FHFA’s 2015 counterparty rule gave the GSEs 30 days to report; its watchdog found FHFA’s own review backlogged

FHFA’s December 2015 Suspended Counterparty Program rule gave Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the Home Loan Banks 30 days to report counterparties’ mortgage fraud findings, without a duty to investigate. The harder work was FHFA’s own review, which its inspector general found backlogged in 2017.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

FHFA’s December 2015 Suspended Counterparty Program rule gave Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the Home Loan Banks 30 days to report counterparties’ mortgage fraud findings, without a duty to investigate. The harder work was FHFA’s own review, which its inspector general found backlogged in 2017.

  1. The week The program was not new.
  2. The trigger: what kind of finding counts The program does not start from suspicion.
  3. The report: what a regulated entity must tell FHFA In our reading, FHFA separated two duties.
  4. The decision: how FHFA moves from report to suspension The regulated entities may respond too.
  5. The reach: which relationships an order cuts off A suspension does not have to cut every tie at once.
  6. How the program reached different organizations The Enterprises bear the reporting duty and must comply with orders. [2] The Enterprises told FHFA’s inspector general that, as of December 31, 2016, they had almost 5,000 counterparty relationships. [4] Their counterparties include mortgage sellers and servicers. [4] For an Enterprise, a suspension order changes onboarding, loan acquisition and servicing transfers at once.
  7. Trade-offs the design created Publishing suspensions gives every lender and vendor a way to check a counterparty. [3] It also attaches a public mark to a person or firm.
  8. The strongest objections FHFA’s answer was that looking is a supervisory expectation, not a program duty. [1] That answer depends on examination.
  9. What a third-party risk manager would check These checks are good practice, not requirements of the rule.
  10. Why the bottleneck was the regulator’s queue The 2015 rule made the regulated entities’ duties clearer and somewhat lighter.
  11. With hindsight The follow-up did not go smoothly.

The week

On Wednesday, December 23, 2015, the Federal Housing Finance Agency published a final rule titled Suspended Counterparty Program. [1] The rule amended 12 CFR Part 1227 and took effect on January 22, 2016. [1] FHFA’s Director dated it December 15, 2015. [1]

The rule applied to FHFA’s regulated entities: Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the eleven Federal Home Loan Banks. [1] Under the program, FHFA may issue suspension orders directing them to cease doing business with an individual or institution, and any affiliate, for a specified period. [1] The trigger is that the party has committed fraud or other financial misconduct involving a mortgage transaction. [1]

The program was not new. The rule said FHFA established it in June 2012 by letter to the regulated entities. [1] An interim final rule published on October 23, 2013 generally codified its requirements and procedures. [1] FHFA received two comment letters on that interim rule: one from Fannie Mae and one from eleven of the then twelve Banks. [1] The rule noted that the Federal Home Loan Bank of Seattle had merged into the Federal Home Loan Bank of Des Moines as of the close of business on May 31, 2015. [1]

The rule described how the program worked. A regulated entity must report to FHFA if it becomes aware that a party it does business with has committed covered misconduct. [1] The finding must fall within the past three years and involve fraud or other financial misconduct in a mortgage transaction. [1] FHFA may issue proposed and final suspension orders based on those reports or on other information. [1] It offers the affected party and the regulated entities an opportunity to respond to a proposed order. [1]

A final order requires a finding about harm. FHFA may issue one if it determines the misconduct is of a type likely to cause significant financial or reputational harm to a regulated entity, or otherwise threaten its safe and sound operation. [1] Final orders direct the regulated entities to cease or refrain from doing business with the suspended party for a specified period, which may be permanent in appropriate cases. [1]

The final rule made four changes to the interim rule. [1] First, it excluded from final suspension orders any residential mortgage loan secured by the respondent’s own personal or household residence. [1] Second, it gave the regulated entities 30 calendar days, instead of ten business days, to report covered misconduct. [1]

Third, it removed the requirement that FHFA show a regulated entity had done business with the party during the past three years, as a condition of issuing a suspension order. [1] Fourth, it clarified how notices of proposed suspension are sent to affiliates. [1]

The rule also declined several requests. The Banks asked FHFA to say they need not search court dockets or monitor federal debarment notices. [1] FHFA did not change the scope of the reporting duty. It said a regulated entity must report only covered misconduct of which it is aware. [1] It said the program is not intended to require additional review or investigation by a regulated entity. [1]

The Banks asked FHFA to confirm that their existing screening against the Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control list was sufficient. [1] Fannie Mae asked FHFA to say it need not screen individual buyers of its real estate owned properties against the suspended list. [1] FHFA said the program does not define the scope of a regulated entity’s internal procedures. [1] It said the program supplements those efforts and does not replace them. [1]

Commenters asked FHFA to exclude lower-tier parties, such as a subcontractor serving a direct counterparty. [1] FHFA said it would be operationally difficult at this time for the regulated entities to monitor those relationships. [1] It did not require reports on them, or that direct counterparties stop dealing with suspended lower-tier parties. [1] It kept the definition of covered transaction broad, while excluding generic vendors such as mail and package delivery services from its intent. [1]

The rule considered whether the Banks should be treated differently from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. [1] FHFA said it had considered the differences the statute lists and determined that the Banks should not be treated differently for this rule. [1]

In their comments on FHFA’s 2013 interim rule, the Federal Home Loan Banks said they already screened parties against the Treasury Department’s sanctions list. [1] In December 2015, FHFA finalized a different kind of list for the Banks, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. [1] It named parties with mortgage fraud findings that the regulated entities must stop dealing with. [1] The rule told Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the Federal Home Loan Banks what they had to report, and what FHFA would decide. [1]

Our argument is that the rule kept the regulated entities’ part narrow and put the hard part on FHFA. A regulated entity had to report covered misconduct it became aware of within 30 calendar days. [1] It had no duty under the program to investigate. [1] FHFA decided whether to propose a suspension, and could do so only while the underlying conviction or sanction was still within three years. [1] [2] FHFA’s inspector general later found a significant backlog of referrals in FHFA’s own Office of General Counsel. [4]

For a bank, a credit union or a mortgage servicer, the program applies on both sides of the table. Such firms may be counterparties of the Enterprises or members of a Home Loan Bank. They also run third-party programs of their own. The rule’s design, and its later record, apply to both roles.

We take the program in four parts:

  1. The trigger: what kind of finding brings a party within the program.
  2. The report: what a regulated entity must tell FHFA, and when.
  3. The decision: how FHFA moves from a report to a suspension.
  4. The reach: which relationships a suspension order cuts off.

The parts do not overlap. The first defines the event, the second the regulated entity’s duty, the third FHFA’s process and the fourth the effect of the result. After them we look at how the program reached different kinds of organization, take the objections and end with checks a third-party risk manager could run.

The trigger: what kind of finding counts

Convictions and administrative sanctions only

The program does not start from suspicion. Covered misconduct is a conviction or administrative sanction within the past three years. [2] The basis must involve fraud, embezzlement, theft, conversion, forgery, bribery, perjury, false statements or claims, tax evasion, obstruction of justice or a similar offense. [2] It must be connected with a mortgage, the mortgage business, mortgage securities or another lending product. [2]

A conviction includes a judgment entered on a verdict or a plea. [2] It also includes a functional equivalent such as probation before judgment or deferred prosecution. [2] A disposition without the court’s participation counts only if it includes an admission of guilt. [2]

An administrative sanction means a debarment, suspension or similar action by a federal agency that limits a person’s ability to do business with that agency. [2] It includes settlements of proposed sanctions if the settlement has that effect. [2]

What FHFA declined to add in 2015

The interim rule’s notice had asked whether administrative sanction should include other actions, such as enforcement actions by other financial institution regulators. [1] Fannie Mae said the existing definition was sufficiently broad. [1] FHFA left it unchanged. It called the program a limited measure aimed at fraud and other financial misconduct. [1]

The Banks asked whether “a court of competent jurisdiction” excluded foreign courts. [1] FHFA said the definition covers both state and federal courts. [1] It said it had received no reports based on a foreign conviction and would evaluate any it received. [1]

No independent fact-finding

FHFA explained why the trigger was a formal finding. It said it does not engage in independent fact-finding about the conduct underlying a conviction or sanction. [1] The definition is written in terms of convictions and administrative sanctions for that reason. [1]

In our reading, that choice made the program cheap to run and easy to defend. A suspension rests on a court’s or agency’s record, not on FHFA’s own investigation. The cost is timing. A party could engage in mortgage fraud for years before a court or agency acted, and the program would not reach it until then.

What the trigger leaves out

The trigger’s limits are clearest in what FHFA later tried to add. A 2023 proposal would have counted certain orders or judgments in civil matters as convictions. [6] It would also have added knowingly committing a material breach of contract. [6] It would have created immediate suspensions, with a procedure to vacate them. [6]

FHFA described the reaction in its 2024 second proposal. It received eleven unique comment letters, and seven expressed strong opposition. [6] Six raised concerns that the proposal was overly broad and gave FHFA undue discretion. [6] FHFA said material changes were needed and published a second proposal. [6]

Read against those proposals, the 2015 trigger is narrow. In our reading, a civil fraud judgment, a regulator’s consent order or a contract breach does not bring a party within the program unless it is a conviction or an administrative sanction as defined. [2] Those parties remain a matter for each regulated entity’s own counterparty controls.

Why the three-year window matters

The three-year limit on covered misconduct does two jobs. It keeps the program focused on recent findings. It also sets a deadline on FHFA. FHFA’s general counsel, the suspending official, told the inspector general he saw the period as a kind of statute of limitations. [4] He explained that FHFA cannot impose a suspension under the program for covered misconduct outside the three-year period. [4]

In our reading, that makes the window a clock on the regulator, not on the regulated entity. A report that arrives early in the window gives FHFA time. A report that arrives late, or waits unreviewed, may expire before a decision. The rule does not say when within the window a report must be acted on. [2]

Imputation between affiliates

The trigger reaches beyond the person found responsible. FHFA may impute an individual’s covered misconduct to an organization when it occurred in the individual’s duties for the organization, or with its knowledge, approval or acquiescence. [2] The organization’s acceptance of the benefits is evidence of that knowledge. [2]

FHFA may also impute an organization’s misconduct to an individual who participated in, knew of or had reason to know of it. [2] It may impute between organizations in partnerships, joint ventures or where one has power to direct or control the other. [2]

The Banks asked FHFA to clarify who counts as an affiliate, including whether executive officers would. [1] FHFA said it intends “affiliate” to be read broadly, in light of the imputation provisions. [1] Where it imputes conduct from an individual to an organization, it treats them as affiliates for the program. [1]

What the trigger means for a counterparty’s own controls

For a mortgage lender or servicer, the trigger defines a risk to its own access to the Enterprises and the Banks. An employee’s mortgage fraud conviction can be imputed to the firm. [2] The firm’s main defense is evidence that the conduct was not within the employee’s duties for the firm and was not known, approved or tolerated. In our reading, that evidence is the same as a well-run compliance program: hiring checks, supervision, escalation and prompt action when misconduct is found.

The report: what a regulated entity must tell FHFA

Awareness, not investigation

A regulated entity must submit a report when it becomes aware that a party it is engaging, or has engaged, in a covered transaction within the past three years has engaged in covered misconduct. [2] It is aware when it has reliable information that the misconduct occurred. [2]

The Banks asked FHFA to say they need not search dockets, monitor debarment notices or report conduct widely known from national news or agency announcements. [1] FHFA did not change the scope of the reporting duty. [1] It said the extent of a regulated entity’s efforts to evaluate counterparties or address mortgage fraud is a prudential matter, subject to FHFA’s regular supervision. [1] It said the program is not intended to require additional review or investigation, nor to take the place of reviews the entity would otherwise conduct. [1]

In our reading, FHFA separated two duties. The program’s reporting duty is triggered by knowledge. The broader duty to manage fraud risk comes from safe and sound operation and is examined through supervision. [1] A regulated entity that never looked would not breach the reporting rule. It might still face supervisory criticism for not looking.

Confidential examination information

The Banks raised a conflict. They review members’ examination reports under confidentiality agreements with federal financial regulators. [1] They asked that information found there not trigger a report. [1] FHFA said the program is limited to convictions and administrative sanctions, and records of those would be publicly available. [1] It saw no need to change the rule. [1]

Thirty calendar days

The interim rule required a report within ten business days of becoming aware. [1] Fannie Mae said that was not enough to complete its due diligence and confirm whether a covered transaction existed. [1] It asked for 30 calendar days. [1] FHFA agreed. [1]

The current text says a regulated entity must report no later than thirty calendar days after becoming aware, even if it lacks enough information for a complete report. [2] It may supplement the report at any time. [2]

What a report must contain

Each report must identify the person or persons involved and any affiliates known to the regulated entity. [2] It must describe the nature and extent of any covered transaction with them. [2] It must describe the covered misconduct, including its date and any documents evidencing it that the regulated entity holds. [2]

Building the reporting process

A regulated entity needs four pieces to meet the duty. The first is intake: a way for staff who learn of a counterparty’s conviction or sanction to send it to one place. The second is a counterparty register that shows which parties the entity dealt with in the past three years, with known affiliates. [2]

The third is a reliability judgment. The rule ties awareness to “reliable information.” [2] Someone, for example counsel or a fraud team, has to decide whether a news item, a court record or a referral meets that bar. The fourth is a dated log, because the 30-day clock runs from awareness. [2] An entity that cannot show when it became aware cannot show it reported on time.

Reports can come from more than the regulated entities. The rule lets FHFA act on referrals from its Office of Inspector General and on any other source. [2] The inspector general’s 2017 report said others, such as the Department of Housing and Urban Development, may also refer counterparties. [4] For a regulated entity, that means FHFA may learn of a counterparty’s misconduct from someone else first.

The three-year look back on relationships

Both Fannie Mae and the Banks asked to limit reporting to current counterparties. [1] The Banks said their procedures did not address parties that had stopped doing business with them. [1] Fannie Mae said researching contracts that ended years earlier would yield little benefit. [1]

FHFA kept the reporting duty for parties with which the entity did business within the past three years. [1] It gave a reason. A regulated entity may have stopped dealing with a party that another regulated entity still deals with, unaware of the misconduct. [1] Excluding those cases would undermine the program. [1] FHFA encouraged reports on any party with covered misconduct, regardless of when the last transaction took place, where records allow. [1]

In our reading, that reasoning treats the regulated entities as a network. One entity’s former counterparty is another’s current one. A report from the first protects the second.

What the report duty costs

The duty is narrow, but it is not free. A regulated entity needs a way to learn of convictions and sanctions involving its counterparties. It needs records showing which parties it dealt with in the past three years. It needs someone to decide whether the information is reliable, and a clock to meet the 30-day deadline.

The Banks’ comment that it would be difficult, if not impossible, to know the full extent of any entity’s affiliates shows the hardest part. [1] A report must name affiliates known to the entity. [2] Knowing them requires ownership data that a counterparty file may not hold.

The decision: how FHFA moves from report to suspension

The steps in the rule

A suspending official may base a proposed suspension on a regulated entity’s report, a referral from FHFA’s Office of Inspector General or any other source. [2] The official may propose a suspension if there is evidence of covered misconduct and the misconduct is of a type likely to cause significant financial or reputational harm, or to threaten safe and sound operation. [2]

The notice of proposed suspension goes to the respondent and to all regulated entities. [2] It must give at least 30 calendar days to respond. [2] The respondent’s response must identify specific facts contradicting the notice, since a general denial is insufficient to raise a genuine dispute. [2]

The regulated entities may respond too. Their response must include any information that suspension could have a negative financial impact or other significant adverse effect on them. [2] It must identify existing contracts for which they might request a limitation. [2] They may also suggest alternatives to suspension. [2]

A final order rests on the written record. [2] The official may issue one if there is adequate evidence of covered misconduct and the harm standard is met. [2] The rule provides for an appeal to the Director, reconsideration after twelve months and requests for exceptions for particular transactions. [2]

How long a suspension lasts

The rule leaves the length to the order. A final order directs the regulated entities to cease dealing with the respondent for a specified period of time or permanently. [2] FHFA filled that gap with guidelines. The 2017 inspector general report described them. [4]

Under those guidelines, a counterparty sentenced or sanctioned for less than five years was to be suspended for five years, absent mitigating conditions. [4] A sentence or sanction of at least five but less than ten years meant a ten-year suspension. [4] A sentence or sanction of ten years or more meant an indefinite suspension. [4]

The inspector general found the suspending official generally followed the guidelines. [4] It found three instances in which a suspension was shorter than the guidelines provided, with no written explanation of the mitigating conditions. [4] It recommended that FHFA document its reasons for departures, and FHFA accepted. [4]

The guidelines later changed. The 2026 audit said that before 2023, FHFA’s guidance allowed suspensions for a specified duration at its discretion. [8] In 2023, FHFA decided that all proposed suspensions should be indefinite by default. [8] Counterparties can still seek reconsideration, and FHFA considers mitigating factors case by case. [8]

The discretionary “may”

The Banks asked that a written notice be mandatory whenever grounds exist. [1] FHFA declined. It said the decision to propose suspension is discretionary, and that the official may find grounds yet decide a proposal is not appropriate for other reasons. [1]

The three-year business requirement removed

The interim rule had required FHFA to show that a regulated entity had done business with the party during the past three years, as a condition of proposing or issuing a suspension. [1] The 2015 rule removed that requirement. [1] FHFA said suspension orders reflect a forward-looking determination that dealing with the party presents a safety and soundness risk. [1] That determination does not depend on whether a regulated entity recently transacted with the party. [1]

In our reading, the change let FHFA suspend a party before it reached any regulated entity, which makes the program preventive. It also widened FHFA’s workload, since referrals could now lead to suspensions of parties with no current relationship.

Where the program’s capacity sat

The rule placed every decision with FHFA. [2] The regulated entities reported, responded and complied. FHFA reviewed, proposed, decided and posted. In our reading, the rule assumed FHFA could process reports faster than the three-year window on covered misconduct closed. The rule sets no deadline for FHFA to act on a report before proposing a suspension. [2] Once a suspension is proposed, the rule gives the official 30 calendar days after the response deadline to decide on a final order, subject to its exceptions. [2] A final order takes effect at least 45 calendar days after it is signed. [2]

That assumption is what FHFA’s inspector general tested later. Its 2017 report found that from August 2012 through December 31, 2016, FHFA’s Office of General Counsel received 771 referrals and suspended 24 counterparties. [4] It found a backlog of 424 referrals as of December 31, 2016, the majority pending for a year or more. [4]

The reach: which relationships an order cuts off

Covered transactions

A suspension directs the regulated entities to cease or refrain from covered transactions with the respondent and its affiliates. [2] A covered transaction is a contract, agreement or financial or business relationship between a regulated entity and a person and its affiliates. [2]

Fannie Mae asked FHFA to limit the definition to contracts or agreements. [1] It worried that “financial or business relationships” could cover service providers with which it had an account but no contract. [1] FHFA kept the wording. [1] It said it intends the definition to reach parties that present a particular risk, while excluding generic third-party service providers only incidentally involved, such as mail and package delivery vendors. [1]

Limits, qualifications and exceptions

A suspension does not have to cut every tie at once. When responding to a proposed order, a regulated entity must identify any existing contract with the respondent for which it might request a limitation or qualification. [2] It may recommend alternatives to suspension that would reduce the risk. [2] After a final order, the rule provides for requests for an exception to engage in a particular covered transaction with the suspended person. [2]

In our reading, these provisions recognize that a counterparty may be embedded in operations. A servicer handling a large book of loans may not be replaceable quickly without disruption to borrowers and investors. The rule lets the regulated entity make that case on the record before the order becomes final.

Lower-tier parties

The interim rule’s notice had asked whether to cover lower-tier transactions, such as a subcontractor serving a direct counterparty. [1] The Banks and Fannie Mae both said they could not monitor such relationships. [1] FHFA said a regulated entity that bought a mortgage loan may be directly affected by fraud even where none of the parties has a direct relationship with it. [1] It nonetheless did not require reports on lower-tier transactions, or that direct counterparties stop dealing with suspended lower-tier parties. [1]

FHFA added an expectation. It said it expects the regulated entities to take all appropriate measures to address mortgage fraud risk, scaled to the nature of the relationship. [1] In our reading, lower-tier risk moved from the rule to supervision.

The respondent’s own home

The 2015 rule added one exclusion. A final suspension order has no effect on any transaction involving a residential mortgage loan secured by the respondent’s own personal or household residence. [1] FHFA said it did not intend orders to prevent respondents or their households from obtaining mortgage financing for their own homes. [1] The interim rule’s text had no such limit, so the change narrowed the orders’ reach. [1]

Publicity

Suspensions are public. FHFA maintains a list on its website of each person currently suspended under the program. [3] The list gives names, cities, states, effective dates and end dates, with links to the orders. [3] As checked on November 16, 2026, the page listed 288 items. [3]

How the program reached different organizations

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

The Enterprises bear the reporting duty and must comply with orders. [2] The Enterprises told FHFA’s inspector general that, as of December 31, 2016, they had almost 5,000 counterparty relationships. [4] Their counterparties include mortgage sellers and servicers. [4] For an Enterprise, a suspension order changes onboarding, loan acquisition and servicing transfers at once.

The Federal Home Loan Banks

The Banks’ counterparties include the financial institutions that borrow from them. [4] In 2015 the Banks raised the burden of monitoring affiliates and former counterparties. [1] FHFA said it considered the Banks’ cooperative structure and other statutory differences and decided not to treat them differently. [1]

A member bank or credit union

A bank or credit union that is a Home Loan Bank member, or that sells loans to the Enterprises, is a potential respondent. The imputation rules mean an employee’s conviction can reach the institution. [2] In our reading, such an institution should treat employee mortgage fraud as a risk to its access to wholesale funding and secondary markets, as well as a source of direct losses.

A smaller lender selling to the Enterprises

A community bank or credit union that sells loans to an Enterprise faces the same imputation rules as a large lender. [2] It may have fewer staff to document why an employee’s conduct fell outside his or her duties. The rule’s response process gives it at least 30 calendar days to answer a proposed suspension with specific facts. [2] An institution that keeps hiring records, supervision records and records of how it handled the misconduct when it surfaced can answer in that time. One that must reconstruct them may not.

An internal fraud unit

The program changes little about how a fraud unit investigates. It changes what happens after a court or agency acts. A fraud unit that refers a case to law enforcement may see a conviction years later. At that point the reporting clock starts for any regulated entity that becomes aware. [2]

For a regulated entity, the practical link is between the fraud unit’s case files and the counterparty register. When a case closes with a conviction or sanction, the unit should check whether the party, or a known affiliate, is a current or recent counterparty. [2] For a lender that is itself a counterparty, the same link protects it. If one of its employees is convicted, the lender will want its own account of the facts ready before FHFA considers imputation. [2]

A mortgage technology or services vendor

A vendor serving lenders but not contracting with an Enterprise is a lower-tier party. In 2015 FHFA did not require the regulated entities to police those relationships. [1] Lenders that rely on such vendors may still choose to screen them against FHFA’s list. FHFA said in 2015 that a regulated entity may still screen beyond what the program requires where it judges that prudent. [1]

Trade-offs the design created

Public listing and due process

Publishing suspensions gives every lender and vendor a way to check a counterparty. [3] It also attaches a public mark to a person or firm. The rule’s procedure answers part of that cost: notice, at least 30 calendar days to respond, a decision on a written record, an appeal and later reconsideration. [2] The rule also states that a suspension order is not intended to be, and may not be issued as, a form of punishment. [2]

In our reading, the public list does more than the rule says. A suspended party’s name on a federal agency’s website may affect its dealings with lenders outside the program. The rule’s statement about punishment describes FHFA’s purpose, not every effect.

Reliance on the list

A public list can become a substitute for diligence. FHFA warned against that in 2015. It said the program supplements the regulated entities’ own efforts and does not replace them. [1] The program also cannot see misconduct that has not yet produced a conviction or sanction. [2] An organization that screens only against FHFA’s list will miss parties under investigation, parties sued civilly and parties with findings outside the mortgage business.

The staff cost inside FHFA

The inspector general’s 2017 report described the program’s staffing. OGC had assigned an Associate General Counsel as program manager, supported by an administrative assistant. [4] The program manager said she devoted a large part of her time to the program. [4] The administrative assistant estimated spending 90 percent to 95 percent of her time supporting the program manager. [4]

Against that staffing, the program received 771 referrals from its start through 2016. [4] OGC’s 2012 enforcement manual had called for each referral to be resolved within 126 days, but OGC told the inspector general the manual no longer governed the program. [4] The inspector general found OGC had established no other timeline. [4]

The strongest objections

Objection one: reporting only what you know rewards not looking

FHFA’s answer was that looking is a supervisory expectation, not a program duty. [1] That answer depends on examination. An entity with weak screening may face criticism from FHFA examiners, but the program rule itself would not be breached. The objection has force. The rule’s design trusts supervision to fill the gap it leaves.

Objection two: the harm standard is too vague

The standard asked whether misconduct was of a type likely to cause significant financial or reputational harm. [2] “Reputational” is hard to measure. FHFA itself later proposed removing it. [7] Its 2026 proposal gave two reasons: removing a redundancy, and basing counterparty supervision on material and measurable risks. [7]

Objection three: suspension duplicates debarment

Administrative sanctions are already debarments or similar actions by other agencies. [2] Suspending a debarred party adds little if the regulated entities already screen debarment lists. The answer is reach. The administrative sanctions the rule counts are actions that limit a person’s ability to do business with a federal agency. [2] An FHFA suspension instead directs Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the Banks, across all their covered transactions. [2] The program also captures convictions that may not have produced a debarment.

Objection four: the program is too small to matter

Of the 738 referrals the inspector general analyzed through 2016, FHFA had reached a determination on 289: it suspended counterparties in 24 and declined to suspend in 265. [4] A skeptic would say a program that suspends so few parties cannot change the system’s risk.

The numbers support caution about the program’s reach, not its value. In our reading, a suspension list works as a deterrent and a signal as well as a block. Each suspension applies across Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and every Bank at once. [2] The program also sits beside the regulated entities’ own counterparty programs, which FHFA said it supplements. [1] Its role was narrow by design. [1]

What a third-party risk manager would check

These checks are good practice, not requirements of the rule. Organizations should check with counsel on what applies to them.

  • Does onboarding for vendors that touch loans sold to the Enterprises, or pledged to a Home Loan Bank, include a check of FHFA’s public suspension list?
  • Is there a named owner for reporting duties that are triggered by knowledge, and a separate owner for proactive screening?
  • Can the organization list its counterparties of the past three years, with known affiliates, on demand?
  • Is the age of each open third-party review item tracked, with escalation before deadlines that cannot be extended?
  • If the organization is itself a counterparty, does it have evidence that employee misconduct was outside the employee’s duties and not tolerated?

Why the bottleneck was the regulator’s queue

The 2015 rule made the regulated entities’ duties clearer and somewhat lighter. They got 30 calendar days instead of ten business days. [1] They kept no duty to investigate. [1] FHFA took on a broader power to suspend parties with no recent dealings. [1]

That design put the program’s capacity in one office. FHFA’s inspector general found in 2017 that the office had a backlog of 424 referrals at the end of 2016. [4] It found five instances in which referrals were not resolved within three years of the covered misconduct, which precluded the suspending official from deciding whether to suspend. [4] In our view, the lesson for any third-party program is that a reporting rule is only as fast as the review behind it. A short reporting clock means little if the queue it feeds has no clock.

With hindsight

FHFA’s inspector general examined the program in July 2017. [4] It found that the Office of General Counsel had a backlog of 424 referrals as of December 31, 2016, the majority pending a year or more. [4] It found five instances in which unresolved referrals passed the three-year period after a finding of covered misconduct, which precluded the suspending official from deciding whether to suspend. [4] It recommended a plan with a timeline to reduce the backlog, and FHFA accepted. [4]

The follow-up did not go smoothly. A 2021 compliance review said a 2019 review had found the agreed timeliness standards were never implemented, so the recommendation was reopened. [5] OGC then adopted a standard of sending referrals to the regulated entities within “approximately” 90 days of receipt. [5] The 2021 review found OGC did not track whether it met that standard. [5] Because effective timeliness standards were not implemented as found in two consecutive reviews, the inspector general closed the 2017 recommendation as rejected. [5] OGC disagreed with certain conclusions. [5]

By 2026 the picture had changed. An audit dated September 29, 2026 covered calendar year 2025. [8] It found that OGC provided sufficient oversight of the program and generally designed and implemented controls consistent with 12 CFR Part 1227. [8] It found that certain controls were not written into OGC’s operating procedures, including quality checks for completeness and procedures for appeals. [8] FHFA agreed with its two recommendations. [8]

The 2026 audit also described the program’s later practice. FHFA signed 17 final suspension orders in calendar year 2025. [8] In 2023, FHFA decided that all proposed suspensions should be indefinite by default, while counterparties can still seek reconsideration. [8] OGC guidance aims for a proposed suspension or a decision not to suspend within one year of receiving a referral. [8] The audit said final suspensions become effective no sooner than 45 calendar days after the suspending official’s signature. [8]

The rule text has stayed as amended in 2015. As checked on November 16, 2026, the current text of Part 1227 shows the 2015 amendments and no later ones. [2] FHFA proposed expanding covered misconduct to certain civil enforcement sanctions in July 2023. [6] It published a second proposal on October 1, 2024, saying material changes were needed after reviewing comments. [6] Neither appears in the current text. [2]

On July 13, 2026, FHFA proposed removing “reputational harm” from the suspension standard. [7] The proposal cited Executive Order 14331, which it said directed federal banking regulators to remove reputation risk from their materials. [7] It said FHFA is not a federal banking regulator under that order but was aligning with other financial regulators. [7] Comments were due by August 12, 2026. [7] As checked on November 16, 2026, the change does not appear in the current regulation. [2]

What held up from 2015 is the division of labor. The regulated entities still report what they become aware of within 30 calendar days. [2] FHFA still decides. [2] What changed is that the deciding office, after two critical reviews, was found in 2026 to be overseeing the work sufficiently. [5] [8]

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • FHFA
  • Suspended Counterparty Program
  • third-party risk
  • mortgage fraud
  • Federal Home Loan Banks
  • Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac