OCR’s 2016 NY Med settlement treated film crew access as a disclosure and made filming a supervised activity

On April 21, 2016, OCR announced a $2.2 million settlement with New York Presbyterian over filming for ABC’s NY Med. Its corrective action plan required active monitoring of all recording on the premises. In our reading, that made media access a workforce control.

Looking Back revisits past weeks one at a time, up to the most recent, and asks what it meant for the banks, health systems and public agencies we serve. The series was written in 2026, with the benefit of hindsight, and each article says which week it looks back on.

Two-minute summaryThe dek and the first sentence of each section, quoted from the article

On April 21, 2016, OCR announced a $2.2 million settlement with New York Presbyterian over filming for ABC’s NY Med. Its corrective action plan required active monitoring of all recording on the premises. In our reading, that made media access a workforce control.

  1. The week The announcement also set out OCR’s view of the safeguards.
  2. The trigger: when media access becomes a disclosure The FAQ placed the line at access.
  3. The permission: what a valid authorization requires The Privacy Rule sets out what an authorization must contain.
  4. The supervision: who must watch, and what happens when rules are broken One distinctive term in the plan was about presence.
  5. The proof: what the plan required OCR to see The minimum content was specified.
  6. How the case reaches different health organizations An academic medical center may receive requests from news programs, documentary makers and its own communications team.
  7. Objections, in order The FAQ addressed that directly.
  8. Checks a privacy officer or operations leader could run Confirm there is one documented route for every request to film, photograph or record on the premises, from outside media and from internal teams.
  9. With hindsight OCR returned to the subject in September 2018.

The week

On Thursday, April 21, 2016, the Office for Civil Rights at the Department of Health and Human Services announced a $2.2 million settlement with New York Presbyterian Hospital. [1] The case concerned filming for NY Med, an ABC television series. [1]

OCR’s announcement said the settlement related to the disclosure of two patients’ protected health information to film crews and staff without first obtaining the patients’ authorization. [1] OCR described the disclosure as egregious. [1] It said it found that the hospital allowed the crew to film a person who was dying and another person in significant distress, even after a medical professional urged the crew to stop. [1]

The announcement also set out OCR’s view of the safeguards. It said OCR found that the hospital failed to safeguard protected health information and allowed ABC film crews virtually unfettered access to its facility. [1] In OCR’s words, that created an environment where the information could not be protected from impermissible disclosure to the crew and staff. [1]

The resolution agreement gives the timeline. It says OCR received a complaint on January 27, 2013, alleging that on April 28, 2011, the hospital impermissibly disclosed protected health information to a film crew and other staff of NY Med. [2] OCR notified the hospital of its investigation on May 29, 2013. [2]

The agreement lists two items of covered conduct, which are the conduct OCR’s investigation indicated occurred. First, the hospital impermissibly disclosed the information of two identified patients to the crew and other staff, citing 45 CFR 164.502(a). [2] Second, it said the hospital failed to safeguard its patients’ information from disclosure during the filming and failed to implement policies, procedures and practices to protect it, citing section 164.530(c). [2]

The agreement is a settlement, not an adjudication. It states that it is not an admission of liability by the hospital and was made without trial or any finding of liability. [2] It also states that it is not a concession by HHS that the hospital did not violate the rules. [2]

The terms were a payment and a corrective action plan. The hospital agreed to pay $2,200,000. [2] The plan ran for a compliance term of two years from the effective date. [2] The agreement became effective on signature by the last signatory, and both signature blocks are dated April 19, 2016. [2]

OCR published a new item of guidance the same week. Its announcement pointed readers to a new FAQ on media access to protected health information. [1] The archived FAQ page shows that its content was last reviewed on April 18, 2016. [3]

The FAQ asked whether health care providers can invite or arrange for media, including film crews, to enter treatment areas without prior written authorization. [3] Its answer was that providers cannot invite or allow media into treatment or other areas where patients’ information will be accessible. [3] The exception is prior written authorization from each individual who is or will be in the area. [3]

The FAQ added a point aimed at a familiar workaround. It said it is not sufficient to ask media to mask patients’ identities by blurring, pixelation or voice alteration. [3] The reason it gave was that the Privacy Rule does not allow media access to the information without authorization in the first place. [3]

The NY Med case could be read as a story about television. OCR’s documents frame it differently. The covered conduct was a disclosure to a film crew and a failure of safeguards. [2] The guidance OCR published that week said a crew in a treatment area is a disclosure that needs each affected patient’s prior written authorization. [3] And the corrective action plan required the hospital to monitor all photography and recording on its premises. [2]

Our argument is that the settlement turned media access from a communications decision into a workforce control. The corrective action plan did not mainly require new technology. It required named people, a process for approving authorizations, active monitoring, internal reporting, sanctions, training and signed certifications. [2] In our reading, those are operations and workforce obligations, and they are where a health system’s exposure lay.

We take the question in four parts:

  1. The trigger: when the presence of media becomes a disclosure under OCR’s guidance, and when it does not.
  2. The permission: what a valid authorization requires and how the plan required the hospital to approve one.
  3. The supervision: who must watch, who can be asked and what happens when a rule is broken.
  4. The proof: the training certifications, attestations and reports the plan required OCR to see.

The parts do not overlap. The first is the threshold, the second the consent, the third the conduct on the day and the fourth the evidence afterward. After them we look at how the case reaches different health organizations, take the objections in order and end with checks a privacy officer or operations leader could run.

The trigger: when media access becomes a disclosure

Access, not broadcast

The FAQ placed the line at access. It said providers cannot invite or allow media into areas where patients’ information will be accessible in written, electronic, oral or other visual or audio form. [3] It did not tie the problem to what is later broadcast. [3]

That is a significant choice. A hospital might think its risk begins when footage airs. Under OCR’s reading, the disclosure happens when the crew can see or hear the information. A camera that never records still sees a whiteboard, a monitor or a conversation at a bedside.

Masking does not cure it

The FAQ addressed masking directly. It said asking media to blur faces or alter voices is not sufficient for patients who did not authorize. [3] The Privacy Rule, it said, does not allow the access in the first place. [3]

This closes a door some productions might rely on. Post-production editing protects the audience’s view. It does nothing about what the crew saw and heard on the ward. OCR’s guidance put the control before the crew enters, not after the footage is cut.

Images count

OCR’s announcement made a point about images explicitly. It said the HIPAA Rules were designed to prohibit disclosure of protected health information, including images, in circumstances such as these. [1] A patient’s face, body, bed label or monitor in a frame is information about that patient.

For a records leader, that means video and still images taken on clinical premises can be protected health information. They need the same classification, access control and retention thinking as a note in the chart, whenever they show a patient.

Each person in the area

The FAQ required authorization from each individual who is or will be in the area, or whose information will be accessible. [3] That reaches beyond the featured patient. A trauma bay, an emergency department or a shared ward holds other patients, and their information can be in view.

The FAQ added a second duty. It said the provider must ensure reasonable safeguards are in place to protect against impermissible disclosures, or to limit incidental disclosures, of other information in the area for which no authorization was obtained. [3] That language tracks the safeguards standard in section 164.530(c). [7]

Staff, agents and business associates

The plan’s prohibition was drawn broadly. It required a specific prohibition on use or disclosure by workforce members, agents and business associates to any person planning, coordinating or engaging in recording for purposes not related to care, without prior authorization. [2]

Three features of that wording matter. It covers people who plan and coordinate as well as those holding a camera, so a producer scouting a ward is inside it. It covers agents and business associates as well as employees. And it turns on purpose: recording related to the provision of care is outside the prohibition, while recording for other purposes is inside. [2]

In our reading, that purpose test is where hard cases will arise. Clinical photography for a chart is care. A clip for a teaching conference may be health care operations. A clip for the hospital’s social media feed is neither. A policy needs to say which is which, and who decides.

Where the line does not fall

The FAQ also said what HIPAA does not require. It said the Privacy Rule does not require providers to prevent media from entering areas generally accessible to the public, which may include public waiting areas and entrances. [3] So the trigger is the treatment area and any other place where information is accessible, not the building.

It described narrow situations where limited disclosure to media is allowed without authorization. One was to help identify or locate the family of an unidentified, incapacitated patient, if the hospital judged it in the patient’s best interest. [3] It cited section 164.510(b)(1)(ii) for that point. [3]

Another was the facility directory. Where a patient has not objected to being listed, a provider may disclose the patient’s location and general condition to a person, including media, who asks for the patient by name. [3] The directory rule in section 164.510(a) still allows name, location, general condition and religious affiliation to be kept, with an opportunity for the patient to object. [6]

Crews working for the hospital

The FAQ distinguished a crew working for the provider. It said a provider may use a contract film crew to produce training videos or public relations material if certain protections are in place. [3] If patients are to be interviewed, or information might be accessible, the provider must have a business associate agreement with the crew. [3]

It said that agreement must ensure the crew safeguards the information, uses or discloses it only as the agreement provides and returns or destroys it when the work is done. [3] And it said patients’ authorizations are still required before material including their information is posted online, printed in brochures or otherwise disseminated. [3]

What the trigger means operationally

In our reading, the trigger analysis sorts every request to film into one of four boxes. A crew in a public area only is outside the authorization rule. A crew working for the hospital needs a business associate agreement and, before publication, authorizations. A news or entertainment crew in a treatment area needs authorizations from everyone whose information is accessible. And a narrow set of requests fit the directory or best-interest exceptions.

The sorting has to happen before anyone arrives. That is a front-door task for whoever receives media requests. It is the first point at which communications, privacy and clinical operations must agree.

The permission: what a valid authorization requires

The rule’s elements

The Privacy Rule sets out what an authorization must contain. Section 164.508 says a covered entity may not use or disclose protected health information without a valid authorization, except as the rule otherwise permits or requires. [5] Its core elements include a specific description of the information, the persons authorized to make and to receive the disclosure, and a description of each purpose. [5]

The authorization also needs an expiration date or event, and the individual’s signature and date. [5] If a personal representative signs, the form must describe that person’s authority. [5] The form must tell the individual of the right to revoke in writing, and whether treatment can be conditioned on signing. [5]

Prior means prior

The FAQ used the word prior throughout. It required prior written authorization from each individual in the area. [3] The corrective action plan required the hospital’s policies to prohibit disclosure to anyone filming for purposes not related to care without the prior authorization of the patient or personal representative. [2]

That timing creates a hard operational problem in acute settings. A patient arriving by ambulance cannot give a valid authorization in the moment, and may never be able to. In our reading, OCR’s guidance leaves no route to film such a patient’s care first and seek permission later.

Who approves

The plan required more than a form. It required a process for evaluating and approving authorizations requesting disclosure of protected health information. [2] It required the hospital to identify the people that workforce members, agents or business associates may contact with a question or concern about HIPAA compliance in these activities. [2]

Those are named roles. A hospital following the plan’s model would decide who receives filming requests, who checks each authorization against section 164.508 and who can say no. It would publish those names to staff.

The authorization as a record

An authorization is also a record. Section 164.508 requires a covered entity to document and retain any signed authorization as section 164.530(j) requires. [5] The plan’s document retention section required the hospital to keep all documents and records relating to compliance with the plan for six years from the effective date. [2]

For a technology leader, this is a records management requirement with a clinical edge. Authorizations for media access need to be findable by patient, by date and by production. If a patient later complains, the hospital will need to show what the patient signed and when.

Revocation during a production

The rule lets an individual revoke an authorization at any time, in writing, except to the extent the covered entity has already acted in reliance on it. [5] That raises a practical question for a production that runs over days.

In our reading, a hospital should plan for a patient who signs on the first day and revokes on the third. The production must stop including that patient from the point of revocation. Footage already recorded in reliance on the authorization is a harder question, which counsel would need to answer for the specific facts. The operational point is that someone must receive the revocation and tell the crew at once.

Personal representatives

Some patients cannot sign. The rule allows a personal representative to sign, if the form describes the representative’s authority to act. [5] For a patient in intensive care, that may be a family member with legal authority.

A hospital would need to check that authority before relying on it. That is a task for staff who know the hospital’s rules on personal representatives, not for a production assistant. It adds another named role to the process.

In our reading, a hospital’s general consent to treatment is not a HIPAA authorization for media access, because the authorization must meet the specific elements in section 164.508. [5] A hospital that relies on a general admission form for filming consent would struggle to show a valid authorization under OCR’s guidance.

The supervision: who must watch, and what happens when rules are broken

Active monitoring

One distinctive term in the plan was about presence. It required that all photography, video recording and audio recording conducted on the hospital’s premises be actively monitored by appropriate hospital representatives for compliance with the Privacy Rule and the hospital’s policies. [2]

That term goes beyond media productions. It covers all photography and recording on the premises. [2] In our reading, it describes a staffing commitment: someone must be present and watching whenever recording happens in places where information is accessible.

What monitoring requires in practice

A monitor needs authority and knowledge. The person must know which patients have authorized, which areas are covered and when to stop recording. OCR’s 2016 announcement said a medical professional urged the crew to stop and the filming continued. [1] In our reading, the plan’s answer was a named representative whose job is to enforce the policy, not a clinician busy with care.

Monitoring also needs coverage. Productions can run over long shifts and across departments. A hospital agreeing to monitor all recording must decide the number of representatives it needs and how they hand over. That is a scheduling and budget question for operations, not for the communications team.

When a clinician says stop

OCR’s 2016 account included a medical professional urging the crew to stop. [1] The account does not say what authority that person had over the crew. In our reading, the plan’s structure answers the question for the future: the monitor has authority to stop, and a clinician’s request to stop should go straight to the monitor.

That needs to be written down and rehearsed. A clinician in the middle of care should not have to negotiate with a producer. A short escalation rule, known to every unit that hosts a production, would let the clinician hand the problem to someone whose job it is.

Contracts with productions

A hospital that permits outside filming will sign some agreement with the production. The plan does not prescribe its terms. In our reading, the agreement should at least give the hospital the right to stop recording, require the crew to follow the monitor’s instructions and limit where the crew may go.

It should also deal with footage. If a crew records information it was not authorized to see, the hospital will want a way to require its deletion. Whether such terms are enforceable is a matter for counsel. The point is that the contract should match the privacy policy, so staff are not left choosing between them.

Internal reporting

The plan required workforce members to report violations of the policies to the privacy officer at the earliest possible time. [2] It required the hospital to promptly investigate any information that a workforce member may have violated them. [2]

That puts every staff member on the reporting line. A nurse who sees a camera in a room where a patient has not authorized has a duty under the hospital’s policy to report it. The policy works only if staff know the duty exists and have a way to act on it during a shift.

Business associates on the reporting line

The plan reached contractors too. Its reportable events included a failure by a business associate that had agreed to comply with the hospital’s policies. [2] So a vendor that agreed to follow the media policy, and then broke it, would generate a report to OCR within the same thirty-day window as an employee’s breach. [2]

In our reading, that makes the business associate agreement and the media policy a pair. A vendor should see the policy it is agreeing to follow, and the hospital should know whom at the vendor to call if it is broken.

Sanctions

The plan required appropriate sanctions against workforce members, including supervisors and managers, who fail to comply. [2] It said sanctions may include retraining or other corrective action, depending on the circumstances. [2] Section 164.530 separately requires a covered entity to have and apply appropriate sanctions against workforce members who fail to comply with its privacy policies. [7]

The inclusion of supervisors and managers is pointed. Where a filming arrangement is approved above the front line, the plan made clear that those who approve can also be sanctioned.

Reportable events

The plan created a reporting duty to OCR. During the compliance term, if the hospital determined after investigation that a workforce member or business associate failed to comply with its policies, it had to notify OCR in writing within thirty days. [2] The report had to describe the event, the people involved, the policy provisions implicated and the actions taken, including sanctions. [2]

That changes how an internal investigation is run. Its conclusion becomes a filing to the regulator, on a deadline. A privacy office under such a plan needs a case management process that records when each determination was made.

The proof: what the plan required OCR to see

Policies approved by OCR

The plan required the hospital to send its revised policies to OCR within ninety days for review and approval. [2] It had thirty days to make any changes OCR recommended. [2] It had to implement the approved policies within sixty days of final approval. [2]

The minimum content was specified. The policies had to include a prohibition on disclosure to anyone recording for purposes not related to care without prior authorization, an authorization approval process, named contacts and active monitoring. [2] They also had to address uses and disclosures, safeguards, authorizations, training and internal reporting under the cited sections. [2]

Signed certifications

Distribution came with signatures. The hospital had to distribute the policies to all workforce members within sixty days of approval and to new members within thirty days of starting. [2] At distribution, it had to obtain a signed written or electronic certification from each workforce member that the member had read, understood and would follow them. [2]

Training worked the same way. All workforce members had to be trained within sixty days of the policy’s implementation or of joining. [2] Each had to certify in writing or electronically that they received and understood the training, with the date. [2]

What the training had to cover

The plan set a floor for content. Training had to cover the hospital’s Privacy Rule policies, including the specific media items, and every topic necessary and appropriate for each workforce member’s function. [2] The hospital had to review the training annually and update it for changes in law or guidance, audit findings and other developments. [2]

That role-based requirement matches the Privacy Rule’s general training standard, which requires training as necessary and appropriate for workforce members to carry out their functions. [7] In our reading, a unit that hosts productions needs deeper training than one that never sees a camera, and the training record should show the difference.

Access depends on certification

One term tied training records to system access. The plan said the hospital shall not provide access to protected health information to any workforce member who has not signed or provided the training certification. [2]

That is a technology control. It means the identity and access management system must know who has certified. A workforce member without a certification should not get access, and the hospital must be able to show it. In our reading, this single term turned a training record into an access prerequisite.

The plan’s deadlines as a project plan

The plan’s deadlines read like a project schedule. Policies went to OCR within ninety days. [2] Changes OCR recommended were due within thirty days. [2] Implementation followed within sixty days of approval, distribution within sixty days and training within sixty days of implementation. [2] Reportable events went to OCR within thirty days of a determination. [2]

For a hospital under such a plan, those dates become the critical path. Each depends on a different owner: privacy for policies, human resources for distribution, education for training and information technology for the access block. In our reading, the plan’s structure is a template for any privacy program change that must reach the whole workforce on a schedule.

Attestations

The plan’s Implementation Report required several officer attestations. [2] One attested that the policies were being implemented and distributed and that compliance certifications were obtained. [2] Another attested that all workforce members had completed training and executed certifications. [2]

A further attestation listed every hospital location, with its name, address and phone and fax numbers, and attested that each location had complied with the plan. [2] An officer also had to attest that he or she had reviewed the report and believed it accurate after reasonable inquiry. [2]

The final report

Within sixty days after the compliance term ended, the hospital had to file a Final Report. [2] It had to include training schedules and materials, an attestation about training certifications, a summary of reportable events and their corrective actions, and an officer’s attestation of accuracy. [2]

Why the proof matters more than the policy

A policy is easy to write. The plan asked for evidence that the policy reached every person, at every location, and was enforced. In our reading, that is the plan’s lasting design. It measured compliance by records an organization can only produce if its workforce processes actually run.

The proof also had an internal audience. An officer who signs an attestation that every location complied needs evidence before signing. [2] That pushes the evidence collection down to each site and up to the executive who attests. In our reading, a health system without such a plan could still adopt the same chain of evidence, so that its leaders know the media policy is followed before a regulator asks.

How the case reaches different health organizations

An academic medical center

An academic medical center may receive requests from news programs, documentary makers and its own communications team. It may also host students and researchers who record for education. The plan’s monitoring term covered all photography, video and audio recording on the premises, and its prohibition covered recording for purposes not related to care. [2] An academic center would need to sort educational recording, which may be part of health care operations, from external productions.

A community hospital

A community hospital may see fewer requests, but each can be larger relative to its staff. A single production can consume the attention of its privacy officer for weeks. The plan’s structure suggests the work: one approval process, one named contact, a monitor on site and documented training. [2]

An ambulatory network

An ambulatory network’s exposure is more distributed. Clinics may agree to local news segments or marketing shoots without central review. The FAQ’s rule applies wherever patients’ information is accessible. [3] In our reading, a network needs a single intake point for filming requests across all sites, because the attestation model in the plan was organized by location. [2]

A health system with a fundraising foundation

A foundation that tells patient stories to donors may want video. The FAQ said authorizations are required before material containing patients’ information is posted online, printed in brochures or otherwise publicly disseminated. [3] If the foundation’s crew films on clinical premises, the access question arises too. [3]

In our reading, the foundation’s media work should run through the same intake and authorization process as outside media. A grateful patient’s willingness does not replace a signed authorization that meets section 164.508. [5]

A behavioral health provider

Behavioral health settings raise the stakes. The mere presence of a person in a facility can reveal sensitive information. The FAQ’s line at access applies with special force where being seen is itself the disclosure. [3] Other federal and state confidentiality rules may also apply, which counsel would need to review.

A public hospital

A public hospital may face open-records requests and public-meeting rules alongside HIPAA. In our reading, those obligations do not displace the Privacy Rule’s authorization requirement for media access to treatment areas, and counsel would confirm how they interact under state law. [3] [5] A public hospital’s communications office needs the same intake and authorization process as a private one.

A life sciences company

A life sciences company that films patients for marketing or education may not be a covered entity for that activity. But if it films in a hospital, the hospital’s obligations apply to what the crew can see. [3] A company would need to work with each hospital’s privacy office and expect to provide authorizations that meet section 164.508. [5]

A telehealth provider

A telehealth service raises the same question in a new setting. If a provider records virtual visits for promotional use, the information is accessible to whoever handles the recording. The FAQ’s logic, that access without authorization is the disclosure, would apply to the people who see the footage. [3] In our reading, a telehealth program’s recording policy should follow the same authorization and supervision model.

Objections, in order

1. If patients’ faces are blurred on air, no harm is done

The FAQ addressed that directly. It said masking identities is not sufficient because the Privacy Rule does not allow media access without authorization in the first place. [3] The agreement’s covered conduct was the disclosure to the crew and the failure of safeguards, not the broadcast. [2]

2. Documentaries educate the public about health care

The FAQ recognized a legitimate role. It said covered entities can continue to inform the media about their services and programs, provided they do not share protected health information without authorization. [3] The guidance did not bar productions. It required authorization first.

3. Getting authorizations in an emergency department is impossible

For some patients, that may be so. In our reading, OCR’s guidance means those patients’ care cannot be filmed in a way that makes their information accessible to the crew. [3] A production can still film patients who authorize, in areas where others’ information is protected.

4. A business associate agreement solves the problem

It solves part of it, for crews working on the hospital’s behalf. The FAQ said a contract crew producing training or public relations material needs a business associate agreement. [3] It also said authorizations are still required before material containing patients’ information is publicly disseminated. [3] And in our reading, a news or entertainment crew working for itself is not the hospital’s business associate.

5. The settlement involved two patients; the plan is out of proportion

OCR described more than two disclosures. It said the hospital allowed crews virtually unfettered access, creating an environment where information could not be protected. [1] The covered conduct included the failure to implement policies and practices to protect patients’ information during filming. [2] The plan addressed that environment as well as the two disclosures.

6. This is a communications issue, not an operations one

The plan’s terms say otherwise. It required named contacts, monitoring on site, internal reporting, investigation, sanctions, training, signed certifications and an access block for uncertified staff. [2] Those are workforce and systems obligations. The communications office receives the request; operations carries the duty.

7. The agreement says it is not an admission, so it sets no standard

The agreement does say it is not an admission of liability and contains no finding. [2] But OCR published the FAQ the same week, stating its reading of the rule for every provider. [1] [3] And the 2018 settlements required training that included that guidance. [4] In our reading, the FAQ, not the agreement, is the standard, and the agreement shows what OCR will ask for when it finds a problem.

Checks a privacy officer or operations leader could run

Request intake

Confirm there is one documented route for every request to film, photograph or record on the premises, from outside media and from internal teams. Name the person who receives requests.

Authorization form

Compare the media authorization form with the core elements and required statements in section 164.508. [5] Confirm a general consent to treatment is not used in its place.

Monitoring roster

For any approved recording, name the representative who will be present, with authority to stop it. Record their presence in the production file.

Business associate agreements

List contract crews and agencies that produce training or marketing material. Confirm each has a business associate agreement where information may be accessible. [3]

Certification and access

Check whether training certifications are recorded in a system that the access management process can read. The NY Med plan made certification a condition of access. [2]

Investigation log

Confirm reported violations are logged with the date of each determination, the people involved, the policy provisions implicated and the sanctions applied. [2] [7]

Escalation drill

Run a short exercise with a unit that has hosted filming. Ask a clinician what they would do if a crew recorded a patient who had not signed. Confirm the answer leads to the monitor and the privacy officer.

Location list

List every site where filming or recording for non-care purposes could happen. The NY Med plan required an attestation by location. [2]

Retention

Confirm authorizations, training records and investigation files are kept under a retention rule that meets section 164.530(j): six years from creation or from the date last in effect, whichever is later. [7]

With hindsight

OCR returned to the subject in September 2018. On September 20, 2018, it announced separate settlements with Boston Medical Center, Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Massachusetts General Hospital. [4] Its announcement said the hospitals invited film crews on premises to film an ABC television documentary series without first obtaining patients’ authorization. [4]

The three paid $999,000 in total to settle potential violations of the Privacy Rule, according to OCR. [4] It listed the amounts as $100,000 for Boston Medical Center, $384,000 for Brigham and Women’s and $515,000 for Massachusetts General. [4] Each agreed to provide workforce training as part of a corrective action plan, including OCR’s guidance on disclosures to film and media. [4]

OCR described the Boston cases as the second HIPAA case involving an ABC medical documentary series. [4] Its 2018 release dated the earlier settlement April 16, 2016. [4] The 2016 agreement itself shows signatures dated April 19, 2016, and OCR announced it on April 21, 2016. [1] [2] We give both because the documents differ.

The 2018 release also carried a correction. It said a previous version had mistakenly identified the series as Boston Med, and that Boston Med, also an ABC series, was not involved. [4] That is a small reminder that even regulators’ own accounts get revised.

The 2018 cases followed the 2016 approach. The training OCR required pointed directly to the FAQ it had published in April 2016. [4] So the FAQ became a reference text for later corrective action as well as a statement of policy.

The rule text has not changed on the points that mattered. As checked on November 16, 2026, section 164.508 still says a covered entity may not use or disclose protected health information without a valid authorization, except as otherwise permitted or required. [5] It still lists the same core elements and required statements. [5]

Section 164.530(c) still requires appropriate administrative, technical and physical safeguards, as checked on the same date. [7] It still requires a covered entity to reasonably safeguard information from intentional or unintentional prohibited disclosure and to limit incidental disclosures. [7] Section 164.510 still provides the facility directory rule and the opportunity to object that the FAQ described. [6]

What held up is OCR’s line at access. The 2016 FAQ drew the line at media access to areas where patients’ information is accessible in visual, audio or other form, and said masking does not cure it. [3] The 2018 settlements were framed around inviting crews on premises without authorization. [4] We found nothing in the documents we checked that moved that line.

What held up less well is the assumption that filming means a television crew. The plan’s monitoring term covered all photography, video and audio recording conducted on the premises. [2] In our reading, that language already reached any recording device. Phones with cameras make that reading relevant to a hospital’s staff policies, though we cite no enforcement action on that point.

The workforce design also held up as a model. The plan’s elements were named contacts, an approval process, monitoring, internal reporting, sanctions, certified training and an access block for uncertified staff. [2] A privacy officer building a media policy today could use that list as a checklist, while checking with counsel on any later guidance.

In our view, the NY Med case is best remembered for what it asked a hospital to prove. The payment was the headline. The plan asked for proof that every workforce member, at every location, knew the rule and that someone was watching when cameras were present. [2]

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it and correct the article where needed.

  • HIPAA
  • Privacy Rule
  • authorization
  • media access
  • corrective action plan
  • workforce training