FITARA scorecards 1 to 15, 2015 to 2022: what the federal IT grades show

We counted every overall grade the House oversight scorecard gave 24 agencies in its first 15 editions to see how far federal IT management moved and where it stalled.

What the scorecard is

The Federal Information Technology Acquisition Reform Act (FITARA) was enacted in December 2014, and in November 2015 the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee began grading agencies on four areas of it: data center consolidation, IT portfolio review savings, incremental development and risk assessment transparency, combined into one overall grade from A to F [5]. The scorecard grades 24 major agencies, and later editions added other statutory topics, such as software licensing, working capital funds, cybersecurity, chief information officer (CIO) reporting lines and the move off the old Networx telecom contracts [7] [1]. The first grades rested on data GAO collected at the committee's request [5]. GAO reported in January 2022 that the scorecards had been effective oversight tools and that grades had improved steadily [7].

The scorecard was issued twice a year with a subcommittee hearing; the 15th, "FITARA 15.0", was the subject of one on December 15, 2022 [6], and it is the last scorecard hearing we found. The series continued after it. A press release of September 17, 2024 from Representative Gerald E. Connolly, ranking member of the Subcommittee on Cybersecurity, Information Technology, and Government Innovation, announced that he would host a roundtable on "the 18th iteration of the FITARA Scorecard" on September 20, 2024 [10], so editions 16, 17 and 18 exist. We found no official copy of their grades, on a House site still online or in an archived copy of one, as checked on 16 November 2026, so this report does not count them and says nothing about their grades. On the committee's own website, a search for "FITARA" returned no item dated after September 16, 2022 when we checked on 16 November 2026 [14].

Data and method

Source of grades: the December 2022 scorecard ("COR Biannual Scorecard - December 2022"), which prints every agency's overall grade for all 15 editions from November 2015 to December 2022 in one table [1]. The committee's Democratic staff site hosted it; the file is no longer served there, so we used the Internet Archive copy of the exact official URL; adding "id_" after the capture time in that link downloads the original PDF [1]. To repeat the count: extract the words on the page with their coordinates (we used the PyMuPDF library), assign each grade to the agency row and edition column it sits in, check the grid against the page image, then apply the rules below.

  • Cross-check: the same agency histories appear in the June 2019 and December 2020 scorecards and agree with the December 2022 table [3] [2]. The November 2017 scorecard prints USAID's December 2016 and June 2017 grades as "D+" and "A+", where the later scorecards print "D-" and "A-"; the letters are the same, so no count changes [4] [1]. The December 2020 scorecard labels the 10th edition "Aug 2020" and the December 2022 scorecard labels it "July 2020"; we use the later label [2] [1]. The November 2015 counts match the original one-page scorecard (0 A, 2 B, 5 C, 14 D, 3 F) [5].
  • Letters only: from December 2016 to July 2022 many printed grades carry a plus or minus (for example "C+" or "D-"), and the December 2022 grades have none [1]. We count by letter, as the scorecards' own tally rows do, so "C+" and "C-" are both C [1].
  • Up or down: an agency counts as up or down when its letter changes from the previous edition; a change from "C+" to "C" is no change. On this rule our counts match the arrows printed on the December 2020 scorecard (3 up, 16 unchanged, 5 down) and the December 2022 scorecard (7 up, 17 unchanged, 0 down) [2] [1].
  • June 2019: the scorecard printed two grades for four agencies (HUD, VA, EPA and SSA) and two sets of totals and change counts, without a note we could find on the page [3]. We show both sets: the first uses the left-hand grade in each split cell (C+, B+, D+ and B+), the second the right-hand one (B+, C+, C+ and C+) [3]. Headline totals use the first set.
  • Components: counts of A and of D or F per component, read from the November 2017, June 2019, December 2020 and December 2022 scorecards [4] [3] [2] [1].
  • Out of scope: editions 16 to 18 exist (the 18th is named in the roundtable notice [10]), but as checked on 16 November 2026 we could not find an official copy of their grades on a House site still online or in an archived copy of one, so every count here stops at the 15th edition, December 2022. The series did not end then.

Two published tallies differ from the grade cells. The committee staff memo for the 15.0 hearing is dated December 12, 2022 and says the scorecard would be released before the hearing; for December 2022 it gives 1 A, 10 B, 13 C, 0 D and 0 F, with 5 agencies up, 0 down and 19 unchanged [6]. The published December 2022 scorecard's cells give 1 A, 12 B and 11 C, and its own tally row and arrows agree with the cells: 7 up, 17 unchanged, 0 down [1]. For July 2022 the memo gives 1 A, 7 B, 14 C and 2 D, which matches the scorecard's cells, while the scorecard's printed tally row for that column shows 1 A, 9 B, 12 C and 2 D [6] [1]. Neither document explains the differences. We count from the cells.

Overall grades: from mostly D to all C or better

Overall grades by scorecard edition, counted from the December 2022 scorecard's historical grades for 24 agencies [1]
Edition (date as published)ABCDFAgencies up a letterAgencies down a letter
1 (Nov 2015) [1]0 [1]2 [1]5 [1]14 [1]3 [1]n/an/a
2 (May 2016) [1]0 [1]1 [1]12 [1]10 [1]1 [1]7 [1]1 [1]
3 (Dec 2016) [1]0 [1]8 [1]10 [1]5 [1]1 [1]12 [1]1 [1]
4 (June 2017) [1]1 [1]7 [1]10 [1]5 [1]1 [1]4 [1]5 [1]
5 (Nov 2017) [1]1 [1]4 [1]14 [1]3 [1]2 [1]3 [1]6 [1]
6 (May 2018) [1]0 [1]3 [1]12 [1]8 [1]1 [1]5 [1]11 [1]
7 (Dec 2018) [1]0 [1]11 [1]7 [1]6 [1]0 [1]11 [1]0 [1]
8 (June 2019) [1]0 [1]8 / 7 [1] [3]12 / 14 [1] [3]4 / 3 [1] [3]0 [1]5 / 6 [1] [3]5 / 6 [1] [3]
9 (Dec 2019) [1]3 [1]4 [1]15 [1]2 [1]0 [1]7 [1]4 [1]
10 (July 2020) [1]2 [1]8 [1]14 [1]0 [1]0 [1]7 [1]3 [1]
11 (Dec 2020) [1]0 [1]10 [1]14 [1]0 [1]0 [1]3 [1]5 [1]
12 (July 2021) [1]1 [1]10 [1]12 [1]1 [1]0 [1]3 [1]2 [1]
13 (Dec 2021) [1]2 [1]10 [1]12 [1]0 [1]0 [1]7 [1]4 [1]
14 (July 2022) [1]1 [1]7 [1]14 [1]2 [1]0 [1]1 [1]8 [1]
15 (Dec 2022) [1]1 [1]12 [1]11 [1]0 [1]0 [1]7 [1]0 [1]

In November 2015, 7 of 24 agencies scored C or better and 17 scored D or F [1]. By December 2022 all 24 did, with 13 at A or B [1]. No agency has received an F since May 2018, and December 2022 was the fourth edition with no D at all, after July 2020, December 2020 and December 2021 [1]. GAO's own count for the same span, from 29% to 100% of agencies at C or higher between November 2015 and December 2021, agrees with ours [7].

A grades stayed rare. Across 15 editions the most in any one was 3, in December 2019, and only four agencies ever received one: Education, GSA, NSF and USAID [1]. Comparing first and last editions, 19 agencies ended a letter or more higher than they started, 5 ended where they began and none ended lower [1].

Moraph's view

Moraph's view: the climb is real but most of it came early. The jump from mostly D to mostly C happened between November 2015 and December 2018, and after that the typical agency moved between B and C for four years. That pattern fits a tool that pushes hard on what it measures until most agencies clear it, then needs new measures to keep pushing, which is how the committee and GAO described the job in 2022.

Movement between editions: more ups than downs, but grades were not stable

Across the 14 changes between editions there were 82 moves up a letter and 55 moves down, with the rest unchanged; counting the second set of June 2019 grades gives 83 and 56 [1] [3]. Two editions stand out for falls. In May 2018, 11 agencies dropped a letter and 5 rose; in July 2022, 8 dropped and 1 rose, and December 2022 then recovered with 7 up and none down [1]. Some agencies swung repeatedly: DHS went up 4 times and down 5, and SSA up 5 times and down 4 [1].

Overall grades for selected editions, exactly as published; June 2019 shows the two grades printed for four agencies [1] [3]
AgencyNov 2015 [1]Nov 2017 [1]Dec 2018 [1]June 2019 [1]Dec 2020 [1]July 2022 [1]Dec 2022 [1]Source
Agriculture (USDA)DC-D-C-B+C+C[1]
Commerce (DOC)BB+C+C+C+C+B[1]
Defense (DOD)DF+D+C+C+D+C[1]
Education (Ed.)FB+B+B+B+B+B[1]
EnergyFD+B+C+C+C+C[1]
Health and Human Services (HHS)DD-B+C-BBB[1]
Homeland Security (DHS)CC-C-D-CCC[1]
Housing and Urban Development (HUD)DC-C+C+ / B+C+C+C[1]
Interior (DOI)CC+C+C+C+C+C[1]
Justice (DOJ)DC-D-C-C-C-B[1]
Labor (DOL)DD-B-B-B-B-B[1]
StateDC-C-C-C-BB[1]
Transportation (DOT)DF+C+C+C+D+C[1]
Treasury (Treas.)DC-D-C-BCB[1]
Veterans Affairs (VA)CB+B+B+ / C+B+C+C[1]
EPACC+C+D+ / C+B+C+B[1]
GSABB+B+B+B+B+B[1]
NASAFC+B+D-C+C+B[1]
NSFDC-B+B+B+B+B[1]
NRCCC-D-C-C-BB[1]
OPMDC+D+D+C+C+C[1]
SBADC-B+B+C+C+C[1]
SSADC+B+B+ / C+C+C+C[1]
USAIDDA-B-B-BAA[1]

The agencies that moved furthest started lowest. Education, Energy and NASA all began with an F in November 2015; by December 2022 Education and NASA had a B and Energy a C [1]. USAID went from D to A, the only agency at A in December 2022 [1]. Commerce and GSA began at B and ended at B, after reaching "A+" (GSA) and falling to "C+" (Commerce) along the way [1].

The categories changed often, so only some can be followed across editions. GAO reported that all 24 agencies received A grades for software licensing and the data center optimization initiative during 2020 and 2021, which led to the removal of those two components [8]. The December 2022 scorecard grades data centers on "Closures", lists two new categories as previews (a federal cybersecurity progress report and CIO reporting structure, budget and acquisitions), and grades the telecom transition only as "F" or "P" [1]. GAO also gave the subcommittee ideas for further measures, including legacy system modernization and customer experience [9].

Component grades across four scorecards: agencies graded A, and graded D or F
ComponentNov 2017 [4]June 2019 [3]Dec 2020 [2]Dec 2022 [1]
Incremental developmentA 15, D or F 6 [4]A 11, D or F 4 [3]A 10, D or F 5 [2]A 20, D or F 3 [1]
Transparency and risk management (IT Dashboard)A 5, D or F 9 [4]A 8, D or F 5 [3]A 8, D or F 4 [2]A 8, D or F 4 [1]
Portfolio review savings (PortfolioStat)A 5, D or F 9 [4]A 8, D or F 5 [3]A 8, D or F 4 [2]A 8, D or F 4 [1]
Data centers (DCOI; "Closures" in Dec 2022) [1]A 3, D or F 9 [4]A 4, D or F 6 [3]A 19, D or F 1 [2]A 19, D or F 0 [1]
Software licensing (MEGABYTE)A 6, F 17 [4]A 20, F 4 [3]A 24 [2]Removed [8]
Modernizing Government Technology (MGT)Not graded [4]A 3, D or F 4 [3]A 3, D or F 2 [2]A 5, D or F 1 [1]
Cyber (FISMA)Not graded [4]A 1, D or F 12 (23 graded) [3]A 1, D or F 5 (23 graded) [2]A 4, D or F 7 (23 graded) [1]
Telecom transition (EIS)Not graded [4]Not graded [3]A 8, D or F 8 [2]F 19, "P" 5 [1]

Two components appear to rank agencies against each other rather than against a fixed bar. The scorecards mark transparency and risk management and portfolio review savings as graded in "Tiers", and in each of the four editions the two components have the same spread of grades as each other: 8 A, 6 B, 6 C, 3 D and 1 F in both December 2020 and December 2022, for example [1] [2]. A spread that stays fixed cannot show government-wide progress. The components scored against fixed tests improved: agencies with an A for incremental development rose from 15 in November 2017 to 20 in December 2022, and for data centers from 3 to 19 [4] [1]. Cyber improved from a low base and still had the most low grades. In June 2019, 1 of 23 graded agencies had an A and 12 had a D or F; in December 2022, 4 had an A and 7 a D or F, the most D or F grades of any component graded A to F that edition [3] [1].

Moraph's view

Moraph's view: the scorecard moved agencies most where the test was a countable fact an agency could change, such as closing data centers or keeping a license inventory. It left the most low grades on cybersecurity, which rests on inspector general and OMB assessments that we expect to take years to shift. Leaders reading old grades should separate the tiered components, which always hand out the same mix of grades, from the fixed ones, which show real change.

What GAO says now

GAO has listed improving IT acquisitions and management as a government-wide high-risk area since 2015 [12]. In February 2025 it lowered two of the area's five ratings: leadership commitment fell from met to not met, and action plan from partially met to not met [12]. GAO said OMB had not revised its FITARA guidance since 2015 and that the guidance is now outdated [12]. Of 1,881 recommendations GAO has made in the area since 2010, 463 were not implemented as of January 2025, including 32 of 69 priority recommendations [11].

A November 2024 GAO report found that none of the 24 agencies fully met FITARA's requirements for annual IT portfolio reviews, and that OMB was not fully meeting eight of the law's requirements [13]. It made 46 recommendations; when we checked on 16 November 2026, GAO's page showed 1 closed as implemented and 45 open [13]. GAO reports that about 80% of the money the government invests in IT each year is reportedly spent operating and maintaining systems, many of them legacy systems [11].

Moraph's view

Moraph's view: the scorecard years and GAO's 2025 downgrade tell one story from two sides. While a subcommittee graded agencies twice a year at public hearings, letters rose; since the last scorecard hearing we found, in December 2022, GAO has found OMB guidance unrevised since 2015 and portfolio reviews unmet across all 24 agencies. We read that as a sign that regular public questioning mattered, though the two findings alone cannot prove cause.

What to watch

  • GAO's next high-risk update after the one of February 25, 2025, and whether leadership commitment for IT management stays at not met [12].
  • Whether any House committee, subcommittee or member issues a new edition after the 18th, and whether it keeps the 24-agency letter grades or changes the method [10].
  • Progress on the 46 recommendations in GAO's November 2024 portfolio report, shown on its public page [13].
  • Any OMB guidance that replaces the 2015 FITARA implementation guidance GAO called outdated [12].

This report describes published grades and official findings. It is not legal advice and does not say what any law requires of a particular agency or contractor.

What this means for you

  • Federal agency CIOs: Whether or not new scorecards appear, the high-risk area remains on GAO's list with leadership commitment rated not met [12], and GAO's page showed 45 of its 46 portfolio review recommendations open when checked on 16 November 2026 [13]. Keeping the evidence for each statutory FITARA requirement current leaves an agency ready for an audit or any future scorecard.
  • Deputy secretaries and agency CFOs: The components that moved agencies most were the ones tied to budget and organization, such as data center closures and license inventories [1] [8]. CIO reporting lines and IT working capital funds are decisions at your level, and the December 2022 scorecard still graded MGT funding below A for 19 of 24 agencies [1].
  • Companies that sell IT to federal agencies: GAO reports that about 80% of federal IT spending is reportedly spent operating and maintaining existing systems [11]. Proposals that show incremental delivery and a clear path off legacy systems match the measures the scorecard and GAO have tracked for a decade.
  • State and local IT leaders: Under a public, twice-yearly letter grade, federal agencies' overall grades rose from 7 of 24 at C or better to all 24 [1], and GAO credits congressional oversight by the subcommittee with helping spur improvements [12]. A legislature or council weighing similar oversight could use fixed tests rather than tiers, so that grades can show real progress, and plan to refresh measures once most agencies pass them.

Moraph predictions

Every prediction is Moraph's view, not a fact. Each has a date, a confidence level (70% means we expect to be wrong about three times in ten) and a test anyone can apply. We score them on this page when the date comes and never remove one. How we make and score predictions.

  1. P1 By Confidence 85% Open

    GAO publishes its 2027 High-Risk List update with "Improving IT Acquisitions and Management" still listed as a high-risk area.

    How we will check: Open GAO's high-risk page or the 2027 High-Risk Series report published on or before June 30, 2027. Right if the report is published by that date and lists the area; wrong if the area is removed or no update is published by that date.

    Basis: GAO has listed the area since 2015 and lowered two of its five ratings in February 2025 [12]; 463 of its recommendations in the area were open as of January 2025 [11]. GAO's latest update was published on February 25, 2025 [12].

  2. P2 By Confidence 75% Open

    In its 2027 High-Risk update, GAO does not rate leadership commitment for "Improving IT Acquisitions and Management" as met.

    How we will check: Read the rating for leadership commitment for the area in the GAO High-Risk Series report published on or before June 30, 2027. Right if it is "partially met" or "not met"; wrong if "met" or if no update is published by that date.

    Basis: The rating fell from met to not met in February 2025 because OMB had not maintained leadership commitment, including guidance unrevised since 2015 [12]; OMB was not fully meeting eight FITARA requirements in November 2024 [13].

  3. P3 By Confidence 65% Open

    At least 5 of the 46 recommendations in GAO-25-107041 (IT portfolio management) are shown as closed and implemented on GAO's product page.

    How we will check: Open https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-25-107041 on or after December 31, 2027 and count recommendations marked "Closed - Implemented". Right if 5 or more.

    Basis: GAO made 46 recommendations, 10 to OMB and 36 to 24 agencies; when checked on 16 November 2026 its page showed 1 closed as implemented and 45 open [13].

Facts on this page link to their sources. Text marked "Moraph's view", and every prediction, is our own analysis, not a fact or advice. Methodology.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the piece where needed.

  • FITARA
  • federal IT
  • scorecard
  • GAO high-risk list
  • CIO authority
  • IT modernization
  • OMB