury’s own estimates. It put the total annual reporting burden at 735,000 hours, with 21,000 respondents and an average of 35 hours each. [2] It estimated the frequency of responses as monthly. [2]

One other proposal was already pending. On November 30, 2015, the Federal Reserve Board had proposed total loss-absorbing capacity and long-term debt requirements for the largest bank holding companies and for U.S. intermediate holding companies of the largest foreign banks. [3] For those intermediate holding companies, the Board proposed that eligible internal long-term debt be issued to a foreign parent. [3] It also proposed that the debt be contractually subordinated and carry a trigger letting the Board require its cancellation or conversion into equity. [3]

Treasury framed April 4, 2016, around inversions. [1] For a technology, finance or compliance leader, the more durable part was the documentation proposal. Treasury proposed that a large group could no longer rely on the courts’ factor tests alone to defend an intercompany loan as debt. [2] It would have to show a prescribed file, prepared on a deadline, or the IRS could treat the instrument as stock. [1] [2]

Our argument is that the proposal turned intercompany lending into a records problem, and that the regulated-bank exception in the final rule shows why. The documentation rules were softened in October 2016 and removed in November 2019. [4] [6] But the four tests they named came from case law, and the case law still applies. [2] [6] In our reading, the 2016 file design is still a sound way to build a loan record, and the bank carve-out shows that, for the documentation rules, a regulator’s required terms could stand in for part of a tax file.

We take the question in four parts:

  1. The record: what each intercompany loan file had to prove under the four categories.
  2. The clock: when each piece of the file had to exist, and how cash pools and revolving facilities were handled.
  3. The perimeter: which groups and instruments were in scope, and why regulated financial groups were treated differently.
  4. The price: what the documentation cost by Treasury’s own estimates, and how that cost was weighed when the rules were removed.

The parts do not overlap. The first is content, the second timing, the third scope and the fourth cost. After them we look at how the rules would have landed on different kinds of organizations, take the objections in order and end with checks a treasury, tax or finance systems lead could run.

The record: four things an intercompany loan file had to prove

Why a record was needed at all

The preamble described the problem it was solving. Courts had analyzed debt and equity by applying sets of factors to the facts of each case. [2] No regulations under section 385 were in effect. [2] In our reading, the result was that the question turned on facts assembled after the event.

Treasury also described what it saw in audits. The preamble said the lack of guidance, combined with the volume of financial records taxpayers produce, made it hard to identify which documents would support debt treatment. [2] It said this was particularly hard on whether a reasonable expectation of repayment existed when the interest was issued. [2] The result could be the omission of necessary documents, or the production of vast amounts of irrelevant material that required forensic accounting expertise to sort. [2]

That framing matters for anyone who runs finance systems. The proposal did not mainly ask for new transactions. It asked that existing transactions leave a specific trail, and that the trail be findable.

The binding obligation

The first category was a binding obligation to repay. The preamble called this the threshold requirement for debt. [2] It required evidence in the form of timely prepared written documentation of the obligation. [2]

In systems terms, that is the executed note or loan agreement. For a group whose entities lend to each other through journal entries, that is the first gap. A ledger balance between two subsidiaries shows money moved. It does not show that one entity promised to repay the other on stated terms.

Creditor rights

The second category was the creditor’s right to enforce the terms. The proposal pointed to creditor rights such as the right to trigger a default and the right to accelerate payments. [2] It also said the holder must have a right superior to shareholders to share in the issuer’s assets if the issuer is dissolved or liquidated. [2]

This is a legal-drafting requirement more than a data requirement. But it has a data consequence. The terms that grant those rights must be captured in a form that can be produced on request, for each instrument, years later.

A reasonable expectation of repayment

The third category was the hardest. The proposal required timely prepared documentation showing a reasonable expectation that the issuer could repay. [2] Its examples included cash flow projections, financial statements, business forecasts, asset appraisals and debt-to-equity and other financial ratios. [2]

The proposal tied this test to the second working part of the rule. Under proposed section 1.385-1, the IRS could treat an interest as part debt and part stock. [2] The preamble’s example was a $5 million note where analysis showed the issuer could reasonably be expected to repay only $3 million. [2] The Commissioner could then treat $3 million as debt and $2 million as stock. [2]

That example explains why the repayment analysis mattered so much. A group that could not show the analysis risked losing the deduction on part of a loan as well as on all of it.

Conduct consistent with debt

The fourth category covered the life of the loan. The proposal required documentation of actions evidencing a genuine debtor-creditor relationship. [2] For payments, it said evidence could include a wire transfer record or a bank statement. [2] For defaults, it pointed to evidence of the holder’s efforts to enforce the terms or to renegotiate. [2]

This category reaches into treasury operations. If interest is accrued but never paid, or a missed payment is simply rolled into principal, the records will show it. The proposal asked the group to document how a creditor responded, which presumes someone decided to respond.

What the four categories add up to

Taken together, the four categories describe a loan file: the agreement, the rights, the credit analysis and the servicing history. A bank lending to an outside borrower would recognize each item. The novelty in 2016 was requiring it between companies under common control, and attaching a tax consequence to its absence.

The preamble said the four characteristics were drawn from case law and consistent with section 385(b)(1) and (5). [2] That point carries forward. When the rules were removed in 2019, Treasury described them as minimum documentation requirements that ordinarily must be satisfied. [6] It did not say the underlying characteristics stopped mattering. In our reading, a group that keeps the four-part file today is preparing for the same factor analysis courts apply anyway.

Partnerships and the reach of the record

The proposal’s summary said the rules generally affected corporations issuing purported debt to related corporations or partnerships. [2] So the holder could be a partnership, and the file had to cover those loans too. For a group that funds operations through a partnership structure, the inventory of covered instruments was wider than its corporate chart suggested.

The proposal also set rules for deemed exchanges, the tax effects when an instrument changed character. [2] That made the record more than an archive. It was the basis on which the group would know, at any date, what each instrument was for tax purposes.

The clock: when the record had to exist

The 30-day and 120-day windows

The proposal set deadlines measured from events. Documentation generally had to be prepared no later than 30 calendar days after the relevant event. [2] That event was generally the later of the date an instrument became a covered instrument or the date a group member became its issuer. [2]

Documentation of the ongoing relationship had a longer window. The proposal allowed up to 120 calendar days after the payment or relevant event. [2] The preamble said the longer period was meant to avoid inadvertent failures for events during an instrument’s life. [2]

These windows changed the nature of the task. A file assembled at year-end, or when an auditor asks, would not meet a 30-day rule. The proposal required a process that runs as transactions occur.

Cash pools and revolving facilities

The proposal recognized that some intercompany lending is continuous. It provided special timeliness rules for revolving credit agreements and cash pooling arrangements, generally looking to the documents under which they were established. [2]

For cash pools, it set a specific condition. Take an instrument issued under a cash pooling arrangement or internal banking service with sweeps, revolving advances or overdraft set-off. It met the written-obligation test only if the arrangement’s governing documentation was prepared, maintained and provided. [2] That documentation had to set out the rights and responsibilities of group members and of outside parties, such as the bank running the pool. [2]

The preamble also asked for comment on whether special rules were warranted for cash pools, cash sweeps and similar arrangements. [2] That question signals that Treasury knew the pool was the hard case.

Why pools were the hard case

A notional or physical cash pool can move balances between entities every business day. Each sweep can create or reduce an intercompany balance. Under a per-instrument reading, each balance could raise its own documentation question.

The proposal’s answer was to anchor on the master documents. In our reading, that put weight on the cash management agreement with the bank, the internal participation agreement and the treasury policy that governs limits and interest. If those documents were missing or out of date, every balance in the pool inherited the gap.

What an event-driven process would need

A 30-day rule needs triggers. In our reading, the proposal implied at least four: a new instrument, a new issuer, a payment due and a missed payment. The second matters in acquisitions. The clock ran from the later of the date an instrument became covered or the date a group member became its issuer. [2] An acquired company’s existing related-party debt could therefore start a fresh clock on closing.

Each trigger needs an owner and an output. A new instrument needs a signed note and a repayment analysis. A payment needs a wire record matched to the instrument. A missed payment needs a record of what the holder did about it. The proposal named those evidence types. [2]

A hypothetical shows the strain. A regional bank holding company with a foreign parent closes a nonbank acquisition on the last day of a quarter. The target carries loans from its former parent, now inside the group. Under the proposal, the group had 30 calendar days to have the repayment analysis on file for any covered instrument. [2] That is the same window in which the integration team is mapping systems and accounts.

The point is not that the deadline was impossible. It is that it required tax documentation to be designed into treasury and deal processes, rather than assembled by the tax function afterward.

The distribution rule and its own clock

The third working part had a longer horizon. Proposed section 1.385-3 treated certain debt as stock when issued to fund a distribution or acquisition. [2] A principal purpose to fund such a transaction was deemed to exist if the debt was issued during the period beginning 36 months before and ending 36 months after the distribution or acquisition. [2] The preamble called this the 72-month period and said the per se rule did not create a safe harbor outside it. [2]

The preamble explained the choice. It said a non-rebuttable presumption was appropriate because money is fungible and because it is hard for the IRS to establish the principal purposes of internal transactions. [2]

An exception covered ordinary course debt, such as debt arising from the purchase of goods or services in the issuer’s trade or business. [2] The preamble said that exception was not intended to apply to intercompany financing or treasury center activities. [2] In our reading, a group’s in-house bank therefore could not rely on that exception.

Keeping the record

The maintenance rule had no fixed end date. Records had to be kept for all years the instrument was outstanding and until the limitations period expired for any return where the instrument’s treatment was relevant. [2] The proposal did not specify where or how the records had to be kept. [2]

That silence put the design choice on the group. A shared drive of signed PDFs would satisfy the letter. Producing them for one instrument on request, with its payment history and credit analysis, would be a different matter.

The perimeter: who was in, and why regulated groups were treated differently

Large groups only

The documentation rules reached only large groups. The thresholds were a publicly traded member, more than $100 million of total assets on the financial statements, or more than $50 million of annual total revenue. [2] The preamble said these limits, and a $50 million threshold exception in the distribution rules, kept the proposal aimed at large taxpayers. [2]

In our reading, those thresholds would bring in a regional bank holding company or a mid-sized life sciences group with a public parent. For such groups the question was less whether the group was in scope than which of its instruments were.

Consolidated groups

The proposal generally treated members of a consolidated group as one corporation. [2] The preamble said the concerns it addressed were generally not present when an issuer’s interest deduction and the holder’s interest income offset on the same consolidated return. [2]

This narrowed the practical scope. Loans between members of a U.S. consolidated group generally fell outside the rules. Loans that crossed the consolidated group’s boundary, such as those from a foreign parent to a U.S. subsidiary, did not.

The foreign bank’s problem

That boundary is where the proposal met the Federal Reserve’s pending TLAC rule. The Board’s November 2015 proposal would have required U.S. intermediate holding companies of foreign global systemically important banks to issue internal long-term debt to a foreign parent. [3] That debt would be contractually subordinated to third-party liabilities. [3] It would include a trigger letting the Board require its cancellation or conversion into common equity. [3]

Each of those features was set by a prudential regulator for resolution purposes. Each also bears on the tax factors. A creditor whose claim can be canceled by a regulator, and who ranks behind every outside creditor, holds rights that look less like a lender’s.

The Treasury proposal did not mention TLAC. [2] Commenters raised it. The final Treasury rule recorded comments seeking exceptions for U.S. subsidiaries of foreign banks reorganizing under the intermediate holding company requirement. [4] It recorded comments referring to the Board’s proposed internal debt requirement. [4] And the Board’s own final rule recorded that commenters argued its internal debt features could cause the debt to be characterized as equity for tax purposes. [5]

What the final rule did

The final Treasury rule, published October 21, 2016, drew a regulated-group perimeter. [4] It excluded from the distribution rules debt issued by an excepted regulated financial company or a regulated insurance company. [4] It defined regulated financial companies by reference to institutions subject to specific regulatory capital requirements. [4]

The list included bank holding companies, certain savings and loan holding companies, insured depository institutions and certain U.S. intermediate holding companies of foreign banks. [4] It also included broker-dealers, futures commission merchants and swap dealers, among others. [4] The preamble said the exception was tailored to financial intermediaries whose business requires the efficient transfer of money among affiliates. [4]

The final rule also added a documentation exception. An instrument issued by an excepted regulated financial company was treated as meeting the documentation rules if it contained terms a regulator required for regulatory capital or resolution rules, including rules requiring TLAC. [4] The conditions were that the parties expected at issuance that the instrument would be paid according to its terms, and that they kept the documentation needed to show it qualified for the exception. [4] The preamble added that some instruments regulators required raised common law debt-equity issues beyond the scope of the regulations. [4]

What the Fed did

The Board moved too. Its final TLAC rule, published January 24, 2017, said the Board had consulted Treasury on whether internal long-term debt could be considered equity for tax purposes. [5] It made four changes it said should mitigate commenters’ concerns. [5]

The final rule dropped the Board’s ability to require cancellation, keeping only conversion or exchange. [5] It allowed the same acceleration clauses permitted for external debt. [5] It removed the contractual subordination requirement for internal debt. [5] And it allowed partial conversion rather than only full conversion. [5]

Our reading of the perimeter

Two agencies adjusted two rules so that one intercompany note could pass both. Treasury accepted a regulator’s required terms, on conditions, as satisfying its documentation test. [4] The Board removed terms that would have made the note look less like debt. [5]

In our reading, the bank exception was not a holiday from records. It rested on records banks already kept for prudential reasons. The final Treasury preamble said as much about burden: where non-tax regulators already require documentation, such as under the Board’s Regulation W, any additional burden is reduced. [4] The perimeter followed the paper trail.

The price: what the file cost, and how that cost was weighed

Treasury’s own estimate

The proposal priced its documentation burden. It estimated 735,000 total annual reporting hours across 21,000 respondents, an average of 35 hours each, with monthly responses. [2] Those are Treasury’s figures, not ours, and they cover the collection of information in proposed section 1.385-2. [2]

The proposal asked for comment on how the burden could be minimized, including through automated collection techniques or other information technology. [2] That invitation is a direct signal to systems owners. The government expected the file to be produced by software, not by hand.

Where the cost would fall

The cost would not fall evenly. A group with one annual intercompany loan from a foreign parent would face a modest task. A group running a daily cash pool across dozens of entities would face a continuous one.

The categories also mapped to different owners. The note and creditor rights belong to legal. The repayment analysis belongs to treasury or financial planning. The payment history lives in the treasury management system or the general ledger. A 30-day clock forces those owners to hand off on a schedule.

The cost of failure

The proposal attached a heavy consequence to a missing file. Failure to provide the documentation on request would mean the Commissioner treated the requirements as not satisfied. [2] Treasury’s announcement said the instruments would then be treated as equity for tax purposes. [1]

That outcome changes more than one number. Treasury’s measures were aimed at interest deductions on related-party debt, so recharacterization would remove the deduction the loan was meant to carry. [1] Commenters on the Board’s rule said the risk of equity treatment created uncertainty about the deductibility of interest on internal debt and whether payments were subject to withholding tax. [5]

How the cost was weighed in 2016

The final rule in October 2016 cut the cost in several ways. It eliminated the 30-day timely preparation requirement. [4] It treated documentation as timely if prepared by the time the issuer’s federal income tax return was filed, including extensions. [4] It replaced per se recharacterization with a rebuttable presumption for groups otherwise generally compliant. [4] And it applied only to instruments issued on or after January 1, 2018. [4]

The final rule also excluded foreign issuers entirely. [4] It clarified that groups could satisfy the rules for revolving credit, cash pooling and similar arrangements through master agreements. [4] Each change moved the burden from a running process toward a periodic one.

How the cost was weighed in 2019

The removal rule in November 2019 made the cost the deciding factor. Treasury said it had determined that the burdens on taxpayers outweighed the regulations’ intended benefits. [6] It received three comments on the removal proposal: two in favor and one opposed. [6]

The removal rule also gave a reason rooted in later law. It said the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act reduced the advantages the rules targeted, citing the lower corporate rate and the changes to section 163(j). [6] It said the benefits of the documentation rules in reducing interest stripping were reduced as a result. [6]

The removal also listed what it might cost. Treasury said the change may increase IRS costs in administering the distribution rules and potentially lead to more noncompliance by some taxpayers. [6] It said taxpayers that continue to document would not change their behavior in any measurable degree. [6]

What automation could and could not do

The proposal’s invitation to comment on automated collection was a fair one. [2] Some of the file is data a system already holds. Payment records, balances and interest accruals sit in treasury management systems and ledgers. Linking them to an instrument identifier is an integration task.

Other parts resist automation. A creditor-rights clause is legal text. A repayment analysis is a judgment made at a point in time, using projections the business owns. A system can prompt for these, store them and time-stamp them. It cannot produce them.

That split suggests where the cost would have landed. The data half was a one-time build. The judgment half was a recurring workload for treasury, financial planning and legal, on a clock the tax function did not control.

How the rules would have reached different organizations

A large bank holding company

Consider a domestic bank holding company that files a consolidated return with its U.S. subsidiaries. Loans inside that group were generally outside the proposal. [2] Its exposure was at the edges: foreign subsidiaries, partnerships and any non-consolidated affiliates.

After the final rule, its debt was outside the distribution rules as an excepted regulated financial company. [4] Its records under Regulation W and capital rules were the base the final preamble pointed to. [4] The work was to confirm which instruments fell inside the exception and which did not.

A foreign bank’s U.S. intermediate holding company

This was the organization caught between the two proposals. It was being asked by the Board to issue internal debt to its foreign parent. [3] It was being asked by Treasury to show that cross-border related-party debt met the four tests. [2] Until both final rules were out, the two requests pointed in different directions.

The final rules resolved the conflict on paper. Treasury excepted intermediate holding companies from the distribution rules and accepted regulator-required TLAC terms for documentation. [4] The Board removed the features commenters said could make the debt look like equity. [5] The intermediate holding company still had to document everything else.

A health system

A nonprofit health system is a different case. The proposal addressed interests in corporations issued between members of an expanded group, and the documents we cite do not discuss tax-exempt hospitals. [2] A system with for-profit subsidiaries, a captive insurer or joint ventures would ask counsel which entities, if any, raised a section 385 question.

For a for-profit hospital company with a foreign parent or foreign financing, the analysis looked more like any other corporate group. Its intercompany funding of acquisitions would have faced the 72-month presumption. [2]

A life sciences group

A multinational life sciences group was closer to the center of the 2016 debate. Treasury’s April 4 announcement was framed around inversions and foreign parents. [1] In our reading, a U.S. subsidiary borrowing from a foreign parent to fund a distribution was the core case for the distribution rules. [2]

Its records task was also heavy. A group with an in-house bank and a global cash pool would have had to document both the pool’s master agreements and the balances it generated. [2]

A fintech or broker-dealer

A broker-dealer was on the final rule’s list of regulated financial companies. [4] A fintech lender without a bank charter was not obviously so. The perimeter turned on whether a firm was subject to specific regulatory capital requirements, so its charter decided its treatment. [4]

A public agency

In our reading, public agencies were outside the section 385 rules, which deal with interests in corporations. [2] The file design still travels. An agency whose enterprise fund borrows from its general fund could keep the same four items: the authorizing document, the terms, the repayment analysis and the payment record. That would be good practice, not a tax requirement.

Objections, in order

1. The documentation rules were removed, so none of it matters now

Removal took away the prescribed file and its deadline. [6] It did not take away the question of whether an instrument is debt. That question is still decided under the factors courts have applied, which the 2016 proposal said its four characteristics were drawn from. [2] In our reading, the file is still the best defense; it is now voluntary.

2. The thresholds were too low to be meaningful

The thresholds were $100 million of assets or $50 million of revenue, or a public member. [2] The preamble said those limits kept the rules to large taxpayers. [2] Whether they were too low or too high was a policy call Treasury made. A group near the line had reason to plan as though it were in.

3. A bank’s regulators already see every intercompany loan

They see a great deal. The final Treasury preamble recognized that Regulation W documentation reduced the added burden. [4] But a prudential regulator’s file is built for safety and soundness, not for the tax factors. The final rule’s exception covered instruments with regulator-required terms for capital or resolution purposes. [4] Ordinary intercompany loans outside that exception stayed within the documentation rules as written. Those rules were delayed and then removed, and the removal rule said that, because taxpayers could rely on the removal proposal, they applied to no taxpayer’s interests unless it chose to apply them. [6]

4. Cash pools cannot be documented loan by loan

The proposal did not ask for that. It looked to the documents establishing the arrangement. [2] The final rule clarified the use of master agreements. [4] The burden falls on keeping those master documents current and consistent with how the pool actually runs.

5. The Fed and Treasury should have coordinated before proposing

The record shows coordination came during the comment period. The Board said it consulted Treasury on the tax characterization of internal debt. [5] Treasury’s final rule cited TLAC directly in its documentation exception. [4] Whether earlier coordination was possible is not something the documents address. What they show is that the two rules were reconciled before either applied.

6. Tax treatment is the tax department’s concern, not the CIO’s

The proposal invited comment on automated collection techniques and information technology. [2] We doubt its 30-day clock could have been met without systems that capture agreements, analyses and payments as they happen. [2] In our reading, the documentation rules were a data retention and workflow requirement with a tax consequence.

7. The rules were about inversions, and we are not an inverted company

Treasury announced the rules alongside its inversion measures. [1] But the documentation rules were written for any large group with covered related-party instruments. [2] The summary said they generally affected corporations issuing purported debt to related corporations or partnerships. [2] A U.S. group with a foreign subsidiary that lends back to the parent was in scope without any inversion. In our reading, the inversion framing understated how far the documentation rules reached.

Checks a treasury, tax or finance systems lead could run

Inventory

List every intercompany balance that crosses a consolidated return boundary. For each, name the issuer, the holder, the instrument type and the governing document.

The four-part file

For a sample of those instruments, pull the note, the creditor rights, the repayment analysis at issuance and the payment history. Record which of the four the file can produce within a day.

Cash pools

For each pool, confirm the master agreement, the participation agreements and the bank’s cash management agreement are current. Compare the interest and limits in the documents with what the system applies.

Regulator-required terms

List instruments whose terms are set by a banking or insurance regulator. Keep the regulatory basis for each term with the instrument, since the 2016 final rule treated those terms specially. [4]

Servicing evidence

Check whether intercompany interest is paid, accrued or capitalized. Where payments are missed, find the record of how the holder responded. The proposal treated that response as evidence. [2]

Distribution history

List distributions and acquisitions by U.S. members over recent years. Match them against related-party debt issued nearby. The distribution rules in section 1.385-3 remain in the eCFR as checked on November 16, 2026. [7]

Acquisitions

Add a tax-documentation step to the acquisition integration checklist. Under the 2016 proposal, a new issuer joining the group started its own clock. [2] Even without that rule, an acquired company’s related-party debt is easiest to document at closing, when the deal team still has the facts.

Watch list

Track Treasury’s regulatory agenda for any revised documentation proposal. The 2019 removal rule said any modified version would be streamlined and proposed with a prospective effective date. [6]

With hindsight

The documentation rules changed twice in 2016 and 2017, then disappeared. The first change came quickly. Treasury and the IRS published final and temporary regulations on October 21, 2016, as T.D. 9790. [4] [6] The final rules removed the 30-day deadline and treated documentation as timely if prepared by the tax return filing date, including extensions. [4]

The final rules also softened the consequence. A group that was otherwise generally compliant faced a rebuttable presumption rather than automatic recharacterization as stock. [4] Foreign issuers were left out entirely. [4] And the documentation rules applied only to instruments issued on or after January 1, 2018. [4]

The regulated-group perimeter came in the same document. Debt issued by excepted regulated financial companies and regulated insurance companies was excluded from the distribution rules. [4] Instruments with regulator-required capital or resolution terms, including TLAC terms, were treated as meeting the documentation rules if expected to be paid according to their terms. [4]

The Federal Reserve’s final TLAC rule followed on January 24, 2017. [5] The Board said it had consulted Treasury on the tax characterization of internal long-term debt. [5] It made four changes to the internal debt features, including removing contractual subordination and the Board’s power to require cancellation. [5] The rule was effective March 27, 2017, and its preamble said it required full compliance by January 1, 2019. [5]

Then a review of the rules began. Executive Order 13789, issued April 21, 2017, directed Treasury to review significant tax regulations issued on or after January 1, 2016. [6] Notice 2017-38 listed the section 385 regulations among eight identified as meeting at least one of the order’s first two criteria. [6] Notice 2017-36 announced a further delay, making the documentation rules applicable only to interests issued on or after January 1, 2019. [6]

Treasury’s second report under the order said it was considering revoking the documentation rules. [6] It published a proposal to remove them on September 24, 2018, and let taxpayers rely on that proposal until it was finalized. [6]

The removal became final as T.D. 9880 on November 4, 2019. [6] Treasury said it had determined that the burdens outweighed the intended benefits. [6] It received three written comments on the removal: two supporting and one opposing. [6] The opposing commenter argued removal would hamper the IRS against earnings stripping. [6]

Treasury also explained the economic context. It said the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act reduced the statutory corporate rate and significantly reduced the ability to strip earnings through interest deductions by amending section 163(j). [6] It said the benefits of the documentation rules in reducing interest stripping were reduced as a result. [6]

The removal was not a closing of the subject. Treasury said it continued to consider the issues and might propose a modified version. [6] Any such version, it said, would be substantially simplified and proposed with a prospective effective date to give taxpayers time to design and implement systems. [6]

The distribution rules stayed. As checked on November 16, 2026, section 1.385-3 remains in the eCFR, including its definition of an excepted regulated financial company. [7] The parts of the 2016 package that treat debt issued in distributions as stock therefore still apply, subject to their own terms and exceptions. [7]

What held up is the design of the file. The four categories were drawn from case law, and Treasury’s 2019 removal described them as the elements taxpayers would have needed to establish. [2] [6] Those elements are the questions a court still asks.

What did not hold up is the clock. The 30-day deadline was proposed in April 2016, dropped in the October 2016 final rule and never applied. [2] [4] The idea that the government could require a running, event-driven tax record for intercompany loans was tested and withdrawn.

The bank perimeter held up in a different way. The final rule accepted regulator-required terms, on conditions, as meeting the documentation rules, and the Board adjusted its own terms to fit tax debt. [4] [5] Two agencies with different goals arrived at one instrument design. In our view, a regulated firm should take one thing from it: when two regulators define the same instrument, the file has to satisfy both. The 2016 record shows the two agencies adjusted their rules after commenters set out the conflict. [4] [5]

For a technology or finance leader in 2026, the practical residue is modest but real. A group with intercompany debt still needs to defend it as debt if challenged. The 2016 proposal remains a detailed official description of what that defense looks like on paper. [2]

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • Section 385
  • intercompany debt
  • tax documentation
  • TLAC
  • cash pooling
  • treasury operations