Information blocking enforcement: outlook to 2027
Penalties for developers and networks and disincentives for providers are all in force, ONC has started oversight actions, and claims against providers jumped in 2026, but no resolved case was public as of November 16, 2026.
Three kinds of actor, three different consequences
The 21st Century Cures Act names three kinds of information blocking actor, and the consequence depends on which one an organization is. OIG may impose civil money penalties of up to $1 million per violation on developers of certified health IT, entities offering certified health IT, health information exchanges and health information networks [2]. HHS's inflation adjustment published January 28, 2026 lists the maximum penalty per violation for committing information blocking at $1,327,209 [7]. OIG's penalty sections took effect September 1, 2023, and OIG said it will not impose a penalty on conduct that occurred before that date [5]. The statute directs that a penalty amount consider the nature and extent of the blocking and the harm, including the number of patients and providers affected and the number of days it lasted, and OIG has 6 years from the conduct to bring an action [5].
Health care providers face no civil money penalty for information blocking as providers; OIG instead refers a provider it finds to have blocked to the appropriate agency for disincentives [5] [6]. The disincentives rule, effective July 31, 2024, set three [6]. An eligible hospital loses the three quarters of the annual market basket increase tied to being a meaningful EHR user, and a critical access hospital is paid 100 percent rather than 101 percent of reasonable costs [6]. A MIPS eligible clinician scores zero in the Promoting Interoperability category, which the rule says is typically a quarter of the final score [6]. A Shared Savings Program ACO, ACO participant or ACO provider/supplier may be barred from the program for at least 1 year, after CMS considers the facts and circumstances [6]. Each disincentive applies to the reporting or performance period of the calendar year in which OIG makes the referral, not the year the blocking happened [6].
Developers of certified health IT carry a third exposure. ONC can ban a developer that blocks from the Certification Program and terminate the certification of the health IT involved [2]. ONC's claims guide sets out the sequence: a notice of non-conformity under 45 CFR 170.401, a possible corrective action plan, then possible suspension or termination of certification [13].
| Actor | Who acts | Consequence | Available since |
|---|---|---|---|
| Developers and offerors of certified health IT | OIG; for developers, also ONC through the Certification Program [13] | Up to $1,327,209 per violation; for developers, a certification ban or termination [2] [7] | September 1, 2023 for penalties [5] |
| Health information networks and exchanges | OIG [13] | Up to $1,327,209 per violation [7] | September 1, 2023 [5] |
| Hospitals, critical access hospitals, MIPS clinicians, Shared Savings Program ACOs | OIG determines and refers; CMS applies [6] | Lost market basket share, lost cost uplift, zero category score, or a bar of at least 1 year [6] | July 31, 2024 [6] |
From a directive to oversight actions
On September 3, 2025, HHS said Secretary Kennedy had directed it to increase resources dedicated to curbing information blocking, with ASTP/ONC and OIG in the leading roles [3]. The same release quoted National Coordinator Tom Keane saying ONC had already begun reviewing reports of information blocking against developers of certified health IT [3]. The next day OIG and ASTP/ONC issued a joint enforcement alert saying they would intensify enforcement activity and dedicate additional resources, and that "enforcement is active" [2]. OIG says it will prioritize practices that harm patients, significantly impair a provider's ability to deliver care, last a long time, cause financial loss to federal health care programs or other entities, or were committed with actual knowledge [1].
On February 11, 2026, HHS said ONC had initiated its first oversight actions under 45 CFR 170.580 and was issuing notices of potential non-conformity to certain developers of certified health IT, covering the information blocking Condition of Certification and the API Maintenance of Certification requirements [4]. On April 1, 2026, an HHS reorganization notice removed the Assistant Secretary for Technology Policy title and restored ONC as a singly titled office, with information blocking policy among the functions listed for it [15].
What has not appeared is a resolved case. OIG's information blocking page, last updated May 27, 2026, lists no enforcement action, penalty or settlement [1]. The Federal Register documents mentioning information blocking since January 2025 include no notice of a penalty, a provider determination or a disincentive [16].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: the order of events so far favors the certification route. A notice of non-conformity needs no administrative hearing and no penalty calculation, while an OIG penalty follows Social Security Act procedures and can be appealed. We expect developers to see the first visible consequences through corrective action plans, with OIG penalties trailing by a year or more, and providers last, because a provider disincentive needs an OIG determination, a referral and then a CMS payment cycle.
What the complaint data show
ONC's Report Information Blocking Portal received 2,563 submissions from April 5, 2021 through July 31, 2026, of which 2,450 were possible claims of information blocking [11]. ONC says logging a submission as a claim does not mean an investigation has started or that any determination has been made [11]. Claims about different kinds of actor, by the year they arrived, from ONC's monthly data (a claim can name more than one actor) [12]:
| Year | Health care provider named | Certified (CHPL-listed) developer named | HIN or HIE named |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 (from April 5) | 197 [12] | 40 [12] | 2 [12] |
| 2022 | 246 [12] | 40 [12] | 0 [12] |
| 2023 | 286 [12] | 39 [12] | 2 [12] |
| 2024 | 216 [12] | 52 [12] | 7 [12] |
| 2025 | 184 [12] | 72 [12] | 6 [12] |
| 2026 (January to July) | 809 [12] | 95 [12] | 3 [12] |
Claims naming a health care provider rose from 32 in February 2026 to 219 in March 2026, and stayed above 100 a month through July [12]. Claims that ONC's analysts classed as coming from patients numbered 725 in the first seven months of 2026, against 138 in all of 2025 [12]. Every claim is shared with OIG, and claims against developers of certified health IT can also be taken up by ONC under the Certification Program [13].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: the complaint pipeline has turned toward providers just as the enforcement machinery for providers is the slowest of the three. Health systems now generate most of the allegations but, as checked on November 16, 2026, have no public example of a disincentive to calibrate against. That gap will not last indefinitely: a referral needs only one OIG determination, and the patient-access cases that dominate the 2026 claims are the simplest kind to prove.
The rules are shifting around enforcement
The HTI-5 proposed rule, published December 29, 2025, covered both the certification rules in 45 CFR part 170 and the information blocking rules in part 171, and said it sought to address reported misuse and abuse of information blocking definitions and exceptions [8]. Among its part 171 proposals: removing the third party seeking modification use condition from the Infeasibility Exception, revising or removing the manner exception exhausted condition, making clear the Manner Exception cannot be met with contracts that are not market rate or are contracts of adhesion, and removing the TEFCA Manner Exception in subpart D [8]. Comments closed February 27, 2026 [8].
The HTI-5 final rule, published October 28, 2026 and effective December 28, 2026, amends 45 CFR parts 170 and 172 only [9]. ONC said it responded to a narrowed set of proposals, that comments on the others remain under review, and that those proposals may appear in later final rules or revised proposals [9]. The Unified Agenda entry for the rulemaking, RIN 0955-AA09, covers both parts and listed final action for August 2026 [10]. As checked on November 16, 2026, no final rule amending part 171 had been published [16].
CMS is also trimming the provider side of certification oversight. The CY 2027 Physician Fee Schedule final rule removes the ONC Direct Review attestation and the ONC-ACB Surveillance attestation from the MIPS Promoting Interoperability category starting with the CY 2026 performance period [14]. That rule describes the Direct Review attestation as one a clinician had to answer "Yes" to or score zero in the category [14].
Moraph's view
Moraph's view: the pending part 171 changes cut against actors, not for them. Removing the third-party modification condition and narrowing the Manner Exception would take away defenses that developers and some providers rely on when they refuse an integration or price access. Anyone whose current practice leans on those conditions should assume they may not survive into 2027, even though, as of this writing, they are still in force.
What to watch through 2027
- OIG's information blocking page for its first listed enforcement action [1].
- A final rule amending 45 CFR part 171 under RIN 0955-AA09 [10] [16].
- ONC's monthly claims data, which will show whether provider claims stay near the levels seen since March 2026 [12].
- HHS's next annual penalty inflation adjustment, which resets the per-violation maximum [7].
Data and method
Yearly claim counts were summed by us from the monthly figures on the yearly sheets of ONC's July 2026 workbook, using its Potential Actor and Type of Claimant columns as written [12]. ONC notes that actor and claimant types are an analyst's inference from what the claimant wrote, that each claim names at least one potential actor, and that a claimant can be counted in more than one category, so neither set of columns adds up to the total of claims [11]. For 2026 we added the January to July rows; the August to December rows are blank in that workbook [12]. Status statements are as checked on November 16, 2026 against OIG's page, the Federal Register and the rules cited [1] [16]. This page describes public rules and announcements; it is not legal advice on what any organization must do.
What this means for you
- Health systems and physician groups: Treat patient access requests as the main exposure: claims naming providers rose sharply in 2026 and patients were the largest group of claimants [12]. Map which entities in the system are eligible hospitals, MIPS clinicians or ACO participants, since the disincentive differs for each and lands in the year OIG refers [6].
- Developers of certified health IT: Prepare to answer a notice of potential non-conformity on the information blocking condition and API maintenance requirements, which ONC began issuing in February 2026 [4] [13]. Review any refusal that relies on the Infeasibility or Manner Exception conditions HTI-5 proposes to narrow [8].
- Health information networks and exchanges: Document fees, contract terms and onboarding delays against OIG's stated priorities, since networks face the same per-violation penalty as developers [1] [7]. Note that HTI-5 proposed removing the TEFCA Manner Exception [8].
- Compliance and legal teams: Keep a record of each denied or delayed request and the exception relied on: OIG has 6 years from the conduct to act, and the penalty amount turns on patients affected and days the practice lasted [5].
Moraph predictions
Every prediction is Moraph's view, not a fact. Each has a date, a confidence level (70% means we expect to be wrong about three times in ten) and a test anyone can apply. We score them on this page when the date comes and never remove one. How we make and score predictions.
P1 By Confidence 65% Open
HHS OIG publicly announces at least one resolved information blocking civil money penalty or settlement with a developer of certified health IT, a health information network or a health information exchange.
How we will check: OIG's information blocking page, an OIG press release or an HHS press release, dated on or before June 30, 2028, describes a resolved information blocking penalty or settlement with a developer, network or exchange.
Basis: Penalties have applied to conduct since September 1, 2023 [5]; HHS and OIG announced more enforcement resources in September 2025 [2] [3]; ONC began oversight actions against developers in February 2026 [4]; OIG's page, last updated May 27, 2026, listed no resolved case [1].
P2 By Confidence 60% Open
HHS publishes a final rule that amends the information blocking exceptions in 45 CFR part 171, adopting at least one of the HTI-5 proposals to change the Infeasibility Exception, the Manner Exception or the TEFCA Manner Exception.
How we will check: The Federal Register lists a final rule, published on or before December 31, 2027, whose amendatory text changes 45 CFR 171.204, 171.301 or subpart D of part 171.
Basis: The proposals were published December 29, 2025 and comments closed February 27, 2026 [8]; the October 28, 2026 final rule amended only parts 170 and 172 and said the remaining proposals may come in later final rules [9]; the Unified Agenda listed final action for August 2026 [10].
P3 By Confidence 70% Open
ONC's information blocking claims page reports at least 3,500 total possible claims of information blocking received since April 5, 2021.
How we will check: Health IT Quick-Stat #59, in a version published on or before September 30, 2027, shows a total number of possible claims of information blocking of 3,500 or more.
Basis: The total was 2,450 through July 31, 2026 [11], and claims naming a health care provider ran above 100 a month from March through July 2026 [12].
P4 By Confidence 75% Open
No health care provider is publicly identified as having received a CMS information blocking disincentive.
How we will check: No ONC, CMS, OIG or HHS web page, press release or Federal Register document published on or before December 31, 2027 names a health care provider that OIG determined committed information blocking and to which a disincentive was applied.
Basis: A disincentive needs an OIG determination and referral before CMS applies it in the referral year [6]; OIG's page listed no enforcement action as of May 27, 2026 [1], and no such notice appears in the Federal Register through November 16, 2026 [16].
Facts on this page link to their sources. Text marked "Moraph's view", and every prediction, is our own analysis, not a fact or advice. Methodology.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the piece where needed.