Federal electronic records and messaging apps: outlook to 2027

NARA's paper deadline has passed, so the work through 2027 is in exceptions, transfer metadata, the archive's own intake capacity and the messages officials send outside email.

Paper is closed; messages and metadata are open

Two joint OMB and NARA memoranda set the federal government's move off paper. M-19-21 of June 28, 2019 told agencies to create, keep and manage all federal records in electronic formats with appropriate metadata [1]. M-23-07 of December 23, 2022 kept those goals and moved the main dates to June 30, 2024: by then permanent records were to be managed electronically, and after it agencies must transfer permanent records to NARA in electronic form with appropriate metadata, while NARA stops accepting new analog transfers except under a limited exception [2]. That date has passed. What remains live through 2027 is the detail the deadline left behind: the exceptions, the metadata each transfer needs, NARA's capacity to take in what arrives, and the messages officials now send outside email.

This outlook covers federal records under the Federal Records Act and NARA's regulations. All statuses are as checked on November 16, 2026. It describes official documents; it is not legal advice, and it does not reach state records laws or the Presidential Records Act.

Where the instruments stand on November 16, 2026

Federal electronic records and messaging instruments, as checked on November 16, 2026
InstrumentDateWhat it requiresStatus
OMB/NARA M-19-21 [1]June 28, 2019 [1]Electronic recordkeeping with metadata; first targets of December 31, 2019 and December 31, 2022 [1]Targets replaced by M-23-07 [2]; still listed by NARA as OMB guidance [3]
OMB/NARA M-23-07 [2]December 23, 2022 [2]Permanent records electronic, and temporary records electronic or in commercial storage, by June 30, 2024; electronic transfer with metadata after it; limited exceptions [2]Still listed by NARA [3]; no rescission on OMB's current list [4]
36 CFR part 1236, subparts E and F [10] [8]Published May 4, 2023 [10]Standards and metadata for digitizing permanent records; transfer metadata entered in ERA [9] [8]In force [8]
36 CFR part 1236, subpart D [27]April 10, 2019; revised May 30, 2024 [27]Standards and validation for digitizing temporary records [27]In force [27]
NARA Bulletin 2025-01 [12]January 22, 2025 [12]Security classification metadata for transfers of permanent classified electronic records [12]Latest bulletin on NARA's index [26]
44 U.S.C. 2911 [13]Statute [13]Copy an official account, or forward a complete copy within 20 days, for records made on non-official messaging accounts [13]In force [13]
NARA Bulletin 2023-02 and GRS 6.1, Transmittal 33 [14] [15]January 2023 [14] [15]Capstone schedule extended from email to texts, chats and instant messages [14]In force [15]
AC 23.2025 and AC 35.2025 [16] [17]May 2 and September 29, 2025 [16] [17]Third-party messaging apps; a compliance assessment toolkit [16] [18]Current memos to records officers [25]
AC 11.2026 [23]August 21, 2026 [23]How the Federal Records Act applies to AI inputs, outputs, data and audit trails [23]Current [25]

We found no 2025 or 2026 change to the M-23-07 dates. NARA's policy page still lists M-19-21 and M-23-07 as OMB guidance [3], OMB's list of current memoranda shows no memorandum rescinding either [4], and none of the titles of NARA's memos to records officers for fiscal years 2025, 2026 and 2027 so far names M-23-07 [25].

The deadline passed; the exceptions carry on

M-23-07 lets NARA grant a limited exception where replacing analog records would burden the public, cost more than it saves, meet a statutory or regulatory barrier, or lose exceptional intrinsic value in the original [2]. NARA Bulletin 2020-01 asks for one package per agency, approved and sent by the Senior Agency Official for Records Management, with a business case, the cubic footage, the schedule items and time estimates for how long the exception is needed; it sets no fixed expiry [5]. NARA keeps storing and servicing analog records that reached a Federal Records Center by June 30, 2024 and accepts the permanent ones in their analog form when they fall due, but from July 1, 2024 agencies must digitize other permanent analog records before transfer [2].

NARA's Inspector General found in September 2025 that NARA had generally complied with M-23-07 in issuing guidance and handling exceptions, and that every sampled exception was documented and approved under the policy in place when it was submitted [6]. NARA wrote a new exception standard operating procedure in October 2024 [6]. The audit's one finding was about NARA itself: its Electronic Records Archives (ERA) 2.0 system could not ingest large data sets, with about 71 terabytes of accessioned unclassified records stored outside ERA 2.0 because of file size limits, against more than 168 terabytes ingested as of March 2025 [6]. Both recommendations, an analysis of how to scale ERA 2.0 and a tracking mechanism with milestones and resources, went to NARA's Chief Operating Officer [6].

Moraph's view

An all-electronic transfer rule moves the bottleneck from the agency's shelves to the archive's intake. If ERA 2.0 cannot take large transfers smoothly, agencies that have done the work may still wait, and the pressure will show up as delayed accessions rather than missed deadlines. We expect transfer capacity, not the agencies' paper, to be the constraint NARA talks about through 2027.

What agencies told NARA about 2024

NARA's consolidated report on calendar year 2024, dated December 17, 2025, is the latest official measure; it drew a 98 to 99 percent response rate [7]. Agencies' own answers show most of them past the paper deadline and a long tail that is not.

Agency self-reported results against M-23-07 and transfer duties, calendar year 2024
MeasureResult
Met the June 30, 2024 goal for permanent records in electronic format71% of agencies, up from 68% who said in the prior cycle they would [7]
Did not meet it44 agencies (29%); 22 of them had submitted an exception request [7]
Missed it with no exception request and no plan to submit one, or not yet sure18 agencies (12%), nearly 40% of them with fewer than 100 employees [7]
Met the temporary records goal71% [7]
Closed agency-operated storage facilities by June 30, 2024 (agencies that had them)66% [7]
Exception requests submitted when the report was publishedAt least 75 agencies and offices [7]
Transferred electronic records to the National Archives in 202424%, with another 4% requested but not yet moved [7]
Transferred non-electronic records in 202446% [7]

The report calls transfer of permanent records a weakness for both electronic and non-electronic records [7]. It also found a gap between the 86% of agencies using NARA's digitization standards in 36 CFR part 1236, subparts D and E, and the 71% running a validation process to check the digitized versions [7]. NARA opened the calendar year 2025 cycle from March 9 to May 15, 2026, with the same three reports plus a separate inventory of permanent electronic records over 5 terabytes [21].

Transfer now means metadata

Since M-23-07, an electronic transfer is not complete without metadata [2]. 36 CFR 1236.58 requires transfer-level metadata in ERA when the transfer request is created, including a title, inclusive dates, the creating organization, record group, general records type, access and use restrictions, and the records schedule number [8]. For digitized permanent records, 36 CFR 1236.54 requires administrative metadata to be embedded in each image file and kept in a recordkeeping system, consistent in both places, and transferred to NARA in CSV format [9]. Data files still need record layouts, data element definitions and codebooks under 36 CFR 1235.48 [11]. For classified permanent records, Bulletin 2025-01 adds classification and review elements such as previous classification, reviewing agency, review date and declassification date or event [12].

Moraph's view

The metadata rules turn records management into a systems design question. A case management, document or messaging platform that cannot export the record with its dates, creator, schedule number and restrictions leaves the agency to rebuild them by hand at transfer, years later. The cheaper path is to capture those fields when the record is made, which puts records officers in system design reviews. NARA's report found only 29% of agencies said their records staff took an active part in system development, maintenance and operations [7].

Messaging apps: an old rule meets new tools

The statutory rule predates the apps. Under 44 U.S.C. 2911, an executive agency officer or employee may not create or send a record using a non-official electronic messaging account unless an official account is copied, or a complete copy is forwarded to one within 20 days; an intentional violation can be a basis for disciplinary action [13]. In January 2023, NARA extended the Capstone approach from email to texts, chats and instant messages, including messages on personal devices that meet the definition of a record, and told agencies to avoid auto-deletion that contradicts approved disposition authorities [14]. Under GRS 6.1, messages of Capstone officials are permanent, while others' may be deleted at 7 years, or at 3 years for support and administrative positions [15].

On May 2, 2025, NARA's acting Chief Records Officer wrote that officials may conduct business on apps such as Signal and WhatsApp, but the messages are federal records, may be disposed of only under an approved schedule, and may not be assumed transitory and set for automatic deletion; the memo adds that the apps' auto-delete functions may violate recordkeeping requirements [16]. Unlawful or accidental destruction must be reported promptly to NARA with a description of the records, the circumstances and the safeguards put in place [19]. In September 2025 NARA issued a toolkit covering chat services, mobile messaging and third-party apps including Signal, WhatsApp, Telegram, WeChat and Snapchat [17]. It treats messaging as a joint records, security, technical and legal problem, says prohibiting messaging for agency business is difficult to enforce, and encourages approved apps on government-issued devices [18].

The evidence on practice is thin and points the same way. NARA found that 71% of agencies use an approved Capstone schedule for email and 55% said they were approved for other electronic messages, but 47% of those answered incorrectly when NARA checked [7]. Only 12% of agencies managing email and messages under GRS 6.1 or their own schedules had transferred these records to the National Archives, up from 5% the year before [7]. At the Department of Defense, the Inspector General's December 2025 review of seven earlier reports found personnel did not consistently follow policy on electronic messaging and records retention, and 22 of 48 recommendations in those reports remained open as of September 24, 2025; it notes that DoD policy requires such messages to be moved to a DoD records system within 20 days [20].

Moraph's view

The legal question about messaging apps is settled on paper; the gap is capture. An app with disappearing messages on a personal phone leaves the 20-day forwarding duty to individual discipline. We expect agencies that want to allow messaging to move toward enterprise-managed apps with archiving on government devices, which is where NARA's toolkit points, and expect more inspector general work on messaging rather than new statute in 2027.

Beyond the deadlines

NARA's recent guidance has been about what counts as a record rather than about dates. On August 21, 2026 it told records officers how the Federal Records Act applies to AI materials, defined as inputs, outputs, data, audit trails, software and other materials, and that AI-related federal records may be disposed of only under an approved schedule [23]. The Senate confirmed Bradford P. Wilson as the 12th Archivist of the United States on August 7, 2026 [24]; memos to records officers through October 1, 2026 were signed by an acting Chief Records Officer [21] [23], and NARA named Laura Besong Chief Records Officer effective October 18, 2026 [29]. Older oversight is still open too: GAO's 2020 report on electronic recordkeeping made 42 recommendations, and 14 were open as checked, including 3 to OMB and 3 to OPM [22].

Moraph's view

For 2027 we read three likely moves: no new deadline memo, because the dates have passed and NARA reports most agencies across them; continued pressure on transfers and ERA capacity, because that is where the Inspector General and NARA's own figures point; and more guidance by memo on what new tools create, as messaging and AI materials show. A new Archivist and Chief Records Officer could change emphasis, but we found nothing official yet that sets a new records policy.

What this means for you

  • Senior Agency Officials for Records Management and agency records officers: Keep exception records current, since Bulletin 2020-01 asks for time estimates rather than a fixed end date [5], and check whether the agency's NA-1005 actually covers messages other than email; NARA found 47% of agencies claiming that coverage answered incorrectly [7] [14].
  • Agency CIOs and owners of case, document and messaging platforms: Plan for the transfer and digitization metadata fields at the design stage, including CSV export for digitized records [8] [9], and treat messaging apps as records systems with retention settings tied to an approved schedule [16] [18].
  • Capstone officials and other agency staff who use messaging apps: Messages of Capstone officials are permanent under GRS 6.1 [15]; a record created or sent from a non-official account must copy an official account, or be forwarded in full to one within 20 days [13].
  • Contractors and software vendors serving agencies: 36 CFR 1222.32 requires agencies to specify in contracts government ownership and delivery of records, with enough technical documentation to use electronic records and data [28]; expect records, metadata and message capture questions in reviews of messaging and AI tools [18] [23].

Moraph predictions

Every prediction is Moraph's view, not a fact. Each has a date, a confidence level (70% means we expect to be wrong about three times in ten) and a test anyone can apply. We score them on this page when the date comes and never remove one. How we make and score predictions.

  1. P1 By Confidence 80% Open

    OMB and NARA do not issue a memorandum that rescinds M-23-07 or sets a new date for transfers of permanent records in electronic form by the end of 2027.

    How we will check: Open OMB's memoranda page and NARA's records management policy page on December 31, 2027. Right if no memorandum dated after November 16, 2026 rescinds, replaces or changes the dates in M-23-07.

    Basis: The June 30, 2024 date has passed and NARA reports most agencies met it [7]; NARA still lists the memo [3] and OMB's current list shows no rescission [4].

  2. P2 By Confidence 70% Open

    NARA publishes its consolidated Federal Agency Records Management Annual Report covering calendar year 2025 by March 31, 2027.

    How we will check: Open NARA's Federal Agency Records Management Reporting page. Right if a 2025 annual report is posted with a date on or before March 31, 2027.

    Basis: The 2025 reporting period closed May 15, 2026 and NARA said a consolidated report follows [21]; the 2024 report, whose reporting period closed March 14, 2025, was dated December 17, 2025 [7].

  3. P3 By Confidence 70% Open

    The first NARA Federal Agency Records Management Annual Report published after November 16, 2026 reports that fewer than 40% of agencies transferred electronic records to the National Archives in the year it covers.

    How we will check: Read the transfer section of the first annual report NARA posts after November 16, 2026. Right if the share of agencies reporting a transfer of electronic records in the year is below 40%; wrong if it is 40% or more, or if no report is posted by June 30, 2027.

    Basis: In 2024, 24% of agencies transferred electronic records and NARA called transfer a weakness [7]; NARA's ERA 2.0 had a capacity finding open in September 2025 [6].

  4. P4 By Confidence 75% Open

    GAO's product page for GAO-20-59 still shows at least 10 of its 42 recommendations as open (including partially addressed) on December 31, 2027.

    How we will check: Open the recommendations section of GAO-20-59 on gao.gov on or after December 31, 2027 and count recommendations shown as open or open, partially addressed.

    Basis: 14 of the 42 recommendations were open as checked on November 16, 2026, more than six years after publication [22].

Facts on this page link to their sources. Text marked "Moraph's view", and every prediction, is our own analysis, not a fact or advice. Methodology.

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the piece where needed.

  • NARA
  • OMB M-23-07
  • OMB M-19-21
  • 36 CFR 1236
  • 36 CFR 1235
  • 44 U.S.C. 2911
  • Capstone
  • GRS 6.1
  • electronic messages
  • records transfer
  • metadata