Medicare’s 2015 equipment prior authorization rule moved the documentation check to before delivery

CMS’s December 30, 2015 rule made a provisional affirmation a condition of payment for listed items. Citing 2014 data tying 92 percent of equipment improper payments to insufficient documentation, CMS moved the documentation review before delivery, in our reading onto suppliers’ and prescribers’ intake work.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

CMS’s December 30, 2015 rule made a provisional affirmation a condition of payment for listed items. Citing 2014 data tying 92 percent of equipment improper payments to insufficient documentation, CMS moved the documentation review before delivery, in our reading onto suppliers’ and prescribers’ intake work.

  1. The week The item also had to meet one of two further criteria.
  2. The list: which items need prior authorization The rule created a two-stage list.
  3. The request: what must be assembled before delivery The current rule spells out what a request must contain.
  4. The decision: what a review produces “Provisional” is accurate.
  5. The release valves: how CMS can narrow, pause or exempt The authority answered commenters who asked CMS to stop the program if patient access was jeopardized. [1] It also gave CMS a way to correct mistakes without the time a rule change takes.
  6. How the rule reached different organizations The supplier bears the request.
  7. Second-order effects CMS agreed with commenters that prior authorization may reduce a supplier’s need to use the appeals process. [1] The mechanism was the unlimited resubmission. [1] In our reading, the effect on the appeals system depended on suppliers choosing to resubmit rather than deliver and appeal.
  8. The strongest objections The objection is serious.
  9. What an operations leader would check These checks are good practice, not requirements of the rule.
  10. Why the rule was an operations change The rule’s own data framed the problem as documentation. [1] Its own process changed when documentation was checked. [1] Its own estimates counted the cost in staff hours for preparing submissions. [1] In our view, an organization that treated the rule as a billing change missed where the work went.
  11. With hindsight CMS started the program with two items.

The week

On Wednesday, December 30, 2015, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services published a final rule in the Federal Register. [1] Its title was Medicare Program; Prior Authorization Process for Certain Durable Medical Equipment, Prosthetics, Orthotics, and Supplies. [1] It carried the number CMS-6050-F and took effect on February 29, 2016. [1] It was dated by the Acting Administrator of CMS on November 2, 2015, and by the Secretary of Health and Human Services on November 20, 2015. [1]

The rule implemented section 1834(a)(15) of the Social Security Act. [1] That provision authorizes the Secretary to develop and periodically update a list of equipment and supplies that, on the basis of prior payment experience, are frequently subject to unnecessary utilization. [1] It also authorizes a prior authorization process for those items. [1] CMS had proposed the rule on May 28, 2014. [1]

The rule defined unnecessary utilization as furnishing items that do not comply with one or more of Medicare’s coverage, coding and payment rules. [1] It created a Master List of items potentially subject to prior authorization. [1] An item qualified if it appeared on the equipment fee schedule and had an average purchase fee of $1,000 or more, or an average monthly rental fee of $100 or more, adjusted annually for inflation. [1]

The item also had to meet one of two further criteria. It could appear in a GAO or HHS Office of Inspector General report, national in scope and published in 2007 or later, as having a high rate of fraud or unnecessary utilization. [1] Or it could be listed in a 2011 or later report of Medicare’s Comprehensive Error Rate Testing program on equipment improper payments. [1]

The Master List was self-updating annually. [1] Items stayed on it for 10 years from the date they were added, unless their price fell below the threshold or their codes were discontinued. [1] CMS said it would notify the public annually of additions and deletions in the Federal Register and on its website. [1] The rule put the total number of items on the Master List at 135. [1]

Being on the Master List did not by itself require prior authorization. [1] CMS said it would initially apply prior authorization to a subset, called the Required Prior Authorization List. [1] It said it would publish that list in the Federal Register with 60-day notice before implementation. [1] It also said it could limit the requirement to a particular region if claims data showed unnecessary utilization concentrated there. [1]

The rule set the process. Before furnishing the item and before submitting a claim, a requester must submit evidence that the item complies with Medicare’s coverage, coding and payment rules. [1] CMS or a review contractor then conducts a medical review and provisionally affirms or non-affirms the request. [1] A provisional affirmation is a condition of payment. [1] A claim for a listed item submitted without one is automatically denied. [1]

CMS also made the prior authorization decision unappealable. It added the contractor’s prior authorization determination to the list of actions that are not initial determinations. [1] CMS said a requester could resubmit a request an unlimited number of times. [1] A requester who submitted a claim after a non-affirmation, or without requesting prior authorization, would have full appeal rights on the resulting claim denial. [1]

CMS gave its reason in numbers from its own measurement program. It said that for the 2014 reporting period, approximately $5.1 billion was improperly paid for equipment items, a 53.1 percent improper payment rate. [1] It said 92 percent of equipment improper payments were due to insufficient documentation. [1]

CMS estimated the overall economic cost at approximately $1.3 million in the first year. [1] It put the five-year cost at approximately $57 million and the ten-year cost at approximately $212 million, driven mostly by more items being subjected to prior authorization after the first year. [1] It estimated savings, net of premium offsets, of $10 million in 2016, potentially rising to between $10 million and $110 million in 2025. [1]

The 2015 rule described the usual path for an equipment claim. A supplier delivered a wheelchair or a brace, billed the Medicare Administrative Contractor and was paid, unless the claim was picked for pre- or post-payment review. [1] If a claim was denied, the supplier or beneficiary could appeal. [1] The December 2015 rule changed the order of work for listed items. The documentation review would happen before the item left the supplier’s hands. [1]

Our argument is that the rule was an operations change more than a payment change. CMS said 92 percent of equipment improper payments in its 2014 measurement were due to insufficient documentation. [1] CMS said documentation requirements for listed items remained unchanged. [1] The rule changed when the documentation had to exist and who had to assemble it. [1] In our reading, that moved work to the front of the process, into supplier intake teams and prescribers’ offices, and away from audits and appeals.

The rule’s design can be read in four parts:

  1. The list: which items are subject to prior authorization, and how they get there.
  2. The request: what must be assembled before delivery, and by whom.
  3. The decision: what a review produces, and what happens after a non-affirmation.
  4. The release valves: how CMS can narrow, pause or exempt the requirement.

The parts do not overlap. The first decides scope, the second inputs, the third outputs and the fourth the controls on the whole process. After them we look at how the rule reached different kinds of organization and at its second-order effects, take the objections and end with checks for an operations leader.

The list: which items need prior authorization

Two lists, not one

The rule created a two-stage list. The Master List was a pool of items meeting price and risk criteria. [1] The Required Prior Authorization List was the subset CMS chose to subject to the requirement. [1] Only items on the second list needed a provisional affirmation to be paid. [1]

The split let CMS move gradually. It said implementing prior authorization for all 135 Master List items at once would affect 10 million beneficiaries and potentially 90,000 suppliers, using 2014 data. [1] It said an impact of that size would leave the equipment community little time to change its business practices. [1]

The price threshold

The $1,000 purchase and $100 monthly rental thresholds focused the list on costlier items. [1] CMS said the threshold would let it focus limited resources on items with the largest potential savings. [1] It also said a change to the threshold base, as opposed to the annual inflation adjustment, would require new rulemaking. [1]

Commenters argued that some items in competitive bidding areas, and in some large states, fell under the $100 rental threshold. [1] CMS said it had not used particular geographic areas. It averaged fees across all states on the fee schedule. [1] It noted that a threshold of several thousand dollars would miss items with high improper payments, such as continuous positive airway pressure devices. [1]

The risk criteria

The second gate was evidence of a problem. An item had to appear in a national GAO or OIG report from 2007 on, or in a 2011 or later error rate report. [1] Some commenters called the OIG and GAO reports arbitrary as inclusion criteria. [1] CMS kept them. [1]

The list also changed with the evidence. Items already on the list that appeared in a new report would remain for 10 years from the new report’s publication. [1] Items that aged off could be added back if a later report identified them again. [1]

The demonstration that came before

CMS did not start from nothing. The rule pointed to the Medicare Prior Authorization of Power Mobility Devices Demonstration, which began in 2012. [1] It was first implemented in California, Illinois, Michigan, New York, North Carolina, Florida and Texas. [1] CMS expanded it to 12 more states on October 1, 2014, and on July 15, 2015 extended it for all 19 states until August 31, 2018. [1]

CMS reported falling spending. Based on claims processed from September 1, 2012 through November 14, 2014, monthly expenditures for the demonstration’s codes fell from $12 million to $3 million in the demonstration states. [1] In non-demonstration states they fell from $20 million in September 2012 to $6 million in June 2014. [1] CMS suggested suppliers may have adjusted billing nationwide, not in demonstration states alone. [1] It said it was not aware of access issues or barriers to care created by the demonstration’s process. [1]

In our reading, the demonstration was the rule’s operational pilot. It showed CMS that suppliers could run a pre-delivery review at scale. It also showed that the effect could spread beyond the places where the requirement applied. That is a reason the 2015 rule could start small.

Why price and risk criteria work together

The two gates screen for different things. The price threshold asks whether a wrong payment would be large. The report criteria ask whether wrong payments have been documented. [1] A costly item without documented payment errors does not qualify. A cheap item with documented errors does not either. [1]

For an operations leader, the criteria are a forecast. If an item the organization supplies or orders appears in a new national OIG or GAO report on improper payments, and meets the price test, it will join the Master List. [1] Joining the Master List is a warning, not a requirement. It signals that the item could move to the Required List with a Federal Register notice.

Notice before the requirement starts

CMS said it would publish the Required Prior Authorization List in the Federal Register with 60-day notice. [1] Some suppliers said they needed more than 60 days. [1] CMS said it would communicate before the formal notice through calls and contractor webinars. [1]

For a supplier, the Federal Register notice was the operational trigger. From it, the supplier had to retrain intake staff, change order forms and adjust delivery scheduling for the listed codes. In our reading, the 60-day period was the planning budget for all of that.

Who chose the items

The rule left the choice of Required List items to CMS. [1] Commenters asked to exempt items for chronic or lifelong conditions, such as lower-limb prosthetics. [1] CMS disagreed. It said most Master List items are used for chronic or lifelong conditions and that documentation requirements for them remained unchanged. [1]

CMS answered the prosthetics concerns at length. It said longstanding documentation requirements based on the functional levels its coding contractor had developed would apply to prior authorization too. [1] It rejected a suggestion to have a private insurance company process prior authorizations for those items. [1] It said any entity working for the government must follow Medicare’s coverage, coding and payment rules. [1] It said beneficiaries’ costs for those prosthetics should not change because of prior authorization. [1] In our reading, the message for a prosthetics practice was that the documentation standard stayed the same and only its timing moved.

The request: what must be assembled before delivery

The contents of a request

The current rule spells out what a request must contain. It must include all relevant documentation to show that the item meets Medicare’s coverage, coding and payment rules. [5] That includes the written order or prescription, relevant information from the beneficiary’s medical record and relevant supplier-produced documentation. [5] It must be submitted before the item is furnished and before the claim is submitted. [5]

The 2016 notice that started the program said the same. Evidence must include the order, relevant information from the beneficiary’s medical record and relevant supplier-produced documentation. [2]

Where each piece comes from

The three pieces come from different places. The order comes from the physician or other treating practitioner. The medical record is held by the prescriber’s practice or a hospital. The supplier documents come from the supplier. [5] In our reading, a prior authorization request is an assembly job across organizations. The supplier submits it, but depends on others for most of its contents.

That dependency is the operational core of the rule. A supplier with excellent intake staff cannot submit a complete request if the prescriber’s note lacks a required element. A prescriber’s office that writes complete notes cannot help if the supplier submits the wrong pages. The rule’s benefit depends on both doing their part before delivery.

The time each request takes

CMS estimated the private sector’s time burden for a request. It said the time to submit documentation and do related clerical work was equivalent to that for prepayment review, 0.5 hours per submission. [1] It applied that estimate to initial submissions, resubmissions and expedited requests. [1]

CMS’s high estimate was 11,250 hours in the first year and 112,500 hours per year in years two and three. [1] Those totals rested on its high estimates of 22,500 and 225,000 affected cases. [1] In our reading, the figures show that CMS expected volume to rise sharply after the first year, as more items moved onto the Required List.

Who did the work before the rule

Before prior authorization, the same documents mattered, but later. Medicare paid for equipment only if the medical record supported the need for the type and quantity of items ordered. [1] The supplier had to keep proof of delivery. [1] Gaps surfaced, if at all, when a claim was selected for review or audited after payment. [1]

The rule moved the moment of truth. The documentation had to be complete before the supplier delivered, or the supplier risked furnishing an item it would not be paid for. [1] In our reading, the workforce effect was a shift from back-office appeals staff to front-office intake staff, and from after-the-fact record requests to before-the-fact order quality.

Designing the order template

One fix comes upstream. If an order template for a listed item prompts the prescriber for each element the coverage rules require, fewer requests will fail. The rule did not require templates. It made their absence costly, because an incomplete request delays delivery. [1] [5]

A template has limits. It cannot create clinical facts that are not in the record. It can make sure that facts which are present are written down where the reviewer will find them. For a health system, building those prompts into the electronic health record’s ordering screens is a joint project between clinical informatics and the supplier relationship team.

Measuring the intake process

The rule did not set performance measures for suppliers. An operations leader running the process would want a few anyway. The first is the share of requests affirmed on first submission. The second is the number of resubmissions per affirmed item. The third is the time from order to decision, and from decision to delivery.

Those measures point to different fixes. A low first-pass rate points to templates and intake checks. A high resubmission count points to a specific missing element. Long times from order to decision point to staffing or to delays in getting records from prescribers. In our reading, the same measures later mattered for the supplier exemption, which turns on a payable-claims rate. [5]

Beneficiary notice and liability

Commenters asked how the Advance Beneficiary Notice of Non-coverage process would interact with prior authorization. [1] Some recommended making the beneficiary liable if a supplier failed to obtain prior authorization. [1] CMS said beneficiaries would benefit from knowing in advance whether they would incur financial liability for non-covered items. [1] For a supplier, that made the timing of the patient conversation part of the workflow: before delivery, once the review outcome was known.

The decision: what a review produces

Provisional affirmation and non-affirmation

After receiving a complete request, CMS or its contractor reviews it for compliance with coverage, coding and payment rules. [5] If the rules are met, it issues a provisional affirmation. [5] If not, it issues a non-affirmation. [5] A provisional affirmation is a preliminary finding that a future claim meets Medicare’s rules. [5]

“Provisional” is accurate. A claim with a provisional affirmation may still be denied for technical requirements that can be evaluated only after the claim is submitted, or for information not available at the time of the request. [5] CMS gave proof of delivery as an example of a requirement that can only be evaluated after submission. [1]

No appeal of the decision, unlimited resubmissions

A prior authorization decision is not an initial determination and is not appealable. [1] CMS said a prior authorization decision is not a payment decision. [1] The remedy for a non-affirmation is to fix the request and resubmit. [5] CMS allowed resubmission an unlimited number of times. [1]

CMS said unlimited resubmission gives requesters multiple chances to understand documentation requirements and correct omissions before a claim is submitted. [1] It agreed with commenters that the process was less burdensome than preparing an appeal. [1] A supplier that delivers anyway after a non-affirmation, or without requesting review, keeps full appeal rights on the resulting claim denial. [1]

In our reading, the design converts a legal process into an operational one. An appeal involves deadlines, levels of review and records requests. A resubmission involves fixing a document and sending it again. The cost moves from legal and appeals staff to the people who prepare requests.

Timeframes left to guidance

CMS had proposed to make reasonable efforts to communicate a decision within 10 days of receiving all applicable information. [1] In the final rule, it said a 10-business-day timeline for an initial decision might create access barriers. [1] It did not finalize the proposed timelines. [1] It said it would set them in subregulatory guidance, which allows greater flexibility if modifications are warranted. [1]

The rule kept an expedited path. A request for expedited review must show that the standard timeline could seriously jeopardize the beneficiary’s life or health, or ability to regain maximum function. [5] If CMS or its contractor agrees, it expedites the review. [5] The proposed rule had described a 2-business-day effort for expedited decisions. [1]

For an operations leader, leaving timelines to guidance has two sides, one favoring flexibility and one adding uncertainty. CMS can shorten or lengthen them without rulemaking. The supplier cannot rely on a regulatory deadline when planning delivery dates. The supplier’s scheduling must follow whatever guidance is current.

Reading a non-affirmation

A non-affirmation says that the coverage, coding or payment rules were not met on the documents submitted. [5] It does not say the patient lacks a need. The supplier’s next step is to find what was missing and resubmit before furnishing the item. [5]

That step needs a feedback loop. If the same element is missing in many requests, the fix belongs in the order template or the intake checklist, not in each case. A supplier that resubmits case by case without changing its process will keep paying the same half hour per request that CMS estimated. [1]

Who owns the clock

From the patient’s side, the time that matters runs from the order to the delivery. The rule inserted a review into that span. [1] Its length depends on how fast the supplier assembles the request, how fast the contractor decides and how many resubmissions follow. [1] [5]

No single party owns that whole span. The prescriber controls the record, the supplier controls the submission and the contractor controls the decision. In our reading, the process works better with one named coordinator, for example at the supplier, who tracks each pending item and tells the patient and prescriber where it stands.

Some protection from audits

CMS said claims with a provisional affirmation would receive some protection from future pre- and post-payment audits. [1] Review contractors could still audit them if they identified potential fraud, inappropriate utilization or changes in billing patterns. [1] Claims could also fall within the random sample used to measure improper payments, where they would not be protected. [1]

In our reading, that partial protection is the payoff the rule offered for front-loading the work. A supplier that completes the documentation before delivery should face fewer audit requests later. The protection is real, but it is not a safe harbor.

The release valves: how CMS can narrow, pause or exempt

Suspension without rulemaking

The rule gave CMS authority to suspend prior authorization generally or for particular items at any time, without rulemaking. [1] It must notify the public in the Federal Register and on its prior authorization website. [1] CMS described this as a way to halt the program, or an item, quickly if problems arose. [1]

The authority answered commenters who asked CMS to stop the program if patient access was jeopardized. [1] It also gave CMS a way to correct mistakes without the time a rule change takes.

Regional limits

CMS may limit the requirement to a particular region if claims data show unnecessary utilization concentrated there. [5] The current rule also lets CMS consider factors such as geographic location, item utilization or cost, system capabilities, emerging trends and vulnerabilities in official agency reports when choosing items. [5]

Supplier exemptions in the current text

The current rule contains a release valve not found in the 2015 text. CMS may exempt suppliers from prior authorization if they show compliance through the process. [5] An exemption is provided for a supplier that achieves a payable-claims rate of at least 90 percent during an initial or periodic review. [5] It is withdrawn if the rate of non-payable claims becomes higher than 10 percent on a periodic assessment. [5] CMS gives at least 60 days’ notice of an exemption or withdrawal. [5]

In our reading, the exemption rewards exactly the front-end work the 2015 rule demanded. A supplier that consistently submits complete documentation can earn its way out of the requirement. One that slips can earn its way back in.

How the valves met the field

The 2022 suspension showed how narrowly the valves can be cut. CMS suspended prior authorization only for listed orthoses codes billed with a modifier showing urgent furnishing. [3] It also covered certain orthoses furnished under a competitive bidding exception, billed with specific modifiers. [3] Those were cases where a physician or practitioner determined during an office visit that the brace was needed immediately, or a therapist furnished it during a therapy session. [3]

For a supplier or a clinic, that narrowness has a cost. Staff must know which codes and which modifiers qualify. Billing must apply the modifier only where the facts support it. The suspension relieved one workflow by adding a rule to another.

Why the valves matter to the argument

The release valves show that CMS treated prior authorization as an operational control to be tuned. It could add items, limit regions, pause items and exempt good performers. [1] [5] None of those changes required a new rule. That flexibility is the counterpart of the rule’s main move. If work is shifted to the front of the process, the regulator needs ways to relieve it where it causes harm.

How the rule reached different organizations

An equipment supplier

The supplier bears the request. It must collect the order, the medical record excerpts and its own documents, submit them and manage resubmissions. [5] Its intake, scheduling and billing staff all change roles. Intake staff become document reviewers. Schedulers wait for a review outcome before delivery. Billing staff see fewer denials and appeals on affirmed claims, if the process works.

The 2015 rule’s numbers give a sense of scale. CMS said beneficiaries used approximately 90,000 suppliers in 2014. [1] Each supplier dealing in a listed item would need the new workflow.

A physician practice or hospital that orders equipment

Prescribers are not the requester, but their records are the core of the request. [5] A practice that orders power wheelchairs or orthoses must document the clinical basis in a way that meets the coverage rules for that item. When the documentation is incomplete, the supplier will ask for more before it can deliver. In our reading, a health system’s ordering workflow becomes part of the supplier’s prior authorization performance.

A health system with its own equipment supplier

A health system that owns an equipment supplier is in a different position. For it, the prescriber and the supplier sit inside one organization. That can make the assembly job easier, since records and orders share systems. It also puts the whole workflow, and its failures, inside one compliance program.

A home health agency

Medicare’s definition of durable medical equipment includes equipment furnished by a supplier or a home health agency. [1] A home health agency that furnishes a listed item faces the same request and decision process. For an agency, the documentation may be held by the clinicians who visit the patient at home. The agency must route it to whoever prepares the request before the item is furnished.

A small or rural supplier

A small supplier has fewer staff to absorb the intake work. CMS’s estimate of half an hour per submission applies to large and small suppliers alike. [1] For a small supplier, one staff member may handle intake, scheduling and billing. Resubmissions compete with deliveries for that person’s time. In our reading, the exemption added later favors suppliers whose processes are mature, which may be harder for small suppliers to reach. [5]

A Medicare contractor

The review work moved too. CMS or its review contractors conduct the medical review of each request. [1] CMS’s cost estimate counted an increase in Medicare spending to conduct reviews, alongside private-sector paperwork costs. [1] A contractor’s staffing, its turnaround times and the quality of its non-affirmation explanations shape the supplier’s experience. Because timeframes were left to guidance, a contractor’s capacity and CMS’s guidance together decide how long suppliers wait. [1]

A Medicare Advantage plan or other payer

The 2015 rule applied to Medicare fee-for-service claims for listed items. [1] It did not set rules for other payers. Organizations that also deal with commercial or Medicare Advantage prior authorization would run two or more processes with different rules. In our reading, that adds training and systems work.

The beneficiary

CMS argued beneficiaries would benefit by knowing before delivery whether an item would be covered. [1] Commenters worried about delays and access. [1] The expedited path and the suspension authority were CMS’s answers. [1] [5]

Second-order effects

Fewer appeals, more resubmissions

CMS agreed with commenters that prior authorization may reduce a supplier’s need to use the appeals process. [1] The mechanism was the unlimited resubmission. [1] In our reading, the effect on the appeals system depended on suppliers choosing to resubmit rather than deliver and appeal. A supplier that delivers without an affirmation keeps its appeal rights, but takes the payment risk. [1]

Pressure on supplier choice

Commenters raised a concern about access through suppliers. They worried that the payment threshold could lead suppliers to deny Medicare beneficiaries their supplies. [1] CMS disagreed. It said the payment threshold does not establish a new price but sets the criteria to start a prior authorization process. [1] The final rule also let CMS suspend the requirement at any time without rulemaking. [1]

We think the concern points to a real choice for suppliers. A supplier facing new intake work for a listed item can absorb it, pass the work to prescribers or stop supplying the item to Medicare patients. The rule could not prevent the third choice. Its tools were speed, expedited review and suspension. [1] [5]

Documentation versus fraud

CMS noted that not all improper payments are fraudulent. [1] The rule’s target was documentation. A supplier committing fraud with fabricated records could still submit a complete-looking request. CMS kept review contractors’ ability to audit affirmed claims where they identified potential fraud or changes in billing patterns. [1] In our reading, prior authorization narrowed one kind of error and left fraud detection to other tools.

Pressure on prescribers

The rule did not name prescribers as requesters. [5] It still changed their workload. A supplier needing a missing element will ask the prescriber’s office for it before delivery. A practice that orders listed items for many patients may receive repeated requests. In our reading, a practice that treats equipment orders as a documentation task at the point of ordering reduces those later requests.

The strongest objections

Objection one: prior authorization delays care

The objection is serious. CMS itself declined to finalize its proposed 10-business-day timeline because it might create access barriers. [1] Later, CMS suspended prior authorization for certain orthoses furnished urgently, because the 2-day expedited review would delay care and risk the beneficiary’s health or life. [3]

The answer is that the rule built in ways to respond. The suspension authority let CMS act quickly in 2022, without rulemaking. [3] [5] The objection still holds where the valves are slow to open. An operations leader should assume that urgent cases need their own path and evidence.

Objection two: the rule shifts cost to suppliers and prescribers without paying for it

CMS’s estimates treated request preparation as a private-sector cost. [1] The rule’s cost estimates counted that work as a burden on suppliers and other requesters. [1] The objection has force. CMS’s answer was that prior authorization is less burdensome than preparing appeals and offers some protection from later audits. [1] Whether that trade benefits a given supplier depends on how many of its claims were denied and appealed before.

Objection three: documentation is not the same as necessity

Prior authorization tests whether the record supports the item. [1] A well-documented but unnecessary item may pass. A necessary item with a thin record may fail. CMS’s own figures concerned insufficient documentation, not proven lack of need. [1] The objection identifies the limit of the tool. Prior authorization enforces Medicare’s documentation rules. It does not by itself establish clinical judgment.

Objection four: the list only grows

The record supports the concern. The thresholds fell from $1,000 and $100 to $500 and $50, before inflation adjustments. [1] [5] The criteria now include items with aberrant billing patterns and items accounting for at least 1.5 percent of equipment spending. [5] The Required List grew from two codes to 74 items. [2] [4]

The answer is that growth came with relief. CMS added a supplier exemption for high payable-claims rates. [5] It suspended items where urgent care was at risk. [3] Items still age off the Master List after 10 years unless a recent report keeps them on. [5] An operations leader should plan for growth and for the exemption at the same time.

What an operations leader would check

These checks are good practice, not requirements of the rule. Organizations should check with counsel and current CMS guidance on what applies to them.

  • Does the order template for each listed item prompt for every element the coverage rules require?
  • Is there a named owner, at the supplier and at the ordering practice, for missing documentation requests?
  • Are non-affirmations tracked by reason, with fixes made to templates rather than to individual requests?
  • Is there an urgent path, with a record of why each urgent case qualified?
  • Does the organization follow Federal Register notices on the lists, given the 60-day notice period?

Evidence a compliance officer would keep

A supplier’s compliance file for each listed item would hold the request as submitted, the decision and any resubmissions. It would show the dates of each, so the sequence before delivery is clear. [5] It would hold proof of delivery, since that is a requirement checked only after the claim is submitted. [1]

For urgent cases under the 2022 suspension, the file would show why the case qualified: the code, the modifier and the clinical reason the item was needed immediately. [3] For a supplier with an exemption, the file would include CMS’s notice of exemption and the periodic results that keep it. [5]

Why the rule was an operations change

The rule’s own data framed the problem as documentation. [1] Its own process changed when documentation was checked. [1] Its own estimates counted the cost in staff hours for preparing submissions. [1] In our view, an organization that treated the rule as a billing change missed where the work went. The work went to intake desks, order templates and the handoff between prescriber and supplier. Budgets, staffing plans and performance measures for those functions are where the rule’s effects would show up first. An organization that measured only denial rates would see the result late, after the front-end work had already succeeded or failed.

With hindsight

CMS started the program with two items. A notice published on December 21, 2016 added two power wheelchair codes, K0856 and K0861, to the Required Prior Authorization List. [2] It noted that these Group 3 power wheelchairs were not part of the separate power mobility device demonstration. [2]

The rollout came in two phases. Phase one, effective March 20, 2017, limited the requirement to Illinois, Missouri, New York and West Virginia, one state in each equipment contractor jurisdiction. [2] Phase two, effective July 17, 2017, expanded it to the remaining states. [2] CMS said the phasing was to test new claims processing systems on a smaller volume first. [2] It gave 90 days’ notice, more than the 60 days the 2015 rule had said it would give. [1] [2]

The list structure changed in 2019. A 2026 notice recounted that a final rule published November 8, 2019, effective January 1, 2020, harmonized earlier lists into one Master List. [4] That list covers items potentially subject to face-to-face encounter and written order prior to delivery requirements, prior authorization or both. [4]

CMS used the suspension authority. In April 2022 it suspended prior authorization indefinitely for specified orthoses in limited circumstances. [3] The covered cases were items furnished urgently, or furnished by a practitioner or therapist who determined the brace was needed immediately. [3] CMS said the 2-day expedited review would delay care and risk the life or health of the beneficiary in those cases. [3] Prior authorization continued for those items in other circumstances. [3]

The thresholds fell. The current rule sets the Master List threshold at an average purchase fee of $500 or an average monthly rental of $50, adjusted annually. [5] It also includes items accounting for at least 1.5 percent of Medicare equipment expenditures, and items with aberrant billing patterns. [5] For calendar year 2026, CMS put the adjusted thresholds at $614 and $62. [4]

The lists grew. The July 30, 2026 notice said the Master List, as last updated in January 2026, included 530 items. [4] It said the Required Prior Authorization List included 74 items. [4] It added 20 codes to the Master List and selected eight more codes for the Required Prior Authorization List: a pressure reducing support surface, a manual wheelchair and six orthoses. [4] It scheduled prior authorization for upper limb orthoses in three phases, effective October 28, 2026, January 26, 2027 and April 26, 2027. [4]

The required list itself expanded after the 2019 rule. The 2022 suspension notice recounted that a January 13, 2022 Federal Register document selected certain lower limb orthoses, lumbar sacral orthoses and power mobility devices for required prior authorization. [3] That document was effective April 13, 2022. [3]

The current rule also contains the supplier exemption for a payable-claims rate of at least 90 percent. [5] The section’s history line cites the 2015 rule and amendments in 2019 and 2025. [5]

What held up is the rule’s core move. Documentation is still checked before delivery for listed items, and a provisional affirmation is still a condition of payment. [5] What changed is scale and tuning. The program grew from two codes in 2017 to 74 items on the required list by 2026. [2] [4] CMS also added suspensions and exemptions to manage the work that moved to the front of the process. [3] [5]

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • Medicare
  • prior authorization
  • DMEPOS
  • improper payments
  • condition of payment
  • CMS