The 2017 health choice order set three coverage rulemakings in motion and decided none of them
Executive Order 13813, signed October 12, 2017, told agencies to consider rules on association plans, short-term policies and reimbursement arrangements. In our reading, health systems could plan only from the later rules, which took three different paths.
Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.
Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article
Executive Order 13813, signed October 12, 2017, told agencies to consider rules on association plans, short-term policies and reimbursement arrangements. In our reading, health systems could plan only from the later rules, which took three different paths.
- The week On Thursday, October 12, 2017, the President signed Executive Order 13813, Promoting Healthcare Choice and Competition Across the United States.
- Pooled employer coverage: association health plans and small employers The order asked the Secretary of Labor to consider letting more employers form association health plans.
- Coverage outside the federal individual market rules: short-term, limited-duration insurance The order asked the three departments to consider expanding short-term, limited-duration insurance.
- Employer money for individual coverage: health reimbursement arrangements The order asked the three departments to consider increasing the usability of health reimbursement arrangements.
- The rules of the provider market: the competition clause and the report it ordered Section 1(c) went beyond insurance products.
- How the order reached different organizations The order’s reach varied by the role each organization plays in buying or providing care.
- Objections, in order The argument that the order set three rulemakings in motion and decided none of them faces objections.
- What a health system finance or benefits leader could check Each product the order named has been the subject of federal rules since 2017.
- With hindsight Each of the three rulemakings produced a final rule, and each then took its own course.
The week
On Thursday, October 12, 2017, the President signed Executive Order 13813, Promoting Healthcare Choice and Competition Across the United States. The White House published the text that day. The order did not change any coverage rule by itself. It directed three departments to consider proposing regulations or revising guidance, and set deadlines for them to do so.
Section 1 stated the policy. The executive branch would, to the extent consistent with law, facilitate the purchase of insurance across state lines and a healthcare system with high-quality care at affordable prices. The order criticized the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. It asserted that the law had limited choice and produced large premium increases in many state individual markets.
The order named three priorities for the near term. They were association health plans, short-term, limited-duration insurance, and health reimbursement arrangements. It described each. Association health plans could let small businesses group together to self-insure or buy large group coverage. Short-term plans were exempt from the law’s title I insurance requirements. Health reimbursement arrangements were tax-advantaged, account-based arrangements that employers can establish for employees’ healthcare.
The order also stated a broader policy on competition. Government rules affecting the healthcare system should, to the extent consistent with law, expand access to alternatives such as the three products. They should re-inject competition by lowering barriers to entry, limiting excessive consolidation and preventing abuses of market power. They should improve access to information on healthcare prices and outcomes while minimizing reporting burdens on plans, providers and payers.
Sections 2 to 4 gave the instructions. Within 60 days, the Secretary of Labor would consider proposing regulations or revising guidance to let more employers form association health plans. The order suggested expanding the commonality-of-interest conditions under Labor’s advisory opinions, and promoting plans based on common geography or industry.
Within 60 days, the Secretaries of the Treasury, Labor and Health and Human Services would consider proposals to expand short-term coverage. The order suggested allowing it to cover longer periods and be renewed by the consumer. It noted that the previous administration had cut the allowable coverage period from less than 12 months to less than 3 months.
Within 120 days, the same three Secretaries would consider proposals to increase the usability of health reimbursement arrangements. The order asked them to expand employers’ ability to offer them, and to allow them to be used with nongroup coverage. Section 5 required the Secretaries to consider public comments on any proposed rules.
Section 6 asked for a report. Within 180 days, and every two years after, the Secretary of Health and Human Services, consulting Treasury, Labor and the Federal Trade Commission, would report to the President. The report would detail state and federal laws and policies that did not conform to the order’s policy, and identify actions to further it.
The same day, the Department of Health and Human Services announced that cost-sharing reduction payments would be discontinued immediately. Its release said the decision followed a legal opinion from the Attorney General, and that Congress had not appropriated money for the payments. The release said the previous administration had made the payments to insurance companies without an appropriation.
The two actions were separate. The order set out a rulemaking agenda for alternatives to marketplace coverage. The payment decision affected insurers offering marketplace coverage. Both reached the same markets in the same week.
Executive Order 13813 is easy to summarize as a push for cheaper, lighter health coverage. Read closely, it was a set of instructions to consider rules, with three products named and deadlines attached. Each product would move health spending through a different channel. Each would need its own rule, written by agencies under their own statutes and open to challenge on its own terms.
For health systems, the order mattered in two roles. A health system buys coverage as a large employer. It is also paid by the coverage its patients carry. Each of the three products touched one or both roles. The order’s competition clause and its report touched a third: the rules that govern how providers enter and compete in markets.
Our argument is that the order set three separate rulemakings in motion and decided none of them. Its effects on a health system depended on what each department later wrote, what courts did with it, and what later administrations kept. We take the order in four parts, one for each channel it opened:
- Pooled employer coverage: association health plans and small employers.
- Coverage outside the federal individual market rules: short-term, limited-duration insurance.
- Employer money for individual coverage: health reimbursement arrangements.
- The rules of the provider market: the competition clause and the report it ordered.
The first three are the products the order named. The fourth is the policy it stated for everything else. Together they cover the order’s reach. After the four parts we look at how the order reached different organizations, at objections, and at what a health system finance or benefits leader could check.
A note on sources and our reading. We describe the order from its text and the cost-sharing reduction decision from the department’s release. Later events come from the Federal Register, a departmental report and a joint statement of the three departments. Statements about what a rule required are our reading of those documents. Organizations should check with counsel. We take no position on the policy debate over the Affordable Care Act.
Pooled employer coverage: association health plans and small employers
The order asked the Secretary of Labor to consider letting more employers form association health plans. The legal hook was the definition of “employer” in section 3(5) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. Under Labor’s advisory opinions, a group of employers could sponsor a single plan only if they shared a commonality of interest.
What pooling would change
The order’s reasoning was about scale. It said large employers can obtain better terms because they spread risk and costs across larger pools. It said association plans could let small businesses self-insure together or buy large group coverage. In our reading, that would let small employers reach the large group market, with its different rules, through an association.
The order suggested two ways to widen eligibility. One was to expand the conditions that satisfy commonality of interest. The other was to promote plans formed on common geography or industry. Either would let more unrelated businesses join one plan. The order gave Labor 60 days to consider proposing regulations or revising guidance.
Who would bear the risk
An association plan moves risk from an insurer’s small group pool to the association. If the plan self-insures, the association and its members bear claims risk directly. If it buys coverage, the insurer prices the group. Either way, the plan’s cost depends on who joins. In our reading, a plan that attracts healthier members would price well, and the small group pool left behind would carry the rest.
That is a pricing effect, not a legal conclusion. It matters to a health system in two ways. A health system that employs few people in a subsidiary, such as a physician group, could be a small employer itself. And a health system that contracts with insurers would see its patients’ coverage shift between pools with different benefit rules.
What the order did not decide
The order did not say which conditions Labor should adopt. It did not address state insurance regulation of multiple employer arrangements. It did not say how working owners without employees would be treated. Those choices would be made in a rule. Each would affect who could join and what protections members would have.
A procurement question for small employers
For a small employer, an association plan would be a new purchasing option. It would sit beside small group insurance and individual coverage funded by the employer. Evaluating it would need the questions any buyer asks of a pooled arrangement. Who governs the association? Who bears claims risk, and what reserves stand behind it? What benefits are covered, and under which state and federal rules? In our reading, the order created a product category without the buyer protections that a mature category builds over time.
Provider contracting
For providers, a new kind of plan means new contracts. An association plan that self-insures needs a network, either rented or built. Its claims would be paid by a third-party administrator or an insurer acting on its behalf. A hospital revenue cycle team would need to know who the payer of record is and how claims and appeals flow. In our reading, each new plan type adds a payer profile to manage.
Governance a member would need to see
An association plan is only as sound as the association that runs it. A member employer would want to know how the board is chosen, whether members vote, and how the association can change benefits or contributions mid-year. It would want audited financial statements, the claims reserve policy and any stop-loss coverage. It would want to know what happens to claims in flight if the association dissolves.
Those questions mirror what a large employer asks of its own self-insured plan. The difference is control. A large employer sets its own reserve policy and can see its own claims. A member of an association sees what the association chooses to share. In our reading, a member employer would need contract terms that give it data rights and notice of changes, because it gives up direct control.
What changes at renewal
Pooling changes the renewal conversation. In a small group policy, the insurer sets a rate under the rules for that market. In a pooled plan, the rate depends on the pool’s experience. A bad claims year for the association could raise every member’s cost, or prompt the association to change benefits. A member could leave, but leaving mid-cycle may carry costs.
For a buyer, the question is stability. A pool that attracts a narrow group of healthy members may price well early and deteriorate as members age or fall ill. A pool with broad membership may price higher but move less. In our reading, a small employer would want several years of the association’s rate history before joining, if the association had any.
The workforce as members
Employees in a pooled plan have rights as plan participants. They need plan documents, claims procedures and appeal rights. A member employer would still answer to its employees for the coverage it chose. In our reading, a small provider organization offering pooled coverage would want its human resources team to understand the plan as well as it would understand an insured policy, because staff will ask.
Coverage outside the federal individual market rules: short-term, limited-duration insurance
The order asked the three departments to consider expanding short-term, limited-duration insurance. It suggested letting such coverage run longer and be renewed by the consumer. It said such coverage was exempt from the Affordable Care Act’s title I insurance requirements, which it described as onerous and expensive.
Why the definition mattered
Short-term coverage is defined by exclusion. It is not individual health insurance coverage under the Public Health Service Act, so the individual market rules do not apply to it. The definition of short-term therefore decides how much coverage can be sold outside those rules. A longer allowed term means more people can hold such coverage for longer.
The order noted the prior change. The previous administration had cut the maximum period from less than 12 months to less than 3 months, and barred policyholder extensions beyond 3 months in total. The order invited the departments to reverse that. It left the length to the rule.
The provider side of a lighter policy
For a health system, short-term coverage matters at registration and billing. A patient may present an insurance card that looks like any other. The policy may exclude conditions or cap benefits in ways a marketplace plan cannot. In our reading, a hospital’s eligibility checks, prior authorization steps and financial counseling would need to recognize such policies and explain them to patients before services where possible.
The effect on a hospital’s finances would depend on what the policies covered and who bought them. If people moved from comprehensive coverage to policies with exclusions, some care would shift to self-pay balances or charity care. If uninsured people bought short-term policies, some uncompensated care would become partly covered. The order did not estimate either effect. Neither do we.
What the order did not decide
The order did not set a term. It did not address disclosures to consumers, state rules on such policies, or interactions with special enrollment periods. Each of those would decide how a patient would understand the policy. The departments would set them in a rule.
The employer angle
Short-term coverage is sold to individuals. A health system as employer would not buy it. But a health system’s part-time, seasonal or contract workers who lack employer coverage could buy it. In our reading, a benefits leader would want to know which workforce groups might rely on such policies, because those workers are also patients and colleagues.
Coverage verification as a control
A hospital’s front-end processes verify coverage before or at the time of service. A short-term policy changes what verification has to answer. It is not enough to know that a patient has a policy. The hospital would need to know what the policy covers for the planned service, whether a preexisting condition exclusion could apply, and whether benefits are capped. In our reading, eligibility checks built for comprehensive plans would not capture those facts by default.
The control would sit in three places. Scheduling could flag policies that need review before elective services. Registration could capture policy type and limits. Financial counseling could explain to patients what the policy may not pay. Each step costs staff time. A hospital would decide how far to go based on how often it saw such policies, which it could measure from its own registration data.
Price estimates and patient balances
When a policy pays less, the patient owes more. A patient with a lighter policy may face a larger balance than expected. A hospital that offers price estimates before scheduled care would want them to reflect the policy’s actual terms. An estimate based on an assumption of comprehensive coverage could mislead. In our reading, the accuracy of estimates for such patients would depend on getting benefit details from the issuer, which may take time.
Collection policies would also be tested. A larger share of balances owed by insured patients would move revenue from payer to patient. Financial assistance policies set income thresholds and eligibility rules. A hospital would need to decide how those policies apply to patients who hold a policy that excludes the service. That is a policy decision for the hospital and its board, with legal review.
Disclosure as the buyer’s protection
For a consumer buying a short-term policy, the main protection is understanding what it does not cover. The order did not address disclosure. The departments’ 2018 rule later kept a requirement that issuers display a notice prominently in the contract and application materials, in at least 14-point type. In our reading, a hospital’s financial counselors would find that notice useful when a patient asks why a claim was denied. They would need to know to ask for it.
Renewal and gaps in coverage
The order suggested that short-term policies could be renewed by the consumer. Renewal matters to providers because a patient’s coverage may change between visits. A course of treatment that spans a renewal could cross from one policy period to another. In our reading, a hospital treating such a patient over months would need to re-verify coverage more often than for a patient with an annual plan.
Employer money for individual coverage: health reimbursement arrangements
The order asked the three departments to consider increasing the usability of health reimbursement arrangements. It asked them to expand employers’ ability to offer them, and to allow them to be used with nongroup coverage. That last instruction was the important one. Under the rules then in force, as the departments’ 2019 rule later described, an arrangement could not be integrated with individual coverage.
What the change would allow
If arrangements could pay for individual coverage, an employer could fund a defined amount for each employee to buy a policy on the individual market. The employer would set the contribution. The employee would choose the plan. In our reading, this would move an employer from buying a group plan to funding a budget, and move plan choice to the employee.
For an employer, that changes the procurement task. Buying a group plan involves broker selection, insurer negotiation, network review and renewal cycles. Funding an account involves setting contribution levels by employee class, administering reimbursements and substantiating that employees have coverage. Each requires different vendors, controls and staff skills.
Where adverse selection would enter
The risk in such arrangements is that an employer could steer sicker employees to the individual market and keep healthier ones in its group plan. The order did not address this. Any rule would need conditions to prevent it. The order left that design to the departments.
Older workers and Medicare
The order asked for arrangements usable with nongroup coverage. The question of employees eligible for Medicare sat close by. The departments’ 2019 rule noted that earlier rules and guidance already let an arrangement be integrated with Medicare in some cases. Its new individual coverage arrangement could be integrated with individual coverage or Medicare, if conditions were met. For a health system with older staff in part-time or per diem roles, that detail would matter. In our reading, benefits teams would need to understand how an arrangement interacts with Medicare enrollment before offering it to those staff.
Health systems as employers
The order said wider use of arrangements would give more options to many Americans, including employees at small businesses. A large health system that offers its own group plan would read that differently. In our reading, a large health system would look at the change for particular groups, such as part-time staff, residents or employees in a separate subsidiary, rather than for its whole workforce. Any such use would depend on the conditions in the final rule.
Health systems as providers
On the provider side, more employees buying individual coverage would change a hospital’s payer mix. Patients would arrive with marketplace or other individual policies instead of employer group plans. Reimbursement rates under individual policies may differ from group rates. In our reading, a health system’s managed care team would want to know which individual market plans its local employers’ staff might buy.
The data a funded account needs
An arrangement that reimburses premiums needs proof of coverage and proof of payment. Proof moves between employee, insurer and administrator as a data flow. A health system that offered such an arrangement would hold premium and coverage information about its staff. In our reading, that information would need the same privacy handling as other benefits data, and possibly more care because the employer is also the employees’ provider.
Contribution design by employee class
An arrangement that funds individual coverage needs a contribution design. An employer would decide how much to fund, whether amounts vary by age or family size, and which employees are eligible. Any final rule would likely constrain those choices to prevent discrimination and steering. The order left the constraints open. In our reading, an employer considering the option would need the final conditions before modeling cost.
The modeling itself is a procurement exercise. The employer compares the cost of funding accounts with the cost of a group plan for the same employees. It also compares what employees would pay out of pocket under each. Individual market premiums vary by age and location. An employer with staff spread across several rating areas would need premium data for each. That data comes from the individual market, not from the employer’s broker.
Vendors and administration
Administering an arrangement involves enrollment, substantiation of coverage, reimbursement processing and required notices. Employers buy those services from administrators. The administrator would need to confirm, for each employee, that individual coverage was in force. In our reading, the employer would remain responsible for the arrangement’s compliance even if an administrator ran it, so contract terms on data, timing and error correction would matter.
The effect on recruitment and retention
For a health system competing for nurses and technicians, benefits are part of the offer. A shift from a group plan to an account would change what candidates are told. Some may prefer choosing their own plan. Others may value a familiar group plan with the employer’s own facilities in network. In our reading, a health system would test any change with its workforce before adopting it, because the cost of losing clinical staff can exceed any savings.
The rules of the provider market: the competition clause and the report it ordered
Section 1(c) went beyond insurance products. It said government rules should re-inject competition by lowering barriers to entry, limiting excessive consolidation and preventing abuses of market power. It said rules should improve access to information on prices and outcomes while minimizing reporting burdens. Section 6 asked for a report on laws and policies that did not conform.
Barriers to entry
Barriers to entry in healthcare include licensing, scope-of-practice limits and state certificate-of-need laws that require approval for new facilities or services. The order did not name any of them. It asked for a report that would. In our reading, the clause pointed at rules that shape where a health system can build, whom it can hire and what clinicians may do.
Consolidation
The order said the administration would continue to focus on limiting excessive consolidation. It gave no instruction to any agency on mergers. The Federal Trade Commission was named only as a consultee for the report. In our reading, a health system planning an acquisition would see no change from the order itself, but would see a stated policy that its federal government viewed consolidation as a concern.
Price and outcome information
The order’s information policy would reach providers directly. It said Americans need data about healthcare prices and outcomes to make informed decisions. It added the condition of minimizing reporting burdens. In our reading, this set a direction without a mechanism. Any price disclosure duty would come from a later rule under its own authority.
What a health system’s data teams would face
Price information sits in chargemasters, payer contracts and claims systems. Outcome information sits in clinical systems and quality reporting. Neither is designed for public release. A requirement to publish either would mean extracting, normalizing and explaining data across systems. The order did not require that. It signaled interest in it.
The report as an agenda
The report under section 6 was due within 180 days and every two years after. It would identify actions states or the federal government could take. For a health system, the report would be a guide to which state laws federal agencies would criticize, and which federal programs they might change. In our reading, it was the order’s map of future rulemaking for providers.
Scope of practice and the workforce
Scope-of-practice laws decide what nurse practitioners, physician assistants, pharmacists and other clinicians may do without physician supervision. They are state laws. A federal policy favoring lower barriers to entry points toward broader scope. For a health system, broader scope would change staffing models, credentialing and supervision policies. In our reading, it would also change how a health system competes with clinics that use advanced practice clinicians.
The order did not change any scope law. Its policy statement and report invited states to reconsider them. A health system’s workforce planning would follow state legislation, not the order. But the federal direction could shape grant conditions, demonstration programs and federal agency comments on state bills. In our reading, those are the channels to watch.
What price transparency would ask of contracts
Payer contracts set negotiated rates. They may also contain confidentiality terms. A future duty to disclose prices would sit uneasily with such terms. The order did not create that duty. It stated a policy favoring price information. In our reading, a health system’s managed care team would want to know which contracts restrict disclosure and how those terms would interact with any future federal requirement.
Outcome information raises different questions. Outcomes need risk adjustment to be fair. In our reading, outcome data published without adjustment could disadvantage hospitals that treat sicker patients. The order’s phrase about minimizing reporting burdens did not address method. In our reading, a health system’s quality team would want any future outcome reporting to rely on measures it already produces for existing programs.
How the order reached different organizations
The order’s reach varied by the role each organization plays in buying or providing care. The text addressed small businesses, consumers without workplace coverage, and the markets as a whole.
Large health systems
For a large health system, the order touched three functions. Benefits would watch the arrangement rules for possible use with some employee groups. Revenue cycle would watch for new plan types and lighter policies at registration. Strategy and government relations would watch the competition report for state laws affecting expansion. None required action in October 2017. Each would require planning once rules appeared.
Ambulatory networks and physician groups
Smaller provider organizations can be small employers. For them, association plans and arrangements would be purchasing options as well as payer types. A physician group of modest size might join an association plan through a professional or regional association. In our reading, such groups would weigh pooled coverage against small group insurance on cost, benefits and the stability of the association.
Health plans and insurers
Insurers would see new products to sell and new competition. The cost-sharing reduction decision announced the same day affected marketplace insurers directly. The HHS release said the payments would stop immediately. In our reading, marketplace insurers had to plan premiums and participation with that change and with the prospect of short-term plans drawing enrollees away.
State insurance regulators and agencies
States regulate insurance. Association plans and short-term policies would need state rules or oversight. The order’s policy statement favored purchase of insurance across state lines, but the order gave no instruction on it. In our reading, state regulators would face new filings and new consumer complaints, and would decide how far to align with federal definitions.
Health systems near state borders
The order’s first sentence of policy favored the purchase of insurance across state lines. No section gave an instruction to carry it out. In our reading, that left the idea as a statement of direction. For a health system near a state border, cross-state products would matter because patients from one state are treated in another. Network adequacy, claims rules and prompt-pay laws differ by state. A product sold under one state’s rules to residents of another would raise questions about which rules apply at the hospital’s billing office. The order did not answer them.
Public employers and agencies
Public agencies are employers too. A county or city might look at arrangements for some workers. State Medicaid agencies would see coverage shifts at the margins as people moved between individual coverage, short-term policies and public programs. In our reading, these effects would arrive through enrollment data long after the order.
Benefits brokers and administrators
Brokers and third-party administrators sell and run the products the order named. Association plans would need administrators and networks. Arrangements would need administrators and individual market enrollment support. In our reading, these firms would be early movers, building products once each rule appeared. Health systems that buy from them, or contract with them as payers, would see the order’s effects through their offerings.
Objections, in order
The argument that the order set three rulemakings in motion and decided none of them faces objections. We take the strongest six in order.
1. Executive orders always work this way, so the point is trivial
Executive orders of this kind direct agencies rather than regulate directly. The point is not that the order was unusual. It is that a health system could not plan from the order. It had to plan from each rule, each court decision and each later policy. The order set direction. The rules set duties.
2. The direction was clear enough to plan around
The direction was clear: more choice outside the federal individual market rules. But the effect on a health system depends on details the order left open. They include the length of a short-term policy, the conditions on arrangements and the eligibility test for association plans. Planning on direction alone risks building for rules that never arrive in that form.
3. Health systems are not the order’s audience
The order addressed consumers and small businesses. Health systems are affected indirectly, as payees of coverage and as employers. Indirect effects still reach revenue, staffing and benefits. A finance leader who waited for direct rules about hospitals would miss changes in the coverage patients carry.
4. The cost-sharing reduction decision mattered more
For marketplace insurers in late 2017, it may have. The decision took immediate effect, according to the HHS release. The order took effect only through later rules. Our argument concerns the order’s design, not its relative weight that month. The two actions reached different parts of the market through different mechanisms.
5. More choice for patients and employees is good, so the design does not matter
We take no position on whether more choice was good policy. The design still matters, because each product’s value to patients and employees depends on its conditions. A short-term policy with clear disclosures and a predictable term serves a buyer differently from one without. The order left those conditions to rules, so the rules decided the value.
6. Uncertainty argues for waiting, not planning
Waiting is reasonable for building systems. It is not reasonable for understanding exposure. A health system can map which of its patients, employees and contracts each product would touch without committing to any response. That map would be useful whatever the rules said.
What a health system finance or benefits leader could check
Each product the order named has been the subject of federal rules since 2017. The order’s pattern, a policy that works through later rules, recurs. The history suggests a short set of checks:
- Map patients, employees and contracts against each coverage type a policy change would touch, before the rules are written.
- Confirm that registration and eligibility checks can identify short-term and other limited policies and route patients to financial counseling.
- Review whether any employee groups, such as part-time staff, could be offered an individual coverage arrangement, and what the conditions would require.
- Track each rule from proposal to final to litigation, and plan builds only when the text and status are settled.
- Keep a register of state laws on facilities, scope of practice and price reporting that federal reports have flagged.
The checks also change what a board hears. A report that says the order may affect payer mix tells a board little. A better report says how many registrations last quarter carried limited policies. It says how many employees sit in classes that could be offered an arrangement. It names the pending rules that would change either number. That gives the board something to govern. The same structure works for any coverage change, from either direction of policy.
These checks give a leader something to report: which revenue, which staff and which contracts depend on each coverage rule. Those facts support decisions whatever the policy direction. In our view, a health system should plan from the rules as finally written, while knowing in advance where each could reach.
With hindsight
Each of the three rulemakings produced a final rule, and each then took its own course. The report the order requested was also published. The order itself did not survive the next change of administration.
Association plans came first. The Labor Department’s rule was published on June 21, 2018. The department’s 2024 rescission says it was issued in response to the 2017 order. It set a more flexible commonality-of-interest test, including common geography, and let certain working owners without common-law employees participate. In July 2018, eleven states and the District of Columbia sued. On March 28, 2019, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia held the rule’s core provisions invalid.
The department appealed, and the appeals court later held the case in abeyance. On April 30, 2024, the department published a rule rescinding the 2018 rule, effective July 1, 2024. It said the 2018 rule’s core provisions were not consistent with the best reading of ERISA. It said it was not aware of any association plans then existing in reliance on the 2018 rule.
Short-term coverage followed a different arc. The three departments’ rule of August 3, 2018, allowed an initial term of less than 12 months and a total duration, with renewals, of no longer than 36 months. On January 28, 2021, Executive Order 14009 revoked Executive Order 13813, according to the departments’ 2024 rule. That 2024 rule limited new policies sold from September 1, 2024, to no more than 3 months, and 4 months in total.
Then policy turned again. On August 7, 2025, the three departments said they intended to undertake rulemaking on the definition. Until then, they did not intend to prioritize enforcement actions for failures to meet the 2024 definition, including its notice provision. HHS encouraged states to take a similar approach. As checked on November 15, 2026, that statement is the latest federal document on short-term coverage that we cite.
Health reimbursement arrangements had the steadiest path. The departments’ final rule was published on June 20, 2019, and applied generally to plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2020. It allowed an individual coverage arrangement integrated with individual health insurance or Medicare, if conditions were met. Among them, an employer could not offer a class of employees a choice between a traditional group plan and such an arrangement.
The report under section 6 was issued as Reforming America’s Healthcare System Through Choice and Competition. Its cover letter said HHS prepared it with Treasury, Labor, the Federal Trade Commission and several White House offices. It identified four areas: the workforce, provider markets, insurance markets and consumer-driven care. It recommended broadening scope of practice, repealing or scaling back certificate-of-need laws, and developing price and quality transparency initiatives.
What held up is the order’s design as a set of separate bets. The association plan rule did not survive. The short-term rule was reversed in 2024, and in 2025 the departments said they did not intend to prioritize enforcing the 2024 definition. None of the later documents we cite changed the arrangement rule. A health system that planned from the order would have planned for three outcomes that diverged. One that planned from each rule’s text and status would have tracked each change as it came.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.