Medicare’s 2019 virtual check-in priced a phone call and put the patient’s consent in the chart

CMS’s July 2018 proposal to pay for brief check-ins and patient-submitted photos turned a courtesy into a service with a bill. That made four things part of the patient’s experience: who could use it, consent to the cost, the visit calendar and the channel.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

CMS’s July 2018 proposal to pay for brief check-ins and patient-submitted photos turned a courtesy into a service with a bill. That made four things part of the patient’s experience: who could use it, consent to the cost, the visit calendar and the channel.

  1. The week On Thursday, July 12, 2018, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services issued its proposed rule for the calendar year 2019 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, together with proposed changes to the Quality Payment Program, the program that adjusts clinicians’ Medicare payments under the Merit-based Incentive Payment System and Advanced Alternative Payment Models, as the CMS fact sheet described it.
  2. Why CMS said the old bundling stopped working The proposed rule set out the reasoning behind the change at some length, and the reasoning matters because it explains why the patient became a party to the transaction.
  3. The door: established patients and the billing practitioner The proposed code descriptor for the virtual check-in described a service by “a physician or other qualified health care professional who can report evaluation and management services, provided to an established patient,” with “5-10 minutes of medical discussion.”
  4. The bill: cost sharing and consent The proposed rule was candid about the patient’s financial role.
  5. The calendar: seven days back, 24 hours forward The proposed descriptor made the check-in billable only if it was “not originating from a related E/M service provided within the previous 7 days nor leading to an E/M service or procedure within the next 24 hours or soonest available appointment.”
  6. The channel: phones, portals, photos and privacy CMS did not define the technology in the proposal.
  7. One call traced through the four parts The parts are clearest when followed through a single call under the proposed rules.
  8. Telehealth’s statutory limits stayed where they were The virtual services sat beside, not inside, Medicare’s telehealth benefit, and the same proposal showed how narrow that benefit remained.
  9. Services the patient never sees: e-consults and monitoring The same proposal reached further than calls and photos.
  10. Documentation: one half of the proposal removed, the other added The press release led with documentation burden, and the proposed rule’s headline change for office visits was large.
  11. Clinics paid under their own systems Rural Health Clinics and Federally Qualified Health Centers are paid differently from practices under the physician fee schedule, so CMS proposed a separate route for them.
  12. How to tell whether the experience works The proposal did not set any measure of patient experience for the new services.
  13. Objections: small money, good intentions, and simple calls One objection is that the amounts involved were small, so the experience questions were minor.
  14. What a health system leader can check The four parts translate into checks that a CMIO, a revenue cycle leader or an ambulatory operations director can run on any virtual service, then and now.
  15. With hindsight The final rule answered the proposal part by part, and the answers are a useful test of the 2018 reading.

The week

On Thursday, July 12, 2018, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services issued its proposed rule for the calendar year 2019 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, together with proposed changes to the Quality Payment Program, the program that adjusts clinicians’ Medicare payments under the Merit-based Incentive Payment System and Advanced Alternative Payment Models, as the CMS fact sheet described it. In a press release headed “CMS Proposes Historic Changes to Modernize Medicare and Restore the Doctor-Patient Relationship,” the agency described the package as a way to reduce the paperwork clinicians face when billing Medicare and to let clinicians use their electronic health records “to document clinically meaningful information, instead of information that is only for billing purposes.”

The release grouped the physician fee schedule changes under three headings. On documentation, CMS proposed to simplify, streamline and offer flexibility in documentation requirements for evaluation and management office visits, which it said “make up about 20 percent of allowed charges under the Physician Fee Schedule.” It estimated that removing unnecessary paperwork through the fee schedule proposal would save individual clinicians an estimated 51 hours per year if 40 percent of their patients were in Medicare. On virtual care, it proposed paying clinicians for “virtual check-ins – brief, non-face-to-face appointments via communications technology,” paying for evaluation of patient-submitted photos, and adding prolonged preventive services to the list of Medicare-covered telehealth services. On drug costs, it proposed a change to Part B payment for new drugs.

The fact sheet CMS published the same day gave the details for virtual care. It proposed to pay separately for two newly defined services: a “Brief Communication Technology-based Service, e.g. Virtual Check-in,” with the placeholder code GVCI1, and a “Remote Evaluation of Recorded Video and/or Images Submitted by the Patient,” code GRAS1. Practitioners could be paid for the first “when they check in with beneficiaries via telephone or other telecommunications device to decide whether an office visit or other service is needed,” and for the second when reviewing patient-transmitted photo or video information sent by “store and forward” technology to assess whether a visit was needed. The fact sheet also proposed separate payment for new codes for chronic care remote physiologic monitoring and interprofessional internet consultation.

Rural Health Clinics and Federally Qualified Health Centers, paid under their own systems, would get a newly created virtual communications G-code. These services would be payable, the fact sheet said, “for medical discussions or remote evaluations of conditions not related to an RHC or FQHC service provided within the previous 7 days or within the next 24 hours or at the soonest available appointment,” with payment set at the average of the national non-facility fee schedule rates for the two new services.

The press release quoted the HHS Secretary and the CMS Administrator. The Administrator said CMS was committed to modernizing Medicare through technologies such as audio and video applications and patient-facing health portals, which would help beneficiaries reach high-quality services conveniently. The release said Medicare payment would be established “for when beneficiaries connect with their doctor virtually using telecommunications technology (e.g., audio or video applications) to determine whether they need an in-person visit.”

Before 2019, a short call to a doctor’s office to ask whether a symptom needed a visit was, for Medicare purposes, part of some other service or of nothing at all. CMS said so in the proposed rule: it considered a check-in furnished before an office visit to be bundled into the payment for the resulting visit, and when a check-in did not lead to a visit, there was no visit to bundle it into. The July 2018 proposal changed that. It defined the check-in as a service, priced it and made it billable. Once a phone call is a billable service, the patient is a party to a transaction, with a share of the cost and a claim that a record must support.

Our argument is that this change was, at bottom, a change to the patient’s experience, and that it had four separate parts:

  • The door: who could use the service and with whom, which the proposal limited to established patients speaking directly with a billing practitioner.
  • The bill: cost sharing, which led CMS to ask about, and later require, consent noted in the record.
  • The calendar: the rules that made a check-in billable only if it was not tied to a visit in the previous seven days or the next 24 hours or soonest available appointment.
  • The channel: which technologies counted, how a patient’s photos reached the practitioner and how the answer came back.

Each part touches a different team in a health system or practice. The door is a registration and eligibility question. The bill is a financial counseling and consent question. The calendar is a scheduling question. The channel is an IT and privacy question. A provider organization could solve one or two and still produce a poor or noncompliant experience. After the four parts we look at the clinics paid under their own systems, take the objections and set out what a leader can check.

Why CMS said the old bundling stopped working

The proposed rule set out the reasoning behind the change at some length, and the reasoning matters because it explains why the patient became a party to the transaction.

CMS began with a distinction. The telehealth provisions of the Social Security Act, section 1834(m), define “Medicare telehealth services” as a discrete set of services that would ordinarily be furnished in person but are furnished instead through interactive, real-time telecommunication. The statute limits those services to beneficiaries in certain kinds of originating sites, in certain, mostly rural, areas, and to certain practitioners. CMS wrote that it had “come to believe that section 1834(m) of the Act does not apply to all kinds of physicians’ services whereby a medical professional interacts with a patient via remote communication technology.” Services “defined by and inherently involve the use of communication technology” would instead be paid under the fee schedule like other physicians’ services, without the telehealth limits.

In our reading, that interpretation is what made the virtual check-in available to a patient at home anywhere in the country, rather than only in a qualifying originating site. From the patient’s point of view, the legal distinction is invisible. A call from home to a practitioner is a call from home. But it decided whether the service could be offered at all, and to whom.

CMS then explained the payment problem. Under the old approach, a check-in that led to a visit was paid through the visit, and one that did not was not paid. “Effectively,” CMS wrote, “the better practitioners are” at furnishing effective check-ins that avoid unnecessary visits, “the fewer billable services they furnish.” It said this created incentives inconsistent with current trends in medical practice and potentially undermined payment accuracy.

The logic is coherent. If a practice resolves a patient’s concern by phone, it has done work that would otherwise have been paid as a visit. Paying for the call removes a reason to bring the patient in. But the fix had a consequence the reasoning did not dwell on: the work that had been free to the patient now carried cost sharing. The proposed rule acknowledged that consequence directly when it turned to consent, and the four parts follow from it.

The door: established patients and the billing practitioner

The proposed code descriptor for the virtual check-in described a service by “a physician or other qualified health care professional who can report evaluation and management services, provided to an established patient,” with “5-10 minutes of medical discussion.” The proposed rule, published in the Federal Register on July 27, 2018, explained the limit to established patients: CMS believed “the practitioner needs to have an existing relationship with the patient, and therefore, basic knowledge of the patient’s medical condition and needs.”

For the photo review service, CMS was less certain. It asked whether the service should be limited to established patients, or whether, in cases such as dermatology or ophthalmology, a new patient might appropriately receive it. Its example was a patient seeking care for a skin condition from a dermatologist she had not seen before, sending images so the dermatologist could judge whether an in-person visit was needed.

From the patient’s side, the door rule determines whether a free-seeming question becomes a service at all. An established patient who calls with a question may receive a billable check-in. A new patient asking the same question of a practice she has never visited cannot, under the proposed descriptor, receive the same billable service. The practice still has to decide how to answer her, and the answer is likely to be an appointment.

The descriptor also required the service to be furnished by a practitioner who can report evaluation and management services. That excludes calls handled entirely by nurses or other clinical staff from this code. The final rule said so explicitly, as discussed below. For a health system, that turns the door into a workflow question: which calls reach a billing practitioner, which are handled by staff and how the system knows which is which when it decides whether to bill.

Office visit billing already depends on whether a patient is new or established. The virtual check-in added a need to apply that status at the moment a message or call arrives, before anyone has decided whether it will become a visit. For a contact center or nurse line, that means the patient’s status should be visible to the person answering, and the routing rules should reflect it.

The proposed rule was candid about the patient’s financial role. CMS said it expected these services to be initiated by the patient, “especially since many beneficiaries would be financially liable for sharing in the cost of these services. For the same reason, we believe it is important for patients to consent to receiving these services, and we are specifically seeking comment on whether we should require, for example, verbal consent that would be noted in the medical record for each service.”

That sentence describes the change in the patient’s experience exactly. A call that had cost the patient nothing could now produce a coinsurance amount on a statement. CMS proposed pricing the service below an in-person visit, to reflect the low work time and intensity, but a lower price is still a price. A patient who did not expect a charge for a phone call may read the statement as an error and call the billing office about it.

Consent is the obvious answer, and the question CMS asked was about its form. Written consent for each call would be burdensome. A one-time agreement would be easy to file and easy to forget. Verbal consent documented in the record for each service, the option CMS floated, puts the burden on the practitioner at the moment of the call and leaves a record that can be audited.

For a health system’s revenue cycle and patient financial services teams, the operational questions follow directly. Someone has to tell the patient, before or at the start of the call, that the service may be billed and that cost sharing may apply. Someone has to record that the patient agreed. The billing system has to be able to find that record before a claim is sent. And the billing office has to be ready to explain a small charge for a phone call to a patient who does not remember agreeing to it.

There is also a design question about what happens when consent is refused. A patient who declines a billable check-in still has a question. The practice has to decide whether it answers without billing, offers an appointment or does something else, and it has to treat patients in the same situation consistently. Each answer has a cost, and none is in the rule.

The calendar: seven days back, 24 hours forward

The proposed descriptor made the check-in billable only if it was “not originating from a related E/M service provided within the previous 7 days nor leading to an E/M service or procedure within the next 24 hours or soonest available appointment.” CMS proposed that a check-in arising from a related visit in the previous seven days by the same practitioner would be bundled into that visit, and that one leading to an in-person visit with the same practitioner would be bundled into the pre- or post-visit time of that visit. It said the service was partially modeled on CPT code 99441 for telephone evaluation and management, whose descriptor carried the same seven-day and 24-hour language.

CMS was open about the risk in a time window. “We do not want to bundle only the services that occur within 24 hours of a visit only to see a significant number of visits occurring at 25 hours after the initial service,” it wrote, and asked whether to broaden the window or the circumstances for bundling.

For the patient, the calendar rule produces outcomes that are hard to explain. Two patients make the same call. One is told to come in the next morning; the call is bundled and not billed. The other is told the condition can wait, or the next appointment is several days away; the call may be billed. The patient who needed less care, or who could not get an appointment quickly, pays. The rule’s logic is sound from a payment point of view, since the bundled call is paid through the visit, but it is not visible to the patient.

For a provider organization, the calendar rule makes the scheduling system part of the billing decision. To bill correctly, the organization has to know, at claim time, whether the patient had a related visit with the same practitioner in the previous seven days and whether the call led to a visit within 24 hours or at the soonest available appointment. The phrase “soonest available appointment” is especially difficult, because it requires knowing what was available when the call took place as well as what was booked. Commenters raised this difficulty, as the final rule records.

The calendar also links the check-in to the organization’s access. If appointments are scarce, more check-ins lead to visits days later rather than within 24 hours, and more check-ins become billable. That is a payment consequence of a capacity problem, and it lands on patients as a charge.

The channel: phones, portals, photos and privacy

CMS did not define the technology in the proposal. It said it understood that the kinds of communication technology used for these services had broadened, and it asked what types practitioners used, “including whether audio-only telephone interactions are sufficient compared to interactions that are enhanced with video or other kinds of data transmission.”

The photo review service was by definition asynchronous. The proposed descriptor described “remote evaluation of recorded video and/or images submitted by the patient (e.g., store and forward), including interpretation with verbal follow-up with the patient within 24 business hours.” CMS noted that under the telehealth statute, payment for store-and-forward telehealth is permitted only in federal demonstration programs in Alaska and Hawaii, and explained why it did not consider these new services to be Medicare telehealth services subject to those limits. It added that “in furnishing these proposed services, practitioners would need to comply with any applicable privacy and security laws, including the HIPAA Privacy Rule.”

That last sentence is where the patient experience and the security function meet. A patient who photographs a rash and sends it to a practice uses whatever channel the practice offers, or whatever channel the patient already has. If the practice offers a secure portal upload, the image lands in a controlled system. If it does not, the image may arrive by personal email or text message to a clinician’s phone. In our reading, the proposal did not change any privacy rule; it created a payment reason to receive patient images, and therefore a reason for every practice to decide how it would receive them.

The 24-business-hour follow-up in the proposed descriptor added a service level. A practice that billed for reviewing an image needed to answer the patient within that time. For a health system, that is a queue with a deadline, and someone has to own it: who watches incoming images, who reviews them, how the response is sent and how the time is recorded.

Choosing the channel also decides who can use the service. A portal-only design excludes patients who do not use the portal. A phone-only design excludes images. An organization that wants the service to work for its whole Medicare population needs more than one route, each meeting its own privacy and documentation requirements.

One call traced through the four parts

The parts are clearest when followed through a single call under the proposed rules. An established Medicare patient calls her primary care practice about a new symptom. She was last seen three weeks earlier for something unrelated.

At the door, the person answering has to see that she is established and route the call to a practitioner who can bill evaluation and management services, if the practice intends the call to be a billable check-in. If a nurse handles the question alone, there is no billable service, and nothing more is needed for billing.

At the bill, the practitioner, or someone before the practitioner, tells her that the call may be billed and that cost sharing may apply, and asks whether she agrees. Her answer is recorded. If she declines, the practice follows whatever policy it has set for that case.

At the calendar, the practitioner spends five to ten minutes on medical discussion and decides. If she needs to be seen and can come in the next morning, the call is bundled into that visit and not billed separately. If the symptom can be managed without a visit, or the soonest available appointment is days away, the call may be billable on its own. Her previous visit was three weeks ago and unrelated, so the seven-day look-back does not bundle it.

At the channel, the call happened by telephone. Had she sent a photo through the portal instead, the photo review service, with its own follow-up deadline, would have applied, and the image would be stored in the record.

At each step, a different system holds the fact that decides the outcome: the registration system for her status, the call record or chart for her consent and the discussion, the scheduling system for the visits before and after, and the portal or phone system for the channel. The claim is correct only if all four agree. That is the practical reason to treat the four parts as separate workstreams with separate owners, and then to test them together.

Telehealth’s statutory limits stayed where they were

The virtual services sat beside, not inside, Medicare’s telehealth benefit, and the same proposal showed how narrow that benefit remained. The fact sheet proposed adding two codes for prolonged preventive services to the list of Medicare telehealth services. It also proposed implementing the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 for two groups: beneficiaries with end-stage renal disease receiving home dialysis, for whom renal dialysis facilities and the patient’s home would be added as originating sites without the usual geographic requirements for the monthly clinical assessments, and beneficiaries with acute stroke, for whom mobile stroke units would be added as originating sites and the originating site type and geographic requirements would not apply. Both changes were proposed effective January 1, 2019.

Those were statutory changes for specific conditions. For everyone else, in our reading of the rules as they stood in July 2018, a full visit by video from home was still outside the telehealth benefit, because the statute limited originating sites and geography. The virtual check-in did not change that. It paid for a brief exchange to decide whether a visit was needed, not for the visit itself.

That boundary is part of the patient’s experience too. A patient who has a five-minute call with a practitioner may reasonably ask why the same practitioner cannot simply treat the problem on the call, or by video. Under the 2018 framework, the answer depended on which service was being furnished and which statute governed it. Front-line staff needed a plain explanation of the difference, because patients would ask.

For a health system’s virtual care strategy, the boundary meant two separate product lines with different rules: brief communication services available broadly to established patients, and telehealth visits available only in the circumstances the statute allowed. Designing the patient journey so that one leads sensibly to the other, rather than confusingly to a refusal, was a design task the rule left to providers.

Services the patient never sees: e-consults and monitoring

The same proposal reached further than calls and photos. The fact sheet listed separate payment for new codes describing chronic care remote physiologic monitoring and interprofessional internet consultation. The second of those shows the patient experience problem in its sharpest form.

The interprofessional codes, the proposed rule explained, describe assessment and management through telephone, internet or electronic health record consultations, when a patient’s treating practitioner asks a consulting practitioner with specialty expertise for advice “without the need for the patient’s face-to-face contact with the consulting physician.” CMS had declined to pay separately for such services in 2014, treating them as bundled. It now proposed to pay for them, noting that under the bundled approach specialist input was sought, in its words, “through scheduling a separate visit for the patient when a phone or internet-based interaction between the treating practitioner and the consulting practitioner would have been sufficient.”

Because these services happen without the patient present, CMS proposed that the treating practitioner “obtain verbal beneficiary consent in advance of these services, which would be documented by the treating practitioner in the medical record,” and added: “Obtaining advance consent includes ensuring that the patient is aware of applicable cost sharing.”

From the patient’s side, this is a service performed by a clinician the patient may never meet, on a day the patient may not know about, producing a charge the patient agreed to in advance during a different conversation. The consent conversation carries the whole of the patient’s understanding. If it is rushed, or recorded without being held, the statement that follows will be a surprise.

For a health system, the e-consult adds a twist to the four parts. The door is the treating practitioner’s referral decision. The bill depends on consent obtained by one practitioner for work billed by another. The calendar matters less, but the record has to connect the request, the consultation and the report. And the channel is clinician to clinician, by telephone, internet or the electronic health record as the codes describe, which makes it an internal workflow and documentation question more than a patient-facing one.

Documentation: one half of the proposal removed, the other added

The press release led with documentation burden, and the proposed rule’s headline change for office visits was large. CMS proposed a single payment rate for new patient office visit levels 2 through 5 and another for established patient levels 2 through 5, and a minimum documentation standard tied to level 2 requirements for Medicare payment purposes. It said eliminating the payment distinction would “eliminate the need to audit against the visit levels” and provide “immediate relief from the burden of documentation.”

The virtual services moved the other way. Each new billable check-in, image review or e-consult needed its own documentation: the patient’s status, the practitioner, the medical discussion, the time, the consent and the absence of related visits inside the windows. CMS asked in the proposed rule how clinicians “could best document the medical necessity of this service.”

We do not see a contradiction in this. The two changes addressed different services. But for the clinicians and staff who experience documentation as a single workload, the proposal removed requirements from one kind of encounter and created them for several new ones. For a CMIO, the practical implication was to build the documentation for the new services into the electronic record as structured fields and templates, so that the consent and timing facts were captured once and found again at billing, without adding free-text notes that no one would search.

The patient sees none of this directly. What the patient sees is whether the clinician seems to be talking to them or to a screen, and whether the bill that follows matches what they were told. Good structured documentation helps both.

Clinics paid under their own systems

Rural Health Clinics and Federally Qualified Health Centers are paid differently from practices under the physician fee schedule, so CMS proposed a separate route for them. They would bill a newly created virtual communications G-code for check-ins and remote evaluations furnished by an RHC or FQHC practitioner when there was no associated billable visit, under the same seven-day and 24-hour conditions, with payment set at the average of the national non-facility fee schedule rates for the two new services.

For these clinics the four parts apply with their own edges. The door rule depends on the clinic’s definition of an established patient. The consent and cost-sharing question meets patients who may be especially sensitive to small charges. The calendar rule depends on appointment availability, which may be limited. And the channel question meets patients whose connectivity varies; commenters on the virtual check-in, the final rule records, noted that not all patients have the same level of connectivity and recommended allowing audio-only communication.

For a health system that owns both fee-schedule practices and RHCs or FQHCs, the two routes mean two billing configurations for what a patient experiences as the same service. The patient-facing explanation, the consent script and the scheduling logic should be consistent across both, even though the codes differ.

How to tell whether the experience works

The proposal did not set any measure of patient experience for the new services. A health system that offered them would need its own, and the four parts suggest where to look.

For the door, the useful measure is how requests are resolved: how many calls and messages from established patients become billable check-ins, how many are handled by staff without billing and how many become appointments. A sharp difference between clinics serving similar patients points to a routing or training issue rather than a clinical one.

For the bill, the measure is surprise: billing inquiries and complaints about remote service charges, and claims held for missing consent. A rising number of either says the consent conversation is not doing its job.

For the calendar, the measure is the pattern of visits after check-ins. CMS itself worried about visits clustering just outside the 24-hour window. A provider organization can watch the same pattern in its own data, both to protect itself in an audit and to see whether access problems are turning into charges.

For the channel, the measures are response times against the follow-up promise and the share of images and messages arriving through approved channels. An image that arrives by personal text message is a privacy exception and a sign that the approved channel is not working for patients.

No number on this list requires new technology. Each comes from data a health system already holds about calls, claims, appointments and messages. Collected together, they turn the four parts from a design exercise into something leaders can watch.

Objections: small money, good intentions, and simple calls

One objection is that the amounts involved were small, so the experience questions were minor. The proposal priced the check-in below an in-person visit. But a small charge the patient did not expect is still a complaint, and the consent and documentation duties attach to each billed service regardless of size. The operational cost of getting the process wrong can exceed the revenue from getting it right.

A second objection is that CMS meant the change to help patients, so dwelling on the bill misreads it. The press release did present it as improving access and convenience, and the proposed rule argued that bundling created incentives that penalized practitioners for resolving problems remotely. Both can be true. A payment change can make a service more available and also introduce a charge that the patient has to understand and agree to. The four parts are about delivering the first without mishandling the second.

A third objection is that a phone call is simple and does not need four workstreams. The call itself is simple. Deciding whether it is billable is not, because that depends on the patient’s status, the practitioner’s role, the patient’s consent, the visits before and after, and the channel used. Each of those lives in a different system.

A fourth objection is that practices could just not bill. Some might choose that. But not billing does not remove the experience questions; it removes the revenue while keeping the work. And a practice that bills inconsistently, sometimes charging and sometimes not for the same kind of call, creates its own fairness and compliance problems.

A fifth objection is that the problem belongs to Medicare, and that commercial and Medicaid patients may see different rules. If so, that makes the case for the four parts stronger. A health system serving several payers needs a consistent patient-facing approach to remote services, with payer-specific billing rules behind it. Building the Medicare version as a one-off would leave the organization redesigning the experience for every payer that followed.

What a health system leader can check

The four parts translate into checks that a CMIO, a revenue cycle leader or an ambulatory operations director can run on any virtual service, then and now.

  • Confirm the person who answers a call or message can see whether the patient is established and whether the request should reach a billing practitioner.
  • Write the consent script, decide where consent is recorded and test that the billing system will not send a claim without it.
  • Check that the scheduling and billing systems can see related visits before and after the service, and decide how the organization will evidence the soonest available appointment.
  • List every channel through which patients can send images or messages, and confirm each one is approved for protected health information, with an owner for the response queue.
  • Prepare billing office staff to explain a charge for a phone call, and track those calls as a measure of whether consent is working.

Each check produces something an auditor or a patient advocate can review: a routing rule, a script, a field in the record, a list of channels, a log of questions. Those are the pieces that decide whether the service feels like access or like a surprise. They also travel: the same checks apply to any later remote service a payer decides to price, whatever its code, because each new code brings the same four questions about who may use it, what the patient pays, when it counts and how it is delivered.

With hindsight

The final rule answered the proposal part by part, and the answers are a useful test of the 2018 reading. CMS finalized both services in its calendar year 2019 physician fee schedule final rule, published in the Federal Register on November 23, 2018, with permanent codes: G2012 for the virtual check-in and G2010 for the remote evaluation of patient-submitted images or video.

On the door, CMS kept G2012 to established patients, citing commenters’ concern about furnishing the service without familiarity with individual patients and the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission’s concern about increases in volume “not related to ongoing, informed patient care.” It deferred to the CPT definition of an established patient, after commenters asked whether patients seen by another practitioner in the same group practice would count. Having asked whether new patients might receive the photo review service, it finalized G2010 only for established patients too. It also stated that telephone calls “that involve only clinical staff could not be billed using HCPCS code G2012,” because the code requires direct interaction between the patient and the billing practitioner.

On the bill, CMS noted that many commenters found per-service consent burdensome, but said it was “persuaded by those commenters who suggest that unexpected cost to beneficiaries would be particularly problematic.” It required “verbal consent that is noted in the medical record for each billed service” for G2012, and for G2010 consent “that could be verbal or written, including electronic confirmation.”

On the calendar, it kept the seven-day, 24-hour and soonest-available-appointment language. It acknowledged that “it might be challenging to prove whether or not other appointments were available,” but said the wording guarded against abuse better than a purely time-based window, and that it would monitor the service. Commenters had offered alternatives, the final rule records, including dropping “or soonest available appointment,” extending the forward window to 48 hours, or using 14 days before and 72 hours after the service. CMS did not adopt them. It also did not set a frequency limit for 2019, saying it would monitor utilization and consider a limit in future rulemaking.

On the channel, it was “persuaded by the comments advising us not to be overly prescriptive,” and allowed audio-only real-time telephone interactions as well as audio interactions enhanced with video or other data. For the photo review, it finalized that follow-up could take place by phone, audio or video, secure text messaging, email or patient portal, and dropped the word “verbal” from the descriptor, noting that “any such communications must be compliant with HIPAA and other relevant laws.”

The code itself did not last. In its calendar year 2025 final rule, published December 9, 2024, CMS described a new CPT code 98016 whose descriptor “mirrors existing HCPCS code G2012” and which, per CPT Editorial Panel materials, “is intended to replace that code.” CMS finalized separate payment for 98016 in lieu of G2012 and wrote that “HCPCS code G2012 will no longer exist in CY 2025.” The descriptor carried over the established-patient limit and the same seven-day and 24-hour conditions. Two of the four parts, the door and the calendar, outlived the code that introduced them, written into the descriptor of its replacement.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • Medicare
  • virtual check-in
  • physician fee schedule
  • patient consent
  • store and forward
  • telehealth