Medicaid’s 2016 managed care rule put directories on an update clock and left access testing to states

CMS’s May 6, 2016 rule set content and update deadlines for Medicaid plan directories and had states write network standards. It declined to require secret shopper checks; the 2024 rule required them.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

CMS’s May 6, 2016 rule set content and update deadlines for Medicaid plan directories and had states write network standards. It declined to require secret shopper checks; the 2024 rule required them.

  1. The week The preamble explained why an update was due.
  2. The directory: content, clocks and format The 2016 rule listed eight items for each network provider.
  3. The network standard: what states had to write Several commenters asked CMS to clarify that states should set specific quantitative time and distance standards for adults and children.
  4. The access test: what CMS left to the states Commenters asked for national standards.
  5. The data supply: where directory accuracy is decided Commenters told CMS that directory information comes from numerous sources and must be validated before acceptance. [1] A single listing can draw on credentialing files, contract records, practice updates and provider rosters.
  6. How the rule reached different organizations The rule regulated states and, through state contracts, managed care plans.
  7. Objections, in the order we would hear them Enrollee advocates could fairly say that a month is a long time to see a closed practice listed as open.
  8. Checks a plan, state or provider could run These checks follow the rule’s structure.
  9. With hindsight The 2016 network standard did not last in its original form.

The week

On Friday, May 6, 2016, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services published its final rule on Medicaid and CHIP managed care in the Federal Register. [1] The document ran from page 27498 to page 27901 of that day’s Register. [1] The rule took effect on July 5, 2016, except for two provisions that took effect on publication. [1]

The rule’s summary said it modernized the Medicaid managed care regulations to reflect changes in how managed care was used. [1] It said the rule aligned many Medicaid managed care rules, where feasible, with those for Qualified Health Plans and Medicare Advantage plans. [1] It also said the rule strengthened actuarial soundness payment provisions, promoted quality, and enhanced beneficiary protections and program integrity. [1]

The preamble explained why an update was due. Comprehensive Medicaid managed care regulations had been adopted in 2002 after a series of proposed and interim rules. [1] Since then, CMS said, states had expanded managed care to new geographic areas and broader groups of beneficiaries, including older adults, people with disabilities and those needing long-term services and supports. [1]

CMS gave enrollment figures from its own reports. It said that as of July 1, 2013, more than 45.9 million people, or 73.5 percent of all Medicaid beneficiaries, received part or all of their benefits through managed care. [1] It said about 4.3 million children enrolled in CHIP in fiscal year 2013 were in managed care. [1]

The proposed rule had been published on June 1, 2015. [1] The final rule covered marketing, appeals and grievances, medical loss ratios, rate setting, quality, program integrity and beneficiary information. [1] It required capitation rates to be developed so that plans would reasonably achieve a medical loss ratio of at least 85 percent. CMS had called 85 percent the industry standard for Medicare Advantage and large employers. [1]

Two provisions in the rule went to what an enrollee sees when looking for care. The first was the provider directory, in section 438.10(h). [1] Plans had to publish, for each network provider, a name and group affiliation, street address, telephone number, website, specialty and whether the provider would accept new enrollees. [1] Directories also had to show languages offered, including American Sign Language, and whether the office had accommodations for people with physical disabilities. [1]

The rule set update clocks. A paper directory had to be updated at least monthly. An electronic directory had to be updated no later than 30 calendar days after the plan received updated provider information. [1] Directories had to be available on the plan’s website in a machine readable file and format specified by the Secretary. [1]

The second provision was network adequacy, in a new section 438.68. A state contracting with managed care plans had to develop and enforce network adequacy standards. [1] At a minimum, it had to develop time and distance standards for listed provider types, including adult and pediatric primary care, OB/GYN, behavioral health, specialists, hospitals, pharmacy and pediatric dental. [1]

States had to publish those standards on their websites. [1] The directory provisions applied to rating periods beginning on or after July 1, 2017. [1] For network adequacy, states would not be held out of compliance before rating periods starting on or after July 1, 2018, if they met the earlier standards. [1]

The 2016 Medicaid managed care rule is long, and its headline features are financial: the medical loss ratio, rate setting and directed payments. [1] In our view, two short provisions mattered more to the person holding a Medicaid card. One said what a plan’s directory must show and how fast it must change. The other said states must write standards for whether a network is big enough. [1]

Our argument is that the 2016 rule regulated the inputs to access and left the test of access to states. It put directory updates on a clock and made states write network standards. [1] CMS considered requiring secret shopper checks of whether listed providers could actually be reached, and declined. [1] The 2024 rule later required them. [3] [4]

We take the rule’s access provisions in four parts:

  1. The directory: what each listing must contain, how fast it must change, and the machine readable format.
  2. The network standard: what states had to write, for which providers, and how exceptions worked.
  3. The access test: how the rule expected states to check that standards were met, and why CMS declined a national test.
  4. The data supply: where directory and network data came from, and what that meant for accuracy.

The parts are distinct. The first is what enrollees are told, the second is the promise about capacity, the third is the check of whether the promise holds, and the fourth is the plumbing beneath all three. After them we look at how the rule reached different organizations, take the objections in order, and end with checks a plan, state or provider could run.

The directory: content, clocks and format

What each listing had to show

The 2016 rule listed eight items for each network provider. They were the provider’s name and any group affiliation, street addresses, telephone numbers, website as appropriate, specialty as appropriate, and whether the provider would accept new enrollees. [1] The last two were cultural and linguistic capabilities, including languages offered and whether the provider had completed cultural competence training, and accommodations for people with physical disabilities. [1]

Directories had to cover physicians including specialists, hospitals, pharmacies, behavioral health providers, and long-term services and supports providers as appropriate. [1] CMS said the list was a minimum and encouraged states and plans to add provider types as useful to enrollees. [1]

Commenters asked for more fields, including provider gender, subspecialties, hospital privileges, hours of operation and expected periods of open or closed panels. [1] CMS said many of them could be useful, called the list a minimum, and encouraged states and plans to add them as appropriate and feasible. [1]

Accessibility information

The proposed rule asked whether a provider’s office “is accessible.” CMS changed the wording to “has accommodations” after comments. [1] Many commenters said information about internal office accommodations is not collected on most credentialing applications or through any uniform mechanism, and some raised liability concerns. [1]

CMS said it still believed accessibility information was critical, particularly as managed long-term services and supports programs grew. [1] It listed examples such as wide entries, wheelchair access, accessible exam tables and rooms, lifts, scales and grab bars, and said it expected the information to be specific enough to be useful. [1]

In our reading, the change of wording moved the field from a legal conclusion to a factual description. A plan cannot easily certify that an office is accessible. It can record which accommodations an office reports.

From three business days to thirty calendar days

The proposed rule would have required electronic directories to be updated within 3 business days of receiving updated provider information. [1] Commenters generally supported stronger directory requirements and agreed provider data needed to be as accurate as possible. [1] But many said directory information comes from numerous sources and must be validated before acceptance, which made 3 business days impossible. [1]

Many commenters asked CMS to align with Marketplace and Medicare Advantage requirements. CMS agreed that consistency with QHPs and Medicare Advantage was the most prudent approach. [1] It said that while this extended the proposed timeframe, supporting accuracy was more productive than retaining an unrealistic timeframe. [1] CMS encouraged plans to shorten the monthly timeframe while keeping directories as accurate as possible. [1]

In our reading, that exchange is the center of the directory provision. CMS chose a clock that plans could meet with validated data over one that would have forced faster, less checked updates. The clock measures speed after receipt, not accuracy.

What the clock starts on

The 30 calendar days run from when the plan receives updated provider information. [1] The rule did not say how a plan must find out that information has changed. A provider who moves, retires or stops taking new Medicaid patients and does not tell the plan starts no clock.

That gap is where directory accuracy is decided. A plan can meet the update clock perfectly and still publish stale listings, if its process for learning about changes depends on providers volunteering them. The rule regulated the plan’s response time and left the plan’s detection method to contract and practice.

Detection has a cost, and the rule did not price it. A plan can learn of changes from returned mail, claims that stop arriving, enrollee complaints, provider portal updates or outbound verification calls. Each costs something different and finds a different kind of error. Returned mail finds moves; claims patterns find inactive providers; calls find closed panels. The rule left the mix to the plan, which is why two plans meeting the same clock could publish directories of very different accuracy.

Paper on request

Commenters were confused about whether paper directories had to be sent routinely. [1] CMS clarified that paper directories need only be provided on request. [1] It encouraged single data source files or printing the online directory, so paper copies would be accurate within the required timeframe. [1]

Machine readable

CMS proposed machine readable directories to align with Medicare Advantage and with QHPs in the federally facilitated Marketplace. [1] It said Medicare Advantage plans had to post directories online, and that HHS had recently required Marketplace QHPs to post directories in a machine readable format specified by the Secretary. [1] CMS said the purpose was to improve transparency and provide an opportunity for third-party aggregation. [1]

CMS applied the same reasoning to formularies. It said machine readable formulary files would let software developers build tools to help enrollees compare plans. [1] In our reading, this was a forward-looking feature. It treated directory data as a public data set that others could test and reuse, which would also expose its errors.

The rules around the directory

The directory sat inside a broader information section with its own conditions. Information could be provided electronically only if it was readily accessible, placed prominently on the website, retainable and printable, and consistent with the content and language requirements. [1] Enrollees also had to be told that paper was available free on request, and receive it within 5 business days. [1]

The state had to develop definitions for managed care terms and model enrollee handbooks and notices, and require plans to use them. [1] In our reading, common definitions are what make directories comparable across plans. If one plan’s specialist is another plan’s primary care provider, a machine readable file can be well formed and still mislead.

Language access

The same section set language duties that reach the directory. States had to identify the prevalent non-English languages in the state and in each plan’s service area. [1] Plans had to make written materials critical to obtaining services available in those languages, and the rule named provider directories among them. [1]

Oral interpretation had to be available in all languages, free of charge, including American Sign Language and TTY/TDY, for every non-English language rather than the prevalent ones alone. [1] Written materials had to carry taglines in the prevalent languages and in large print, defined as no smaller than 18 point. [1]

For a plan’s data team, translation turns one directory into several. Each language version needs the same update discipline, or the translated directories drift behind the English one. The rule’s clock applied to the information, whatever the language it was published in. [1]

Who reads the directory

Enrollees are one audience. The rule also required states to run a beneficiary support system offering choice counseling to all potential enrollees, reachable by phone, Internet, in person and through auxiliary aids. [1] Choice counselors use plan networks to help people pick a plan. When the directory is wrong, the advice built on it is wrong too.

One commenter asked whether plans could link to the networks of large subcontractors, such as pharmacy benefit managers, instead of listing them. [1] CMS said nothing in the directory section prohibited links for large subcontractors. [1] The duty for accuracy did not move with the link. On our reading, the plan still owed enrollees a current directory, wherever the data was hosted.

The network standard: what states had to write

Time and distance as the floor

Section 438.68 required states to develop and enforce network adequacy standards for their managed care contracts. [1] At a minimum, states had to set time and distance standards for primary care, OB/GYN, behavioral health, specialists, hospitals, pharmacy and pediatric dental, adult and pediatric where listed. [1] CMS could add provider types where that promoted the objectives of the program. [1]

Several commenters asked CMS to clarify that states should set specific quantitative time and distance standards for adults and children. CMS said states must develop quantitative time and distance standards for adult and pediatric primary care, behavioral health and specialists, and for pediatric dental. [1]

For long-term services and supports, the rule recognized two kinds of provider. Where the enrollee travels to the provider, states needed time and distance standards. Where the provider travels to the enrollee, states needed other kinds of standards. [1]

What states had to consider

The rule listed nine elements states must consider in setting standards. [1] They included anticipated enrollment, expected utilization, the health needs of covered populations, and the number and types of providers needed. [1] They also included the number of network providers not accepting new Medicaid patients, travel time and means of transportation, and providers’ ability to communicate with enrollees with limited English proficiency. [1]

The list also named physical access and accommodations for enrollees with disabilities, and the availability of triage lines, telemedicine, e-visits and other technological solutions. [1] In our reading, the list was a set of considerations, not a formula. A state could weigh them differently and still comply.

Geography and exceptions

Standards had to cover all geographic areas in the program or contract, and states could set different standards for the same provider type in different areas. [1] Where a state allowed exceptions, the standard for granting them had to be in the contract and based, at a minimum, on the number of providers in that specialty practicing in the service area. [1]

A state granting an exception had to monitor enrollee access to that provider type and report findings to CMS in its managed care program assessment report. [1] In our reading, the exception process was the rule’s honest acknowledgment that some places lack providers no matter how a network is built.

Publication also disciplines the state. A standard posted for anyone to read is harder to loosen without notice in a contract amendment. In our reading, that public record is part of why the 2016 rule could leave the numbers to states: outsiders could see what each state chose and compare it with what plans delivered. [1]

Long-term services and supports

The standards for long-term services and supports had extra considerations. States had to weigh elements that support an enrollee’s choice of provider, strategies for the enrollee’s health, welfare and community integration, and other considerations in the interest of enrollees needing such services. [1] The rule also required states to solicit and address the views of beneficiaries, providers and other stakeholders in designing and overseeing managed LTSS programs. [1]

In our reading, these provisions recognized that for home-based care, distance is the wrong question. The provider comes to the enrollee. Whether an aide is available on the days needed is the access measure, and the 2016 rule left states to define it. [1]

Publication

States had to publish their standards on the website the rule required, and provide them in alternate formats on request to enrollees with disabilities. [1] That made the standards checkable by outsiders. An advocate or researcher could compare a plan’s network with the state’s published distance and travel time limits.

Exceptions and payment

The 2016 exception standard looked at supply: the number of providers in a specialty practicing in the area. [1] The current text adds that the exception standard must consider the payment rates plans offer to the provider type. [4] In our reading, that later addition names a cause the 2016 rule left implicit. A shortage can reflect what plans pay as well as how many providers exist.

What time and distance cannot show

A time and distance standard measures whether a listed provider is close enough. It does not measure whether that provider will see a new Medicaid patient, or how long the wait is. [1] The rule’s own list of considerations included providers not accepting new Medicaid patients, which acknowledges the problem. [1] But the standard itself could be met by a directory full of providers who would not take the call.

That is where the network standard depends on the directory. If the listings are wrong, a network can pass a distance test on paper and fail enrollees in fact. The two provisions were written in different sections and tested different things, yet each needed the other to be accurate.

The access test: what CMS left to the states

Timely access

Separately from network adequacy, section 438.206 required states to ensure plans met standards for timely access to care. [1] CMS said it interpreted the provision as requiring states to set standards for timely access to all state plan services in the contract, which could be classified as routine, urgent or emergency care. [1]

CMS said that for access standards to be effective, states would need mechanisms to ensure the standards were being met. [1] It said it had considered requiring a mix of approaches: enrollee surveys, encounter data review, HEDIS access measures, secret shopper efforts and systematic evaluation of consumer service calls. [1]

Secret shoppers declined

Commenters asked for national standards. Several recommended that CMS add secret shopper standards and benchmarks to the network adequacy section. [1] CMS declined. It said that while secret shopper and patient satisfaction standards may be beneficial, it was unclear whether they were an appropriate and meaningful national standard for all states and populations. [1] It said such standards should be considered at the state level, and encouraged states to keep exploring them. [1]

On timely access, many commenters asked CMS to add quantitative standards for provider and enrollee surveys, encounter data audits, secret shopper efforts and appointment wait times. [1] CMS declined these as well. It said states should be allowed to set appropriate quantitative standards and were best placed to reflect their programs, populations and demographics. [1]

Why the choice mattered

In our reading, declining a national test was a defensible choice in 2016. Medicaid programs differ across states, and a federal benchmark could have been set too low for some and impossible for others. [1] But it meant the rule had a clock for directory updates and a requirement for network standards, with no federal requirement that anyone call the listed numbers.

The effect was that directory accuracy and appointment availability were measured, if at all, by state choice. A state could run secret shopper surveys, review encounter data or rely on plan attestations. The rule allowed each of these and required none of them. [1]

What a test would have measured

A secret shopper survey answers questions a time and distance map cannot. Does the listed number reach the listed practice? Is the provider in the network? Will the office book a new Medicaid patient, and when? Those are the questions the 2024 rule later wrote into the federal text. [4]

Each answer maps to a field the 2016 directory already required: phone number, address, network listing and acceptance of new enrollees. [1] In our reading, the 2016 rule defined the data a test would check, and stopped short of requiring the test. That made later adoption easier, because the fields existed.

The trade-off CMS described

CMS framed its choice as flexibility. It said states were best placed to set quantitative standards that reflect the scope of their programs, the populations served and their demographics. [1] The cost of that flexibility was comparability. Without common tests, results from one state could not be set beside another’s, and enrollees moving between states met different levels of protection.

Plan attestations

Section 438.207 required each plan to give the state assurances, with supporting documentation, that it had the capacity to serve expected enrollment under the state’s access standards. [1] In our reading, documentation from the plan is a claim; a secret shopper call is a test. The 2016 rule relied mainly on the first kind of evidence for access.

The program assessment report

States had to report on their managed care programs to CMS, including the findings from monitoring exceptions to network standards. [1] The rule also said states must comply with one reporting provision no later than the rating period starting after CMS published guidance. [1] That made federal oversight of access depend on state reporting, and state reporting depend on whatever tests the state chose.

The data supply: where directory accuracy is decided

Many sources, one listing

Commenters told CMS that directory information comes from numerous sources and must be validated before acceptance. [1] A single listing can draw on credentialing files, contract records, practice updates and provider rosters. Each source can have its own owner and its own cycle.

The 2016 rule did not prescribe a data model or a source of truth. It set content requirements and an update clock. [1] The choice of system, the validation steps and the method of learning about changes were left to plans and their contracts with states.

Accessibility and languages as new data

Two directory items asked plans to report information they had not always collected. Commenters said office accommodation data was not on most credentialing applications. [1] The final rule also added cultural competence training to the language item, and changed it from languages spoken to languages offered so that sign language was covered. [1]

A field that is not collected at credentialing has to be collected some other way, by survey, attestation or site visit. Each method has a cost and an accuracy profile. The rule required the field and left the method open.

Provider screening

Some commenters suggested that states obtain accessibility information through licensing or through the provider screening requirement the rule proposed in section 438.602. [1] CMS did not adopt that suggestion, but the link is useful. State provider enrollment and screening data is a second source of truth that can be compared with a plan’s directory.

Aggregation as a check

Machine readable directories create a third source of checking. When directory files are published in a common format, a state or a third party can compare plans’ listings for the same provider. [1] A provider who appears at different addresses in different plans’ files is a signal that at least one listing is wrong.

In our reading, the rule assembled the pieces for data-driven directory checking: content standards, an update clock, machine readable files and state screening data. What it did not do was require anyone to run the check.

Who owns the truth of a listing

Every listing has three parties with a stake in its accuracy. The provider knows the facts. The plan publishes them and answers to the state. The state answers to CMS and to enrollees. The 2016 rule put the publishing duty on the plan and the oversight duty on the state, and gave the provider no direct duty. [1]

In our reading, that allocation explains why accuracy was hard. The party with the facts had the least obligation to report them. Plans could add reporting duties to provider contracts, but the federal rule did not require them.

A practical answer is to make the provider’s update the cheapest action available. One roster, one portal, one schedule, accepted by every plan. The rule’s machine readable requirement pointed in that direction without building it. [1]

The formulary parallel

The formulary provisions followed the same pattern. Plans had to show which medications were covered and their tier, in a machine readable file. [1] CMS said this would let third parties build comparison tools. [1] As with directories, the rule standardized publication and left verification to whoever used the data.

How the rule reached different organizations

The rule regulated states and, through state contracts, managed care plans. Its effects reached providers and the systems that serve enrollees. [1]

A state Medicaid agency

The state had to write network standards, publish them, operate a website with directory content or links, and run a beneficiary support system. [1] It also decided how to check compliance. A state with a strong encounter data program could test networks from claims. A state without one depended more on plan reports.

For a state agency’s technology team, the practical questions were about data. The test was whether the state could ingest plans’ machine readable directories, match them against its own provider enrollment file and flag mismatches. The rule made those files available. Using them was the state’s choice. [1]

A managed care plan

For a plan, the directory requirement was a data operations commitment. It needed a process that received provider changes, validated them, and published them within 30 calendar days. [1] It also needed to collect new fields, such as accommodations and languages, that its credentialing process might not capture. [1]

Plans in several programs could align processes. CMS chose Medicare Advantage and QHP timing so plans would not run different clocks for the same provider data. [1] A plan offering Medicaid, Marketplace and Medicare Advantage products could run one directory pipeline, if its data model allowed program-specific network status.

A health system or physician group

Providers were not regulated by the directory section directly, but their data drove it. A health system contracted with several Medicaid plans would see requests to confirm addresses, panel status, languages and accommodations from each. [1] A single maintained roster, sent to every plan on a schedule, reduces both the burden and the chance that plans publish different facts about the same clinic.

A behavioral health or LTSS provider

Behavioral health providers were a required directory category and a required network standard category. [1] For long-term services and supports, a commenter noted that some providers frequently do not have a business phone or address. CMS acknowledged that some LTSS providers lack formal business information, and expected states and plans to judge which types to list. [1] For those providers, the directory question was whether to list at all, as well as how to keep a listing current.

An enrollment broker

The rule’s information duties applied to enrollment brokers as well as states and plans. [1] A broker helping a family choose a plan relies on each plan’s directory to answer a question families ask: is my doctor in it. A broker cannot fix a plan’s listing, but it can log the cases where a family was told a provider was in network and later found otherwise. That log is evidence a state can use.

A plan in several programs

CMS chose Medicare Advantage and Marketplace alignment for directory timing because many commenters asked for it. [1] For a company offering all three products, the practical gain is one change-intake process. The practical risk is that a provider in one product’s network but not another’s is shown as in network everywhere. Network status has to be stored per product.

A county or community organization

Counties and community organizations that help people enroll or find care use plan directories as a working tool. When listings are wrong, their staff absorb the cost in repeated calls. The rule’s publication of state standards gave such organizations a basis to document gaps for the state. [1]

Objections, in the order we would hear them

1. Thirty days was too slow

Enrollee advocates could fairly say that a month is a long time to see a closed practice listed as open. But CMS’s choice rested on commenters’ statements that faster updates would publish unvalidated data. [1] The clock was the wrong place to look for accuracy in any case. Detection of changes, not speed of publication, decides whether a listing is current.

2. Leaving tests to states produced uneven protection

This objection is correct, and CMS accepted the trade-off knowingly. It said national secret shopper standards might not be meaningful across all states and populations. [1] The 2024 rule reached a different conclusion and set a federal floor. [3]

3. Time and distance was the wrong measure

CMS itself later agreed in part, replacing the time and distance requirement with a broader quantitative standard in 2020. [2] The 2016 rule’s list of considerations already included providers not accepting new patients and telemedicine. [1] The standard was narrower than the considerations behind it.

4. Directories matter less than networks

A sufficient network that enrollees cannot find is not accessible to them. The directory is how enrollees and their helpers turn a network into an appointment. The 2024 rule treated directory accuracy and appointment availability as two parts of one survey program, which supports reading them together. [4]

5. Machine readable files invite misuse

Provider directory data is business information about providers, not health information about enrollees. CMS’s stated purpose was transparency and third-party aggregation. [1] The risk is less misuse than misreading: aggregators may display stale data longer than plans do. That is an argument for accuracy at the source.

6. A federal rule should not dictate data fields

States run Medicaid, and a federal field list can seem intrusive. But CMS called its lists minimums and invited additions. [1] Common fields are what made machine readable files and cross-plan comparison possible. A floor of shared fields served states as much as enrollees.

Checks a plan, state or provider could run

These checks follow the rule’s structure. None requires a new system.

Find the change signals

List every way your directory learns that a provider has moved, retired or closed a panel. If the only route is the provider telling you, the 30-day clock may start late or not at all. [1]

Measure from receipt to publication

Record the date each change was received and the date it was published. That is what the rule’s clock measures. [1] [5] Report the distribution, not the average, because a few slow changes are the ones enrollees find.

Call a sample

Before any rule requires it, call a random sample of listings each quarter and record whether the address, phone number and new-patient status were right. The current federal text names those fields for state surveys. [4]

Compare against enrollment data

Match directory listings against the state’s provider enrollment file and against claims. A listed provider with no Medicaid claims over a long period is a candidate for review.

Collect accommodations and languages deliberately

Decide how accommodations and language data are gathered and refreshed, since commenters told CMS credentialing forms did not capture them. [1] Record the method and date for each listing so the field can be trusted or discounted.

Check every language version

For each prevalent language in which you publish a directory, confirm it carries the same changes as the English version within the same timeframe. The rule named directories among materials to be translated. [1]

Test paper on request

Ask for a paper directory as an enrollee would, and time the response against the 5-business-day requirement for paper copies of electronic information. [1] Check that the paper reflects the latest online changes.

Track errors to their source

When a listing is found wrong, record which source supplied the wrong fact: the provider roster, credentialing, a delegated vendor or manual entry. Over a year, that record shows which feed to fix first. Without it, every error looks like the directory team’s fault, and the cause stays in place.

Publish one roster

For providers contracted with several plans, send one maintained roster to all of them on a fixed schedule. It reduces conflicting listings across plans and makes errors traceable to one source.

With hindsight

The 2016 network standard did not last in its original form. In a final rule published November 13, 2020, CMS replaced the requirement that states set time and distance standards with a requirement to set a quantitative network adequacy standard. [2] CMS said some states had found that time and distance results did not accurately reflect provider availability, for example where telehealth was heavily used. [2]

CMS listed quantitative standards states could choose. They included minimum provider-to-enrollee ratios, maximum travel time or distance, a minimum percentage of contracted providers accepting new patients, maximum appointment wait times and hours of operation. [2] It encouraged states to use them in combination. The 2020 rule also let plans with a mobile-enabled electronic directory update paper directories quarterly instead of monthly. [2]

The 2024 rule went the other way on testing. In a final rule published May 10, 2024, CMS added appointment wait time standards and required secret shopper surveys. [3] As checked on November 16, 2026, section 438.68 required states to set routine appointment standards no longer than 10 business days for outpatient mental health and substance use disorder services. [4] It set no longer than 15 business days for primary care and for obstetrics and gynecology. [4]

Plans are deemed compliant when secret shopper results show appointment availability meeting the standards at least 90 percent of the time. [4] CMS said the 10- and 15-business-day standards with 90 percent compliance would be consistent with standards for Marketplace QHPs for plan year 2025. [3]

The current text requires states to contract with an entity independent of the state Medicaid agency and of the plans surveyed, to run annual secret shopper surveys. [4] The directory survey must check, for primary care, OB/GYN, outpatient mental health and substance use disorder providers and one state-chosen type, each provider’s active network status, address, phone number and new-patient status. [4]

Errors found must reach the state within 3 business days, and the state must send them to the plan within 3 business days of receipt. [4] CMS explained that those deadlines are for data transmission, not correction. [3] The current directory section requires plans to use that information to update directories within the existing timeframes. [5]

Results must be reported to CMS and posted on the state’s website within 30 calendar days of submission to CMS. [4] The applicability text says the secret shopper requirement applies to the first rating period beginning on or after 4 years after July 9, 2024; we state it as the rule does. [4]

The directory section itself changed in detail. As checked on the same date, it required a searchable electronic directory, added whether a provider offers covered services by telehealth, and no longer listed cultural competence training. [5] The 30-calendar-day clock for electronic directories remained. [5] The source note for section 438.68 cited amendments in 2020 and 2024 and none later. [4]

What held up from 2016 is the directory’s content, its update clock and the machine readable requirement. What did not hold up is the decision to leave access testing entirely to states. [1] [4] The federal rule moved from regulating what plans publish to requiring an independent check of whether it is true.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • Medicaid managed care
  • provider directories
  • network adequacy
  • secret shopper
  • CMS